Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 13:54

And if you are on a minimum wage job, in most cases you can get back into work fine if you take time out.

SirMingeALot · 18/11/2022 13:52

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:23

@Topgub That sounds like someone in a decent job with talk of pensions and mental health.
Loads of jobs are bad for people's mental health and childcare costs during school holidays and afterschool can still make work not worth doing. No way would I work unless it was for money.

It's true, the stuff about the longer term benefits of working simply isn't applicable to all jobs. Plenty of roles aren't a career, don't involve much if anything in the way of skills, don't pay enough pension contribution for the person to be able to avoid relying on the state, don't provide financial independence and do nothing positive for mental health. It should not therefore come as a surprise to anyone that when people have the opportunity to take a few years away from them, they take it.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 13:43

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 13:34

You really are missing the point. The reason many use the woman’s wage as a reference is because women are still often paid significantly less than men, so it would make more sense for the woman to give up work. Any many women are stuck in jobs that they can’t advance in. I think perhaps you are further ahead than many and don’t quite realise that.

Even when entitled to free childcare hours, it isn’t readily available, there aren’t enough providers or spaces.

Does the Tory rhetoric of “get a better job” sit well with you? Because it’s just not possible for many

No, but but neither does the sexist rhetoric of women are slaves to the wage gap.

Or the sexist rhetoric of 'it makes more sense for women to give up work'.

You seem to be confusing dont agree with and don't realise/don't understand

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 13:34

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:35

I'm not middle class 🤷‍♀️

I'd have fully subsidised childcare available to all of possible.

I dont think the poor should work for 'no money' (it could be argued that if you can afford to fund a sahp on 1 wage you're not poor anyway) but saying all your wage (always the womans and never the mans) will go on childcare and think thats always a bad thing is short sighted at best

You really are missing the point. The reason many use the woman’s wage as a reference is because women are still often paid significantly less than men, so it would make more sense for the woman to give up work. Any many women are stuck in jobs that they can’t advance in. I think perhaps you are further ahead than many and don’t quite realise that.

Even when entitled to free childcare hours, it isn’t readily available, there aren’t enough providers or spaces.

Does the Tory rhetoric of “get a better job” sit well with you? Because it’s just not possible for many

lieselotte · 18/11/2022 13:02

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:38

But if childcare swallows up one wage, then it does not matter if you theoretically apportion it to both salaries. You are still no better off with two going out to work than one.

Not in the short term but you will be in the long term.

lieselotte · 18/11/2022 13:01

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 11:18

Longer term benefits of working? What are they? There really are not any unless you are going to advance up the ladder.

Having your own income, not having to ask DH if you want to buy new underwear, not having to rely on a man, having a life separate to the kids, having the interest a job brings (though that can come from a voluntary role too).

I am surprised that any school does not have after-school care these days, whether after school club or childminders. My ds' school didn't and doesn't have an after-school club because the local childminders lobbied against it, but did and still does have a breakfast club. Maybe parents need to get lobbying too. I know covid affected things, but it's time to get the wraparound care back.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:54

@antelopevalley

Both parents? What's the point in anyone working a mw job then? Might as well just claim benefits

RincewindsHat · 18/11/2022 12:46

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/11/2022 11:59

If someone can legitimately fund themselves without claiming support from the state, then why should they be forced to work?

This.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:45

But if your work is in minimum wage jobs then best to just wait until that time.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:41

As per my first post, you are in the longer term.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:38

But if childcare swallows up one wage, then it does not matter if you theoretically apportion it to both salaries. You are still no better off with two going out to work than one.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:35

I'm not middle class 🤷‍♀️

I'd have fully subsidised childcare available to all of possible.

I dont think the poor should work for 'no money' (it could be argued that if you can afford to fund a sahp on 1 wage you're not poor anyway) but saying all your wage (always the womans and never the mans) will go on childcare and think thats always a bad thing is short sighted at best

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:29

And only poor people are expected to work and not actually make any money from it.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:28

I don't give a shit about the middle-class ideal of not relying on the state. I don't, but not because of ideology.
But I will do what makes economic sense. If that means working I will do it. If that means claiming benefits I will also do that.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:26

Well almost everyone works for money.

There is a cost benefit analysis in most things. That should include long term. Not just short tern. Not completely relying on the state or anyone else should always be a factor

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 12:23

@Topgub That sounds like someone in a decent job with talk of pensions and mental health.
Loads of jobs are bad for people's mental health and childcare costs during school holidays and afterschool can still make work not worth doing. No way would I work unless it was for money.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:16

Better income once kids get free hours/are in school. Not having to try to get back into work after a long break, not losing skills and career, keeping paying pensions/NI. Benefits to mh. Financial independence.

@antelopevalley

Topgub · 18/11/2022 12:14

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 11:05

I think you may have missed my point. Choice is something many people don’t have.

Firstly, childcare wasn’t an option for us, we have a handful of local providers and they had no spaces. I didn’t have a car and live rurally with virtually no public transport. I meant that even if there were spaces and we could’ve paid, why would I want an entire wage plus a chunk of my husbands to go just on childcare.

Also, what about the long term benefits of staying at home with children (works both ways) and all the time we wouldn’t have had together.

I was actually lucky enough to pick up some wfh work, and when I say lucky, what I mean is, I was in the right place at the right time, it wasn’t a job being advertised and I wouldn’t have got it had I not been where I was that exact moment. Although this was not a wage and not regular enough to be relied upon.

It’s not as cut and dry as “we made it work”, that’s a very narrow view often made by someone who relies on their own opinions as facts. The ability to make it work means you were in a better position than many people to start with.

I didnt miss your point. Women often say there's no point in them paying out their whole wage in childcare, like its only their cost/responsibility.

I'm not aware of any benefits of staying home with children long term.

I'm not sure I'd agree we were in a better position than others. Maybe our priorities were just different.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 11:18

Longer term benefits of working? What are they? There really are not any unless you are going to advance up the ladder.

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 11:05

Topgub · 18/11/2022 10:28

Why would you only count your wage towards childcare?

And why discount all the longer term benefits of working?

I think you may have missed my point. Choice is something many people don’t have.

Firstly, childcare wasn’t an option for us, we have a handful of local providers and they had no spaces. I didn’t have a car and live rurally with virtually no public transport. I meant that even if there were spaces and we could’ve paid, why would I want an entire wage plus a chunk of my husbands to go just on childcare.

Also, what about the long term benefits of staying at home with children (works both ways) and all the time we wouldn’t have had together.

I was actually lucky enough to pick up some wfh work, and when I say lucky, what I mean is, I was in the right place at the right time, it wasn’t a job being advertised and I wouldn’t have got it had I not been where I was that exact moment. Although this was not a wage and not regular enough to be relied upon.

It’s not as cut and dry as “we made it work”, that’s a very narrow view often made by someone who relies on their own opinions as facts. The ability to make it work means you were in a better position than many people to start with.

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 18/11/2022 10:57

He’s a dentist and earns a fortune

So could cover childcare to enable you to work / upskill.

AnnieJessie · 18/11/2022 10:43

It's not a question of "only counting the wife's wage towards childcare"

It's a sum:
If DH earns X
DW earns Y
Childcare costs Z

Then if X is > X+Y-Z then it makes no sense for Y to work., unless there are other reasons.

I know one family who cut costs and dipped into their savings because they had twins and their childcare care costs massively outstripped the wife's earnings for three years. They felt it was worth it because Y's potential future earnings.

It wouldn't have been worth it for us. Firstly, DH's job involved international travel - with the best will in the world you can't "make shared childcare work" if the partner whose turn it is to do the school pick up is in the USA, while the children are in the UK.

Secondly, DH's earning potential was massively higher than mine, so it made sense for his career to be our family priority, and our kids would have had very limited family life if we both worked the sort of hours DH works.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 10:28

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 10:11

You are spot on with that! Not everyone has friends/relatives who provide free childcare. We’re lucky to have a night a year with a babysitter. Couldn’t utilise free childcare at 3 as there were no spaces and providers were closed for a time due to covid, if we paid, it was more expensive than my wage so the best option was to stay home with one wage pennies over threshold and no benefits. Now school age and it’s not much easier.

While I do believe the system should be a safety net and not a long term choice (with exceptions for health, disabilities and carers), I do see how this becomes the only option for some people. This country makes it too hard for many families to just exist. Ultimately, we shouldn’t be in a society where we still struggle to live on 2 wages, where kids miss out on much need time with parents etc. Nobody should be too poor to have a choice, we have progressed from all women staying at home to not being able to decide for ourselves and that isn’t good progress IMO.

Why would you only count your wage towards childcare?

And why discount all the longer term benefits of working?

PiggyInTheLidl · 18/11/2022 10:22

We are not rats in a laboratory cage or contestants in the Hunger Games (or even IACGMOOH).

We will not get through this better by sniping and scapegoating and adding to the fragmentation of society.

The instinct under pressure may well be to point the finger, blame Petra to make it feel easier to pay Paulette but in the end we all need to understand, have compassion and imagination and stand alongside each other to demand the system and society that will support us all better.

Tiredqu · 18/11/2022 10:22

I fall into this group, disability that makes it hard to get a job, but not on benefits. did a few years doing crappy online self employment jobs that didn't pay anywhere near min wage, dh has a wage that enables us both to live now, so that's what we do, took the stress and pressure off me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread