Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
TollgateDebs · 18/11/2022 17:31

@healthadvice123 Did you know, that the employment and training teams, funded by housing associations, are more successful in helping people into work than many of the 'hyped' programmes running with funding from the DWP and counting on referrals from Job Centres. If anyone on this thread, or you know of anyone, that is living in a property managed by a housing association, then please encourage them to ring in and see what help can be given. I am an Employment and Training Officer, for a large housing association, and cover the full range of support from producing a CV from scratch (I've been a recruiter, worked in multiple industries, taught in schools, colleges and universities....) so know what is needed to get results, to conducting mock interview, skills audits, helping with upskilling and access to accredited and funded courses, apprenticeships, looking at sustainable work and even signposting to vacancies that are not easy to trip over; you name it, if it helps we will throw it into the mix of help we offer. We helped over 400 people into work last year and some had not worked for years, or were struggling to even get an interview, so please do ring if you are connected to a HA for your housing to see if they can help. Many HAs also offer money advice and benefits and well-being and we brought in an additional £2.5m in benefits for our customers last year! There's a great deal of help out there and we bang our heads in frustration at how often we try to get Job Centres to look beyond their own doorstep!

the80sweregreat · 18/11/2022 17:22

A lovely lady caller on lbc today with James o Brien summed it up : she was tired of the rat race and managing people , so it was early retirement and having time for herself
She felt guilty, but it sounds as if she worked for years and had just had enough of it all
Working is hard these days ; it's long hours and your not appreciated at all
Anyone getting out of it , I don't blame them at all

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 18/11/2022 17:01

There is a difference between what women are PAID and what they choose to EARN.

Men and women are PAID comparably in most jobs. Women tend to EARN less because they choose lower-paid occupations, and/or voluntarily take time out of the workforce for personal reasons.

There's no standing to complain about the latter; no one is forced to have kids or make other lifestyle choices that necessitate dropping work. Childfree women who don't take large gaps generally are economically equal to men who don't take gaps.

The notion of "having it all" was always absurd. There are tradeoffs financial, career, social, etc. to every lifestyle choice. Presumably the joy of having children outweighs the resulting economic hardships.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 16:56

@Battyfumworts

Ok

You find me stats that prove me wrong then.

Or that agree with you and most men are earning double what their female ohs are pre kids

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 16:52

The first claims that the gender pay gap is still large and relates to fertility (as I said earlier some employers actively avoid employing women of childbearing age), it also uses a report from the U.S and incomplete data from UK councils who also are government departments.

The ONS is a government department.

And the last 3 are referring to life in other countries, mainly the U.S.

Joystir59 · 18/11/2022 16:34

I'm in this category, but I'm 65 and work part time. No intention doing more.

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 16:19

Topgub · 18/11/2022 14:52

@Battyfumworts

The stats don't come from the govt.

It's statistically rare for a man to be earning double his female partner pre kids. Most couples will be earning similar amounts.

And yet its still women giving up work and going part time

What stats are you referring to? Where from?

SirMingeALot · 18/11/2022 15:57

Jaxhog · 18/11/2022 15:50

I doubt he has a problem with people who don't work and don't claim any benefits. Why would he? It's people who COULD work but choose not to and then claim benefits, he is concerned with. As should we be.

We know that Hunt is concerned about the shrinking workforce and the number of 'economically inactive' people (stupid term) because he's said as much. We have a labour shortage and so naturally he would prefer people who could work but choose not to because they can financially support themselves without doing so to be back in the workplace. But obviously he can't just make them.

ComtesseDeSpair · 18/11/2022 15:55

Getoff · 18/11/2022 15:43

Even when women are the higher earners its still more likely to be them who give up work.

This could be evidence that though almost as many men as women say they want children, when it comes down to what sacrifices you're willing to make to have them, it turns out women want them more. (I don't know that this is true, it's something I suspect is true, that I wish I could find some evidence for.)

It’s also why it isn’t always necessarily true to talk about the “sacrifices” which women make in terms of putting their career second to their family. All the women I know who became SAHMs or went part-time did so as an absolute non-negotiable - even where their OH would have preferred to a) not have children or b) to have them in childcare and for her to work full time so the burden of being breadwinner didn’t fall on him.

But in terms of men outearning their female partners even well before they have children, I think that’s a systemic result of both a) women still being underrepresented in STEM and other occupations which offer huge progression and b) a lot of women actually starting off in their working life knowing that they’d probably like a family at some point and assuming that it will be their career which takes a backseat if they do, so investing in it less than men do right from the start. I’m still not sure how we adequately address either.

midgetastic · 18/11/2022 15:54

He has a problem with people who don't work and don't claim benefits because we have a huge problem of not enough workers which is harming the economy

Jaxhog · 18/11/2022 15:50

I doubt he has a problem with people who don't work and don't claim any benefits. Why would he? It's people who COULD work but choose not to and then claim benefits, he is concerned with. As should we be.

Getoff · 18/11/2022 15:43

Even when women are the higher earners its still more likely to be them who give up work.

This could be evidence that though almost as many men as women say they want children, when it comes down to what sacrifices you're willing to make to have them, it turns out women want them more. (I don't know that this is true, it's something I suspect is true, that I wish I could find some evidence for.)

Getoff · 18/11/2022 15:38

The reason many use the woman’s wage as a reference is because women are still often paid significantly less than men

It would be more accurate to say that wives earn less than husbands. Women have a tendency to marry men who are slightly older than them, and who earn more than them. Wives can earn less than husbands even if women earn the same or more than men.

SirMingeALot · 18/11/2022 15:29

I doubt many men are earning double what their partners do pre kids, it's a smaller gap than that. There isn't much difference between what men and women of the same age earn before that, but the female partner is usually younger.

Additionally, it's important to remember that looking at data pre kids misses out the discrimination that happens to women when they get pregnant. The relevant figure isn't actually the one pertaining to the period before the woman does the thing that's liable to have an impact on her earnings.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 18/11/2022 15:28

I am surprised that any school does not have after-school care these days, whether after school club or childminders. My ds' school didn't and doesn't have an after-school club because the local childminders lobbied against it, but did and still does have a breakfast club. Maybe parents need to get lobbying too. I know covid affected things, but it's time to get the wraparound care back.

I live rurally, our village school is large for the area with 70 odd children. There is no pre or post school provision and we struggle with childminders as there aren't many locally and they can be spread over multiple schools.

It's statistically rare for a man to be earning double his female partner pre kids. Most couples will be earning similar amounts.

We were 37 when dc1 was born. Dh earned more than double my salary when his bonuses were factored in. I worked for the LA doing something of societal value and loved my job, he works in IT. We both pursued promotions and were on similar trajectories, mine just had a much lower ceiling but I got more job satisfaction. Most of my friends (accountants/doctors aside) had a similar discrepancy. Obviously if we'd had kids earlier then our earnings would have been closer together but we didn't want kids in our 20s.

SheWoreARaspberryBeret123 · 18/11/2022 15:08

User98866 · 17/11/2022 12:03

It’s almost like they need a large influx of working aged people Hmm

🙈🤷‍♀️

Topgub · 18/11/2022 14:52

@Battyfumworts

The stats don't come from the govt.

It's statistically rare for a man to be earning double his female partner pre kids. Most couples will be earning similar amounts.

And yet its still women giving up work and going part time

xogossipgirlxo · 18/11/2022 14:46

lieselotte · 18/11/2022 13:01

Having your own income, not having to ask DH if you want to buy new underwear, not having to rely on a man, having a life separate to the kids, having the interest a job brings (though that can come from a voluntary role too).

I am surprised that any school does not have after-school care these days, whether after school club or childminders. My ds' school didn't and doesn't have an after-school club because the local childminders lobbied against it, but did and still does have a breakfast club. Maybe parents need to get lobbying too. I know covid affected things, but it's time to get the wraparound care back.

Why would you ask your husband to allow you buy underwear? Unless you married a bully, but you don't need to be unemployed to experience financial abuse in this case.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 14:44

Agreed.
And the average wage only includes those on full time contracts. Not anyone working part-time, or on zero hour contrasts but working full time. The calculation excludes those who are most likely to be on low wages.

Familydilemmas · 18/11/2022 14:37

My Mums one of these. Effectively forced out of her job of 25 years at 62 as she wouldn’t study for a degree they were adamant her role needed. It took her a year to emotionally recover, then covid hit and within those 2 years she’s become an unpaid carer to her parents. She’s living off my Dad pension.

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 14:34

Topgub · 18/11/2022 14:20

@Battyfumworts

Yeah you do seem confused because you're arguing against points I haven't raised.

Of course women face sexist discrimination in the work place. I haven't said other wise.

But largely, the wage gap doesn't exist prekids and yet its still women giving up work and not men. Even when women are the higher earners its still more likely to be them who give up work.

We need to be asking why so many men are seemingly earning double what their female partners do before they even have kids and why in reality the stats don't back this up.

Not really, there are points you have raised further up. I’m not responding to every post individually and adding in further info and context doesn’t make me confused.

The stats are skewed to suit, just like the average wage being whatever they are claiming it is nowadays. Ultimately if any of these figures were true there wouldn’t be such a huge need for food banks, winter fuel payments, cost of living payments etc. And this claim of return to 2010 austerity levels, well plenty of people never left 2010. This government can’t lay straight in bed so I would take any figures with a very large amount of salt.

Topgub · 18/11/2022 14:20

@Battyfumworts

Yeah you do seem confused because you're arguing against points I haven't raised.

Of course women face sexist discrimination in the work place. I haven't said other wise.

But largely, the wage gap doesn't exist prekids and yet its still women giving up work and not men. Even when women are the higher earners its still more likely to be them who give up work.

We need to be asking why so many men are seemingly earning double what their female partners do before they even have kids and why in reality the stats don't back this up.

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 14:06

Topgub · 18/11/2022 13:43

No, but but neither does the sexist rhetoric of women are slaves to the wage gap.

Or the sexist rhetoric of 'it makes more sense for women to give up work'.

You seem to be confusing dont agree with and don't realise/don't understand

Ha ha ha ha ha not confused at all.

You see when referring to a specific set of circumstances, which I have, it does make more sense for the woman to give up work. Of course if the woman was earning double the man’s wage it would make more sense for him to give up work, but these circumstances aren’t as common.

Sexist rhetoric, are you a man?

if it wasn’t true then women wouldn’t be suing employers/ex employers and winning; just because you haven’t experienced something doesn’t mean it doesn’t happen. I’d bet than many women on here have.

Example, I worked in an industry for over 15 years, in 2006 I earned £1k less than I did in 2018. In 2006 I had the ability to earn unlimited commission but my basic salary was enough to live on. In 2018 I had no ability to earn overtime, commission or bonuses, my basic pay had not increase significantly but my living costs had more than doubled. A colleague at the next desk was a school leaver with no experience and was paid the same basic salary as I was, was not very good at his job, sat and talked all day, wouldn’t turn up after nights out and wasn’t productive at all, but promoted very quickly. What was the difference between us? I was efficient, productive, highly experienced and knowledgable, female, and pregnant. Other women who were also better at the job, more reliable and mature also took forever to be promoted. I have witnessed similar in a number of workplaces over the years and been part of discussions where male employers have admitted taking on men or women over child bearing age with the assumption that women of age could already be pregnant at the time of employment. That is what I would call sexist

SirMingeALot · 18/11/2022 13:56

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 13:54

And if you are on a minimum wage job, in most cases you can get back into work fine if you take time out.

Mmm. And the reality is that those jobs don't allow everyone in them to progress either. Sometimes, people (usually women) really are making the most sensible economic decision available to them when they give up work for a few years.