Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
mnhqceo · 19/11/2022 19:54

It's futile having a dogmatic opinion about other people's lives because you can never understand unless you are in their minds or have walked in their shoes.

Kidsfortea · 19/11/2022 18:53

fetchacloth · 18/11/2022 18:45

Hunt's efforts would be better placed forcing employers to be kinder and more flexible to older workers. Some employers are downright nasty to over 50s and treat their employees like a piece of rubbish to the point where some of those workers feel forced out of their jobs, or feel obliged to take early retirement against their will.
Many people would continue working beyond 60 if there were flexible working or part time options available to them.

I agree. I retired at 63, a few weeks ago. I was self employed in the hospitality trade and could not cope with the hours any longer.
I look after an elderly parent so really need a job for a couple of days a week.
Am very worried about being unemployable tbh.

Topgub · 19/11/2022 17:39

mnhqceo · 19/11/2022 16:50

Topgub - my point was that there's no point having a rigid mindset about these things. It's a waste of energy. It doesn't really matter what you or anyone else would "rather" have. Just as you exist in your own sphere will are making the best of it, other people navigate their very different lives in their own ways.

People are just answering the op.

You'd be as well saying there's no point in having any opinion on anything

Kidsfortea · 19/11/2022 16:50

MidnightMeltdown · 17/11/2022 12:36

I think the only issue is that some people retiring early will have underestimated the cost, won't have a big enough pension, and may find themselves destitute in old age.

Even if you own your own home, repairs and upkeep are expensive, and you also need to estimate the cost of inflation over the years.

I have been told by people that they don't need to worry about old age as the government will always look after them. They mean it as well.
A member of my family is withdrawing their pension to spend now.
I tried to say that it is my tax money that they will be relying on but no forward thinking at all.

mnhqceo · 19/11/2022 16:50

Topgub - my point was that there's no point having a rigid mindset about these things. It's a waste of energy. It doesn't really matter what you or anyone else would "rather" have. Just as you exist in your own sphere will are making the best of it, other people navigate their very different lives in their own ways.

WTAFhappened123 · 19/11/2022 16:09

Nope not pensioners but working age men and women making career out of claiming benefits - needs overhaul but our government are more interested in spending money rather than saving it!

Topgub · 19/11/2022 16:09

@mnhqceo

Id much rather my dd made her own millions personally. If she had to

Im not a fan of millionaires or sexism really

Topgub · 19/11/2022 16:06

@SirMingeALot

Yes the op is about paid work but someone asked me why I equate not working with not doing much.

I equate it with not doing much because its not

TimBoothseyes · 19/11/2022 16:02

xJ0y · 19/11/2022 15:47

@TimBoothseyes tell your sister to sign o for credits

She's not eligible for any benefits and will receive a full state pension when she reaches retirement age so not sure what credits you mean.

NCFT0922 · 19/11/2022 15:53

@mnhqceo all of this 🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

fetchacloth · 19/11/2022 15:53

TimBoothseyes · 19/11/2022 14:22

My sister has not worked (or claimed any benefits), since November 2020. She now wants to get back into work but, despite applying for jobs that she has 30 years of experience for and some she has no experience of but has transferable skills, she has yet to receive a single interview. At the age of 58 she has now resigned herself to the fact that she may never work again. It's all well and good saying "early retirees" should think about returning to the workforce, but if employers aren't even going to consider them then what's the point. If "older" people should be "morally obliged" to work then employers should be "morally obliged" to employ them.

I agree it's appalling how people in their 50s and 60s are treated in the workplace and it must change if this country is to get back on it's feet post covid.

With the retirement age increasing employers' attitudes must change

It's also clear that going forward, this country has to have more people in the workforce and paying tax and national insurance so something has to give.

mnhqceo · 19/11/2022 15:51

There is no point in people generalising or extrapolating their own very personal and specific circumstances / perspectives / values on this issue into other people and expecting those other people to care. That way lies madness!

For instance, would the people who argue "work is the meaning to life" apply this rigid doctrine to their own children? What if their own daughters happen to meet a mega millionaire one day, who spends three moths in Switzerland, three months in the Bahamas and so on. He buys property and investment in her name (better for tax purposes) and her children grow up in this lifestyle, with a mum who doesn't work, but throws herself into life in other ways. Would you seriously be telling them to jack it all in to stay put in the U.K. doing the same job for ever more? Would their lives be meaningless? I don't think so. Maybe different to your life, but not by any means meaningless because life is what you make it. Think of all the experiences and time snd freedoms she would have that you wouldn't. This is why there is no point in rigid thinking. Everyone has to find their own path and their own optimal balance. Live and let live!

RPerrin · 19/11/2022 15:49

ScrawlyEmbroidery · 19/11/2022 14:53

I watch a lot of off-grid lifestyle videos on YouTube and do ask this question when I see some people. There are a fair number of people who live outside the "system" and they grow their own food, make their own electricity and do whatever the minimum is for them to buy in the things they can't make themselves. And that's all roses up until you factor in old age, emergencies, publicly funded things (roads, libraries, street lights, street cleaning etc) and other such things that can only exist from other people paying into a larger system.

I think people are morally obligated to contribute to a system that they also benefit from. It's difficult to say how much that contribution should be - but it almost certainly doesn't amount to a 40 hour work week.

If the channels you watch are a decent number of subscribers they will self employed as content creators and paying tax anyway.

xJ0y · 19/11/2022 15:47

@TimBoothseyes tell your sister to sign o for credits

SirMingeALot · 19/11/2022 15:44

I count volunteering and caring for disabled kids or elderly parents as work.

You're coming at this from a different standpoint to the OP then, which is about paid work. I agree that caring labour is work, but it looks like most people are responding in the context of the thread being about paid jobs. This may explain the different conclusions.

xJ0y · 19/11/2022 15:44

@TimBoothseyes
Completely agree

ScrawlyEmbroidery · 19/11/2022 14:53

I watch a lot of off-grid lifestyle videos on YouTube and do ask this question when I see some people. There are a fair number of people who live outside the "system" and they grow their own food, make their own electricity and do whatever the minimum is for them to buy in the things they can't make themselves. And that's all roses up until you factor in old age, emergencies, publicly funded things (roads, libraries, street lights, street cleaning etc) and other such things that can only exist from other people paying into a larger system.

I think people are morally obligated to contribute to a system that they also benefit from. It's difficult to say how much that contribution should be - but it almost certainly doesn't amount to a 40 hour work week.

KimberleyClark · 19/11/2022 14:53

I know two women who gave up work when their first child was born and never went back. Both their first (of several) children are in their early thirties now. As someone who worked for 38 years full time without breaks for children, and retired at 58 I don’t think I’ve contributed any more or less than they did.

Topgub · 19/11/2022 14:47

Well people are saying work is harmful, that's why they don't want to do it. Harmful to mh etc.

I can't imagine if thats the case they are doing much incase it harms their mh?

I count volunteering and caring for disabled kids or elderly parents as work.

People seem to be suggesting it's OK to never work or even that not ever working should be the ideal because of the harms (environmental, being taken advantage of etc)

But if that's the ideal, how does society function?

NCFT0922 · 19/11/2022 14:42

Topgub · 19/11/2022 14:21

I honestly can't imagine a life where you have never worked.

Being unemployed has proven detrimental affects on mh.

60 to 80 years is a long time do to not much.

Why do you assume not working equates to not doing much?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 19/11/2022 14:30

DrFoxtrot · 18/11/2022 20:28

All the PP saying they don't work, don't want to ever get back into work, don't use taxpayer funded services (Confused) - let's hope that enough of us carry on to keep the country going, eh? Keep contributing so that there's money for those who need benefits and the essential services.

I contributed for 45 years and I've yet to hear anyone say thank you.

TimBoothseyes · 19/11/2022 14:22

My sister has not worked (or claimed any benefits), since November 2020. She now wants to get back into work but, despite applying for jobs that she has 30 years of experience for and some she has no experience of but has transferable skills, she has yet to receive a single interview. At the age of 58 she has now resigned herself to the fact that she may never work again. It's all well and good saying "early retirees" should think about returning to the workforce, but if employers aren't even going to consider them then what's the point. If "older" people should be "morally obliged" to work then employers should be "morally obliged" to employ them.

Topgub · 19/11/2022 14:21

I honestly can't imagine a life where you have never worked.

Being unemployed has proven detrimental affects on mh.

60 to 80 years is a long time do to not much.

SirMingeALot · 19/11/2022 14:06

Work gives meaning and dignity to life.

Universalising your experience like this is not going to aid your understanding. There's nothing inherent about working that means it does either of those things. It just does for some people, that's all.

Also, I wouldn't say workplace practice has improved hugely in the last 40 years. There are some things that are undeniably better, yes, but a lot of jobs have undergone shittification in recent decades.

TheLostNights · 19/11/2022 13:16

I know someone who was able to give up work mid forties as her husband is a very high earner. She now judges everyone else for not working enough. 😕 I would love to be in her position.
Work is definitely not everything and your job role does not define you as a person. If others are in a position not to work as are financially ok then good on them. I would as I say, give up working tomorrow if I could. I get no joy from it and it causes so much anxiety.

Swipe left for the next trending thread