Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
2tired2careanymore · 17/11/2022 12:38

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/11/2022 11:59

If someone can legitimately fund themselves without claiming support from the state, then why should they be forced to work?

So that they are forced to pay more tax.

whowhatwerewhy · 17/11/2022 12:38

@wherearebeefandonioncrisps
That's how I understand it , several in my workplace who refuse overtime as it affects there UC .

KvotheTheBloodless · 17/11/2022 12:38

ChuggingtonMum · 17/11/2022 12:04

Just been made redundant, am job hunting. Too much in savings to claim benefits.

I'm doing what I can, Jezza.

You're entitled to 6 months of the jobseeker's element of Universal Credit based on your National Insurance contributions (assuming you paid them).

Liebig · 17/11/2022 12:37

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2022 12:35

I think there are a lot of early retirees who think or feel as though they’ve earned their keep and thus the right to sit back and claim their pension, when the reality is that the tax and NI they paid during their lifetimes didn’t even cover the services they and their family used, let alone decades of a state pension. Which isn’t an attitude I’ve much time for

Using your logic no-one would ever be entitled to state pension as their tax and NI didn't cover it. Fortunately the state has made the deal with pensioners that if they pay into the state system for a certain amount of time they are entitled to that pension.

And I bet you'll claim yours when the time comes. You can say thank you for the 45 years of tax I paid and am still paying to educate you and your children and give them healthcare in your own time. I'll have been paying tax for a lot longer than I'll be claiming pension, that's for sure.

Thing is, there is nothing like the resources available to honour these pension obligations globally. People are being promised things that can’t physically be provided when the time comes to call it in.

Buteverythingsfine · 17/11/2022 12:37

Of course people aren't morally obliged to work if they can support themselves. Good for them that they have seen that the workplace simply doesn't care for them, and sees them as a unit of production, and they can resist that if they have the money to do so. Most jobs are very boring and not even highly valuable to society. I think the experiments with a four day week in Nordic countries to provide better work-life balance deliver much better job satisfaction and happiness. I like to work myself (mid-fifties) as I like my job and it keeps my mind active, but if I hated it, I'd be the first out of the door. It's immoral to expect you to do otherwise, given you never know how long you will live or whether you will see retirement.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 12:37

People are always paying taxes anyway do early retirees etc , every time they pay vat etc its a tax paid , c tax etc

CoffeandTiaMaria · 17/11/2022 12:37

I retired at 64, completely burned out, no way could I work any longer.
I have an NHS pension and private pension so I managed until my state pension kicked in.
I do volunteering as and when I can and don’t feel I owe anyone anything. I have paid tax (and NI) since I was 15, I pay tax on my pensions.
I’m lucky and I appreciate where I am but no way at 69 am I going to be going back to work!

MidnightMeltdown · 17/11/2022 12:36

I think the only issue is that some people retiring early will have underestimated the cost, won't have a big enough pension, and may find themselves destitute in old age.

Even if you own your own home, repairs and upkeep are expensive, and you also need to estimate the cost of inflation over the years.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 12:35

Would rather we target those on benefits who can work and I don't care if thats only a 1000 , its still a 1000 more people with better life prospects

Parky04 · 17/11/2022 12:35

I'm 51, fit and healthy and have no intention of returning to full time work. I do cash in hand work when it suits me. If we didn't have that ridiculous lockdown, then I would still be in full time employment paying an awful lot of tax!

Nolongera · 17/11/2022 12:35

Waterlooville · 17/11/2022 12:27

I can see the OPs point. You can have all the money in the world to support yourself but if there is no-one to staff shops, restaurants, visitor attractions, airports etc you're not going to able to do much. That's without considering staff in the NHS, utilities, schools, police etc. If there aren't enough workers the country will fall apart, regardless of how much the early retirees, sahms etc say they support themselves. It feels we are moving towards that point. The workers can only provide infrastructure to a certain number of other people. There is a tipping point.

Make these jobs attractive then.

I thought the current government were mad keen on " The Market"?

Doesn't the market solve everything?

COVID and Brexit changed the market, we can't import people to treat like shit and many of our own people are sick of being treated like shit.

This is " The Market" now.

Both of us worked in jobs that are now desperate for staff, they claim the can't get staff for love nor money.

Things they haven't tried, love, money.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 17/11/2022 12:35

I think there are a lot of early retirees who think or feel as though they’ve earned their keep and thus the right to sit back and claim their pension, when the reality is that the tax and NI they paid during their lifetimes didn’t even cover the services they and their family used, let alone decades of a state pension. Which isn’t an attitude I’ve much time for

Using your logic no-one would ever be entitled to state pension as their tax and NI didn't cover it. Fortunately the state has made the deal with pensioners that if they pay into the state system for a certain amount of time they are entitled to that pension.

And I bet you'll claim yours when the time comes. You can say thank you for the 45 years of tax I paid and am still paying to educate you and your children and give them healthcare in your own time. I'll have been paying tax for a lot longer than I'll be claiming pension, that's for sure.

wherearebeefandonioncrisps · 17/11/2022 12:35

Those 600,000 + on UC are to be given extra mentoring in order to encourage them to increase their hours.
That's how I understood it.

lieselotte · 17/11/2022 12:33

She worked on for a bit then gave up as she said that she felt as she no longer needed to work, she was taking a job from someone who did need. She felt morally obliged to step back and free up a job for someone else

That is a very reasonable argument.

lieselotte · 17/11/2022 12:33

Personally I work, but part time, and have zero intention of working as much as I could. This is very affordable for my household, not funded by top up benefits so the coercive opportunities are limited, and if anyone suggested there's a moral obligation to work more, the response would be derisory laughter

Same here. I work 3 days a week plus a bit of freelance work. I have no intention of doing longer hours, I don't need to to fund the lifestyle I want.

If Hunt wants more economically active adults, he needs to do something about (a) childcare costs - I'd make the care for the first child tax deductible and (b) ageism which keeps over 50s and even some over 40s out of the employed workforce.

Liebig · 17/11/2022 12:33

Dontaskdontget · 17/11/2022 12:30

This is an interesting conversation. We pay £100000+ in income tax a year, and we have private healthcare, private dentists, private school etc. Certainly never had any help paying for opticians! I use council bin collection but not much else. Don’t even have streetlights on my road. Not everyone is a getting out more than they put in, some you could say are being ripped off funding services for others over which they have no control.

Got your own police, fire, ambulance, utility infrastructure and roads too? Living the high life there.

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 12:33

Ageism is an issue too. Especially in some sectors and for women. That could be better.

WinterLobelia · 17/11/2022 12:32

Interesting. i have a former colleague who inherited a shedload of money.

She worked on for a bit then gave up as she said that she felt as she no longer needed to work, she was taking a job from someone who did need. She felt morally obliged to step back and free up a job for someone else.

I had never thought of it in that way before.

Babyroobs · 17/11/2022 12:31

The chancellor has announced more help to get people back to work. I do think there are a lot who could work with the correct support. Some people just seem to get onto the mindset that they will never work again. I guess it's fair enough people retiring early if they have worked and paid into the system for years but too many have never worked. I'm not talking about those that can't work through disability or because they are carers.

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 12:31

A huge number of Britain’s ‘economically inactive’ citizens are actually quite busy working as unpaid carers for the elderly/young

Yep

Dontaskdontget · 17/11/2022 12:30

emmylousings · 17/11/2022 12:25

So you don't use any council services? Never used NHS? Opticians? Dentists? Don't use business services, which depend on an educated workforce? The fact you don't have kids is irrelevant. The previous OPs post is quite correct in stating that the value of services you use and pension you draw down, is more in cash terms than the average earner pays in. A fact which people completely ignore when they say "I've paid in all my life" etc

This is an interesting conversation. We pay £100000+ in income tax a year, and we have private healthcare, private dentists, private school etc. Certainly never had any help paying for opticians! I use council bin collection but not much else. Don’t even have streetlights on my road. Not everyone is a getting out more than they put in, some you could say are being ripped off funding services for others over which they have no control.

WatchoRulo · 17/11/2022 12:30

Afterfire · 17/11/2022 12:29

I think it would be nice if people stopped thinking in terms of “paying in / taking out” for public services. It perpetuates this view that those who are less fortunate and need more services / help are somehow there because of their bad choices when quite often that just isn’t the case. Disability and poverty can and does affect people from all walks of life.

Exactly - all these "weel how much have you paid in" wonks are anti-society - the anti-social children of Thatcher.

TimBoothseyes · 17/11/2022 12:30

CornishGem1975 · 17/11/2022 12:12

From the BBC...

Hunt says he is committed to helping people raise their income, find work and become financially independent.

To this end, he announces he will ask over 600,000 more people on universal credit people to meet with work coach "so they can get the support they need to increase their work hours or earnings."

Can you just imagine that conversation "Sorry boss I've got to take some time off to see my work coach...apparently you're not paying me enough or giving me enough hours. Oh and if you can't/won't do either of those then I'm going to need more time off so that i can get another job that will. You're ok with that aren't you?" Bet employers are going to love that idea.

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/11/2022 12:29

Wishawisha · 17/11/2022 12:25

Yes this. If your household has enough to support itself without state help then I don’t care how many of you work, if none of you work. It is no one’s business and I don’t see how it’s a dilemma or a difficult question.
If you are not asking anything of the state, the state can butt out.

Do any of us live without state help? Even if we don’t have our own DC to educate we benefit from other people’s receiving the education which alllws them to carry out vital jobs. We all expect the police or the fire brigade or the ambulance service to show up if we need it. We presumably quite like that the criminal justice system keeps the bad guys off the streets, and that social services try to ensure older people can receive care.

Considering the Tories are so often roasted for Thatcher’s claim that “there’s no such thing as society” it seems odd to essentially agree with them like this that we all only owe a duty to our own immediate families and nothing further.

Dragonskin · 17/11/2022 12:29

I think as long as you are self sufficient and don't expect others to pay for you not to work/to only work part time, then no you aren't morally obliged to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread