Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
Dinosauratemydaffodils · 22/11/2022 23:27

I would provide much less at the state level except to people who really can’t work and reduce income tax so if you are working it works out the same but if you’re not working and could then you need to get a job. Eg no NHS for most people but reduce basic rate income tax to 15p or whatever so a working person can afford private insurance using the tax saving.

What about people who don't meet your threshold for not working but can't get a job? Last year I applied for loads of minimum wage type jobs (mostly service type jobs), I didn't get a single one. The ones I asked for feedback said they didn't think I'd stick it given my previous experience/qualifications so they went with someone else.

LauraIAm · 22/11/2022 20:10

@KimberleyClark @bridgetreilly @PiggyInTheLidl @Onnabugeisha @lieselotte Fair point, if people are paying income tax on unearned income plus VAT, road tax etc such that they pay in what they are likely to cost over a lifetime plus their share of what needs to be put in to cover people who really can’t work, I am ok with that. However I doubt most people’s VAT & road tax etc comes anywhere near this. Tax on unearned income for wealthy and retired people might.

@lieselotte I don’t know how to format a quote but you said “Who do they think should be paying for people who can’t work

The younger workforce who still need to work to pay their mortgages/rents?

And pensioners who pay income tax.” I’m not sure why you think younger people or pensioners should be paying YOUR share of what needs to be put in to cover people who really can’t work?

@Dinosauratemydaffodils What would I do to encourage people to work? I would provide much less at the state level except to people who really can’t work and reduce income tax so if you are working it works out the same but if you’re not working and could then you need to get a job. Eg no NHS for most people but reduce basic rate income tax to 15p or whatever so a working person can afford private insurance using the tax saving.

Nicklebox · 22/11/2022 19:26

ClearHead · 17/11/2022 12:20

I never went back to work once we had children and our children are now teens. My partner works, we don’t claim benefits. I do lots to contribute but I like being here for the kids, even though they’re teens.

Morally, should I work to personally contribute tax, who knows?

Same here i never went back to work I have inherited money which paid off mortgage and invested the rest to provide some interest. Also now get a work pension. My husband now only does 4 days a week. We do not claim any benefits and dont need any extra income.

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 17:31

Well if you pool your money like a lot of married couples, does it make any difference? It’s still the same drop to the overall household income
I hear you and maybe it shouldn't make a difference but sadly it is used all to often to ensure that it's women who sacrifice their career ambitions & earning potential rather than men

CurlyhairedAssassin · 20/11/2022 17:28

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 17:20

true, but I think it's also a huge problem that society see's childcare as a cost to be deducted from the mother's wage, it should be seen as a cost borne jointly by both parents

Well if you pool your money like a lot of married couples, does it make any difference? It’s still the same drop to the overall household income.

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 17:20

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/11/2022 08:37

If childcare were a lot more affordable, I dare say quite a few women who at the moment can’t afford to work, since their earnings won’t cover childcare costs, might well think of returning to work.

true, but I think it's also a huge problem that society see's childcare as a cost to be deducted from the mother's wage, it should be seen as a cost borne jointly by both parents

Soothsayer1 · 20/11/2022 17:17

Onlyforcake · 20/11/2022 15:49

I'd love a job. I've had to leave my care job because I can't work until 9.30 pm nor on some other shifts start until 8.00. I've been in the job for a year but now I'm out unless I can change my life so can do that. I can't get childcare for it, so not a single call for me. I'm looking hard for more work. Nothing yet. So don't believe the rhetoric they're on their knees for carers. It's ludicrous.

I've had to leave my care job because I can't work until 9.30 pm nor on some other shifts start until 8.00
that does seem mad, why wont they be more flexible if they are desperate for staff?? Are employers just too used to having the whip hand?
I hope you find something soon @Onlyforcake 🙏

Onlyforcake · 20/11/2022 15:49

I'd love a job. I've had to leave my care job because I can't work until 9.30 pm nor on some other shifts start until 8.00. I've been in the job for a year but now I'm out unless I can change my life so can do that. I can't get childcare for it, so not a single call for me. I'm looking hard for more work. Nothing yet. So don't believe the rhetoric they're on their knees for carers. It's ludicrous.

Topgub · 20/11/2022 12:42

@NCFT0922

Sorry, I've lost your point? I was talking about your comments about me judging and disliking when I haven't mentioned either.

What happened to you?

NCFT0922 · 20/11/2022 12:39

@Topgub You think? That’s pretty much what happened to me. I’m bemused you think it’s a misrepresentation.

Topgub · 20/11/2022 10:55

@NCFT0922

Thats an awful lot of strawman

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/11/2022 08:37

If childcare were a lot more affordable, I dare say quite a few women who at the moment can’t afford to work, since their earnings won’t cover childcare costs, might well think of returning to work.

fetchacloth · 20/11/2022 00:01

chaosmaker · 19/11/2022 23:10

Society needs to start encouraging and rewarding the childfree before we reproduce ourselves into extinction.

I wish, but it's not going to happen in my lifetime.

I agree but too late to change the direction of travel.

Liebig · 19/11/2022 23:41

AnnieSnap · 19/11/2022 01:10

A tax that remains payable even after retirement

Because, as mentioned above, there is nowhere near enough going into the system to account for the expected value needed.

I’m happy for this burden to go onto corps and rich individuals, however.

chaosmaker · 19/11/2022 23:10

Society needs to start encouraging and rewarding the childfree before we reproduce ourselves into extinction.

I wish, but it's not going to happen in my lifetime.

chaosmaker · 19/11/2022 23:09

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 21:38

We are supposed to accept that having children is a choice
It is a choice, but it's also the most important work, growing birthing & nurturing new humans, there is growing awareness that we dont have enough new ones, just because you dont get paid for it, doesnt mean it's not contributing to society, it is VITAL work

The world is overpopulated. The answer is for more migration so that each country has enough people for its needs. Also giving those people a means of survival especially if they are from areas with more mouths to feed than jobs. Would disrupt countries that are badly run as their population would be able to seek better conditions elsewhere. It's really not that hard a problem. Too many people is screwing up the planet.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/11/2022 22:42

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 22:08

We have more than enough human beings
yes, lots of elderly, but falling birthrates now threaten population collapse

Ridiculous. Inform yourself.
We are killing this planet and every species on it with our excessive reproduction. The trajectory is still upwards, regrettably.

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 22:08

We have more than enough human beings
yes, lots of elderly, but falling birthrates now threaten population collapse

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/11/2022 21:58

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 21:38

We are supposed to accept that having children is a choice
It is a choice, but it's also the most important work, growing birthing & nurturing new humans, there is growing awareness that we dont have enough new ones, just because you dont get paid for it, doesnt mean it's not contributing to society, it is VITAL work

The planet is burning and the global population just passed 8 billion. We have more than enough human beings and there is no looming shortage. Other species are dying off every single day thanks to us.

Society needs to start encouraging and rewarding the childfree before we reproduce ourselves into extinction.

Soothsayer1 · 19/11/2022 21:38

We are supposed to accept that having children is a choice
It is a choice, but it's also the most important work, growing birthing & nurturing new humans, there is growing awareness that we dont have enough new ones, just because you dont get paid for it, doesnt mean it's not contributing to society, it is VITAL work

NCFT0922 · 19/11/2022 21:12

geraniumsandsunshine · 19/11/2022 20:51

Question- if you don't work, but don't claim benefits, do you still get the same access to NHS etc? I wonder if that's the problem in that by not paying tax there is no contribution.

You can buy better access to the NHS. Many of my social group do. They don’t work.
The majority of people I know who don’t work but don’t claim benefits fall into the wealthy spouse/family group.

NCFT0922 · 19/11/2022 21:10

Topgub · 19/11/2022 16:09

@mnhqceo

Id much rather my dd made her own millions personally. If she had to

Im not a fan of millionaires or sexism really

But if she met a boy in school, they stayed together, married, had a family etc and he, at this point, was able to offer her them a very wealthy lifestyle and she WANTED to stay at home, was indeed happier doing so; you’d judge her for that? Would you really want her to be unhappy? For what?

How can you be “not a fan” of people with only a similar wealth in common. It’s not like they’re a homogeneous bunch. That’s like saying “I’m not really a fan of people who earn between 30-35k a year” as though they will all be the same and not providing any reason for this generic dislike of a hugely diverse bunch of people.

Tired2tired · 19/11/2022 20:58

geraniumsandsunshine · 19/11/2022 20:51

Question- if you don't work, but don't claim benefits, do you still get the same access to NHS etc? I wonder if that's the problem in that by not paying tax there is no contribution.

Yes, no one asks for your payslips when you go.

geraniumsandsunshine · 19/11/2022 20:51

Question- if you don't work, but don't claim benefits, do you still get the same access to NHS etc? I wonder if that's the problem in that by not paying tax there is no contribution.

geraniumsandsunshine · 19/11/2022 20:48

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 12:14

I would love a proper job! Could someone please point me in the direction of a decent job which allows me to work 9-2 only? Or work 9-2 in the office then make up the rest working from home? Thought not. How am I supposed to work when I have to pick up the kids from school and no employer will accommodate that?

We are supposed to accept that having children is a choice and we pay the burden so pay for childcare before and after school. Sadly, I've accepted this and whilst baby is at nursery then I hardly make anything as majority of wage is on childcare. Should be a bit better once he is at school but still have wrap around care to pay for

Swipe left for the next trending thread