Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
vera99 · 17/11/2022 13:13

These buggers get to spaff £30 billion up the wall in Truss's notorious mini-budget (and the rest not forgetting £150 bn Brexit and counting) and are happy when the plebs fight amongst themselves discussing the morality or otherwise of whether folk who are able to maintain themselves should work or not.

Got it. Punch down and around but never up. Classic Tory divide and rule.

IncompleteSenten · 17/11/2022 13:13

If it's morals were talking about, is it really morally right to take a job you don't need instead of leaving it for someone who can't financially support themselves without working?

VitaminX · 17/11/2022 13:12

It's not possible to be 'self-sufficient' in a modern welfare state. Even if you don't need specific benefits for the basic costs of surviving, you're still using infrastructure, healthcare, emergency services, the education system, etc. Everyone receives benefits. That's the whole idea behind taxation.

However, no, I do not believe we are morally obliged to work because there are many, many ways to contribute to society that add value beyond paying tax. And of course there are also lots of taxes that you pay besides income tax.

I think it's extremely complicated to settle the true balance between what each individual contributes to and takes from society.

xJ0y · 17/11/2022 13:12

Wow, cheek of him. People who aren't claiming don't need to justify themselves.
I bet a lot of these women are caring. In some capacity.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 17/11/2022 13:10

MidnightMeltdown · 17/11/2022 12:36

I think the only issue is that some people retiring early will have underestimated the cost, won't have a big enough pension, and may find themselves destitute in old age.

Even if you own your own home, repairs and upkeep are expensive, and you also need to estimate the cost of inflation over the years.

Yep, and we have a generation in their 30s who maybe won't ever be able to own their own home anyway. Who is going to pay their rent when they are retired, because I'm pretty sure their pension isn't going to cover it? There is an absolute shit storm coming in 20 years or so. People WILL end up destitute in old age.

The major, major mistake is not putting a cap on mortgage and rent limits from the end of the 1990s, combined with not building enough new houses, plus allowing too many buy to let mortgages and making houses become an investment vehicle. The most fundamental need in life is to first and foremost have shelter. Everyone needs that. It doesn't matter how much you put people's wages up, if the cost of housing keeps going up and up and up then so will the demand for wages to cover the cost of housing. If you can make housing affordable rather than spending far too big a proportion of your income on it, so that there isn't enough to cover energy or food costs (which they tell us we don't have any control over due to global issues), then people would have more disposable income to put into things like hospitality, or risking starting a new business etc. Or being more likely to be able to afford to work in low-paid but fulfilling jobs like TA, carer etc.

To me, the answer is housing, housing and housing. And the rest would follow on from there.

HumourReplacementTherapy · 17/11/2022 13:09

I dont think that was it.
It's the people who are currently claiming UC and working part time. The state is funding via a top up.
However. ....
It's not that easy. Lots of people can't increase their hours/the full time jobs aren't there and employers don't offer enough flexibility to allow someone could take 2 part time jobs.

FootfallFootball · 17/11/2022 13:09

As someone who turns 50 next birthday, I'd like better help from the National Careers Service regarding retraining, etc. Rang them recently and they were pushing me to become a TA. Because of course TAs are leaving in droves with very good reason

LaGioconda · 17/11/2022 13:08

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/11/2022 11:59

If someone can legitimately fund themselves without claiming support from the state, then why should they be forced to work?

There's a decent argument about repaying society for your education (including Higher Education), health care etc. Even if you access all those privately, chances are you are heavily reliant on work and services from people who don't.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 13:07

@DuchessDandelion 600000 with potentially families so the effect is on more than just those targeted and maybe changes that whole families prospect
You can't always just tax the companies and never address anything else as well
It takes looking at everything not just doing some things
Plus tax companies too much they leave for overseas its a balance

Sunnysideup999 · 17/11/2022 13:07

Make childcare more affordable and available and you will have lots of SAHM feeling like they could return to work without keeling over from exhaustion.
also, make it much easier to return to work after a career break (usually to raise children).
I’d be happy to go back to work as a fully trained and experienced professional , but after 5 years out of the work force, with no contacts or references or up to date market knowledge it would be virtually impossible .

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/11/2022 13:07

Luckynumbereight · 17/11/2022 13:04

No, you are not morally obliged to work. If you can find a way to live without having to work you’ve basically won at life.

However, you are morally obliged to not be a burden on others.

Can anyone find a way to live, though, in why they don’t rely on any public services - which have to be funded - whatsoever. Most of us believe that there should be a welfare state and a social safety net. If we want it to exist then we all need to think about our moral duty to fund it. There have been several posters on this threads who have basically acknowledged they want the welfare state to exist for those who need it and in case they ever need it, but also admitted that they do not personally pay into it because they don’t need to work for their own family’s needs. Is that tenable? Society is all of us. If we want the benefits of society why shouldn’t we be prepared to put ourselves out to protect it?

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 13:07

DuchessDandelion · 17/11/2022 13:01

630,000 people is nothing. Barely a blip of demographics. Will make for soundbites so it appears like the Tories are tackling the 'workshy' and economy but taxing the very rich and companies will be far more effective.

As would improving pay and working conditions in certain sectors, as well as making it financially easier to retrain.

Yep. But people are very attracted to the idea that there's a conveniently sized cohort of skivers available for the state to plug the labour market hole. It's easier than addressing the reality that we have very significant structural issues that aren't easily fixed.

Saltywalruss · 17/11/2022 13:06

Afterfire · 17/11/2022 12:07

This.

I haven’t worked since I was 32. A combination of high income when I was younger, inheritance and then subsequently disabilities means I won’t work again - I’m 42 now. It doesn’t mean I don’t contribute to society, I advise on various health related forums and am involved with charities. I really hate the way we judge people in our society by their earnings and career.

Yes, I agree. So many vital services are run by volunteers.

Aleaiactaest · 17/11/2022 13:06

I think he is talking to me at the moment…. I work 25 hours and have 4 DC. I could work more. DH works 60 hours and pays huge amounts of tax. I shall not work more for you Jeremy Dear because you are just going to tax me 40 pc if I do and if I go all out, you are going to tax me 45 per cent now. Would rather watch/supervise my DC because the shit education you are providing where I have to plug the gaps. And the poor teachers are on their knees.

I have friends in my category who are trained doctors etc, lawyers, teachers. Provide some good quality education and childcare if you want us to be at our most productive. An educated mother is always going to prioritise her DC if she is already comfortable enough.

Lozzybear · 17/11/2022 13:05

@edwinbear there is a part of me that wants to downsize our home, pay the school fees in advance, take a minimum wage job and then stick two fingers up at the future Labour government and everyone else who thinks that they are subsidising my DC’s education when in fact DH and I have been subsidising others for years. I barely use the NHS and then I am expected to pay more tax on my private health cover. It’s all bollocks and I am sick and tired of it.

Luckynumbereight · 17/11/2022 13:04

No, you are not morally obliged to work. If you can find a way to live without having to work you’ve basically won at life.

However, you are morally obliged to not be a burden on others.

ChuggingtonMum · 17/11/2022 13:04

KvotheTheBloodless · 17/11/2022 12:38

You're entitled to 6 months of the jobseeker's element of Universal Credit based on your National Insurance contributions (assuming you paid them).

Thank you. I was in the last few months of maternity leave so think I'm not not "available for work" until DC starts nursery in January but I'll look into it.

Princessglittery · 17/11/2022 13:03

ComtesseDeSpair · 17/11/2022 12:05

I think we’re morally obliged to provide for ourselves financially if we can. I think we have a moral obligation, if we expect to benefit from the NHS, the education system, and the welfare state generally, to contribute via taxation if we can or via other methods if we cannot.

I think there are a lot of early retirees who think or feel as though they’ve earned their keep and thus the right to sit back and claim their pension, when the reality is that the tax and NI they paid during their lifetimes didn’t even cover the services they and their family used, let alone decades of a state pension. Which isn’t an attitude I’ve much time for.

Early retirees do not get their state pension early they have to wait until State Pension age. At state pension age they get the state pension they have contributed to.

I am an early retiree and pay tax on my work pension, I also pay tax on savings income over £1k a year with rising interest rates I will pay more tax this year. When I get my state pension I will pay tax on that, I am therefore still contributing to NHS etc. I also pay council tax and VAT on purchases which all go to council and government services.

I am not sitting back and expecting society to fund me.

GloomyDarkness · 17/11/2022 13:03

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 12:05

I wouldn’t be surprised if a lot of them are SAHMs whose partner earns too much for them to be entitled to claim benefits, but childcare costs too much for them to be able to work.

Been there people are surprisingly nasty about it or insist it's not so as if we hadn't done the sums.

DH Uncle ended up giving up work - MIL didn't help us or her parents with even minor care - he had so many hospital appointment with both parents couldn't cope with work as well- went p/t then though oh well will only be a few years - nearly 15 and by end nearer 60 and people weren't keen to take him on.

My Dmum stopped before retirement age as she was so exhausted and her own health was starting to fail from 4 lots of GP care and medical appointments and my Dad increasingly failing health. Then they helped Dsis single mother out a lot. They did end up okay as one set of GP left some wealth to their children.

I knew a few women take early retirement to provide full time childcare for their usually daughter when they split - so they could work ft.

Also know a few who had to give up work as waiting for operations their health decline to such an extent it wasn't possible any more.

There's quite a few reason people can support themselves or really can't work.

StressedToTheMaxxx · 17/11/2022 13:03

Pixiedust1234 · 17/11/2022 12:45

I'm in this category. Three different medical conditions that enable me to have blue badge and disability bus pass but I cant claim benefits as my DH earns too much (benefits cap). Unfortunately I don't see any of his wages so I'm destitute but unable to earn my own money. Now the government want to force me? Yay 🙄

DLA isn't means tested, or at least it didn't used to be. Are you sure you've been given the correct advice? I'd look into it again.

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2022 13:02

Unless someone has found a way of buying shit without paying tax on it, or without the people you buy it from and who made it paying taxes (and so on) then nobody in the UK can possibly "economically inactive" and Jeremy Hunt is a stupid cunt.

Buy a bus ticket to your UC interview ? Then you, my friend, are economically active.

Wishawisha · 17/11/2022 13:02

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 12:37

People are always paying taxes anyway do early retirees etc , every time they pay vat etc its a tax paid , c tax etc

Yes this too, although apparently retired people get hefty discounts, we’re all paying council tax for at least the majority of our lives. VAT on almost everything we buy.
If you have a big inheritance the tax has been paid on the income originally and you’re then paying tax again when you get it. Stamp duty when you move house etc.

AnnieJessie · 17/11/2022 13:02

I'm economically inactive, fit, healthy and in my 50s.

If I were to go out to work, either my husband would have to cut back his extremely well paid hours, or we'd have to employ a part-time cleaner, a part-time gardener and a part-time carer for my elderly mother. Plus the charity I support would lose that support.

So I suppose my going out to work would create a further three part time jobs (the gardener would only be a couple of hours a fortnight, so not exactly a job).

My husband is a higher rate taxpayer, so he if cut back, and I went out to work, our tax bill would drop dramatically, so that would be a plus for us, though maybe not what Mr Hunt wants to happen. We are aware that we'd be financially better off if the hours my husband works were split between us, but he's in a job which is both specialised and important, whereas the sort of job I could get would be the sort of job anyone with the right degree could do.

DuchessDandelion · 17/11/2022 13:01

630,000 people is nothing. Barely a blip of demographics. Will make for soundbites so it appears like the Tories are tackling the 'workshy' and economy but taxing the very rich and companies will be far more effective.

As would improving pay and working conditions in certain sectors, as well as making it financially easier to retrain.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 13:00

@Pixiedust1234 you wouldn't be included or forced but why does your dh not let you have access to money that is more worrying