Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
Livinginanotherworld · 17/11/2022 13:33

Dontaskdontget · 17/11/2022 12:30

This is an interesting conversation. We pay £100000+ in income tax a year, and we have private healthcare, private dentists, private school etc. Certainly never had any help paying for opticians! I use council bin collection but not much else. Don’t even have streetlights on my road. Not everyone is a getting out more than they put in, some you could say are being ripped off funding services for others over which they have no control.

Private health care won’t help you if you are in a car accident and need an ambulance and A&E, plus you still need to call the police if you are getting robbed or attacked. Libraries, roads, rubbish collection, public services. Will you call a private fire engine if your house is on fire ?

Supersimkin2 · 17/11/2022 13:33

No one in UK is or could be economically inactive. Everyone pays tax - Mars bars are taxed to the max, for instance.

Tories after free money again. You don’t say.

Dreamwhisper · 17/11/2022 13:32

It's also so fucking stupid anyway. 630k people? Out of a population of 70 odd million? Just leave them be. If they're supporting themselves then they are already contributing economically by spending their money.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 13:31

@HeraldicBlazoning but your not claiming UC either I guess

TollgateDebs · 17/11/2022 13:31

Hunt wants functioning, productive, skilled people back, as it is affecting UK PLC and politicians really should be focusing on the real reasons that those in demand choose not to be wage slaves, when they can support themselves happily outside of the workplace! Many employers don't want to pay them what their worth and, in real terms, wages are well down on what they should be. Employees are too often referred to as head count and thought of that way. Employers talk about retiring like most of us have a choice and we don't, but if we did, what would you do? I've seen one company replace each retiree with an apprentice and then moan they can't do the job, as there is no one to train them, so you get the picture of what is driving some employers, which is profit! Me, if I could, I'd be off and doing where I felt valued and my full NI history means I pay in for something I've already qualified fully for and can't claim for 6 years, having worked in an era where private pensions didn't always get offered, companies went pop and took your money with them and then not having money to pay for the far future, when I just had enought to pay for the day!! It is only Covid that has really pushed the fast forward button on more flexible ways of working. Being a Carer is all consuming and the lack of any respite or help is frankly a national disgrace, if they don't do this job, then who does and is JH saying this is not a real job then? We've got disabled individuals stuck in their homes, often with chronic accessibility issues and what does JH think they can do and what employers would he suggest take them on, or are their roles in parliament and the civil service being made ready for them? Our parliamentarians, all of them, allowed this situation to grow like topsy and have allowed the world of work to become so squeeky tight on headcount that there is no one to supervise in many instances, no one to train and no time for someone who can't hit the ground running. Many of those retired support our communities as volunteer for all the roles that are no longer funded, mind their grandchildren, and are so vital to our society, is he suggesting they go work in Lidl and then who picks up the knock on of their actions? I work in the employability sector and a real issue is whether that individual can do anything that is valued anymore? Community volunteering requires funding and support and everyone wants this, but no one wants to fund the infrastructure. Perhaps National Service would be an answer and would certainly mandate compulsory education, work on fitness, language skills and even give those involved a skill that society would value; other countries they do this, so why not us? I agree that many would rather not work and there is a large group that should, but the way we house people (in rural areas totally cut off from where there is the demand for an unskilled workforce), where rents run at 60% of average earnings, then factor in the bills and you would struggle to stay above zero, means many are disincentivised,especially when council tax and lack of access to things like free schools meals and prescriptions (to name but a few) disappear too. We need to properly invest in schools from day one, get parents back into education and make their benefits mandatory on attendance at programmes that they might not want, but really would help them in so many ways, alongside how this would translate to future generations. We should definitely make zero hour contracts illegal (they are not the same as bank, or temp) and make childcare part of schooling from age 3, so no excuse for parents not to work. Other issues, I have people who've been waiting a year for a scan for a suspected stroke and now have lost the use of their legs, dental care causing blood infections as 3 year local waiting list for NHS dentistry, so a lack of care for a tooth, is now a health issue. Sports and leisure decimated and yet we need to keep all of our population healthy and with access to areas to help them keep well, as the well can work and not make leisure and sport something that only those with money can do. Don't get me started on the lack of resilience, mental health.... Hybrid working will help but that's for those with skills that match the work, too many have little or no value to employers and we have failed to ensure we train for tomorrow and instead we've relied on importing for today! Sorry for the rant and brain dump and sometimes repeating myself, but I sit round tables where practitioners know what is needed and are never listened to; this is such a complex societal issue. I get frustrated that for want of some common sense, a united sense of contributing to our society to make it better and approaching those who could, but don't work, with realistic practical interventions and mandatory participation in 'real' valuable training, that what we have is simply the tip of the economically inactive iceberg. Oh, by the way, Job Coach don't coach, they ensure that the person in front of them complies, and DWP funded programmes are really not working effectively either, but that's another story for another day and like so much, you get a good 'un and then you get one that ticks the boxes.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 13:30

Anyone who has retired early etc will still be paying tax if they get enough pension etc to live on , plus we pay tax in more ways that just wages
But this isn't who the work coaches are aimed at , oP thread is a little misleading really

Emmawashyourchildren · 17/11/2022 13:30

SerendipityJane · 17/11/2022 13:02

Unless someone has found a way of buying shit without paying tax on it, or without the people you buy it from and who made it paying taxes (and so on) then nobody in the UK can possibly "economically inactive" and Jeremy Hunt is a stupid cunt.

Buy a bus ticket to your UC interview ? Then you, my friend, are economically active.

Eloquently put 😆

Dreamwhisper · 17/11/2022 13:28

EndlessRain · 17/11/2022 12:01

Well, some people need to work to support the system. And those who can't work. That's the way even the most basic societies work.

Preumsably though, people who have retired have done a fair bit of work and are (again presumably) supporting themselves in their choices. Also working to support a scoiety doesn't necessarily mean paid work.

It's a tough one.

It's not really tough though because the vast majority of people will work. Either they need to so will do minimum wage jobs, or they will want to because their earning potential and career goals are high.

This stuff from Hunt is just pure ideological crap. They want a return to the Victorian era where poorer people accepted that they had to essentially give their lives away to the grind in order to survive.

Elphame · 17/11/2022 13:28

I guess I fall into this category. I'm still 10 years off my state pension.

It would have to be a very large solid 24ct gold carrot to get me back into the paid workforce again.

HeraldicBlazoning · 17/11/2022 13:28

Haven't worked full time for 20 years. Work part time self-employed, pay a little NI and income tax but not much. This is balanced by DH who pays shitloads.

Not feeling guilty in the slightest.

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 13:26

Haffiana · 17/11/2022 13:21

Amazing. They kicked out all those tax-paying forriners who were here stealing our jobs and - o dear, too many jobs unfilled now, and no tax income from them anymore.

You tolerated this, so your children will be next.

nice lyrics 😂

SofiaSoFar · 17/11/2022 13:26

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 17/11/2022 13:22

I would think he's talking about families in reciept of UC where, at least, one adult doesn't work full time.

For example, a family of 4 (two adults and two children between 4 and 10) where one adult works 30 hours per week (NMW) will recieve around £270 per week UC. going up to 39 hours reduces the UC claim to around £240. It may seem a small amount but it adds up.

The means-tested benefits bill should drastically fall with the NMW increase next year anyway.

It shouldn't be an option to just not work enough hours and then rely on the taxpayer to make up the shortfall.

Hopefully this is what he's addressing.

mimi0708 · 17/11/2022 13:25

vera99 · 17/11/2022 13:13

These buggers get to spaff £30 billion up the wall in Truss's notorious mini-budget (and the rest not forgetting £150 bn Brexit and counting) and are happy when the plebs fight amongst themselves discussing the morality or otherwise of whether folk who are able to maintain themselves should work or not.

Got it. Punch down and around but never up. Classic Tory divide and rule.

This!! Why don't the Tories take responsibility for the shit they have done. Why would I work more in shit conditions for shit pay when the government is happy to throw money to their friends and incapable of taking responsibility for what they have done. Jeremy Hunt is the master of gaslighting it makes me so mad.

luckylavender · 17/11/2022 13:23

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/11/2022 11:59

If someone can legitimately fund themselves without claiming support from the state, then why should they be forced to work?

Because if everyone did that the country would grind to a halt. No money for public services.

ForTheLoveOfSleep · 17/11/2022 13:22

I would think he's talking about families in reciept of UC where, at least, one adult doesn't work full time.

For example, a family of 4 (two adults and two children between 4 and 10) where one adult works 30 hours per week (NMW) will recieve around £270 per week UC. going up to 39 hours reduces the UC claim to around £240. It may seem a small amount but it adds up.

The means-tested benefits bill should drastically fall with the NMW increase next year anyway.

Haffiana · 17/11/2022 13:21

Amazing. They kicked out all those tax-paying forriners who were here stealing our jobs and - o dear, too many jobs unfilled now, and no tax income from them anymore.

You tolerated this, so your children will be next.

Newlifestartingatlast · 17/11/2022 13:20

Ffsmakeitstop · 17/11/2022 13:13

Absolutely spot on. If I could afford to retire without being a drain on society I would.

If you can retire early, you normally were high wages . You will still pay tax on pensionable income , so not just “funding yourself” , you’ll be continuing to support the “system” by net tax contribution.
any of same people will become higher rate tax payers when their state pension finally kicks in too. Hardly just funding themselves.
they’ll probably pay more tax than likes of Rees Mogg

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 13:18

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 17/11/2022 13:18

Well he can just fuck off generally.

I mean, yeah ☺️

OP posts:
SouperNoodle · 17/11/2022 13:18

I'm a SAHM so also in that category. I do plan to go back to work when youngest starts school next year though

FirstnameSuesecondnamePerb · 17/11/2022 13:18

Well he can just fuck off generally.

Newlifestartingatlast · 17/11/2022 13:17

EndlessRain · 17/11/2022 12:01

Well, some people need to work to support the system. And those who can't work. That's the way even the most basic societies work.

Preumsably though, people who have retired have done a fair bit of work and are (again presumably) supporting themselves in their choices. Also working to support a scoiety doesn't necessarily mean paid work.

It's a tough one.

I’m one of those early retirees you’re referring to as “supporting themselves”
. I retired at 55 . I was already signed off sick for 5 months before I left. I was in a very bad place mentally due to work related stress (business reorganisation and bullying bosses). I was also doing a job that should have been 30% time travel away form home, In last 2 years I was away from home for over 50% of my nights including weekends - mostly abroad in Europe or long haul destinations. I was jet lagged, sleep deprived and to cap it all had the most horrendous menopause symptoms including interstitial cystitis that wasn’t being treated effectively, and bowel incontinence- none of which work well on long haul flights and being in hotels.

I am very fortunate that I earned enough to have acquired sufficient pension to retire at such an early age and help myself to get to a better, healthier place.

but in referring to people like me as “self sufficient”, you are missing a big point. I’m not just “self sufficient”: people like me, who are fortunate enough to retire voluntarily early, are also paying still paying tax on their pension income, to continue to support the “system”. I will continue to pay tax when my state pension kicks in finally- some of that will be at higher rates by then (quite rightly)

So whilst I’m economically inactive on paper, I most certainly am still contributing to society’s financial needs. I also do a lot of volunteering to help society in other ways- again in common with a lot of people who can retire early.

I was contacted recently by an old ex boss asking if I wanted some short term contract work (skills I have are in demand). I seriously contemplated it for about 2 weeks as I liked working for him, and would have got a lot of money for something that I liked doing. Big as I started to really think of reality of what I’d be doing I remembered just how ill and depressed I had become . So, here i am still economically inactive.

I now use my brain in a completely different way. I could make money from it- but what I’d get wouldn’t come anywhere close to my labour time. So I do it purely for pleasure and without any pressure of having to do it.

second point: I supported my ex for 20 years as a carer and wife due to his severe and enduring mental illness. I was sole breadwinner for 20 years, effectively sole parent and the best thing he had to a CPN. At no time did we get any benefits from the state, as I earnt too much, and for those benefits he may have got he didn’t want to go through the process of applying and interviews (he had paranoia so not exactly conducive for going through interviews about his mental health). He couldn’t work- safeguarding issues meant he’d been fired a few times, exited under other reasons even more time - he was unemployable . There are thousands of families like ours where 1 person is “economically inactive” but in reality have illnesses etc that make it impossible to hold down a job but do not want to go through horrible process of applying for disability benefits. They’re on the list of “economically inactive”. In reality if they got into the “system” they’d be net “takers” not contributors”.

In all, it’s a very misleading, headline grabbing statistic. Click bait really.

If the government is batshit crazy enough to try to do something about it as a “single” entity they’re even more dumb than I thought. There are multiple complex and personal reasons people are economically inactive -a lot could be resolved with funding for NHS, mental health services, better labour regulations, menopausal support , better social care for elderly , available /cheaper child care, etc- but government isn’t going to spend money on even what we currently have, let alone resolving the route causes.

TheLostNights · 17/11/2022 13:16

I hate working. Find it mind numbingly boring, as well as physically draining. I am constantly tired. If I didn't have to work for money I would give up tomorrow. Life shouldn't be just about paying bills and then dying.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 13:15

@CurlyhairedAssassin that is so true and nobody sees it
So many were happy to make the huge profits in their houses going up but not seeing the bigger picture
Its successive goverment who have failed at this yet no one seems to recognise this
House prices and rent take a huge percentage of peoples wages , often if a couple one persons wage can be on rent
Any person on an average salary in london now cannot afford to live there, and other uk cities and places like cornwall etc
I live in a small town in sw where houses rent seems cheap compared to many parts but still 6 x peoples salary or rent one half if a couples entire wage
If we sort housing it would be a huge step in the right direction but its been allowed to go on too long

NowWhatBipolar · 17/11/2022 13:14

I’m economically inactive and don’t claim benefits.

As soon as I can access adequate mental health treatment and care, and fund retraining, and get affordable childcare, I will be able to get back into the workforce.

At the moment I’m not fit to work and wasting my best years waiting for mental health help that doesn’t seem to be coming. I’ve been in this situation for 7 years so I won’t hold my breath for change.

Ffsmakeitstop · 17/11/2022 13:13

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/11/2022 11:59

If someone can legitimately fund themselves without claiming support from the state, then why should they be forced to work?

Absolutely spot on. If I could afford to retire without being a drain on society I would.