Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 15:13

@bigbluebus but I don't think its aimed at you

bigbluebus · 17/11/2022 15:10

I'll await my instructions from Mr Hunt then and he can f*ck right off

I'm late 50's and haven't been in paid employment since I was I was 35. I had to give up work to care for my DD (who had many and varied disabilities and health conditions). Believe me I'd have preferred to carry on earning rather than survive on the pittance that is Carers Allowance for my 24/7 365 'job'. Sadly DD died in 2016 and I figured I'd earned a bit of a rest.

Because I couldn't work - due to DDs multiple illnesses/hospital stays and no holiday care, I did volunteer at a school for 13 years and multiple other charities. None of which I'd have done if I'd been working. I also volunteered at a Vaccine clinic during Covid.

DH earns enough to support us both (thankfully) and is winding down towards retirement. I get a workplace pension in 18 months time from the years I did work and am only 2 year's contributions short of a full state pension - unless they move the goalposts yet again!

I have been out of work for so long now I'd struggle to get a job in anything other than retail, hospitality or care - None of which I'd choose to work in unless I needed the money.

We don't claim any benefits (since DD died) and my DH pays more than enough tax for both of us. So I'd be interested in what JH's motivation is for sending me out to work.

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 15:09

Probablymagrat · 17/11/2022 14:55

If someone can afford to live without claiming benefits how will they 'encourage' them to return to work? It sounds like a dream life to me!

By inflating away their savings, by increasing house prices to the point where it takes two incomes to secure even the most basic accommodation preventing the future stay at home mum. By increasing the costs of food and fuel so that any fixed incomes simply just will not cover it. No doubt they have lots of tricks up their sleeves.

OP posts:
ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 17/11/2022 15:09

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 17/11/2022 11:59

If someone can legitimately fund themselves without claiming support from the state, then why should they be forced to work?

Agree with this.

There is no shortage of human beings on this poor old planet. Changes to immigration laws can take care of any labour shortage in the UK and anywhere else on earth.

FaazoHuyzeoSix · 17/11/2022 15:08

There's a fundamental difference between the question in the thread title and the detail in the OP.

From the basic laws of causality of the universe - everything decends into chaos unless work is done to prevent it and effort is put in to combat the inevitable spiral towards death. Anyone who doesn't work is living from the explotation of others, whilst still living in such a way as to generate waste, mess and chaos which someone else therefore has to deal with. So on that level yes we are morally obliged to work - as a very minimum anyone capable of doing so should be putting enough useful work and effort into the universe every day to counteract the negative impact that their existence has on the universe, plus a bit more than that to account for those to little, or old, or weak to care for themselves. This work doesn't have to be directly about feeding yourself or cleaning up after yourself - e.g. it's not exploitative for someone who is skilled at computer programming or teaching or house building to spend all their working time on exercising those skills and maybe paying others or being in partnership with others who deal with such practicalities. A life spend in ease and luxury doing no real work of importance when one has the mental and physical capacity to work is morally bankrupt and there are plenty in the1% richest who do no useful work at all, gaining all their income from the sweat of others.

But the detail in the OP isn't about that, it's about doing PAID work, and there's lots of valuable and important work that needs to be done that isn't paid, so there's no moral implication if one is doing valuable work but is nevertheless considered "economically inactive"

millymog11 · 17/11/2022 15:08

No you are not morally obliged to work at all. If your partner is wealthy enough and there is no need for you to work because you can spend his/her earnings and especially if you are able to make use of tax avoidance schemes etc there is no point at all in you working and most definitely no moral reason to work.
The UK government absolutely wants there to be "people who work and pay taxes" and separately "people who don't work because they do not need to" and they are absolutely fine with the latter category not contributing anything to society financially (apart from whatever tax is absolutely unavoidable/they cannot get away with not paying for them).

smooththecat · 17/11/2022 15:05

I work 2 days per week and absolutely would not work more in that job, which is purely for the cash and gives me nothing else. My professional job in the public sector turned out not to be as billed, that’s putting it mildly. No way I could have stayed for a whole career without getting ill. I am in training though, so I suppose I may still become more productive in future. There is a big problem with work, it’s not working for many people. The other people I know who are not in work are either too ill and being looked after by family (no benefits), or independently wealthy enough not to, but not necessarily living lavishly or spending a lot of money in the economy, just subsisting.

Tamrastarr · 17/11/2022 15:05

Why do you link encouraging these people to work and "cheap labour"? I know a few people like this, one mid-forties and one mid-fifties. They are not rich by any means, but they have planned carefully and decided to give up work as a choice. I can't see then being "encouraged" back into work and why should?

KimberleyClark · 17/11/2022 15:03

emmylousings · 17/11/2022 12:25

So you don't use any council services? Never used NHS? Opticians? Dentists? Don't use business services, which depend on an educated workforce? The fact you don't have kids is irrelevant. The previous OPs post is quite correct in stating that the value of services you use and pension you draw down, is more in cash terms than the average earner pays in. A fact which people completely ignore when they say "I've paid in all my life" etc

I said I’d never made use of many of these services. As I never had children I’ve never used maternity services, claimed child benefit, schools, free dentistry, never had NHS IVF, but have subsidised all of those things with my taxes.

Dreamingcats · 17/11/2022 15:02

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 12:05

I wouldn’t be surprised if a lot of them are SAHMs whose partner earns too much for them to be entitled to claim benefits, but childcare costs too much for them to be able to work.

This is me.

WhoWants2Know · 17/11/2022 15:00

In my experience, the number includes lots of unpaid carers for family members with disabilities. The ones who currently save the state hundreds of thousands of pounds by working for no reward. It's all very well tempting them back into work, but he'll need to spend more on carers-- especially if he wants to reduce bed blocking in hospitals.

Mumsnut · 17/11/2022 14:57

Most of the early retirees i know are teachers. Nothing would lure them back to teaching.

mam0918 · 17/11/2022 14:57

Im not sure if I could as on benefits.

I always got carers allowence as I have always been a carer since childhood (got carers since 18) and I get child benefit and Im currently waiting to here from PIP (never claimed before but should qualify from my brain damage).

I did claime income support for a year once over a decade ago but other than that no benefits but also no 'proper' job (part time self employed and make below the taxable amount so they don't really seem to care).

In the last year DH claimed UC (he is full time employed but with everything going up) so I guess that links to me as the asked me a bunch of questions but the money goes straight to him.

I have zero time, energy or urge to go be someones lacky for very little pay... If I got an employed 9-5 job with my massive CV gaps I would likely be paid a pitence. Far less than the childcare costs I would have to pay (and that not taking into account the previously mention caring I do) so would be losing money. Besides people arent falling over themselves to hire brain damaged disabled people, no previous real experiance and a bunch of prior care commitments.

Onlyforcake · 17/11/2022 14:56

I don't earn enough to be (income) taxable. I don't claim any benefits, I wonder if I am in this category or not? Possibly not, but I'd be interested if there's more information on this category.
Either way, I can't work more because it wouldn't work with school times etc. I suppose the sahp I know are mainly in this category, school age children mean IF there are two parents at least one of you is hugely restricted in availability to support the other and the children, certainly here where childcare is notable by its near absence

QueueEtwo · 17/11/2022 14:56

I bet a lot of these 'economically inactive" people are also the volunteers running the food banks, church groups, community librarie all the other stuff that a lot of people are relying since this Govt cut Public Services to the bone!

SafferUpNorth · 17/11/2022 14:55

MGMidget · 17/11/2022 14:49

There are probably lots of economically inactive mothers with good qualifications and work experience who are not working because the costs of childcare have made it not worth their while at a particular time of their lives. Maybe he could look at those barriers to help encourage some well-qualified, hardworking mums back into the workforce?

Yes, this. I am sure a significant percentage of economically inactive or under active women are engaged in some kind of caring role - be it kids, disabled adult relatives, elderly relatives. Until childcare and social care are properly funded, the govt is not giving them much of a choice. Beating them with a stick won't help.

Probablymagrat · 17/11/2022 14:55

If someone can afford to live without claiming benefits how will they 'encourage' them to return to work? It sounds like a dream life to me!

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 14:53

FavouriteDogMug · 17/11/2022 14:44

It just sounds like a made up problem the government invented to hide other problems they are responsible for and don't have a solution for. It's like when you procrastinate an important project by tidying up the cupboard under the stairs. I still think Jeremy Hunt is rhyming slang.

There's some truth to that.

Onnabugeisha · 17/11/2022 14:53

mydogisthebest · 17/11/2022 14:40

He needs to look at those claiming UC or job seekers and working cash in hand. Two couples in my street are doing that. Nothing at all stopping them working. All fit and healthy, all can drive and have a car each but don't want to work legit and pay tax.

One couple have been living like that for at least 7 years. How many others across the country are the same?

Just curious but how do you distinguish the nonworking lay abouts from the working from home neighbours? Is there a lot of curtain twitching and interrogation by the bins going on?

JustLyra · 17/11/2022 14:52

This will mean that over 600,000 Universal Credit claimants that are in work will be required to meet with a dedicated work coach so that they have support to increase their hours or earnings.

I wonder how many people will be given appointments in their work hours and then being sanctioned for either not showing or losing their job…

MGMidget · 17/11/2022 14:49

There are probably lots of economically inactive mothers with good qualifications and work experience who are not working because the costs of childcare have made it not worth their while at a particular time of their lives. Maybe he could look at those barriers to help encourage some well-qualified, hardworking mums back into the workforce?

AnApparitionQuipped · 17/11/2022 14:48

Gov UK tells me there are 5.6 million people on UC - how are the government determining which 630,000 of them will be subject to this intervention?

beAsensible1 · 17/11/2022 14:48

Storge · 17/11/2022 14:00

👏👏👏 Well said. I agree.

anyone whose ever experienced will tel you the work coaches DWP provide are garbage someone less qualified than me try to get me to apply for jobs that require driving and a car as a necessity when i dont drive. AND suggesting i ask someone in the job for a lift everyday forever.

Absolute rubbish, just wasting everyones time. 90% of roles on the government s job portal which you were required to use were just full of fake sales or MLM roles. worst 3 months of my life.

The biggest issue is that working full time in this country doesn't guarantee you the ability to house feed and clothe yourself. SO much so that there is need for a work tax credit.

Hangupsrus · 17/11/2022 14:47

@schlaar I'm working in a nursery in school hours only so that I can do school run for my dc. I'm not qualified in child care but I can still work there. Ive also worked as a midday prior to that. Perhaps you could think along these lines?

ilovebrie8 · 17/11/2022 14:45

mydogisthebest · 17/11/2022 14:40

He needs to look at those claiming UC or job seekers and working cash in hand. Two couples in my street are doing that. Nothing at all stopping them working. All fit and healthy, all can drive and have a car each but don't want to work legit and pay tax.

One couple have been living like that for at least 7 years. How many others across the country are the same?

Spot on...it is an issue that needs addressing. What an almighty mess...

Swipe left for the next trending thread