Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
ForTheLoveOfSleep · 17/11/2022 16:08

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 16:01

Yes, it would probably be sensible to raise the allowed earnings threshold for those on carers allowance. I realise many carers can't work at all, but some are effectively being forced to limit their economic activity for no reason other than system says no.

Not to mention childcare/holiday club costs for an SEN child. Here are the rates for the one at my child's SEN school.

Table of costs

Amount Cost Type

£95.00 1:1 Staff Ratio Per day

£65.00 1:3 Staff Ratio Per day

£50.00 Per day

£33.00 Per half day

JustLyra · 17/11/2022 16:08

FlamingBells · 17/11/2022 15:58

There's not enough flexibility for carers to work and keep their carers allowance or credit. It's hard managing hospital appointments, a full time job and earning a decent wage. I know lots of highly qualified people who have children with SEND who are either working p/t minimum wage jobs or not at all. It's a shame that these skilled people aren't being used for the good of the economy.

Basic support structures would help.

I worked in schools my whole career so should be ideally placed to have gone back to work when my DD started school.

She goes to a specialist school and is taken to and from bu taxi. The taxi arrives at some point between 8am and 8.30am, which is too late for me to get to work. They do offer a breakfast club from 8am, but because it’s voluntary they won’t provide the taxis earlier. To drop her off at 8am and get back I wouldn’t get to work on time because of traffic. The taxi wouldn’t cost any different to them, but they won’t do it.

Also her community dentist, physio and speech therapy are only available 9am to 2pm term time so every single appointment has to be within school time. Not a single one can be planned for before, after or in the holidays. So the last place I can now work is in a school because you can’t have time off.

hesbeingabitofadick · 17/11/2022 16:06

pollyannaperspective · 17/11/2022 16:01

Just to add a different perspective on those who, for whatever reason are not economically active in a 'working capacity', they will be making a contribution to the total tax take through their spending of whatever income they have - for example VAT on purchases, fuel duty, VAT on gas/electricity/phone etc.

Yup.
And that is all DH and I will pay until we drop.
He's 60 and I'm 50.
Neither of us will work again.

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 16:01

FlamingBells · 17/11/2022 15:58

There's not enough flexibility for carers to work and keep their carers allowance or credit. It's hard managing hospital appointments, a full time job and earning a decent wage. I know lots of highly qualified people who have children with SEND who are either working p/t minimum wage jobs or not at all. It's a shame that these skilled people aren't being used for the good of the economy.

Yes, it would probably be sensible to raise the allowed earnings threshold for those on carers allowance. I realise many carers can't work at all, but some are effectively being forced to limit their economic activity for no reason other than system says no.

pollyannaperspective · 17/11/2022 16:01

Just to add a different perspective on those who, for whatever reason are not economically active in a 'working capacity', they will be making a contribution to the total tax take through their spending of whatever income they have - for example VAT on purchases, fuel duty, VAT on gas/electricity/phone etc.

AlmostGrinchyTime · 17/11/2022 16:00

I'd love a job where I could go to exotic locations and get paid for eating non human animal genitalia, while claiming that this is for the good of my clients and my employer back home.

FlamingBells · 17/11/2022 15:58

There's not enough flexibility for carers to work and keep their carers allowance or credit. It's hard managing hospital appointments, a full time job and earning a decent wage. I know lots of highly qualified people who have children with SEND who are either working p/t minimum wage jobs or not at all. It's a shame that these skilled people aren't being used for the good of the economy.

JustLyra · 17/11/2022 15:54

Of the 8.999 million, 1.739 million want a job, and 7.26 million don't.

You mean “7.26 million don’t, or can’t” surely?

jcyclops · 17/11/2022 15:52

I just want to correct assumptions that run through this thread and provide some data.

The 623,000 economically inactive mentioned in various reports are people NEWLY economically inactive in the period July-September. The actual number of economically inactive in the UK (figures release 15th November) is 8.999 million.

The definition is "People aged 16-64 not in employment who have not been seeking work within the last 4 weeks and/or are unable to start work within the next 2 weeks." The receipt of benefits (or not) is irrelevant to these figures, except to note that those who make up the unemployed figures are not included as by definition they are seeking work.

The breakdown of these (thousands) is
Non-working Students 2408
Looking after family/home 1720
Temp Sick 161
Long Term Sick 2519
Discouraged workers 18
Retired 1157
Others 1016
Total 8999

Discouraged workers are those not looking for work as they believe no work is available. "Others" includes those not seeking work because they don't need to or are awaiting a start date or the result of a job application.

Of the 8.999 million, 1.739 million want a job, and 7.26 million don't.

JustLyra · 17/11/2022 15:51

It’ll have nothing to do with people who don’t work and fund themselves. It’ll be a subtle way to increase pressure on other people on UC to earn more or work more hours.

Thats what this government do. Look at the attack on Widowed Parents Allowance. It was dressed up as “we’re going to change it so that people can claim new bereavement support allowance if they have no children and are under 45”. Seemed like a good thing, but whilst it was for childless younger widows it absolutely slashed support to widowed parents from until their child was 18 (or they remarried) to 18 months. The Tories wanted it to be 12 months and only caved under pressure about withdrawing financial support around the anniversary.

This will be another example of a stealth remove of UC from people.

How many in work claimants will end up being sanctioned for not being able to meet their work coach because it clashes with work? I doubt it’ll be long before the number is high.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 17/11/2022 15:47

Surely if people don’t need to work and not claiming benefits it’s none of Hunt’s business? I mean by all means try to give people opportunities- help SAHPs who want to return to work to do so, let people have flexible options to ease into retirement or to allow them to care for the elderly etc. But “tackle this” sounds odd!

Or we could go back to having FMP with the EU….

PortiasBiscuit · 17/11/2022 15:45

I would welcome a more flexible work schemes for the over sixties. I expect I will retire, but then go back to my old company on a project by project basis.

OverTheRubicon · 17/11/2022 15:44

No moral obligation, but it's short sighted for a lot of people and definitely expensive as a country.

Most people in this category aren't independently wealthy, and many will still end up on benefits, one way or another. The mother unable to work due to the cost of childcare or difficulty accessing care for a dependent with serious illness or SEN isn't claiming anything now, but the years out of work will make it much harder if she ever does want to go back, even more if her marriage breaks down. When she's older, she'll still need govt funded healthcare, social care and likely state support.

Same goes for the person who is at home because they're struggling with mental or other health issues, but haven't qualified for (or haven't tried to access) disability benefits. Or the ones who have given up after many attempts. Or the others who are now working cash in hand, and aren't properly insured if they injure themselves or someone else, nor are paying into any kind of pension.

caroleanboneparte · 17/11/2022 15:44

They will be people supported by a partner. Like sahms or people who care for others but don't qualify for carers allowance. Or sick/disabled people who don't qualify for esa/sick pay/PIP.

Also people doing things like unpaid internships, recent graduates, people doing volunteering to get back to work, part time students, people who are doing creative pursuits (art/writing etc) but aren't classed as working as zero pay, and small business start ups that aren't earning yet eg hobby businesses.

Not sure if it includes prisoners?

NCFT0922 · 17/11/2022 15:43

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 15:09

By inflating away their savings, by increasing house prices to the point where it takes two incomes to secure even the most basic accommodation preventing the future stay at home mum. By increasing the costs of food and fuel so that any fixed incomes simply just will not cover it. No doubt they have lots of tricks up their sleeves.

But there are a whole group of people that this simply will not effect. There are a number of children in my DCs school who have 1 parent earning over 30k a week (professional sportspeople)

No matter how much the price of food goes up; they will not be effected.

The majority of parents in their school, us included, own multiple properties; the majority of which aren’t mortgaged. The more people who cannot afford to get on the property ladder only increases profits for this cohort as there will be more people whose only choice is to rent.

Ericaequites · 17/11/2022 15:42

If the government funded better child care options including wraparound, more women could work. Parents should share caring for the children, but what about single moms and useless husbands.

KarenOLantern · 17/11/2022 15:41

If they're not claiming benefits then presumably they are either living off their own funds or someone else is subsidising them who is happy to do so.

Some of them will be carers, SAHMs, etc., but those that aren't (like my dad when he was made redundant and lived quite comfortably off his redundancy and savings for 3 years before feeling the need to look for another job)... the only way to tempt them back into the workforce is surely to offer such good pay and conditions that it's worth giving up their leisure time for.

That's the market the Tories are normally so keen on...

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 17/11/2022 15:37

Mumsnut · 17/11/2022 14:57

Most of the early retirees i know are teachers. Nothing would lure them back to teaching.

As a student, I once had a temporary job the occupational health department of a very large local council.

There were more teachers on protracted sick leave with stress-related conditions than any other profession. In a lot of schools it's mostly crowd control and I simply cannot imagine having to do that year in, year out (I'm also an educator).

Same goes for hospital wards: it was notable how many of the nursing and medical staff were young people. I'd put very few of them at over thirty. As a recent patient, I could easily see why this would not be a longstanding profession. The conditions and working hours were dreadful.

Clovacloud · 17/11/2022 15:30

He’s got to find me first 😁

I’m 50, And I currently care for our autistic daughter. Before that I was a higher rate tax payer for 25 years (husband still is and he pays a 6 figure tax bill every year) and I’ve worked since I was 15.

We’ve had no help from any government with our daughter’s schooling or mental health care. The only benefit we’ve had was child benefit for 10 years before it was taken because we earnt too much. They have had, and will continue to have more than enough out of us. Frankly he can fuck, the fuck off.

SundownOnTheStair · 17/11/2022 15:25

If you can work, then you shouldn't expect the state to support you.
If you can't work, then the state should support you.
It's not really complex.

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 15:22

midgetastic · 17/11/2022 15:18

I think sense of duty to society can decline if you feel it's a one way street

I think we are seeing a lot of that sentiment in this thread.

midgetastic · 17/11/2022 15:18

I think sense of duty to society can decline if you feel it's a one way street

Dolleey · 17/11/2022 15:17

My fear is that they know this so the only option is force - screwing pensions and saving

Mine too. The reason I’m living in this country and not dp’s is because we can both earn more here. Making hay while the sun shines. But I prioritise saving for retirement because I don’t want to work the whole of my healthy life. If that became impossible I’d be looking into moving abroad tomorrow. If I’m obliged to work til I drop I’d rather do it somewhere sunnier.

BaddogGooddoggy · 17/11/2022 15:16

I need to work to pay the bills, like most people. Even if i could afford not to work, I still would if I was healthy as I like working and feel it is my duty to contribute to society. No slimeball politician could persuade me of that though - it’s my free choice!

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 15:15

Most of the people who've taken early retirement will have paid off their mortgages. Deliberately inflating house prices has been and will continue to be a useful tool in extracting participation from some cohorts, but not this one.