Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
Madamecastafiore · 18/11/2022 07:25

I don't need to work and have a full and active life (I do 5 hours a week hobby job) and when I did work got hideous amounts of grief from colleagues (in the NHS) who decided I didn't financially need to work and so was taking a job off of someone who did need to work!

You really can't win.

WhatNoRaisins · 18/11/2022 07:12

I've said it before in a different context but I strongly suspect few people are motivated to work by a desire to give back to society. Work has to be of benefit to yourself and your family to motivate you to do it.

SEND2022 · 18/11/2022 06:38

It would be better to make childcare more accessible to all children and a wider scope of hours

Getoff · 17/11/2022 23:52

Changes17 · 17/11/2022 14:02

So reforming childcare would be a help. I wonder if subsiding childcare might results in enough extra tax being paid to cover that cost?

How can subsidising childcare do the state or the economy any good, when the premise of the question is that her time is worth less than the cost of professional childcare?

Subsidy won't make her labour worth more, and it won't make childcare cheaper. The only way subsidy makes sense is if your way of computing the benefit regards "subsidy" as money extracted from someone who doesn't matter, so it doesn't have to be counted as a cost.

QueenOfHiraeth · 17/11/2022 23:33

emmylousings · 17/11/2022 12:25

So you don't use any council services? Never used NHS? Opticians? Dentists? Don't use business services, which depend on an educated workforce? The fact you don't have kids is irrelevant. The previous OPs post is quite correct in stating that the value of services you use and pension you draw down, is more in cash terms than the average earner pays in. A fact which people completely ignore when they say "I've paid in all my life" etc

The poster would be correct if referring to those claiming state pension but most early retirees are not able to claim that as the state pension age is fixed.
Early retirees will be living on private pensions, savings, inheritances or other assets so this is not applicable

Getoff · 17/11/2022 23:20

KimberleyClark · 17/11/2022 12:08

I think there are a lot of early retirees who think or feel as though they’ve earned their keep and thus the right to sit back and claim their pension, when the reality is that the tax and NI they paid during their lifetimes didn’t even cover the services they and their family used, let alone decades of a state pension. Which isn’t an attitude I’ve much time for.

I’m childless so have never made use of many of these services, and my taxes when working were going towards those who did use them.

If the people have earned enough money to retire early, surely they've paid as much tax and NI in that compressed timespan as other people pay by normal retirement age? In fact they will have paid more, because by compressing a lifetimes worth of working income into fewer years, they've paid more higher rate tax.

TimeFlysWhenYoureHavingRum · 17/11/2022 23:18

The "west" as a whole has an aging population. We need a certain number of people to be working and paying tax to pay for the pensions of those that have retired. That's the system we have chosen.

Onnabugeisha · 17/11/2022 23:13

jcyclops · 17/11/2022 23:07

You've hit on one of the problems with data that has been measured over many years. If you change the criteria now from 16-64 to 18-65, or exclude students then the figures are no longer comparable to previous years, and often when changes like this are made, the government of the time is accused of "fiddling the figures" (which sometimes they are, but not always).

They must have raised it from 14 and from 55 at some point? So, just adjust again and put in a statisticians note that the measure has been updated to reflect current school leaver and state pension age…

XenoBitch · 17/11/2022 23:10

How?
Will anyone economically inactive and not on benefits be getting a letter summoning them to the Job Centre?

jcyclops · 17/11/2022 23:07

Onnabugeisha · 17/11/2022 17:04

@jcyclops
Thank you for posting the full facts. I thought the majority were FT students. They really should not count them as “economically inactive” and should raise the age of measuring this from 16 to 18 as the law now requires FT education until 18. People get shocked at 9 million people unemployed, when it’s really 6.6m once you subtract the students.

You've hit on one of the problems with data that has been measured over many years. If you change the criteria now from 16-64 to 18-65, or exclude students then the figures are no longer comparable to previous years, and often when changes like this are made, the government of the time is accused of "fiddling the figures" (which sometimes they are, but not always).

Schlaar · 17/11/2022 22:51

I can tell you why a lot of people who could work choose not to. Simply because the jobs available to them are shit. Unemployment and scraping by on benefits is better than being taken advantage of and disrespected.

I’m talking about employers who only offer zero hour contracts with no reliable hours or guaranteed income. At least benefits are secure!

Employers who give so few shits about their employees that they fiddle the paperwork so they don’t have to pay sick pay or holiday pay or pension contributions. Often they falsely claim the employee is self employed in order to avoid paying. Or they offer a rolling short term contract and terminate it for several weeks every summer in order to avoid the employee gaining any entitlement to job benefits or protections. Or they hire through an agency knowing full well that they take half of the employee’s pay, because it reduces their liability compared to hiring the employee directly.

And they pull tricks like not paying employees for time spent travelling between sites, or asking them to do unpaid overtime “you don’t have to but if you’re not willing to do it we’ll have to reconsider your employment”.

It’s all about maximum profit for minimum wages, and the employee isn’t valued at all. In fact the employer ties themselves in knots trying to prevent the employee gaining any legal entitlements. Because god forbid they have to treat their employees like people and offer them a reliable salary and support them when they’re sick!

If that was what you were facing in the job market, wouldn’t you opt out too? I blame the employers who don’t want to hire permanent staff and treat them like human beings. But mostly I blame the government which has failed to legislate to prevent employers taking the piss like this.

BakedRightOff · 17/11/2022 22:41

This is me. I’m mid-40’s, highly qualified and quit my role 18 months ago. Was taxed at 45% and the stress of my role relative to the take home pay meant it was one reason of a few why I decided to jack it in. I have savings and don’t claim any benefits. I’ve been doing volunteer work and spending time with my family instead of working 80 hour weeks and being away for weeks at a time. I will go back at some point. I realise I’m lucky but it’s all relative, my work was v hard. Not as hard as some, but much harder than others.

There’s an irony on MN that another thread is asking about using £30k to pay off a mortgage and claim UC. This is a SAHM. Lots of ‘well you’re entitled to it’. I went back to work (as so many do) and paid a shit load of tax so people like that can ‘chose’ to stay home and be topped up, so don’t think anyone needs to be telling me about ‘paying in’.

PottyDottyDotPot · 17/11/2022 22:27

My DH and I are 53 and 55 and don’t work, don’t claim any benefits, pay a lot of tax so are contributing to society and we have private health cover.

SofiaSoFar · 17/11/2022 22:18

Who do they think should be paying for people who can’t work

Anyone except them.

It's the same on any MN thread talking about the economy, incomes, etc. There are plenty of people who are certain that group X and group Y should definitely get more money but no one thinks they should be the one to contribute more to fund it.

PiggyInTheLidl · 17/11/2022 22:18

lieselotte · 17/11/2022 22:05

People pay all sorts of consumption taxes - VED, VAT, fuel tax, tax in alcohol etc so they are still paying for the roads they drive on. And some people are lucky with their health and so don't use the NHS. Or aren't, but have private health insurance.

And many people retired on decent enough pensions employ cleaners, gardeners, taxi drivers. Eventually Pay for carers. Etc.

lieselotte · 17/11/2022 22:07

Who do they think should be paying for people who can’t work

The younger workforce who still need to work to pay their mortgages/rents?

And pensioners who pay income tax.

And people who don't work often pay income tax anyway.

much paid work, after all, is very destructive, to people and the environment, so is very immoral indeed this is also very true

Florenz · 17/11/2022 22:05

People should work if they are able to.

lieselotte · 17/11/2022 22:05

LauraIAm · 17/11/2022 19:38

Lots of people saying I don’t claim benefits so it’s no one’s business that they don’t work:

  1. They are still taking out of the communal pot eg driving on roads someone else is paying to maintain and using the NHS
  2. Who do they think should be paying for people who can’t work?

People pay all sorts of consumption taxes - VED, VAT, fuel tax, tax in alcohol etc so they are still paying for the roads they drive on. And some people are lucky with their health and so don't use the NHS. Or aren't, but have private health insurance.

Fantasiamop · 17/11/2022 22:02

bridgetreilly · 17/11/2022 20:32

You know what else our society relies on? People with the time and money to do volunteer work, caring, child rearing, and so many other unseen and unpaid things. No one has any moral obligation to work if they don’t need the money and frankly we would fall apart if everyone were made to work.

This.

Fantasiamop · 17/11/2022 22:00

Of course everyone is morally obliged to do what they can to support others, but this doesn't mean by doing paid work necessarily (much paid work, after all, is very destructive, to people and the environment, so is very immoral indeed). You could (were it legal) live on benefits and do far more good volunteering or looking after children or relatives than you would working in many well-paid jobs.

Fantasiamop · 17/11/2022 21:52

Most people on benefits do caring work or voluntary work, which is essential to society and wouldn't get done otherwise. I imagine a lot of those not in paid work nor on benefits are also doing essential work of some kind.

Fossie · 17/11/2022 21:44

Nolongera · 17/11/2022 12:35

Make these jobs attractive then.

I thought the current government were mad keen on " The Market"?

Doesn't the market solve everything?

COVID and Brexit changed the market, we can't import people to treat like shit and many of our own people are sick of being treated like shit.

This is " The Market" now.

Both of us worked in jobs that are now desperate for staff, they claim the can't get staff for love nor money.

Things they haven't tried, love, money.

Absolutely

Onnabugeisha · 17/11/2022 21:36

PiggyInTheLidl · 17/11/2022 21:27

And pension beyond the basic allowance is taxed too. So any pension (including the state pension amount) over £12,570 is taxed.

This. I’m totally disabled and cannot work. But I’m still a net contributor. The only benefit I receive is PIP. And I pay more in income taxes on my private disability pension than I receive in PIP. Not even everyone who is “economically inactive” & disabled is living off the State.

PiggyInTheLidl · 17/11/2022 21:27

bridgetreilly · 17/11/2022 20:34

@LauraIAm you don’t have to work to pay tax! All income is taxed, whetheror not it comes from employment or investments. Everyone pays VAT, road tax, council tax etc.

And pension beyond the basic allowance is taxed too. So any pension (including the state pension amount) over £12,570 is taxed.

Bintymcbintface · 17/11/2022 21:17

If they want to recoup some money why don't they increase tax on the billion £ corporations who aren't paying their fair share. Why aren't they closing the loopholes for the mega rich stashing their cash elsewhere to avoid paying up. How are these not feasible options but increasing the retirement age, forcing people into work even if they aren't claiming benefits and increasing taxes on people already struggling are?

Swipe left for the next trending thread