Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Are we morally obliged to work ?

611 replies

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 11:55

630,000 economically inactive people in the UK not claiming benefits. Early retiree’s I guess.

Hunt plans to tackle this and encourage work force participation to allow businesses to grow. ie cheap labour I presume ? But also preventing a brain drain.

Will be interesting to see how he plans to address this.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Movinghouseatlast · 25/11/2022 11:27

I am one of these people. I have glamping in my garden which I rent out, this is my sole income. Its counted as 'income from property' on a tax return so on.paper I have no 'income' as it's classed as an investment. There must be thousands like me. I'm the 'escape to the country' cliche!

I certainly didn't jack my whole previous life in in order to get another ( worse) job to make Jeremy Hunt happy.

Schlaar · 25/11/2022 11:20

Maverickess · 24/11/2022 17:02

I've known a few who worked on the community and their stories are all similar to yours, and they got a pittance in petrol allowance too.
It's shocking how people who are so relied upon are treated and what they're expected to put up with to keep someone else's profit margin looking good.

I was a TEACHER at college and still got treated like crap. Budget cuts meant they got rid of permanent jobs and hired the same teachers back as self employed contractors through an agency which took half of their earnings. It still worked out cheaper for the employer because they didn’t have to pay for holidays or sick pay or maternity or pension contributions.

I was only paid for classroom time but I had to be there about 30 minutes beforehand to fetch the books and set up. Then they would schedule me for lessons 9-11, 11.15-12.15, 1.15-3.15 and 3.30-5.30. Then I had to spend half an hour tidying up and putting the books away. So I was at work for 10 hours but only got paid for 7.5 hours.

And that was a good day! On a bad day I’d have a lesson 9-11 then would have to hang around unpaid to teach another lesson 1.15-3.15. A full time teacher would be paid for that time and would do marking. I would still end up doing marking but wasn’t being paid! Sometimes my second lesson would be at another campus but I wouldn’t get paid any travel time. Unsurprisingly I don’t teach any more!

Maverickess · 24/11/2022 17:02

TimBoothseyes · 24/11/2022 16:54

I used to be a community support worker and often I was scheduled to end a visit at 1pm (it started at 10), then be at the next one at 2pm...it was an hours drive away, so no chance of any lunch. If I got there late then I would have to leave late. There were many days when I went the whole shift without having anything to eat.

I've known a few who worked on the community and their stories are all similar to yours, and they got a pittance in petrol allowance too.
It's shocking how people who are so relied upon are treated and what they're expected to put up with to keep someone else's profit margin looking good.

TimBoothseyes · 24/11/2022 16:54

Maverickess · 24/11/2022 16:36

I totally agree, and it's not just restricted to office jobs, as a care assistant I was expected to be changed (not allowed to wear uniform outside work - fair enough, but also nowhere set aside for us to change either, no dedicated staff area anywhere and this place was purpose built, so we got changed in a cupboard full of cleaning stuff - where we also kept our bags and coats) and in handover at least 15 minutes before we started getting paid, when challenged we were told it benefitted us all because then you can get away on time! Erm well only because the next shift gives you 15 minutes of their time free too!

There was no where to eat or take your breaks away from the 'floor', like I said this place was purpose built and within the last 10 years so it goes to show how little staff were regarded even in the planning phase - and we only had a toilet because it's a legal requirement. 14 hour shifts and minimum wage.

It does seem like we're just regarded as robots these days without the need to rest, eat, drink and use the toilet like humans have to do. And don't even get me started on punishing people for getting ill or needing medical treatment now and again like humans tend to!

I used to be a community support worker and often I was scheduled to end a visit at 1pm (it started at 10), then be at the next one at 2pm...it was an hours drive away, so no chance of any lunch. If I got there late then I would have to leave late. There were many days when I went the whole shift without having anything to eat.

Maverickess · 24/11/2022 16:36

KimberleyClark · 24/11/2022 14:35

I agree. Where I last worked you were expected to make or fetch your hot morning or afternoon drink and drink it at your desk rather than go to the canteen with colleagues for a chat as happened in my earlier days. Also lunch - latterly it was frowned upon to spend more than 20 minutes away from your desk whereas it used to be the case you were expected to go out to the shops/to the canteen/for a walk for up to an hour.

I totally agree, and it's not just restricted to office jobs, as a care assistant I was expected to be changed (not allowed to wear uniform outside work - fair enough, but also nowhere set aside for us to change either, no dedicated staff area anywhere and this place was purpose built, so we got changed in a cupboard full of cleaning stuff - where we also kept our bags and coats) and in handover at least 15 minutes before we started getting paid, when challenged we were told it benefitted us all because then you can get away on time! Erm well only because the next shift gives you 15 minutes of their time free too!

There was no where to eat or take your breaks away from the 'floor', like I said this place was purpose built and within the last 10 years so it goes to show how little staff were regarded even in the planning phase - and we only had a toilet because it's a legal requirement. 14 hour shifts and minimum wage.

It does seem like we're just regarded as robots these days without the need to rest, eat, drink and use the toilet like humans have to do. And don't even get me started on punishing people for getting ill or needing medical treatment now and again like humans tend to!

antelopevalley · 24/11/2022 16:06

I remember years ago in a factory we would all be lined up with our bags and coats at 5 pm waiting so we could punch out. We were also counted as in as soon as we punched in the morning. None of this, you have to be ready at your desk with your PC on before you are counted as starting work.

KimberleyClark · 24/11/2022 14:35

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 20:33

Not only that, but terms and conditions are greatly reduced. I used to have scheduled morning and afternoon breaks as well as an hour's lunch break. The work wasn't highy paid, but having those made the day more enjoyable and manageable. You had time to make personal calls at lunchtime eg make dentist appts etc, go to a local cafe for lunch or do your shopping if you were in town. I think those kinds ofthings are gone for a lot of people. We have become workhorses and not human beings with needs.

I agree. Where I last worked you were expected to make or fetch your hot morning or afternoon drink and drink it at your desk rather than go to the canteen with colleagues for a chat as happened in my earlier days. Also lunch - latterly it was frowned upon to spend more than 20 minutes away from your desk whereas it used to be the case you were expected to go out to the shops/to the canteen/for a walk for up to an hour.

Merryweather80 · 24/11/2022 13:33

Get yourself appointed to the House of Lords....
£323 per day attendance allowance just for turning up, plus travel expenses and highly subsidised restaurant facilities. No electorate to vote you out either - so a job for life.

Maybe Hunt should start there if he wants to make some savings?

That's more in a day than we claim in a week from UC as a family of five with one if the adults too poorly to work!!!
How the xxxx is that fair. When I could I paid well in to the system. I would love to be able to work. I'd live to be able to eat properly too and put the heating on- but no. I'm making myself worse by not being able to do these things. Making the kid's asthma worse too.
The way disabled people in this country are treated is utterly disgusting.

Those who make the decisions need a dose of reality from this side of the fence.

(Throws self onto the pyre)

lieselotte · 24/11/2022 12:31

I’m not sure why you think younger people or pensioners should be paying YOUR share of what needs to be put in to cover people who really can’t work

I'm not sure I said that, especially as I do work and despite working 3 days a week, am a higher rate tax payer and have been a higher rate tax payer for a large proportion of my working life. I have never not worked other than the odd month here and there between jobs.

But the point is, pensioners who pay tax do pay their fair share (and probably paid in their working lives even if they don't pay tax now) and younger people who are working pay tax so cover the costs too.

SirMingeALot · 24/11/2022 11:04

the80sweregreat · 24/11/2022 10:53

Our local primary has two clubs that would provide wrap around care, but there is a restriction on the spaces and it still involves people being available to run it and do the admin , food orders and just everything really.
It just about breaks even , especially as food has gone up too and staff have to be paid.
I can see why some schools are reluctant to start one up.

Especially with the recruitment problems now.

the80sweregreat · 24/11/2022 10:53

Our local primary has two clubs that would provide wrap around care, but there is a restriction on the spaces and it still involves people being available to run it and do the admin , food orders and just everything really.
It just about breaks even , especially as food has gone up too and staff have to be paid.
I can see why some schools are reluctant to start one up.

toffeecrisps · 24/11/2022 09:48

That said I have met a few people who are on long term benefits because of autism and have no plans to ever work, it would be good to find a better path to employment for them because I know personally two who are listed as unable to work when they could easily do a wfh proofreading type job.

@Dontaskdontget

You do you know?

Battyfumworts · 23/11/2022 21:25

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 19:29

Out of interest, why do people think that it's up to schools to provide childcare outside of school hours? Schools are there to education children. Childcare for working parents is a different thing altogether. Providing childcare for 100s of children before or after school is really different for a school to manage inhouse because there simply isn't the staff to do it. Teaching and support staff and caretakers already work long hours, they are prepping for the school day before school and after school phoning parents, planning,having meetings etc.

So where exactly do the staff come from? You need to consider ratios. Where does the space come from? Do you want rows and rows of children sitting in the hall watched over by teenagers? Would retired people want to come in and do these few hours a day? Who is responsible for ensuring there are enough first-aid trained people there? Where are the extra caretakers going to come from to open up the site earlier and close it down later? Where are the cleaners who are going to ensure that the school is ready for, er, ACTUAL school in the morning? And the kitchens ready for the catering staff to come in to prepare for the lunches? Where is the money going to come from for extra heating costs?

It is very short-sighted to assume that schools should be responsible for this. It is not the job of schools to look after your children before and after the school day so that you can work, I'm afraid.

excuse my rambling, sleep deprived response, hopefully it makes some sense.

When I wrote

I’m becoming convinced that schools in these areas thinks that most mums are SAHMs by choice and have enough money in the bank to not be bothered by any of it.

I was actually thinking about the amount of times I’m asked to go in to school most weeks, during working and schools hours to attend xyz, I then adapt my hours and agree only to be given a few hours notice that x has changed and will now be at 10am instead of 9am and will last an hour rather than 20 mins. That reduces my work day by 50%, I can’t afford to be doing that every time I send a slip back agreeing to attend. In fact if was that disorganised at work I wouldn’t have a job.

I have mentioned that there are no breakfast or after school clubs available, I don’t expect school to provide additional childcare, however, I would certainly utilise clubs if they were available, even if it were put on by an outside provider and chargeable. Mainly because I have no childcare options available to me, childcare spaces are all full already and no family nearby, but also because of the opportunities it gives kids to do a new sport, hobby, language, whatever.

Many schools do offer these options and it’s certainly not a new thing, was happening when I was at school 30 something years ago. It just seems that in some locations schools seem to think that all mums are SAHM’s and can drop everything at any time. I’m happy to change my working pattern to attend but giving me a few hours notice of changes once I’ve already committed isn’t helpful or acceptable. If I were messing them around like that they’d have something to say to me.

Obviously, my main point is that the lack of available childcare options, breakfast and after school clubs make it difficult for women to work. Many jobs want people full time for set hours and compromises often come at a significant financial cost for families. So while of course it isn’t the schools responsibility to provide additional childcare, there’s nothing parents can do either, short of becoming childminders themselves.

If I could magic up infinite childcare, flexible hours and fair wages for all I would, but that’s not going to happen.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 20:33

Not only that, but terms and conditions are greatly reduced. I used to have scheduled morning and afternoon breaks as well as an hour's lunch break. The work wasn't highy paid, but having those made the day more enjoyable and manageable. You had time to make personal calls at lunchtime eg make dentist appts etc, go to a local cafe for lunch or do your shopping if you were in town. I think those kinds ofthings are gone for a lot of people. We have become workhorses and not human beings with needs.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 20:31

I wouldn't say workplace practice has improved hugely in the last 40 years. There are some things that are undeniably better, yes, but a lot of jobs have undergone shittification in recent decades.

This. I remember when I graduated in the 90s. There were still a lot of part time jobs around. I'm talking genuine part time - with a proper contract, not a shitty zero hours thing on minimum wage. Many were women in ther 50s, or young mums, or maybe men close to retirement age who still wanted some paid work rather than going from FT to notthing at all. Those jobs seemed to be the first to be cut during austerity, putting that work onto the FT workers that were left.

So now the option is to work a FT post that is effectively more than FT because the workload is more than it should be, or a zero hours or minimum wage job in hospitality or somewhere, that used to be done by students. There is not a lot in between at all. Yes, some people can negotiate pt once they're in a job, sometimes a temporary reduction or dropping a day or compressed hours or whatever, but a genuine half of a FT post ie. 18.5 hrs a week, they barely exist anymore.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 19:30

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 19:29

Out of interest, why do people think that it's up to schools to provide childcare outside of school hours? Schools are there to education children. Childcare for working parents is a different thing altogether. Providing childcare for 100s of children before or after school is really different for a school to manage inhouse because there simply isn't the staff to do it. Teaching and support staff and caretakers already work long hours, they are prepping for the school day before school and after school phoning parents, planning,having meetings etc.

So where exactly do the staff come from? You need to consider ratios. Where does the space come from? Do you want rows and rows of children sitting in the hall watched over by teenagers? Would retired people want to come in and do these few hours a day? Who is responsible for ensuring there are enough first-aid trained people there? Where are the extra caretakers going to come from to open up the site earlier and close it down later? Where are the cleaners who are going to ensure that the school is ready for, er, ACTUAL school in the morning? And the kitchens ready for the catering staff to come in to prepare for the lunches? Where is the money going to come from for extra heating costs?

It is very short-sighted to assume that schools should be responsible for this. It is not the job of schools to look after your children before and after the school day so that you can work, I'm afraid.

sorry for typos, rushed the post out

CurlyhairedAssassin · 23/11/2022 19:29

Battyfumworts · 18/11/2022 19:45

Do you live in a rural area by any chance? I’m becoming convinced that schools in these areas thinks that most mums are SAHMs by choice and have enough money in the bank to not be bothered by any of it.

Out of interest, why do people think that it's up to schools to provide childcare outside of school hours? Schools are there to education children. Childcare for working parents is a different thing altogether. Providing childcare for 100s of children before or after school is really different for a school to manage inhouse because there simply isn't the staff to do it. Teaching and support staff and caretakers already work long hours, they are prepping for the school day before school and after school phoning parents, planning,having meetings etc.

So where exactly do the staff come from? You need to consider ratios. Where does the space come from? Do you want rows and rows of children sitting in the hall watched over by teenagers? Would retired people want to come in and do these few hours a day? Who is responsible for ensuring there are enough first-aid trained people there? Where are the extra caretakers going to come from to open up the site earlier and close it down later? Where are the cleaners who are going to ensure that the school is ready for, er, ACTUAL school in the morning? And the kitchens ready for the catering staff to come in to prepare for the lunches? Where is the money going to come from for extra heating costs?

It is very short-sighted to assume that schools should be responsible for this. It is not the job of schools to look after your children before and after the school day so that you can work, I'm afraid.

Soothsayer1 · 23/11/2022 18:10

@the80sweregreat
as someone of similar age and with foot issues...I found birkenstocks very helpful, might help you aswell?

Soothsayer1 · 23/11/2022 18:08

If only our important sectors paid us properly
Surely they'll have to now otherwise they wont be staffed?

chaosmaker · 23/11/2022 12:15

Exactly! Iwas lucky to have an inhertance of about 70k. This let me 'retire' for about 4 years and have a pretty good lifestyle. Now I have to work so am doing care work. Seriously considering going to a supermarket as it pays a fraction more. If only our important sectors paid us properly. Any job working with the general public should also come with an idiot bonus - as there are so many.

Soothsayer1 · 23/11/2022 11:57

chaosmaker · 23/11/2022 10:30

I still think if you don't need to work, thn you shouldn't have to.

Even if an argument could be made that you ought to work how can you be made to if you don't need the money?
If I was ordered to go and dig up potatoes for minimum wage I would just turn up very late to work and then take a break every 10-minutes because my back was hurting or something, theyd soon sack me and then I could carry on with my nice relaxed but frugal life where I have enough to live on from my own little self-employed business.

the80sweregreat · 23/11/2022 10:55

I'm late fifties and I couldn't be on my feet for hours at a time , how people do it I'm not sure
I do really suffer with my feet though , but I admire those who do these tough jobs day in day out
I know many don't have any choice at all , but it's not easy and many people end up with bad feet / backs etc as they age.
I am on my feet for my job, but it's not for that many hours and doesn't involve any heavy lifting or physical work either

WhatNoRaisins · 23/11/2022 10:37

Thing is a lot of those jobs that we can't fill are hard physical roles like catering and caring.
The 60s something's who currently can afford not to work aren't very likely to go for them even if the government applies the stick approach to make them go back to work.

chaosmaker · 23/11/2022 10:30

I still think if you don't need to work, thn you shouldn't have to.

LauraIAm · 23/11/2022 10:11

@Dinosauratemydaffodils There are more jobs than jobseekers (see eg this article www.bigissue.com/news/employment/the-uk-has-more-job-vacancies-than-unemployed-people-for-the-first-time/) so everyone should be able to get a job. Maybe not exactly the role/hours/location they ideally want, but a job. And I think it’s right that people who can work and aren’t otherwise paying their share do work, even if it isn’t their ideal job, rather than expect people who do compromise on role etc and get a job to pay for them because they won’t compromise.