Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Air BNB Should be Banned

159 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:44

This started off as a lovely idea. A way for people to rent a spare room and show people around their home town.

It has since turned into a way for people to make money without adhering to the minimum legal standards that proper holiday accommodation has to meet. Even basic health and safety standards such as smoke alarms do not have to be met.

And it has created chaos, reducing the amount of accommodation for families to rent, pushing up prices, and hollowing out tourist destinations turning them into a Disneyland where few people live.

A ban would mean that anyone wanting to rent out holiday accommodation would have to do it properly. People doing it well could remain running their business but the amateurs who haven't a clue what they are doing would leave the market.

OP posts:
Dreamsoffreedomjoyandpeace · 17/11/2022 12:03

I stayed in one with no working smoke alarms and the front door (at bottom of stairs) deadlocked. Only way out through the kitchen!

When I complained I was told that I was having ‘a little episode’🙄

Although, I do use Airbnb a lot and it’s very useful for booking odd dates, especially with two dogs. Most of my experiences have been pretty good.

slowquickstep · 17/11/2022 11:55

AirBnB ruins communities. A very small village about 12 miles from me has been decimated by this, at least a third of the village is now AIRBnB. The shop makes very little money from the visitors as the arrive already well stocked. No doubt the school will close soon and the church will soon follow.

FacebookPhotos · 17/11/2022 11:46

I completely agree OP. It is a loophole which needs to be closed. I'd support "change of use" planning permission to control the % of properties which are for holidaymakers, as well as licensing for ALL short-term lets to ensure minimum safety standards are met. Persistent anti-social behaviour from guests (impacting neighbours) should be considered a good enough reason to revoke a licence.

I also support high property taxes on empty properties. It should be tapered to account for people trying to sell or in between tenants, of course. But it is simply appalling that some people have no home at all while other have a spare home they keep empty. Often in the same areas too.

romdowa · 17/11/2022 11:38

It definitely needs to be changed somehow. I live in a beautiful seaside town in Ireland. There are countless houses which are air bnbs empty now for the winter because tourist season has finished . There is currently 1 property for residential letting at a price of 2 grand a month. Friends can't leave home because there is no where to rent, businesses can't get staff because they have nowhere to live, some of the bigger businesses have now gone back to having staff halls like they had in the 70s and 80s. The town will literally kill itself with greed .

Itwasntevenblackpudding · 17/11/2022 11:37

Airbnb is simply a portal for owners to advertise their properties.

Loads of the properties on Airbnb are advertised on multiple platforms.

Would you only ban people who advertise solely on Airbnb, or would you let their listings on all of the other advertising sites remain?

The property you see on Airbnb and VRBO (for example) is still the same property with the same owners, why shouldn't the owner be able to choose to advertise on Airbnb.

If you find a lovely cottage on, say, Sykes, do you check whether it is also on Airbnb and then not rent it?

squashyhat · 17/11/2022 11:36

YABU. Every Air BnB experience I have had has been wonderful. I wouldn't stay in anyone's spare room, but the apartments and villas are a great alternative to a hotel stay, much more flexible than traditional holiday home and the owners without exception have been lovely both in the UK and Europe.

londongals · 17/11/2022 11:36

No I u7se bnb much cheaper and better than expensive hotels

Claricethecat45 · 17/11/2022 11:35

Agree to a point. I would LOVE to rent my 3 bed victorian terrace in a well connected village in south east .....and would charge a reasonable rent, would accept dogs/pets and children ( tho Smokers NO)

BUT the costs for me to do this .....registering as a landlord, paying a fee to local authority, changing insurance and using an agent to manage it ( Im abroad) is just so so expensive that any rent in return would be minimal....so easier to leave it empty.

AirBnB is an option for me and I do have a safe home to offer and a neighbour who would arrange inter-tenant cleaning etc....so sadly I hear you but the cost of actually putting a privately owned home up for rent is mad.....and THAT is the problem for a lot of would be 'landlords'. Recent thread here made that clear....

Orenishiicottonmouth · 17/11/2022 11:34

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 11:31

@Orenishiicottonmouth Nobody would stop you running a business. The difference is that people would have to meet legal standards.

Except that air bnb should be banned?

schnubbins · 17/11/2022 11:31

I live in Munich where there is as practically everywhere , a massive housing shortage and sky high rent and property prices . The municipality of Munich have now brought in a new rule where any unit ( house or apartment ) cannot be rented out for any longer than six weeks in a calendar year. A room in any unit is still allowed . So it is possible and should be implemented in many cities to stop them becoming theme parks instead of places where people live and raise their families.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 11:31

@Orenishiicottonmouth Nobody would stop you running a business. The difference is that people would have to meet legal standards.

OP posts:
MavisChunch29 · 17/11/2022 11:31

It shouldn't be banned but the Government should have a massive social housing/affordable housing building programme and local authorities should be able to put controls and regulations in their area.

Also if other holiday cottage places had better websites with as good a search function and as much choice as AirBnB then they'd have competition. Like Amazon, I will continue to use it while they are the best in their field.

Why should I have to go to a hotel on holiday? People have always rented self-catering accommodation. We are five of us plus a dog, I don't want a hotel and I want to be able to see what pet friendly accommodation is available. Clearly there is huge demand in the market for it as there was for Uber in London- there was never a black cab or minicab when you need one before Uber!

shivawn · 17/11/2022 11:30

I understand where you're coming from. I use Airbnb a lot however, we travel often as I family and I love renting a villa with a private pool so that we have plenty space and privacy. We have the pool to entertain us during nap times. If we were in a hotel or whatever then I'd be constantly worried about my toddler making too much noise and disturbing other guests and we'd be stuck sitting in the room while he naps.

Orenishiicottonmouth · 17/11/2022 11:29

EscapeTheCastle · 17/11/2022 11:24

I totally agree with the OP.
Power to the Welsh looking into a change to the taxation.

Greedy, greedy, greedy remote platform reducing the ability of local people being able to - gasp- actually live and work in their local area.

Why aren't people allowed to make a living? The government previously told people to invest in property and not to rely on pensions. Now we're being made to pay 300% council tax if we can't meet the quota of rentals on properties we're we're advised to invest in. Nobody has a problem with caravan sites, holiday camps and b and b's. Just god forbid anyone who wants to make money off a house that most of the general public couldn't afford to buy in the first place.

meloonhead · 17/11/2022 11:28

bloodyeverlastinghell · 17/11/2022 11:08

They are essentially doing this in Scotland. I have a holiday cottage, a converted outbuilding in a farmyard, it has limited impact on the neighbours. They are at the foot of the drive a few hundred metres away so an extra vehicle or two goes past.

Its probably not the target of this legislation but the cost of energy and new costs for licence that’ll be imposed by the council mean it doesn’t really make financial sense anymore.

Lots of tourist stuff locally, nice shops selling wool and cashmere, art galleries, whiskey distillery, people come and they spend money in the local economy. They need somewhere to stay.

I don’t think it’s as simple as saying ban airbnbs. It would be better to take a more nuanced approach which is area dependent.

Planning permission to use as an airBNB would solve this, because buildings like yours are suitable to be used. So if you needed a certificate or something.

SkinnyFatte · 17/11/2022 11:27

@Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble I am guilty of renting a tenement in Edinburgh Old Town via Air BnB. So many flats there are Air BnBs. I didn't know before I went up there for a little holiday. I agree with others, it needs to be better regulated.

Pineapple41 · 17/11/2022 11:27

100% agree - I live next door to one and opposite another and it’s made my life incredibly stressful. I’m desperate to move but can’t at the moment. The LLs live abroad/out of town so don’t give a fuck, and Airbnb don’t want to know. We’ve even had to report tenants to the police several times due to drugs and violence, yet nothing changes. YANBU!

EscapeTheCastle · 17/11/2022 11:24

I totally agree with the OP.
Power to the Welsh looking into a change to the taxation.

Greedy, greedy, greedy remote platform reducing the ability of local people being able to - gasp- actually live and work in their local area.

MuraRocker · 17/11/2022 11:22

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

MoMuntervary · 17/11/2022 11:22

Lockheart · 17/11/2022 11:20

I wouldn't ban outright, but I would forbid any listings which weren't in the owners own home i.e. genuine spare rooms only. No complete apartments or houses.

Absolutely this. Otherwise it's just holiday lets on the cheap with no regulation.

NotDavidTennant · 17/11/2022 11:21

My view is that they should amend the planning laws so that converting a residential property to short term letting should require permission for change of use, just as it would if you converted the same property to business premises. This would give councils power to control the amount and location of holiday lets in their local area.

Lockheart · 17/11/2022 11:20

I wouldn't ban outright, but I would forbid any listings which weren't in the owners own home i.e. genuine spare rooms only. No complete apartments or houses.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 11:18

bloodyeverlastinghell · 17/11/2022 11:08

They are essentially doing this in Scotland. I have a holiday cottage, a converted outbuilding in a farmyard, it has limited impact on the neighbours. They are at the foot of the drive a few hundred metres away so an extra vehicle or two goes past.

Its probably not the target of this legislation but the cost of energy and new costs for licence that’ll be imposed by the council mean it doesn’t really make financial sense anymore.

Lots of tourist stuff locally, nice shops selling wool and cashmere, art galleries, whiskey distillery, people come and they spend money in the local economy. They need somewhere to stay.

I don’t think it’s as simple as saying ban airbnbs. It would be better to take a more nuanced approach which is area dependent.

Art galleries and shops selling cashmere if you are holidaying there is nice. If you live there you want to buy groceries and practical things.

OP posts:
ComtesseDeSpair · 17/11/2022 11:15

AirBandB is just a booking platform. It’s essentially the internet, and online booking systems etc, responsible for the proliferation of holiday lets. Self catered holiday accommodation has always existed; pre-internet, it was just more difficult to find and navigate (I remember my dad sending away for a paper brochure of Cornwall holiday cottages and then spending hours on end phoning up the providers for our annual holiday) and so more people relied on travel agents and packages holidays in hotels out of necessity.

The genie isn’t going to go back into the bottle. Short term lets and the platforms which host then just need to be better regulated.

mummatobeat33 · 17/11/2022 11:10

I liked the idea of it before a house on my street was turned into one. We are in a small street with permit parking which we pay for as residents but the airbnb property is usually used by tradesmen with big trucks/vans which then stop us residents parking but the council wont do anything as they arent doing anything wrong using the visitor permits

Swipe left for the next trending thread