Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Air BNB Should be Banned

159 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:44

This started off as a lovely idea. A way for people to rent a spare room and show people around their home town.

It has since turned into a way for people to make money without adhering to the minimum legal standards that proper holiday accommodation has to meet. Even basic health and safety standards such as smoke alarms do not have to be met.

And it has created chaos, reducing the amount of accommodation for families to rent, pushing up prices, and hollowing out tourist destinations turning them into a Disneyland where few people live.

A ban would mean that anyone wanting to rent out holiday accommodation would have to do it properly. People doing it well could remain running their business but the amateurs who haven't a clue what they are doing would leave the market.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 09:35

That is interesting. Because I have never been to a proper holiday cottage let in iter ways that does not meet basic safety standards. I have with air bnb including one with five star reviews described as luxury - was it fuck. I will no longer use air bnb. Safety is a basic minimum standard.

OP posts:
Movinghouseatlast · 18/11/2022 09:18

Abraxan · 18/11/2022 07:57

You could still do that. Lots of regulated holiday let companies out there. Now AirBnB is predominately a holiday let company it should all be regulated in the same way.

There is no regulation for holiday lets in the UK, nor for companies providing them. There are building regulations which apply to all properties, also specific commercial guidance for things like hot tubs but no actual specific regulations for holiday lets. You are totally wrong to say Air BnB is unregulated but other companies are- it is simply not true.

DarkShade · 18/11/2022 09:01

bellac11 · 17/11/2022 18:46

Why dont they rent an airbnb long term, are the prices very different? A lot of them have quite long term lets like 6months or so.

For most families 6 months is not enough stability. And also it's astronomically expensive. That's precisely why people let out their flats via air BnB - it's more lucrative than renting it as a landlord.

CranfordScones · 18/11/2022 08:52

Banning things that others find useful isn't going to happen.

If you're interested in this matter, there was a Private Member's Bill put forward by Rachel Maskell (MP for York) that proposed licensing short term accommodation and giving local authorities more control over them. I believe the Bill is still live, though they don't usually get enough time to pass all the required stages. You could write to your MP and urge them to support it, or to urge the government to sponsor a similar bill.

Abraxan · 18/11/2022 07:57

shivawn · 17/11/2022 11:30

I understand where you're coming from. I use Airbnb a lot however, we travel often as I family and I love renting a villa with a private pool so that we have plenty space and privacy. We have the pool to entertain us during nap times. If we were in a hotel or whatever then I'd be constantly worried about my toddler making too much noise and disturbing other guests and we'd be stuck sitting in the room while he naps.

You could still do that. Lots of regulated holiday let companies out there. Now AirBnB is predominately a holiday let company it should all be regulated in the same way.

Abraxan · 18/11/2022 07:54

Air BnB is pretty much now just a holiday let company. Therefore, normal holiday let rules and legalities should be applied to them.

No one should be able to,rent out accommodation that doesn't meet simple legal guidelines such as smoke alarms, H&S regs met, etc.

I've never actually used AirBnB as have been concerned about what happens if the let goes wrong whilst there or before/after, and how much protection you have.

Dd has used them a lot abroad as it's been cheaper and so far she's been lucky with her choices. But says, based on her friends experiences, some accommodation can be a bit ropey and not all of the owners seem very genuine.

bellac11 · 17/11/2022 21:41

As usual its the wrong focus. All these people getting het up about self catering places (many of which couldnt even be used for long term housing as they're things like shepherds huts and the like, the focus should be government building and maintaining proper affordable housing (not what they currently call affordable)

Its much easier to attack holiday makers and second home owners.

Pinotpleasure · 17/11/2022 21:40

It’s not just a problem in the UK with AirBnB lettings displacing locals who want to rent long term, but in other countries too eg. Australia and popular US and Canadian cities. It’s actually illegal for Singaporeans to let their (entire) properties out on AirBnB and similar platforms.

I was tempted to book holiday homes on AirBnB and VRBO when I lived in the USA but ultimately was put off by having to pay cleaning fees of around $100 even if I only wanted to stay a night or two and it was ultimately cheaper to stay in hotels.

The business model is becoming far less attractive in the States right now - not just for hosts because of oversupply their bookings are declining. There is a discussion about the AirBnB “bubble” popularity and feasibility of short term rentals likely to burst with:

#AirBnBust on Twitter and TikTok

www.Reddit.com has an AirBnBust forum

#AirBnBust on Facebook

YouTube - lots of videos if you search for “AirBnBust”

In the UK I think that under lockdown and overseas travel wasn’t allowed, people wanted the security of avoiding Covid by staying in holiday homes and suddenly it became extremely profitable to become an AirBnB host with no shortage of bookings.

However, we can now travel overseas again and stay in resort hotels if we want and many singles, couples and families have resumed their usual holidays with Jet2, Tui, Trailfinders, Crystal Ski Holidays or sort out their own flights and accommodation etc. UK holidays are not quite so attractive due to our unreliable climate. AirBnB is attractive for short breaks and probably will continue to be popular year round for cities such as London, Bath, Edinburgh, Oxford etc. but oversupply is problematic for hosts and a disaster for people who need long term rentals., especially so in the coastal town where I live.

leatherboundbooks · 17/11/2022 21:16

I've personally only stayed in spare rooms, and love doing that. I'm able to use the kitchen, have a bit of company if the owner and I get on, find out a bit about the area, see inside some lovely houses, some very historic and the money I pay helps people pay their mortgage, some of the people I've stayed with have been self employed or retired so very helpful for them.
As a single person renting a flat would not be worth it

daffodilandtulip · 17/11/2022 21:00

The one in our tiny residential street is basically a HMO for drug users, parties and foreign workers who get picked up in a van at all hours.

surreygirl1987 · 17/11/2022 21:00

No. It should just be better regulated. I've had so many amazing trips using airbnb where there's no chance I'd have been able to afford a nearby hotel. Hotel prices are the reason people turned to airbnb in the first place - like uber I guess.

mindutopia · 17/11/2022 20:45

Is the issue Airbnb though? Or is it locals looking to make a buck on tourists? We have a barn we plan to convert and put on Airbnb/other platforms. It’s literally in our drive. I’d never rent it out full time as only want someone here a few weeks a year. It’s not suitable as social housing or for families. The barn would literally deteriorate and go to ruin if we didn’t find a way to afford to refurbish it (all with appropriate planning).

We live on the Devon/Cornwall border. There are villages by the sea here where all but a handful of homes are holiday lets. But being a local, I truly don’t blame that on Airbnb or any other holiday let platform. It’s local people like us who have either sold up to property developers or who have decided to turn family homes into income properties in an area where there can otherwise be little opportunity. I can see it’s a golden ticket to people who need a leg up in opportunity, maybe who wouldn’t have that sort of income otherwise. Not to say I blame them individually for wanting to create financial stability for themselves but it certainly it’s Airbnb who is doing it in the absence of actual local people either selling up or turning their homes to holiday lets.

MrsKrankyPants · 17/11/2022 20:20

bloodyeverlastinghell · 17/11/2022 11:08

They are essentially doing this in Scotland. I have a holiday cottage, a converted outbuilding in a farmyard, it has limited impact on the neighbours. They are at the foot of the drive a few hundred metres away so an extra vehicle or two goes past.

Its probably not the target of this legislation but the cost of energy and new costs for licence that’ll be imposed by the council mean it doesn’t really make financial sense anymore.

Lots of tourist stuff locally, nice shops selling wool and cashmere, art galleries, whiskey distillery, people come and they spend money in the local economy. They need somewhere to stay.

I don’t think it’s as simple as saying ban airbnbs. It would be better to take a more nuanced approach which is area dependent.

We inherited a property with a wee cottage we rent out as a holiday let. Doesn't cause any local issues and people love it.

Can't afford to do it this way with all the costs any longer, so it's stopping as a holiday let in January and we'll be turning it into a long term let.
It is a shame, as was lovely and cheap and brilliant for hill walkers. We had many return guests over the years too.

abw94 · 17/11/2022 20:16

ChristmasisRuined · 17/11/2022 20:13

Completely agree.

@abw94 Im presuming you're a host?!?!

Nope, used them a handful of times with groups of friends in the UK and aboard, had no issues with them. Great app 👌🏼

ChristmasisRuined · 17/11/2022 20:13

Completely agree.

@abw94 Im presuming you're a host?!?!

VitaminX · 17/11/2022 20:10

This is why it needs to be more strictly regulated, because so many tourists will not behave ethically if something is convenient or fun for them. They don't give a shit about the communities they are visiting. The worst kind of tourists.

If I had my way the amateur gig economy holiday rentals would be absolutely banned unless it was someone's primary residence while they were on holiday themselves or a room / garage conversion / shed within a primary residence, i.e. not removing housing from the market.

People who want to make a legitimate business out of running holiday lets, paying all taxes and complying with all regulations, should be allowed if they apply for a license. There should be regulations about how much housing can to be used in this way in different areas and if your area already has its quota filled, no license.

You can't just turn a residential house into a shop or a pub and you shouldn't be able to just turn it into a hotel.

JamMakingWannaBe · 17/11/2022 20:08

We rent out our en-suite spare room to medical students on rotational placement at a large local hospital.
We are not annoying the neighbours or preventing anyone from accessing a whole property - either to buy or rent - but we are caught up in the recent Scottish short term let regulations.
The increased regulations of the scheme mean we might not continue in the future.
This means it will be increasing difficult for medical students to find low cost accommodation to support their studies - another problem for the NHS!

meloonhead · 17/11/2022 20:03

Proamble · 17/11/2022 19:50

Airbnb has been amazing for us. With a young baby/toddler, you can’t stay in hotels as otherwise you can’t do anything after 7pm!! It’s allowed us to rent a home from home, have access to a washer/dryer so can pack light and it doesn’t matter if they vomit over the bedsheets at night (speaking from a lot of experience). We’ve had such amazing holidays and memories thanks to be able to get accommodation like this.

Ok but do you really think it's worth residents facing a housing shortage so that you can have access to a dryer? Your child will be grown up in a few years- how is that worth it? Don't get me wrong, I get it- but I'm no way is this an argument for airbnb that holds any real weight.

OhmygodDont · 17/11/2022 20:01

There is a lovely big house down our street. Being turned into a hmo won’t affect me parking wise. Already was going to be four double rooms let, wacking on a massive! Extension to get it to five/six rooms.

As a family home £900 ish as a hmo £500 a room. Ruined a whole lovely large garden, adding to pressure on local services all for greed.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 20:01

OhmygodDont · 17/11/2022 19:57

As student accommodation is one thing. But turning perfectly good family homes nowhere near a uni into a hmo to charge £500+ a room is shit.

Agreed

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 20:00

Proamble · 17/11/2022 19:50

Airbnb has been amazing for us. With a young baby/toddler, you can’t stay in hotels as otherwise you can’t do anything after 7pm!! It’s allowed us to rent a home from home, have access to a washer/dryer so can pack light and it doesn’t matter if they vomit over the bedsheets at night (speaking from a lot of experience). We’ve had such amazing holidays and memories thanks to be able to get accommodation like this.

we don’t have enough purpose built holiday self catering units in this country. In many European countries there are holiday houses, properties built for use as a holiday house that don’t have permission for year around living. You can self cater or own a holiday home without the risk of gouging the local population out of a home. Instead we use the existing housing stock, which was built to house people. Meaning we have less housing stock, meaning housing is astronomically expensive, meaning young adults cannot leave home or start a family or do any of the things that constitute ‘living’. It’s grim.

The average age people are having kids just now is getting older and older, mainly because it takes them so long to get settled enough to think they are able to have a family. The average amount people are prepared to pay in taxes for public services is much lower than in other European countries because we are all so skint because house prices are so high. High house prices have so many knock on effects on our society - and where I live the main cause is the proliferation of airB&B.

OhmygodDont · 17/11/2022 19:57

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 19:52

hmm. I’m against hmos where it’s 4 people in a small room in bunk beds as I think in these situations the landlord is being exploitative, but your average student flat is an HMO, or a flat share. What’s wrong with that?

As student accommodation is one thing. But turning perfectly good family homes nowhere near a uni into a hmo to charge £500+ a room is shit.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 19:52

OhmygodDont · 17/11/2022 19:46

Only if we ban hmos too.

hmm. I’m against hmos where it’s 4 people in a small room in bunk beds as I think in these situations the landlord is being exploitative, but your average student flat is an HMO, or a flat share. What’s wrong with that?

Proamble · 17/11/2022 19:50

Airbnb has been amazing for us. With a young baby/toddler, you can’t stay in hotels as otherwise you can’t do anything after 7pm!! It’s allowed us to rent a home from home, have access to a washer/dryer so can pack light and it doesn’t matter if they vomit over the bedsheets at night (speaking from a lot of experience). We’ve had such amazing holidays and memories thanks to be able to get accommodation like this.

OhmygodDont · 17/11/2022 19:46

Only if we ban hmos too.

Swipe left for the next trending thread