Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Air BNB Should be Banned

159 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:44

This started off as a lovely idea. A way for people to rent a spare room and show people around their home town.

It has since turned into a way for people to make money without adhering to the minimum legal standards that proper holiday accommodation has to meet. Even basic health and safety standards such as smoke alarms do not have to be met.

And it has created chaos, reducing the amount of accommodation for families to rent, pushing up prices, and hollowing out tourist destinations turning them into a Disneyland where few people live.

A ban would mean that anyone wanting to rent out holiday accommodation would have to do it properly. People doing it well could remain running their business but the amateurs who haven't a clue what they are doing would leave the market.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DdraigGoch · 21/11/2022 22:22

JamMakingWannaBe · 17/11/2022 20:08

We rent out our en-suite spare room to medical students on rotational placement at a large local hospital.
We are not annoying the neighbours or preventing anyone from accessing a whole property - either to buy or rent - but we are caught up in the recent Scottish short term let regulations.
The increased regulations of the scheme mean we might not continue in the future.
This means it will be increasing difficult for medical students to find low cost accommodation to support their studies - another problem for the NHS!

No one is objecting to letting out a spare room - as per the original spirit of the scheme. Nor are there anyone on here objecting to letting out of granny annexes, converted barns or garden sheds. For that matter, letting student accommodation out during the summer when there are no students should be fine too, not to mention letting your house out while working abroad.

What they are objecting to is the removal from the local housing stock of entire flats or houses that otherwise could be used as homes.

How to solve it? If people want to let out the entire property as short term lets (say less than a month at a time) for more than a given accumulated number of days per year (six months for example) they should apply for change of use planning permission and run it as a proper business. Granting of permission will take into account the local housing situation, plus the potential for guests to become a nuisance. Obviously legal minds will have to look at closing potential loopholes (locking off one cupboard to claim that it's not the entire property being let). Compliance with fire regs etc. would be mandatory.

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 21/11/2022 10:14

Sorry I should have said it was banned in the capital, Palma, but even where we are along the coast it's definitely 'frowned upon' amongst locals - I don't know anyone who does it on the island, yet I know a few people back home in England who do it

bellac11 · 19/11/2022 14:28

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 18/11/2022 10:06

I'm sort of in agreement. Majorca banned Airbnb a few years back and it was the best thing ever for the island. So many wealthy people were buying up all the houses on the island and letting them on Airbnb, which pushed the house prices up etc, and then local people couldn't afford to buy and it was a really big crisis. They banned it completely, and even though people do still let out their homes on the sly, it's pretty rare.
That said, its provided us with plenty of cheap(er) holidays to places in the uk in particular and we've spent money in local restaurants/shops etc which is good for their local economy.

Funny, just did a random search for Majorca for a week in June next year, over 1000 options come up. In what way is it banned?

Pinotpleasure · 19/11/2022 10:41

@Watchthesunrise - yes they exist everywhere in the USA and Canada .They are often called “efficiency suites” or “extended stay” suites. Google them.

Even the big chains offer them such as Marriott, Choice Hotels, or ICH group hotels such as the Holiday Inns and Staybridge Suites (some are in the UK) and a host of other hotel chains eg. Hilton owned hotels branded as Hilton Garden Inns, Hampton, Fairfield etc.

I’ve stayed in about a dozen of them with my family, including the Staybridge Suites in NYC and a Holiday Inn at Asbury Park in New Jersey plus in other States. Also in Canada (Whistler and Montreal). They do have a kitchenette (small kitchen) with a full size fridge freezer, oven and hob, microwave and slim line dishwasher, toaster, coffee machine etc. The sofa in the lounge converts into a bed (sometimes there may be a ‘Murphy bed’ which pulls down from the wall. There is a seperate bedroom with two Queen or one super King bed and bathroom too. Other configurations might have two bedrooms instead of a lounge with a sofa. There is always room to add an extra bed. There are usually swimming pools, guest cooked or continental style breakfast available on the ground floor and often a bar/lounge in the evenings.

I don’t know why they don’t really have many ‘efficiency suite’ style places in the UK but land costs are much higher here (hence houses are becoming smaller so builders can build more properties on a small plot of land). However I assume that many councils would put homeless families in them long term tbh.

Ponderingwindow · 19/11/2022 01:58

Short-term rental accommodations should have to follow the same
guidelines as hotels and other related businesses. There should be permits, safety regulations, disability compliance, taxes, and zoning consideration.

Livelovebehappy · 19/11/2022 01:43

YABU. I use ABNB all the time. At least three times a year. I research the ones I want to stay in to make sure they meet any expectations I have. I’ve been using them for several years, and have never had a bad experience with them. Unlike Booking.com.

Watchthesunrise · 19/11/2022 01:14

Airbnb, on the other hand, came up with a $400 per night four bedroom home with a pool. 10 minutes drive from Disneyland.

Watchthesunrise · 19/11/2022 01:12

I disagree about American hotels. Even flipping Disneyland Hotel couldn't offer a decent sized affordable family hotel room with space for three kids and seperation between kids sleeping area and adults sleeping area. They all still offered the two queen bed, no space set up that every single other chain hotel in the world offers.
I'm asking for a triple bunk bed, in its own space, a fridge, some bowls and cups for breakfast, and maybe an integrated washer/dryer. Or, a clear booking option for adjoining rooms. Apparently too hard for the hotel industry to understand.

antelopevalley · 19/11/2022 00:54

That is a good point. I would love motels in the UK like in the US. I stayed in one in the US. It was cheap, we had a living room, small kitchenette, and 2 bedrooms, Our car was parked outside and there was a breakfast room with a free basic breakfast. Much cheaper than hiring a cottage, but incredibly practical.

OP posts:
Watchthesunrise · 19/11/2022 00:49

As someone with three kids, what Airbnb did was highlight the GAPING hole in the market for child friendly accommodation. Hotels are impossible and impractical with kids.
No, I don't want my kids to share a bed,
Yes, I want a fridge so we can eat breakfast early,
Yes, I want to watch tv and talk to my husband after my kids go to bed.
Yes, I want a holiday too.

Why don't hotels fill this gap!!? They must know families want realistic hotel experiences too?

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/11/2022 23:39

This is really interesting. I don’t use Air bnb myself as it’s so arbitrary whether you’ll get nice, helpful owners or someone really unreasonable, with ridiculous demands/ expectations.

Id rather pay a bit more for my holiday than to get there and find I’m expected to spring clean the building before a 9 am checkout, despite paying a hefty cleaning fee. Or that there are no bins, and I have to drive to the tip on my holidays.

Reading this, it seems like it’s a good platform to continue for renting rooms within your own house, but that any whole property lets ought to be properly regulated.

slowquickstep · 18/11/2022 23:29

MelchiorsMistress · 17/11/2022 12:12

No, people should be allowed to do what they want with their own properties. If air bnb is helping them make enough money to get by, good for them.

And you would be happy if the house next door was a party pad rented out to half a dozen youngsters every night, loud music all through the night, screaming and shouting in the garden, vomit and broken bottles on your doorstep ? Not everyone who rents AirBnB naice people, they are very popular with young adults who still live at home.

JeanRondeausMadHair · 18/11/2022 22:17

schnubbins · 17/11/2022 11:31

I live in Munich where there is as practically everywhere , a massive housing shortage and sky high rent and property prices . The municipality of Munich have now brought in a new rule where any unit ( house or apartment ) cannot be rented out for any longer than six weeks in a calendar year. A room in any unit is still allowed . So it is possible and should be implemented in many cities to stop them becoming theme parks instead of places where people live and raise their families.

Paris has done something similar to this too.
In our previous apartment, the apartment next door was briefly used as a holiday let - AirBnB or something like that and it was absolutely obnoxious. People coming and going at all hours of the day and night, making enormous amounts of noise, people mistaking the side the apartment was on and trying to get into ours, drunks screaming and yelling, people abusing the interphone system (pressing the buzzer for minutes on end[. These people had no investment in our building, they didn't care about anyone else who lived there.
The system definitely needs regulations. Strict ones.

Itwasntevenblackpudding · 18/11/2022 15:36

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 11:32

Airbnb is different as it encourages total amateurs to enter the market. That is the difference.

Can you explain how it encourages total amateurs, and what measures other holiday letting sites have in place to prevent "total amateurs" advertising a property?

When we bought our gites in France we were "total amateurs", but in order to get bookings and generate income we needed to advertise the properties. We did this on a variety of sites, including Airbnb. None of the other sites contacted us to say "wait a minute, you seem like total amateurs at this game, please go away".

The holiday letting companies want your subscription fees/a portion of your rental income - simple as that.

As @Movinghouseatlast has said, anyone can advertise their property on a huge variety of sites, the singling out of Airbnb is just unnecessary.

Movinghouseatlast · 18/11/2022 15:23

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 14:52

And most cottage sites insist properties meet minimum standards.

They don't. Where do you get this from? I advertise on 7 platforms and none of them do.

I also used to be with a traditional holiday cottage agency and they didn't either.

It is up to the individual owner to comply with any legislation or guidance. Hence why Sykes Cottages etc trot out the 'we are just a marketing agency' if there is a problem with a property.

I'm not saying it's right- I'm all for licencing and registration as some owners are not great. However saying its just an Air BnB 'problem' is factually incorrect.

Heatherland77 · 18/11/2022 14:54

I'm currently staying in an AirBnB next to the owner's farmhouse as I work away/remotely as a contractor.
Whilst I wholeheartedly disagree with the saturation of holiday lets in regions like Cornwall and Skye, which have hollowed out the local communities, I'd also say these communities were changing anyway. Local young people tend to migrate to where the work is. Take Portland as an example. Twenty years ago it was pretty bleak and it had a reputation of Portlanders never leaving the island unless they needed to buy new shoes. Young people were leaving for Poole and Bournemouth, or even New Zealand in their droves. The 2012 Olympics and some nifty regeneration has turned it into an artist's community and better WiFi has made remote working and small online businesses more possible. It means that many of the historic fisherman and quarryman cottages are being restored to a good standard. Most Weymouth people won't touch Portland so it takes outsiders to bring it to life. There are now more food shops and cafés on the island.
So AirBnB isn't all bad. It's the second homes that are left vacant that is a travesty.
I prefer a real home away from home as I like to cook and open actual windows, rather than being penned in an overheated Premier Inn with only burgers and chips on offer.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 14:52

And most cottage sites insist properties meet minimum standards.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 14:52

@Movinghouseatlast But people do not. Whereas air bnb market people encouraging them to enter the market for the first time. The perception is based on air bnbs own marketing.

OP posts:
Heatherland77 · 18/11/2022 14:42

I'm currently staying in an anne

Movinghouseatlast · 18/11/2022 14:36

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 11:32

Airbnb is different as it encourages total amateurs to enter the market. That is the difference.

Anybody can put their property on booking.com, VRBO, Trip Adviser etc. An 'amateur' could just as easily list on any Internet agent as Air BnB.

There is a huge misconception amongst the general public about Air BnB being somehow different to any other marketing platform. They are actually theist draconian with owners of any other platform I list on.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 11:32

Airbnb is different as it encourages total amateurs to enter the market. That is the difference.

OP posts:
phoenixrosehere · 18/11/2022 10:08

Instead of trying to ban AirBnb, why not push for better laws and regulations for all holiday accommodations including hotels being held to a higher standards. Simply banning one company among many solves nothing.

bigfamilygrowingupfast · 18/11/2022 10:06

I'm sort of in agreement. Majorca banned Airbnb a few years back and it was the best thing ever for the island. So many wealthy people were buying up all the houses on the island and letting them on Airbnb, which pushed the house prices up etc, and then local people couldn't afford to buy and it was a really big crisis. They banned it completely, and even though people do still let out their homes on the sly, it's pretty rare.
That said, its provided us with plenty of cheap(er) holidays to places in the uk in particular and we've spent money in local restaurants/shops etc which is good for their local economy.

MuraRocker · 18/11/2022 09:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Movinghouseatlast · 18/11/2022 09:45

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 09:35

That is interesting. Because I have never been to a proper holiday cottage let in iter ways that does not meet basic safety standards. I have with air bnb including one with five star reviews described as luxury - was it fuck. I will no longer use air bnb. Safety is a basic minimum standard.

It is not true that other holiday let companies are regulated- they aren't. There is no UK regulation for minimum standards apart from building regs which apply to all properties.

Swipe left for the next trending thread