Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:43

@Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit exactly. The SNP tried to gaslight Scots into thinking they were passionate about the eu in order to create an opposing view from the tories. In reality the eu ref voter turnout was woeful and the SNP spent less on pro EU referendum campaigning for than they did on a by election in Shetland.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 22:38

So if it was that important to Scotland to remain in the EU why has there been no significant post Brexit bump in the independence polls?

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:36

@CapMarvel A LITERAL QUOTE FROM THE SNPs OWN PAPER IN 2014 🤦‍♀️

Eylis · 17/11/2022 22:35

No thanks

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 22:35

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:11

@CapMarvel Scotland did not vote on that premise - in fact the SNP White paper expressly warned of the consequence of a no vote being a referendum on the EU. On THIS advice Scotland still rejected independence - see direct quote below—

‘A new threat is now emerging: the growing possibility that, if we remain part of the UK, a referendum on future British membership of the EU could see Scotland taken out of the EU against the wishes of the people of Scotland’

Nope, sorry. The principle argument of the no campaign was that staying in the uk was the only way Scotland stayed in the EU.

Pumperthepumper · 17/11/2022 22:35

I never understand why there isn’t more appetite for England to become independent.

BlueBellsArePretty · 17/11/2022 22:26

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 21:50

You do realise that the only people who've ever come up with the 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' line are N Sturgeon and her independence pals. They repeat and repeat the assertion in the hope that Scots will eventually believe that Westminster/the English/pro union supporters think that. To drive another wedge, to fuel division, to shift the focus away from the practicalities, to tug on the emotions, to whip up the hatred.

Actually your unionist co-posters are doing their utmost gleeful best to convince Scots that 'we're too wee, too poor and too stupid' with their comments. A wee selection is underneath for your perusal. Nothing that Nicola Sturgeon has said 👍

'I live in England and wish I could vote to unload Scotland to be independent. It is a drain on the rest of our UK resources.'

'What will you use for currency Nicola when you try to rejoin the EU?'

'They wouldn't have you.'

'Would this mean that Scotland would fund itself? If so then yes please.'

'If the EU will have them.'

'The EU wants contributors not takers. Scotland joining as an independent nation would take out a lot more than it could put in - therefore I doubt the EU would be that keen.'

'The idea that Scots are passionate about the EU is laughable.'

'Have you watched the Scottish parliament in action? Absolutely embarrassing.'

'Who’d want to buy debt from a small, corrupt country with talent free politicians and a civil service as deep as a puddle?'

'You seem to be under the impression that there is a right to secession in international law and politics too. There, in fact, is no such right…'

'thankfully this thread isn’t going the way OP wanted it and is highlighting the shitshow that Scotland has to endure due to the idiots who continue to vote SNP.' (Idiots =The Scottish electorate)

“Exactly this. ^ I reckon if Scotland DO vote to leave the UK, it will be 2 years tops before they're BEGGING to be let back. They don't know how good they've got it being part of the Union, and how much worse off they'll be if they leave. Be careful what you wish for!

Nubbled · 17/11/2022 22:19

You say you have children?
when/if Scotland gets independence free prescriptions, eye tests, dental checks, Uni tuition, and the YSB will go out the window immediately. You are deluded, and NS is an absolute fucker. You should be ashamed of yourself.

DdraigGoch · 17/11/2022 22:19

It beats me why you want to stay in a country - the UK - that only works to benefit the rich.

So much money wasted during covid, so much fraud by big business.
You think that Scotsgov hasn't been lining someone's pocket too? How naive.

Even the current budget deficit could be halved if HS2 was scrapped.
Have you been reading the Daily Mail? The UK's budget deficit is £99bn per year. HS2's construction budget is around £3bn per year.

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:11

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 21:39

Scotland voted to remain in the UK in 2014 largely on the premise that it was the only way to remain part of the EU. How did that work out?

Scotland is a country. It's defined as a country and recognised internationally as country. London is not, this is not a difficult distinction to grasp.

The fact is that Scotland voted overwhelmingly to remain in the EU and yet... yeah. Democracy indeed.

@CapMarvel Scotland did not vote on that premise - in fact the SNP White paper expressly warned of the consequence of a no vote being a referendum on the EU. On THIS advice Scotland still rejected independence - see direct quote below—

‘A new threat is now emerging: the growing possibility that, if we remain part of the UK, a referendum on future British membership of the EU could see Scotland taken out of the EU against the wishes of the people of Scotland’

Notplayingball · 17/11/2022 21:50

I agree OP. YANBU.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 21:50

BlueBellsArePretty · 17/11/2022 21:29

What an absolute hate filled shitshow of a thread. To summarise people gleefully stating 'we're too wee, too poor and too stupid' to be independent.

As a Scot the absolute arrogance of the 'oooh you don't have succession rights lol' 'oooh you have such high drugs deaths lol' posts makes me sick. It is attitudes displayed here that push more people towards independence.

Let's be honest the reasons given why Scotland ought to remain are not benevolent.

You do realise that the only people who've ever come up with the 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' line are N Sturgeon and her independence pals. They repeat and repeat the assertion in the hope that Scots will eventually believe that Westminster/the English/pro union supporters think that. To drive another wedge, to fuel division, to shift the focus away from the practicalities, to tug on the emotions, to whip up the hatred.

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 21:49

BlueBellsArePretty · 17/11/2022 21:29

What an absolute hate filled shitshow of a thread. To summarise people gleefully stating 'we're too wee, too poor and too stupid' to be independent.

As a Scot the absolute arrogance of the 'oooh you don't have succession rights lol' 'oooh you have such high drugs deaths lol' posts makes me sick. It is attitudes displayed here that push more people towards independence.

Let's be honest the reasons given why Scotland ought to remain are not benevolent.

People stating facts really isn’t hate filled. It’s reasoning based on information taken from reputable sources.

Some people will base decisions based on faith, many others will not. And I fear that for that reason, those who make decisions based on those distinctions, will never be able to agree on points. Or, apparently, discuss something without a contemptuous tone.

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 21:46

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 21:39

Scotland voted to remain in the UK in 2014 largely on the premise that it was the only way to remain part of the EU. How did that work out?

Scotland is a country. It's defined as a country and recognised internationally as country. London is not, this is not a difficult distinction to grasp.

The fact is that Scotland voted overwhelmingly to remain in the EU and yet... yeah. Democracy indeed.

But that isn’t true. I, and many others voted to remain in the UK, to be in the UK. It had nothing to do with the EU.

The people who try to push this stance tend to be those who voted for independence, and so would have no real idea the reasons people voted against independence.

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 21:45

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 21:04

I’m British. I live in the part of the UK that is Scotland but I am British. I love Britain. All of it. The Lake District, Pembrokeshire, Norfolk, Dumfriesshire, Giants Causeway, the lot of it. It’s a wonderful country! Yes it’s run by some absolute turds just now, but so is Scotland and I have faith that the public will over turn both parliaments in time. There’s a lot of people just like me.

I absolutely agree with you. I do not find something that makes me any different from relatives living down south. Our ideals, values and way of life is extremely similar. So I struggle with this niche nationalism that the snp have managed to brainwash people with.

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 21:42

DownNative · 17/11/2022 20:56

You are since you framed it as "Why are some people so keen to deny a country the right of self-determination?" implying Scotland as a whole is in favour.

Not only are people divided on the question of the constitution, but they're very divided on when such a referendum might be held too.

As for the rest of your post, that's just ridiculous circular reasoning and it's completely logically invalid. On the contrary, it's up to the Nationalists to persuade enough people to support IndyRef2.

Not for the Unionists to do so. Unionists are well within their rights to refuse to support such a move.

Remember, there is no right to secession in international law and politics.

I implied no such thing. I am fully aware that people are divided on the question which is why it is so important to, y'know, find out the answer in an official way as possible.

And no, it's not circular reasoning to ask why, if the unionists are so confident they would win a referendum which would put the matter to bed for far longer this time round, they are so unwilling to do. To not ask the question at all is very simply anti-democratic and oppresive.

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 21:39

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 17/11/2022 21:24

There is a fundamental difference between individual constituencies and an entire country.

Not one region in Scotland voted for Brexit. Not a single one, and yet here we are suffering the inevitable from the inevitable disaster it has been.

You seem to be confusing a Home Nation with a country - Scotland voted in 2014 to remain in the same country: the UK.

Not one region anywhere in the UK voted for or against Brexit, because it was a referendum of individuals, not regions or constituencies.

If you're referring to the locations where all of those individual voters happened to be located, then with your terminology, London - the economic powerhouse of the whole UK and a way higher population than the whole of Scotland - voted to remain; but they didn't get what 'they' (if we were pretending that it was a regional vote) wanted - because democracy.

Scotland voted to remain in the UK in 2014 largely on the premise that it was the only way to remain part of the EU. How did that work out?

Scotland is a country. It's defined as a country and recognised internationally as country. London is not, this is not a difficult distinction to grasp.

The fact is that Scotland voted overwhelmingly to remain in the EU and yet... yeah. Democracy indeed.

Celia24 · 17/11/2022 21:36

BlueBellsArePretty · 17/11/2022 21:29

What an absolute hate filled shitshow of a thread. To summarise people gleefully stating 'we're too wee, too poor and too stupid' to be independent.

As a Scot the absolute arrogance of the 'oooh you don't have succession rights lol' 'oooh you have such high drugs deaths lol' posts makes me sick. It is attitudes displayed here that push more people towards independence.

Let's be honest the reasons given why Scotland ought to remain are not benevolent.

100% agree. We are always seeing comments on here about anti English the Scots supposedly are but the comments on these threads can be awful and condescending.

DdraigGoch · 17/11/2022 21:34

AnuSTart · 17/11/2022 10:10

Much of north of England gets their water from Scotland. UK benefits from Scottish oil fields and tax on whisky.

Also tourism.

Good luck England without all that.

Bollocks:
I can confirm that there is currently no water supplies being diverted,
piped or channelled to England from Scotland from Scottish Water.

From Scottish Water themselves in a 2018 FOI response.

Would the oil be the same oil that the SNP/SGP government wants to ban the extraction of?

BlueBellsArePretty · 17/11/2022 21:29

What an absolute hate filled shitshow of a thread. To summarise people gleefully stating 'we're too wee, too poor and too stupid' to be independent.

As a Scot the absolute arrogance of the 'oooh you don't have succession rights lol' 'oooh you have such high drugs deaths lol' posts makes me sick. It is attitudes displayed here that push more people towards independence.

Let's be honest the reasons given why Scotland ought to remain are not benevolent.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 17/11/2022 21:29

Britain is unusual in being an island.

That's a very dismissive, commonly-Anglocentric way of looking at things. Yes, geographically, 'Great Britain' is one island, but the UK - the country we're discussing here - is thousands of island, the vast majority of them in Scotland.... where you live.

Many of which have felt utterly overlooked and betrayed by the Scottish government, in spite of NS's insistences that Scotland knows best how to run Scotland for the good of ALL of the Scottish people.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 17/11/2022 21:24

There is a fundamental difference between individual constituencies and an entire country.

Not one region in Scotland voted for Brexit. Not a single one, and yet here we are suffering the inevitable from the inevitable disaster it has been.

You seem to be confusing a Home Nation with a country - Scotland voted in 2014 to remain in the same country: the UK.

Not one region anywhere in the UK voted for or against Brexit, because it was a referendum of individuals, not regions or constituencies.

If you're referring to the locations where all of those individual voters happened to be located, then with your terminology, London - the economic powerhouse of the whole UK and a way higher population than the whole of Scotland - voted to remain; but they didn't get what 'they' (if we were pretending that it was a regional vote) wanted - because democracy.

slowquickstep · 17/11/2022 21:15

Granddadwentdownthepit · 17/11/2022 11:51

Do you think the SNP actually want independence or is it the worst thing that could happen to them?

The last thing they want is independence, they know it wouldn't work but are savvy enough to make a very good living out campaigning for it.

DownNative · 17/11/2022 21:15

ShandaLear · 17/11/2022 20:50

Depends. If you believe that:

Countries should have the power to determine their own destinies
They should be able to make all their own laws and determine how they are applied
They should be able to raise and spend all their own taxes without interference in how they are spent.
Everyone who is elected is directly accountable to the electorate on how the country is governed and run

Lets face it, the UK is an absolute bag of shite and I can’t work out why anyone, least of the Scottish and Northern Irish want to be governed by that absolute bag of dicks in power. Why are English people making laws that Scottish people have to follow? Laws that aren’t necessarily in their interests and don’t benefit them.

First part of your post applies to SOVEREIGN states which England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are definitely not.

Only the UK is a sovereign state so it already has the right in international law and politics to prevent secession in order to protect its territorial integrity.

Under international law, Scotland and others are only entitled to devolution and certainly not unilateral declarations of independence. Hence, there is nothing undemocratic or illegal in the UK Government saying no to IndyRef2.

Second part.....which laws are English people making that Scottish people have to follow?!

We have devolution in Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland and London. Those parts of the UK have the power to make their own laws in accordance with the devolution settlement. The UK Parliament remains the supreme authority and can step in whenever necessary, but usually does not. The UK has reserved powers - Constitution, Defence and the Economy are three examples of reserved powers.

I don't think you understand how it all works otherwise you wouldn't have typed the above.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 21:04

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 21:00

But a lot of Scottish people would call themselves British, as would English people. And so, your personal nation isn’t distinction isn’t felt by the majority of people.

I’m British. I live in the part of the UK that is Scotland but I am British. I love Britain. All of it. The Lake District, Pembrokeshire, Norfolk, Dumfriesshire, Giants Causeway, the lot of it. It’s a wonderful country! Yes it’s run by some absolute turds just now, but so is Scotland and I have faith that the public will over turn both parliaments in time. There’s a lot of people just like me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread