Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 18/11/2022 07:58

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/11/2022 01:34

First, let me apologise for posting the following wall of text again, but lies like the above need called out every time.

When it comes to finances and accounting Scotland is consider to be just another government department.

All UK revenue is pooled into a central resource (the treasurey) which the UK government then re-allocate as they see fit (there's obviously more to it than that but that's a whole other thread).

Due to the way revenue is recorded it is not possible to accurately report on how much of the total revenue comes from each part of the UK. For example oil and gas exported directly from the North Sea are classified as revenue from "other" sources despite being mostly in Scottish water and is not attributed to Scottish revenue. Similarly, corporation tax is considered from where the HQ is registered, not where revenue was actually generated.

It is therefore an accounting impossibility for Scotland to be cost the UK more than it puts in by as a) we don't actually know how much each nation is putting in and b) we are considered as a single financial entity at this point (a bit like a household with multiple incomes).

However, some have tried to estimate the contribution of Scotland to the UK accounts and the results, as expected vary massively with some reporting that Scotland are net contributers and others saying we are net beneficiaries.

The GERS figures, which are widley dismissed as inaccurate and misleading due to how they apportion spending/revenue, are routinely used to illustrate Scotlands finances (particularly from pro union sides).

In their latest report they estimated a Scottish "deficit" (which doesn't actually exist) of £15 billion. The UK deficit (which does exist) by comparison was £187 billion. So in the GERS figures Scotland's deficit is the around 8% of the UK total, while they also estimate we contribute around 9% of the UKs total revenue with 8.2% of the population. Under these outcomes Scotland again, cannot be said to be being costing more than it contributes.

This brings me back the point around how Scotland is considered as just another government department in the UK and how that impacts on the above. Under the Scotland Act, Scotland must return a balanced budget each and every year and therefore it cannot physically or legally run a deficit. It can borrow some additional funding from the national loan fund, however there are strict limits on how much can be borrowed, and any borrowing must be fully repaid in subsequent budgets.

Any Scottish deficit cited is simply an antempt at allocating a portion of the UK deficit to Scotland, but doing so overlooks a major flaw, which is that under the current set up only the UK government can utilise borrowing powers to run a deficit and as such any deficit created stems from Westminster decisions/mismanagement, not from Scotland.

A second point on this is that England are often the sole beneficiaries of this power, in that if Westminster decide to increase borrowing to fund English only services or projects they can do so and all four home nations are then liable to cover the cost of said borrowing, which will then impact their supposed "deficiet" (as well as their actual budgets).

Any figures or stats quoted that claim to show that Scotland costs the UK more than it receives are based on assumptions, guesswork, and hunches and are most certainly not facts.

But this is just not true. I’m sorry but it’s not. Ask any economist and they will say an Indy Scotland will face tough economic times - at least for the first decade or so. the majority of Scot’s understand this. And I think deep down most yes voters do too.

By saying every economist is wrong rather than coming up with a frank and honest debate about how Indy Scotland might cope with 10 years of hardship the SNP does itself no favours whatsoever. it’s like telling us to believe a trans man is every bit a woman. Simply not true. Saying it is won’t change facts.

the gullible and easily led are already yes voter. It’s the rest of us you have to convince, and saving black is white won’t wash.

KenAdams · 18/11/2022 07:54

I'm not Scottish so it's not for me to decide but I think things have drastically changed post Brexit so Scots should be given the opportunity for another vote.

MarshaBradyo · 18/11/2022 07:53

Trez1510 · 17/11/2022 23:16

Don't talk utter shite. Just about everything on this thread by unionists is telling use we're too wee i.e. you do not have the resources to support your population without the broad shoulders of the superbly generous (joke!) English, too poor i.e. you will be an economic basketcase without the broad shoulders of the superbly wealthy (joke!) English, and too stupid i.e. your politicians are not a match for/patch on the superbly diplomatic, able, compassionate, dilligent, integrity-filled, honest, transparent, intellectual, talented and personable (fucking massive joke here!) English politicians.

You just have a comprehension problem if you can't equate what is being said on here and elsewhere, by some people who have never even set foot in Scotland, pontificating on our abilities and right to self-determination.

It’s very emotive as Brexit was. But like Brexit it’s better to look at the economics otherwise this kind of hatred and division that comes from your post will just be internalised.

When you can’t blame the English you’ll just fight amongst yourselves over it. Which is the only plus, although I feel sorry for those who did not want it and still don’t.

AlecTrevelyan006 · 18/11/2022 07:47

In 2014 I was a bit sad at the thought of Scotland leaving the U.K.

nowadays I think they can’t leave soon enough.

Workerbeep · 18/11/2022 07:35

I am scottish, born, bred and lived here all my life. I find the comments that you are ‘talking utter sh*’ offensive and abusive.
it’s embarrassing to push this as how we all talk. I cringe when people who think that this is just the Scottish banter.

that’s where your nationalism loses support and shows it true colours of racism. Criticising posters for lying that they are Scottish. I personally don’t know the ‘rules’ anymore of being Scottish.
Lack of historical knowledge of Europe is astounding here. Nationalism is almost a dirty word in Europe especially after ww2 and the nazi party. Even Macron says that nationalism is a betrayal of patriotism and is not a fan.

I’m fed up with all this moaning, ‘it’s not our fault’. Yeah you need to rejoin the eu if scotland ever got independence because who would we blame for all our troubles?

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 18/11/2022 07:01

'Did you also hold the view the French, German, Spanish had a right to an opinion the Brexit referendum?'

Yep, because that's exactly the same situation as a referendum to break up the UK isn't it Hmm TBH, after your comments above about how Scotland is perceived you should welcome a UK wide vote - if everyone outwith Scotland ( or let's face it, you mean England) feels that way they'd probably vote for Scottish independence anyway. Win win. Hurrah.

Your generally persuasive, inclusive, nuanced posts have persuaded me the OP is right - mea culpa. Or, sorry, is that not Scottish enough for you ?

Murdoch1949 · 18/11/2022 05:37

Cannot wait for independence. Then back in EU. Then EU passport. BRING IT ON.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/11/2022 01:34

Paracetamol · 17/11/2022 20:08

Scotland DOES cost the UK more than it puts in. People have literally provided facts and statistics on this thread to back it up.

Funny how the people claiming Scotland DOESN'T take more money than it brings in don't seem to have any evidence or proof of their statements.

First, let me apologise for posting the following wall of text again, but lies like the above need called out every time.

When it comes to finances and accounting Scotland is consider to be just another government department.

All UK revenue is pooled into a central resource (the treasurey) which the UK government then re-allocate as they see fit (there's obviously more to it than that but that's a whole other thread).

Due to the way revenue is recorded it is not possible to accurately report on how much of the total revenue comes from each part of the UK. For example oil and gas exported directly from the North Sea are classified as revenue from "other" sources despite being mostly in Scottish water and is not attributed to Scottish revenue. Similarly, corporation tax is considered from where the HQ is registered, not where revenue was actually generated.

It is therefore an accounting impossibility for Scotland to be cost the UK more than it puts in by as a) we don't actually know how much each nation is putting in and b) we are considered as a single financial entity at this point (a bit like a household with multiple incomes).

However, some have tried to estimate the contribution of Scotland to the UK accounts and the results, as expected vary massively with some reporting that Scotland are net contributers and others saying we are net beneficiaries.

The GERS figures, which are widley dismissed as inaccurate and misleading due to how they apportion spending/revenue, are routinely used to illustrate Scotlands finances (particularly from pro union sides).

In their latest report they estimated a Scottish "deficit" (which doesn't actually exist) of £15 billion. The UK deficit (which does exist) by comparison was £187 billion. So in the GERS figures Scotland's deficit is the around 8% of the UK total, while they also estimate we contribute around 9% of the UKs total revenue with 8.2% of the population. Under these outcomes Scotland again, cannot be said to be being costing more than it contributes.

This brings me back the point around how Scotland is considered as just another government department in the UK and how that impacts on the above. Under the Scotland Act, Scotland must return a balanced budget each and every year and therefore it cannot physically or legally run a deficit. It can borrow some additional funding from the national loan fund, however there are strict limits on how much can be borrowed, and any borrowing must be fully repaid in subsequent budgets.

Any Scottish deficit cited is simply an antempt at allocating a portion of the UK deficit to Scotland, but doing so overlooks a major flaw, which is that under the current set up only the UK government can utilise borrowing powers to run a deficit and as such any deficit created stems from Westminster decisions/mismanagement, not from Scotland.

A second point on this is that England are often the sole beneficiaries of this power, in that if Westminster decide to increase borrowing to fund English only services or projects they can do so and all four home nations are then liable to cover the cost of said borrowing, which will then impact their supposed "deficiet" (as well as their actual budgets).

Any figures or stats quoted that claim to show that Scotland costs the UK more than it receives are based on assumptions, guesswork, and hunches and are most certainly not facts.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 18/11/2022 01:04

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 20:31

I’m guessing you’re trying to say there’s a younger demographic. But if you look at our new world population graph you will see the issues of an aging population. Although Tbf in Scotland our terrible record on health might not be on par with others..

And yet social care and the issues that come with, a lack of growth or centre for business in Scotland doesn’t seem to matter. It seems it will be magically sorted by the pure hopefulness that all of us who voted no have been blinded by.

Well your guessing is terrible then because that's not what I'm trying to say at all.

What I am saying is that many people have come to realise that the union is fundamentally corrupt and designed to favour only one of the "equal" home nations. And that after being subjected a further 8 years of tory austerity and political madness which has now led to the biggest fall in living standards in 70 odd years, it's probably worth asking the question again.

You do realise that Scotland's "terrible health" has been a long standing issue that has existed from well before devolution or the SNP right? It's crystal clear that the union hasn't worked out too well for us so far, so why would you think staying in it as the Torys decimate what's left of the economy is the best solution?

Why do you think an independent Scotland would be incapable of addressing the issues we face if we were fully in control of our country. For example, an independent Scotland would not be facing an energy cost crisis just now.

Similarly, if it were in our best intrest to increase immigration to help deal with social care issues of an aging population we would be able to do so as unlike England we are not overpopulated, whereas currently that's not an option open to us.

Trez1510 · 18/11/2022 00:56

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 00:37

having been sold a lie on brexit

What lie was Scotland sold? If anybody promised that voting to stay in the UK would guarantee Scotland - or indeed the whole of the UK - would remain in the EU in perpetuity, then they had no right to promise this and should not have been taken seriously by anybody who understands that democracy is an ongoing process and never a one-and-for-all single decision.

Tens of millions of people across the whole of the UK feel bitterly betrayed by results of the Brexit referendum - not just those living in Scotland - as indeed, I have no doubt, do many people who voted in favour of Brexit, based on lies and false promises; but again, that's the nature of democracy, with its benefits and its serious flaws, and of politics and the integrity of politicians, as well as the credulity of the voters in those who were put in their positions by previous democratic processes and previous voters as a group (whether that group did or did not include them).

At least you recognise democracy as being 'an ongoing process' .... we, Scots, are at the stage of this process we wish to assert our right to self-determination.

I just wish there were more like you who understand democracy is not static. 😉

Trez1510 · 18/11/2022 00:52

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 23:43

Trez1510, your post above demonstrates clearly why the abuse won't change anyone's mind. Why on earth would anyone who had their doubts about Scottish independence be converted by that sort of tirade?

Most of those commenting on the thread are either Scottish or resident in Scotland. TBH, I think people in Northern Ireland, England and Wales also have a right to an opinion on the proposed break up of the UK.

The OP has lived in Scotland for a few months. Probably not long enough to have grasped the ins and Outs, no matter how much they've read up on the subject. But I guess that's OK with you because they're giving us the benefit of their wisdom and experience in the matter and telling us that Scotland needs to become independent. So that's alright then. The OP has spoken.

Did you also hold the view the French, German, Spanish had a right to an opinion the Brexit referendum?

I believe they did have opinions, and they've been proven correct it was a collective act of self-harm, they knew it, Scots knew, the NIrish knew it. But, just like aliens who held views on Brexit rUK residents will have no vote when we enact our self-determination. 🙂

Anyone can have an opinion, so long as that opinion is not to simply regurgitate the right-wing media's tropes/rhetoric regarding Scotland being 'too wee, too stupid, too poor' to become a thriving independent nation.

I was born, bred and intend to die in Scotland. Me, and many others on this thread have, it's true, lived here far longer than the OP.

Yet, you still decide to ignore the facts presented to you by Scots regarding the 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' rhetoric we receive from those who zilch, nada, zero to do with our constitution.

You seem to believe, for whatever reason, those who desire/demand independence are influenced solely by our FM. Ironically, the tropes/rhetoric espoused by you/your ilk come direct from the pages of the DM, Torygraph and Sun whose billionaire owners fully understand the importance of Scotland and her resources to rUK.

Btw, I doubt your Scottish if you think being told to not talk utter shite is abusive! lol

Oh, and if you think my earlier post was a 'tirade' you are definitely not Scottish. 🙂

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 00:37

having been sold a lie on brexit

What lie was Scotland sold? If anybody promised that voting to stay in the UK would guarantee Scotland - or indeed the whole of the UK - would remain in the EU in perpetuity, then they had no right to promise this and should not have been taken seriously by anybody who understands that democracy is an ongoing process and never a one-and-for-all single decision.

Tens of millions of people across the whole of the UK feel bitterly betrayed by results of the Brexit referendum - not just those living in Scotland - as indeed, I have no doubt, do many people who voted in favour of Brexit, based on lies and false promises; but again, that's the nature of democracy, with its benefits and its serious flaws, and of politics and the integrity of politicians, as well as the credulity of the voters in those who were put in their positions by previous democratic processes and previous voters as a group (whether that group did or did not include them).

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 00:24

FWIW, if the majority of voters in Scotland want independence, then by all means they should have it - whatever mixture of good or bad it ends up leading to. No nastiness needed and no hard feelings - we can still be friends as neighbouring independent countries.

It just happens that the majority of voters in Scotland explicitly voted against independence. Whatever the rights and wrongs of democracy, we go by the majority of votes - whether counted individually or in groups - and not purely based on who shouts the loudest or feels they are the most passionate/best-informed/wisest/wants it the most.

By all means campaign for another referendum(s); as long as you are genuinely driven by an honest desire to reflect the latest will of the majority - meaning that, should the next vote go in favour of independence, you would be just as much in favour of a future referendum(s), which may well swing the other way. Demanding repeated votes until you get what you want and then suddenly banging the door shut is not really how the spirit of fairness works.

CapMarvel · 18/11/2022 00:17

JingleB3lls · 17/11/2022 23:51

The majority of Scotland do not want independence. We had our vote. We voted no.

Recent polls would suggest that, at best from a unionist point of view, Scotland hasn't made it's mind up and at worst that actually over the last few months there are more people in favour than not of independance.

CapMarvel · 18/11/2022 00:15

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 00:11

Scotland voted to remain in the UK in 2014 largely on the premise that it was the only way to remain part of the EU. How did that work out?

It worked out as well as it could. Staying in the UK was the only realistic way that Scotland could have remained in the EU - but having made that choice, the UK - including Scotland - then made the majority choice to leave. Meaning that the pro-Brexit voters living in Scotland - as part of the UK majority - then got their way, just as the pro-remain voters living in E/W/NI - as part of the UK minority - did not get their way.

As I said before, it was a per capita referendum, so entirely irrelevant where each voter happened to be located. Statistician were free to analyse and publish the data on how many people living in Wales/bald people/people under 5' tall/Audi drivers/Beatles fans/people living in houses with green front doors/accountants/whatever voted one way or the other - but ultimately it meant nothing more than a little vignette of potential arbitrary interest.

Everybody can only vote based on the current circumstances, in good faith - voting one way in an election or referendum in no way guarantees that future votes will go your way based on your choice in this one.

Seriously, what would the alternative have been? Should we have disregarded the (majority) collective vote of the people who happened to be in England, Wales and NI and only counted the votes of voters who happened to be in Scotland? Should we have given voters living in Scotland 2, 3, 5, 10 votes each and everybody else only 1 vote? That's the kind of 'democracy' that would have made the likes of Mugabe beam with pride!

The alternative is, fairly obviously, that having been sold a lie on brexit Scotland should be permitted to hold another independence referendum.

Yes, Scotland voted to remain in the UK. Yes, the UK as a whole voted for brexit like a bunch of fucking idiots and yes, you cannot deny that there is a huge feeling of betrayal in scotland as a result of that.

CapMarvel · 18/11/2022 00:13

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:36

@CapMarvel A LITERAL QUOTE FROM THE SNPs OWN PAPER IN 2014 🤦‍♀️

...which is irrelevant to the point being made. Never mind, eh.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 00:11

Scotland voted to remain in the UK in 2014 largely on the premise that it was the only way to remain part of the EU. How did that work out?

It worked out as well as it could. Staying in the UK was the only realistic way that Scotland could have remained in the EU - but having made that choice, the UK - including Scotland - then made the majority choice to leave. Meaning that the pro-Brexit voters living in Scotland - as part of the UK majority - then got their way, just as the pro-remain voters living in E/W/NI - as part of the UK minority - did not get their way.

As I said before, it was a per capita referendum, so entirely irrelevant where each voter happened to be located. Statistician were free to analyse and publish the data on how many people living in Wales/bald people/people under 5' tall/Audi drivers/Beatles fans/people living in houses with green front doors/accountants/whatever voted one way or the other - but ultimately it meant nothing more than a little vignette of potential arbitrary interest.

Everybody can only vote based on the current circumstances, in good faith - voting one way in an election or referendum in no way guarantees that future votes will go your way based on your choice in this one.

Seriously, what would the alternative have been? Should we have disregarded the (majority) collective vote of the people who happened to be in England, Wales and NI and only counted the votes of voters who happened to be in Scotland? Should we have given voters living in Scotland 2, 3, 5, 10 votes each and everybody else only 1 vote? That's the kind of 'democracy' that would have made the likes of Mugabe beam with pride!

giggly · 18/11/2022 00:01

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:46

Thanks @ILoveXmasChocsInNov
It always amazes me how much MN hate the SNP and yet in real life people keep voting for them.
Scotland will become independent.

Absolutely this. The only people I know in RL who actually hate the SNP are loyalists.
I will struggle to vote for them again if the GR bill goes through, but fuck me no one else to vote for.

JingleB3lls · 17/11/2022 23:51

The majority of Scotland do not want independence. We had our vote. We voted no.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 23:43

Trez1510, your post above demonstrates clearly why the abuse won't change anyone's mind. Why on earth would anyone who had their doubts about Scottish independence be converted by that sort of tirade?

Most of those commenting on the thread are either Scottish or resident in Scotland. TBH, I think people in Northern Ireland, England and Wales also have a right to an opinion on the proposed break up of the UK.

The OP has lived in Scotland for a few months. Probably not long enough to have grasped the ins and Outs, no matter how much they've read up on the subject. But I guess that's OK with you because they're giving us the benefit of their wisdom and experience in the matter and telling us that Scotland needs to become independent. So that's alright then. The OP has spoken.

Trez1510 · 17/11/2022 23:16

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 21:50

You do realise that the only people who've ever come up with the 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' line are N Sturgeon and her independence pals. They repeat and repeat the assertion in the hope that Scots will eventually believe that Westminster/the English/pro union supporters think that. To drive another wedge, to fuel division, to shift the focus away from the practicalities, to tug on the emotions, to whip up the hatred.

Don't talk utter shite. Just about everything on this thread by unionists is telling use we're too wee i.e. you do not have the resources to support your population without the broad shoulders of the superbly generous (joke!) English, too poor i.e. you will be an economic basketcase without the broad shoulders of the superbly wealthy (joke!) English, and too stupid i.e. your politicians are not a match for/patch on the superbly diplomatic, able, compassionate, dilligent, integrity-filled, honest, transparent, intellectual, talented and personable (fucking massive joke here!) English politicians.

You just have a comprehension problem if you can't equate what is being said on here and elsewhere, by some people who have never even set foot in Scotland, pontificating on our abilities and right to self-determination.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 23:08

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:48

@Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble yes that one is particularly special. Not an isolated occurrence from her either…twitter.com/themajorityscot/status/1592590946671042560?s=20&t=rVwlRGm61GbGkkwlmVf0AA

omg that’s hilarious! I love the comment underneath “Ma Broon’s let herself go”. Says it all.

Trez1510 · 17/11/2022 23:08

@DownNative

How very undemocratic of England not allowing EU nationals etc. resident in England (and her chattels lol) to participate in the constitutional vote on exiting the European Union.

The Scottish people live in a COUNTRY, not a state, therefore we can decide to fuck-off out of this (so-called) union of equals 😂without England's permission.

dannyefcfan1 · 17/11/2022 23:08

It's a matter for Scottish people, so I hope they are given another vote soon because of brexit. And then what will be, will be. Not sure why english people get so heated about it.

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 22:48

@Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble yes that one is particularly special. Not an isolated occurrence from her either…twitter.com/themajorityscot/status/1592590946671042560?s=20&t=rVwlRGm61GbGkkwlmVf0AA