Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
DownNative · 18/11/2022 15:28

And, needless to say, there is NO such provision in the Scotland Act, @1dayatatime. It's a logical fallacy known as Non-sequitur to argue the NI Act and the GFA applies to Scotland since it doesn't follow.

DownNative · 18/11/2022 15:21

1dayatatime · 18/11/2022 13:25

@DownNative

"Since you tried being passive aggressive on my point about there being no right in international law to secession.......I challenge YOU to prove there is such a right."

++++

Ooo now I do love a challenge!!

As part of the Good Friday Agreement, an explicit provision for holding a Northern Ireland border poll was made in UK law. The Northern Ireland Act 1998 states that “if at any time it appears likely to him that a majority of those voting would express a wish that Northern Ireland should cease to be part of the United Kingdom and form part of a united Ireland”, the Secretary of State shall make an Order in Council enabling a border poll.

Now that looks like a pretty explicit provision in UK law on the right of Northern Ireland to leave the UK if a majority so wishes.

Nice try! But that's a blatant misunderstanding of the situation, the GFA and my argument.

International law states there is NO democratic right to secession AND that the power to consent to it is wholly within the sovereign government.

In the case of Northern Ireland, the UK Government has had that policy since 1920 due to the threats of coercion of "The Black North" by the Nationalists. Northern Ireland, unlike Scotland, England and Wales, is a special case. GB has zero terrorism problem and so Northern Ireland is NOT a precedent for them. We are an EXCEPTION.

But you didn't undermine my point at all since the UK Government consents to it freely. There is nothing in international law that obliges it to do so.

Indeed, the GFA has already been changed previously and any or all of its contents can be changed by the UK. After all, the GFA makes it clear Northern Ireland is an INTEGRAL part of the UK AND that the UK Government retains FULL Sovereignty.

But there is no democratic right to secession except by consent of the sovereign power. Indeed, Westminster can and has stepped in to enact power in Northern Ireland for decades. It is still the case that Westminster is the Supreme Authority and Legislator over Northern Ireland. A fact Irish nationalists and Republicans could not get away from.

Hence, only the UK via its Secretary of State has complete control over any referendum on Northern Ireland's constitutional status. And it doesn't have to make the criteria explicit either!

Try again....

Trez1510 · 18/11/2022 15:07

Let's turn this on it's head.

How many rUK residents would be happy to have SNP candidates stand in their constituency, and tell them they're too stupid to understand their own nation and Scots know better?

How many other countries in the world permit political parties based in other nations to stand in their elections?

Would Germany, for example, be delighted to have, say, French politicians from French political parties stand in their elections whilst telling them they have no idea how to run their country and should defer to the 'brilliance' of French political/social norms and 'just like it' because that's how it's done.

This is what happens in Scotland and has done so for decades now. Anglo-centric parties retitle themselves 'Scottish' this and 'Scottish' that but their HQs are in London, their masters are in London, and their policies are driven by matters of importance to London.

Of all the countries who have taken their right to govern themselves away from London control, how many have begged to return to English control?

Why do people believe Scotland is uniquely incapable of governing itself when much smaller, with less natural resources etc., countries manage perfectly well?

DownNative · 18/11/2022 15:01

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 14:55

Voting yes is not voting for the SNP.

Likewise, "a vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum" said by Sturgeon. 🧐

DownNative · 18/11/2022 14:59

BlueBellsArePretty · 18/11/2022 13:58

@DownNative

'Less passive aggressive rubbish from you and more engaging with the actual arguments made. 🤷‍♂️'

No I'm under no obligation to engage with your condescending and rapidly googled and pasted wall of text. So no I will not be taking you up on your 'challenge'

Desperate to keep us eh? Here's a 'challenge' for you, explain why?

Of course, you're under no obligation. But you very obviously cannot challenge my assertion that there is no democratic right to secession in international law and politics.

You can try an Ad Hominem attack all you like, but it really doesn't change my argument to you. It's completely fantasy to think independent sovereign states such as the UK, USA, Germany, France, Spain, Italy and many more cannot block secessionist aims.

They can and they have. Germany did it in 2017 as I showed, for example. Spain and France continue to block their own secessionist movements democratically and legally.

antelopevalley · 18/11/2022 14:55

Voting yes is not voting for the SNP.

OP posts:
Notonationalism · 18/11/2022 14:54

@BlueBellsArePretty less desperation to “keep Scotland” and more that most in Scotland show little sign of having moved from their 2014 position
Almost a decade of SNP grievance lingering and shockingly poor govt in Holyrood hasn’t persuaded No voters that they offer a sensible economic case for change.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 14:48

At least you recognise democracy as being 'an ongoing process' .... we, Scots, are at the stage of this process we wish to assert our right to self-determination.
I just wish there were more like you who understand democracy is not static.

Yes, as I explicitly said - I agree with you there.

You just need to get more than half of your fellow country-people to agree with you and then I wish you all the best.

BlueBellsArePretty · 18/11/2022 13:58

@DownNative

'Less passive aggressive rubbish from you and more engaging with the actual arguments made. 🤷‍♂️'

No I'm under no obligation to engage with your condescending and rapidly googled and pasted wall of text. So no I will not be taking you up on your 'challenge'

Desperate to keep us eh? Here's a 'challenge' for you, explain why?

1dayatatime · 18/11/2022 13:25

@DownNative

"Since you tried being passive aggressive on my point about there being no right in international law to secession.......I challenge YOU to prove there is such a right."

++++

Ooo now I do love a challenge!!

As part of the Good Friday Agreement, an explicit provision for holding a Northern Ireland border poll was made in UK law. The Northern Ireland Act 1998 states that “if at any time it appears likely to him that a majority of those voting would express a wish that Northern Ireland should cease to be part of the United Kingdom and form part of a united Ireland”, the Secretary of State shall make an Order in Council enabling a border poll.

Now that looks like a pretty explicit provision in UK law on the right of Northern Ireland to leave the UK if a majority so wishes.

DownNative · 18/11/2022 13:16

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 21:42

I implied no such thing. I am fully aware that people are divided on the question which is why it is so important to, y'know, find out the answer in an official way as possible.

And no, it's not circular reasoning to ask why, if the unionists are so confident they would win a referendum which would put the matter to bed for far longer this time round, they are so unwilling to do. To not ask the question at all is very simply anti-democratic and oppresive.

Of course it is blatantly circular reasoning since you're attempting to reinforce your implication of Unionist fear as well as attempting present it as a False Dilemma between confidence and fear only without any other options. That's two logical fallacies.

As expected, you've nothing other than attempting to appeal to emotions (logical fallacy too!).

Meanwhile, I'm quoting international law and politics to show my point!

Secession is not a democratic right

"Currently, among the constitutional laws of the world, only two states carry the right of secession in their constitution: Ethiopia, and the Federation of Saint Kitts and Nevis."

  • My Country, Europe

“In the Federal Republic of Germany, which is a nation-state based on the constituent power of the German people, states are not ‘masters of the constitution’.

Therefore there is no room under the constitution for individual states to attempt to secede. This violates the constitutional order.”

  • Ruling from the Constitutional Court of the Federal Republic of Germany.

"The Constitution is based on the indissoluble unity of the Spanish Nation, the common and indivisible homeland of all Spaniards; it recognizes and guarantees the right to self-government of the nationalities and regions of which it is composed and the solidarity among them all."

  • Section Two of the Spanish Constitution

"France shall be an indivisible, secular, democratic and social Republic."

  • Article One of the French Constitution

"The Republic, one and indivisible, recognizes and promotes local autonomies; implements in those services which depend on the State the fullest measure of administrative decentralization; accords the principles and methods of its legislation to the requirements of autonomy and decentralization."

  • Article Five of the Italian Constitution

"It is clear that international law does not specifically grant component parts of sovereign states the legal right to secede unilaterally from their "parent" state....

The various international documents that support the existence of a people's right to self-determination also contain parallel statements supportive of the conclusion that the exercise of such a right must be sufficiently limited to prevent threats to an existing state's territorial integrity or the stability of relations between sovereign states...

A state whose government represents the whole of the people or peoples resident within its territory, on a basis of equality and without discrimination, and respects the principles of self-determination in its own internal arrangements, is entitled to the protection under international law of its territorial integrity."

  • Canadian Supreme Court ruling on the issue of secession

"I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."

  • United States of America Pledge Of Allegiance

"The answer is clear. If there was any constitutional issue resolved by the Civil War, it is that there is no right to secede. (Hence, in the Pledge of Allegiance, ‘one Nation, indivisible.’)”

  • Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia in 2006

“Article 52 of the Constitution is a unitarian structure, indivisible, indecomposable."

Dean of the Brazilian Supreme Court, Judge Celso de Mello

"WHEREAS the people of New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia, Queensland, and Tasmania, humbly relying on the blessing of Almighty God, have agreed to unite in one indissoluble Federal Commonwealth...."

  • Preamble to the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia
DownNative · 18/11/2022 13:11

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

DownNative · 18/11/2022 12:58

BlueBellsArePretty · 17/11/2022 21:29

What an absolute hate filled shitshow of a thread. To summarise people gleefully stating 'we're too wee, too poor and too stupid' to be independent.

As a Scot the absolute arrogance of the 'oooh you don't have succession rights lol' 'oooh you have such high drugs deaths lol' posts makes me sick. It is attitudes displayed here that push more people towards independence.

Let's be honest the reasons given why Scotland ought to remain are not benevolent.

Since you tried being passive aggressive on my point about there being no right in international law to secession.......I challenge YOU to prove there is such a right.

What's that?! You can't? That's fine because I'll post it again:

Secession is not a democratic right

"Currently, among the constitutional laws of the world, only two states carry the right of secession in their constitution: Ethiopia, and the Federation of Saint Kitts and Nevis."

  • My Country, Europe

“In the Federal Republic of Germany, which is a nation-state based on the constituent power of the German people, states are not ‘masters of the constitution’.

Therefore there is no room under the constitution for individual states to attempt to secede. This violates the constitutional order.”

  • Ruling from the Constitutional Court of the Federal Republic of Germany.

"The Constitution is based on the indissoluble unity of the Spanish Nation, the common and indivisible homeland of all Spaniards; it recognizes and guarantees the right to self-government of the nationalities and regions of which it is composed and the solidarity among them all."

  • Section Two of the Spanish Constitution

"France shall be an indivisible, secular, democratic and social Republic."

  • Article One of the French Constitution

"The Republic, one and indivisible, recognizes and promotes local autonomies; implements in those services which depend on the State the fullest measure of administrative decentralization; accords the principles and methods of its legislation to the requirements of autonomy and decentralization."

  • Article Five of the Italian Constitution

"It is clear that international law does not specifically grant component parts of sovereign states the legal right to secede unilaterally from their "parent" state....

The various international documents that support the existence of a people's right to self-determination also contain parallel statements supportive of the conclusion that the exercise of such a right must be sufficiently limited to prevent threats to an existing state's territorial integrity or the stability of relations between sovereign states...

A state whose government represents the whole of the people or peoples resident within its territory, on a basis of equality and without discrimination, and respects the principles of self-determination in its own internal arrangements, is entitled to the protection under international law of its territorial integrity."

  • Canadian Supreme Court ruling on the issue of secession

"I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands, one Nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all."

  • United States of America Pledge Of Allegiance

"The answer is clear. If there was any constitutional issue resolved by the Civil War, it is that there is no right to secede. (Hence, in the Pledge of Allegiance, ‘one Nation, indivisible.’)”

  • Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia in 2006

“Article 52 of the Constitution is a unitarian structure, indivisible, indecomposable."

Dean of the Brazilian Supreme Court, Judge Celso de Mello

"WHEREAS the people of New South Wales, Victoria, South Australia, Queensland, and Tasmania, humbly relying on the blessing of Almighty God, have agreed to unite in one indissoluble Federal Commonwealth...."

  • Preamble to the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Australia

So, if there was an actual right to secession in international law.....all the above would be illegal.

Yet they are not. Funny that(!)

Less passive aggressive rubbish from you and more engaging with the actual arguments made. 🤷‍♂️

DownNative · 18/11/2022 12:49

Trez1510 · 17/11/2022 23:08

@DownNative

How very undemocratic of England not allowing EU nationals etc. resident in England (and her chattels lol) to participate in the constitutional vote on exiting the European Union.

The Scottish people live in a COUNTRY, not a state, therefore we can decide to fuck-off out of this (so-called) union of equals 😂without England's permission.

Actually, no, it wasn't undemocratic since the EU is NOT an independent, sovereign state. There is a crucial difference between sovereign states such as the UK, France, Germany, Spain, etc, and the EU.

None of those countries allow secession except for....the UK. Even then, there is nothing in international law that states the UK Government must give in to Nationalist demands for a secession referendum.

Scotland is a non-sovereign country. Under international law, its only entitled to devolution which it has.

International law also makes it VERY clear Scotland cannot unilaterally declare independence. In fact, to do so would mean sovereign states AND the EU would not recognise a UDI Scotland as legally independent. This has a wide range of implications, including the EU refusing to admit a UDI Scotland to the EU.

Canada helpfully gave us a ruling on this the UK will follow:

"It is clear that international law does not specifically grant component parts of sovereign states the legal right to secede unilaterally from their "parent" state....

The various international documents that support the existence of a people's right to self-determination also contain parallel statements supportive of the conclusion that the exercise of such a right must be sufficiently limited to prevent threats to an existing state's territorial integrity or the stability of relations between sovereign states...

A state whose government represents the whole of the people or peoples resident within its territory, on a basis of equality and without discrimination, and respects the principles of self-determination in its own internal arrangements, is entitled to the protection under international law of its territorial integrity."

  • Canadian Supreme Court ruling on the issue of secession

The fact devolution exists within the UK ultimately means international law WILL protect the territorial integrity of the UK in the event of an illegal UDI.

Your argument is full of emotion and without legal political logic. Sad.

DownNative · 18/11/2022 12:32

PineapplePear · 18/11/2022 08:42

Things will not move on until we get another referendum. Whether unionists agree with it or not, things have changed dramatically since 2016 and a large proportion of Scot’s are very unhappy with the ‘union’.

I don’t think anyone wants to see repeated referendums on the same issue, but there does need to be another one given the level of change. Otherwise, we will reach/have already reached a political stalemate we’re a sizeable chunk of the population will not vote for uk parties, in Scottish or Westminster elections, and another chunk will not vote for independence parties. This removes choice and I don’t think that’s good.

As an independence voter I think SNP have reached there peak, and we need fresh blood in power, but I could not bear to vote for a party that thinks it’s morally acceptable for Westminster/politicians outside Scotland to ‘allow’ a referendum. That is not democracy. We didn’t need the EUs permission to vote on brexit.

Of course it's completely democratic for sovereign states to have the power to permit or block secessionist demands for a referendum!

International law makes it very clear that a right to self-determination has to be balanced against a state's right to territorial integrity.

Of course, the UK didn't require the permission of the EU in order to have a referendum on EU membership. That's because the EU is absolutely NOT an independent, sovereign state!

You clearly do NOT understand international law, democracy or politics. 🤷‍♂️ I'm sure you'll be shocked to be told AGAIN that there is NO democratic right to secession.

Snnowflake · 18/11/2022 11:17

I'm not sure the Brexit result reflects what Scotland really thinks.
For the Scottish referendum there was a 85% turnout. For the Brexit vote only 67%.so a good proportion didn't care. Had they voted it could have been leave or it could have been stay. I suspect leave because of the demographic of an older population. Over the UK there was a 72% turnout.

It could also demonstrates that being part of Europe is less important the further you are from it - Scots aren't regularly going to pop to France to stock up on wine or for a weekend in Brittany due to the extra 400 miles involved.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 18/11/2022 11:14

DdraigGoch · 18/11/2022 08:53

Yes, I've got plenty of passport stamps after my last holiday which involved overland travel through several non-Schengen countries. A little inconvenient to have to get off of the bus several times in the middle of the night to go through the frontier on each side, not to mention a train waiting at a station while two sets of border guards scanned and stamped everyone's passports.

Of course if Scotland doesn't join the EU then matters are simplified because as well as remaining part of the Common Travel Area you could set up some kind of Customs Union.

What if Scotland does want to join the EU though? I think that the current situation in Northern Ireland is a clear demonstration of the pitfalls there.

Import export is what I do for a living. The fact that there is no land border in Ireland is entirely down to the Irish political situation. This has moved the UK/ EU border from N Ireland to the Irish Sea in order not to have a physical border dissecting Ireland.

if Scotland was in the EU and the UK was not there would be a hard border between Scotland and England as the EU would demand it. Mind you, I don’t think Scotland will become independent, and I certainly don’t think it will join the EU before the UK rejoins the EU free trade area / single market. There is a public will to bring down the trade barriers between us and the EU. It will happen before too long when enough of the gammons die off so that their xenophobic views no longer sway politics.

DdraigGoch · 18/11/2022 08:53

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 18:42

Have you ever been to other countries with long land borders? They usually have official borders at main roads, but nowhere else. I have lived in other countries and when out for a walk realised I had walked to another country. I did not realise until I saw signposts to local villages. Britain is unusual in being an island. Most countries have land borders with other countries, including NI.

Yes, I've got plenty of passport stamps after my last holiday which involved overland travel through several non-Schengen countries. A little inconvenient to have to get off of the bus several times in the middle of the night to go through the frontier on each side, not to mention a train waiting at a station while two sets of border guards scanned and stamped everyone's passports.

Of course if Scotland doesn't join the EU then matters are simplified because as well as remaining part of the Common Travel Area you could set up some kind of Customs Union.

What if Scotland does want to join the EU though? I think that the current situation in Northern Ireland is a clear demonstration of the pitfalls there.

SudocremOnEverything · 18/11/2022 08:51

HeraldicBlazoning · 18/11/2022 08:25

Perhaps not.

But Scottish people do realise how bad things are in Scotland under the Dear Leader who shall not ever be criticised.

I find it hard ti believe that many people in Scotland are imagining that things are so much worse in England right now.

I mean, objectively, it’s simply not the case that Scotland is somehow unaffected by cost of living issues, or that Scottish public services are brilliantly functional. Or even that they necessarily compare favourably to the rUK equivalent.

it’s not like you cross the border from the land of milk and honey to a post apocalyptic wasteland when you head south. The SNP might like you to believe it was though.

PineapplePear · 18/11/2022 08:42

Things will not move on until we get another referendum. Whether unionists agree with it or not, things have changed dramatically since 2016 and a large proportion of Scot’s are very unhappy with the ‘union’.

I don’t think anyone wants to see repeated referendums on the same issue, but there does need to be another one given the level of change. Otherwise, we will reach/have already reached a political stalemate we’re a sizeable chunk of the population will not vote for uk parties, in Scottish or Westminster elections, and another chunk will not vote for independence parties. This removes choice and I don’t think that’s good.

As an independence voter I think SNP have reached there peak, and we need fresh blood in power, but I could not bear to vote for a party that thinks it’s morally acceptable for Westminster/politicians outside Scotland to ‘allow’ a referendum. That is not democracy. We didn’t need the EUs permission to vote on brexit.

HeraldicBlazoning · 18/11/2022 08:25

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:59

Laughing, I wish I was Nicola.
We have only lived in Scotland since the summer. I am so glad to be in Scotland rather than England. I do not think most Scottish people realise how bad things are in large parts of England now.

Perhaps not.

But Scottish people do realise how bad things are in Scotland under the Dear Leader who shall not ever be criticised.

Fairyliz · 18/11/2022 08:22

Yes I wish they would then we wouldn’t have to hear them whining on so much.

x2boys · 18/11/2022 08:21

Murdoch1949 · 18/11/2022 05:37

Cannot wait for independence. Then back in EU. Then EU passport. BRING IT ON.

I dont think its quite as simple as that ....

Snnowflake · 18/11/2022 08:09

Our population has remained the same in number for decades whilst the English has hugely increased - that must tell you something. Unfortunately our pop has also aged proportionally thanks possibly to retirees.
Doesn’t bode well imv.

SudocremOnEverything · 18/11/2022 08:01

I suspects this ‘forward-looking’ and ‘progressive’ utopia will not live up to expectations.