Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Michellexxx · 19/11/2022 15:44

Alexandra2001 · 19/11/2022 09:54

50% of UK gas usage across the year comes from NSea, a great deal from what would become Scottish waters, vast areas for renewables, tide wave wind.. fishing forestry and a suitable port for Trident.

Plus were would the Royals go? lol

You do know that the oil and gas in the North Sea are owned by private companies? So they’re the ones who get the profits, not the govt. hence the windfall tax.
Also, NS has already said the the royals would remain head of state so your point is totally irrelevant re where they would go. Balmoral is also privately owned, so they can go whenever they want..

DownNative · 19/11/2022 15:10

CapMarvel · 19/11/2022 14:15

Oh look, more cut/pasting. Well done you!

This kind of response never reflects well on YOU because you're willfully ignoring the facts as well as evidence that undermines your attempted argument.

FullFact is an independent fact checker.

Once again, there's nothing wrong with presenting an argument as long as you can actually back it up with evidence. This is what I have done.

You? Definitely not. What you very obviously rely on is emotional based argument that deliberately misleads others. And you hope enough people are taken in by it. It's not working out for you.....is it? 🤷‍♂️

But it suits me!

wigywhoo · 19/11/2022 14:15

Wish they would!

CapMarvel · 19/11/2022 14:15

DownNative · 19/11/2022 14:11

Funny.....you previously claimed Scotland produces 97% of its energy needs via renewables! Now you claim its 98%.

Either way, both figures are misleading as I demonstrated to you several pages ago.

Misleading claptrap regarding the claim that "around 97% of it's needs are met by renewables" for Scotland!

Here's the facts as set out by FullFact:

"The Scottish National Party (SNP) leader and Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has claimed that almost all electricity used in Scotland is from renewable sources. This is not correct....."

And:

"Suggesting that near 100% of electricity used in Scotland is from renewable sources would be true if Scotland used all its renewable electricity and only exported non-renewable.

But that’s not how electricity systems work.

In fact, the Scottish Government estimates that, in 2020, 56% of the electricity consumed in Scotland came from renewable sources, 30% from nuclear and 13% from fossil fuels.

Renewables still account for far more of Scotland’s electricity consumption than in England and Wales.

But to suggest it's almost 100% is misleading."

In fact, the Scottish Government backtracked on that and basically said they didn't mean to mislead anyone!

Here:

"The Scottish Government told Full Fact the First Minister was referring to Scotland’s gross electricity consumption and it was not her intention to suggest otherwise."

FullFact went on to say:

"We deserve better than bad information.

After we published this fact check, we contacted the SNP to request clarification regarding this claim.

They added text underneath the video on their website but this did not explain that Nicola Sturgeon made an incorrect claim in the video.

They did not add any information to their social media pages where the video was shared.

It’s not good enough."

fullfact.org/environment/scotland-renewable-energy/

Don't ye know the SNP have form for misleading people in order to further their independence agenda?!

I'm afraid your attempted argument cannot stand on its own feet....

Oh look, more cut/pasting. Well done you!

CapMarvel · 19/11/2022 14:14

DownNative · 19/11/2022 13:19

Juvenile response.

On the contrary, I made an argument AND then supported it with examples from international law as well as politics.

Your condescending Ad Hominem Fallacy response just demonstrates you have no logical argument to make against international law and politics as it stands.

That suits me. 🤷‍♂️

Sure hen.

DownNative · 19/11/2022 14:11

CapMarvel · 18/11/2022 21:13

I actually wrote to my tory mp on this matter - Scotland is a net exporter of energy and produces about 98% of it's energy needs via renewables. I didn't get an answer of course, because this is a man who couldn't be arsed answering the phone when most of his consituency lost power for 10 days last year so why bother now?

Yet we are suffering from the same massive increase in electricity prices because they are based on the price of gas - when almost none of Scotland's power is generated this way.

So what is happening is that Scottish bill payers are massively subsidising the bills of the rest of the uk. Better together, indeed.

Funny.....you previously claimed Scotland produces 97% of its energy needs via renewables! Now you claim its 98%.

Either way, both figures are misleading as I demonstrated to you several pages ago.

Misleading claptrap regarding the claim that "around 97% of it's needs are met by renewables" for Scotland!

Here's the facts as set out by FullFact:

"The Scottish National Party (SNP) leader and Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has claimed that almost all electricity used in Scotland is from renewable sources. This is not correct....."

And:

"Suggesting that near 100% of electricity used in Scotland is from renewable sources would be true if Scotland used all its renewable electricity and only exported non-renewable.

But that’s not how electricity systems work.

In fact, the Scottish Government estimates that, in 2020, 56% of the electricity consumed in Scotland came from renewable sources, 30% from nuclear and 13% from fossil fuels.

Renewables still account for far more of Scotland’s electricity consumption than in England and Wales.

But to suggest it's almost 100% is misleading."

In fact, the Scottish Government backtracked on that and basically said they didn't mean to mislead anyone!

Here:

"The Scottish Government told Full Fact the First Minister was referring to Scotland’s gross electricity consumption and it was not her intention to suggest otherwise."

FullFact went on to say:

"We deserve better than bad information.

After we published this fact check, we contacted the SNP to request clarification regarding this claim.

They added text underneath the video on their website but this did not explain that Nicola Sturgeon made an incorrect claim in the video.

They did not add any information to their social media pages where the video was shared.

It’s not good enough."

fullfact.org/environment/scotland-renewable-energy/

Don't ye know the SNP have form for misleading people in order to further their independence agenda?!

I'm afraid your attempted argument cannot stand on its own feet....

DownNative · 19/11/2022 13:48

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/11/2022 10:55

They were promised the only way for Scotland to remain in the EU was to vote NO. In good faith they did so, swinging the referendum away from the will of born-Scots.

But that was true: it was the only way that Scotland could remain in the EU. The fact that a later democratic vote took things down a different pathway is immaterial; indeed, the very fact that there was a vote shows that, for everybody in the UK, there was the option to stay in the EU, had the majority wanted it.

Saying 'the only way that this could happen' is absolutely not the same as saying that 'if you choose this, this WILL happen'. The only way you can possibly win a competition is by entering, but that doesn't mean that, if you enter, you WILL win it.

Very well argued!

I would add that the issue of EU membership was NOT a decisive factor for Scottish Nationalism or Scottish Unionism alike in 2014.

See attachment. That blows the Nationalist argument apart that Scotland was lied to in regards to EU membership in 2014. Indeed, a Yes vote in 2014 was a vote to leave the UK AND the EU in one fell swoop!

Again in 2016, Scotland had the second lowest turnout in the UK EU Referendum which demonstrates there wasn't particularly strong support, arguably. Only Northern Ireland had a lower turnout.

To think Scotland should become independent?
DownNative · 19/11/2022 13:37

Trez1510 · 18/11/2022 15:07

Let's turn this on it's head.

How many rUK residents would be happy to have SNP candidates stand in their constituency, and tell them they're too stupid to understand their own nation and Scots know better?

How many other countries in the world permit political parties based in other nations to stand in their elections?

Would Germany, for example, be delighted to have, say, French politicians from French political parties stand in their elections whilst telling them they have no idea how to run their country and should defer to the 'brilliance' of French political/social norms and 'just like it' because that's how it's done.

This is what happens in Scotland and has done so for decades now. Anglo-centric parties retitle themselves 'Scottish' this and 'Scottish' that but their HQs are in London, their masters are in London, and their policies are driven by matters of importance to London.

Of all the countries who have taken their right to govern themselves away from London control, how many have begged to return to English control?

Why do people believe Scotland is uniquely incapable of governing itself when much smaller, with less natural resources etc., countries manage perfectly well?

Unfortunately, you have failed to turn anything on its head!

The SNP are free to campaign for election in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. There's no law that prohibits them, you know! But they, you and I know they won't get elected in England, Wales or Northern Ireland.

Scotland is NOT separate from the rest of the UK. If it were, your campaign for independence wouldn't make ANY sense whatsoever! So, any party from any part of the UK can stand in any other part of the UK. After all, England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are INTEGRAL parts of the ONE sovereign state aka country known as the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. See above - the SNP can stand in ANY part of the UK. Not a problem!

Your attempted argument about French and German political parties standing in each other's respective sovereign territory is laughable!

That's because Germany and France are NOT part of a sovereign state called Germance! They are TWO separate, independent and sovereign states, you know.

Your attempted comparison falls flat on its face. Completely.

Scotland within the UK is far more comparable to Catalonia within Spain or Quebec within Canada. It's also comparable to Bavaria within Germany.

Yet Quebec, Catalonia and Bavaria have all been shown that they have zero democratic rights to secession from their respective parent states. You see, territorial integrity of sovereign states takes precedence.

The only way self-determination takes precedence over territorial integrity is in cases of oppression by the sovereign state or in a colonial context.

Evidence here:

"In a UN context, the right to self-determination in its external shape is applicable to people (not to national, ethnic, and religious minorities, whose rights are recognized in Article 27 of the ICCPR, 1966) or to the nations in the cases of: a) a colonial context; or b) in a situation of any foreign domination or occupation."

"Today, it may be concluded that international law bestows on all peoples the right to self-determination, but that the right to external self-determination, exercised through remedial secession, only applies in extreme circumstances, to colonized and severely persecuted peoples."

Fortunately, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Quebec, Catalonia and Bavaria are neither examples of colonialism NOR are they in any way oppressed by their parent states.

No wonder you wanted to compare Scotland to Germany and France! 🤷‍♂️

Therefore, your bogus comparison is what we call False Equivalence and falls flat on its face.

DownNative · 19/11/2022 13:19

CapMarvel · 18/11/2022 19:06

Well done, you can cut and paste in lieu of having an actual argument.

Juvenile response.

On the contrary, I made an argument AND then supported it with examples from international law as well as politics.

Your condescending Ad Hominem Fallacy response just demonstrates you have no logical argument to make against international law and politics as it stands.

That suits me. 🤷‍♂️

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 19/11/2022 10:55

They were promised the only way for Scotland to remain in the EU was to vote NO. In good faith they did so, swinging the referendum away from the will of born-Scots.

But that was true: it was the only way that Scotland could remain in the EU. The fact that a later democratic vote took things down a different pathway is immaterial; indeed, the very fact that there was a vote shows that, for everybody in the UK, there was the option to stay in the EU, had the majority wanted it.

Saying 'the only way that this could happen' is absolutely not the same as saying that 'if you choose this, this WILL happen'. The only way you can possibly win a competition is by entering, but that doesn't mean that, if you enter, you WILL win it.

Workerbeep · 19/11/2022 10:42

our society and country’s problems are complex and it’s naive and foolhardy to think that independence will solve inequalities and miraculously lead to a utopia.

One thing I can’t understand regarding SNP is when Nicola Sturgeon was health minister she cut the number of training places at university for nurses and doctors. I read the recent rise in Scottish places for medicine actually equated to something like 10 places across the whole country. That’s not going to make much difference.

wasn’t there some problem with the latest cohort of medical students graduating from Dundee too and a lot are having to resit?

Saying a lot of nhs vacancies were filled with EU candidates doesn’t sit well for me either as surely that depletes their home country of their expertise and skills.

energy storage in Scotland needs looking at imo.

my other half deals a lot with exports. Brexit hasn’t really caused that many problems. North America are much more stringent than EU. Brexit has highlighted compliance issues that had been ignored previously. I think it’s good to know the source of ingredients and materials are sound, traceable and sustainable.

if independence movement concentrated on our infrastructure a bit more instead of the virtue signalling I’d be more sympathetic.

Alexandra2001 · 19/11/2022 09:54

Snnowflake · 19/11/2022 09:14

I think England needs Scotland a lot more than the other way round.

hmmm - not really - I can’t see any reason

50% of UK gas usage across the year comes from NSea, a great deal from what would become Scottish waters, vast areas for renewables, tide wave wind.. fishing forestry and a suitable port for Trident.

Plus were would the Royals go? lol

BlueBellsArePretty · 19/11/2022 09:49

@Snnowflake

You'll be happy to see us go then.

Snnowflake · 19/11/2022 09:14

I think England needs Scotland a lot more than the other way round.

hmmm - not really - I can’t see any reason

Alexandra2001 · 19/11/2022 08:36

Doesn't matter what the costs are, its up to Scotland.... IF the union is voluntary, then they have the right to leave at any time.

With Scotlands natural resources plus the money the English would give them to keep Trident there, Scotland would succeed.... plenty of far smaller countries do very well as independent countries.

I trust posters comparing to Brexit are emailing their MP to tell them to reverse Brexit... or maybe they voted for it lol.

I think England needs Scotland a lot more than the other way round.

MarshaBradyo · 19/11/2022 08:23

Notonationalism · 18/11/2022 20:18

It’s totally bonkers. Scexit - like Brexit on steroids, trying to extricate a country from a 300year old union as opposed to a 40yr old one. More success removing the eggs from a Victoria sponge.

Yep good way to put it. It’s going to be horrendous and hugely costly, for us too so it does impact everyone.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 19/11/2022 08:17

Or perhaps EU born residents just preferred the idea of being in Scotland as part of the UK. Now you're treating the will of EU born residents with the contempt you're showing everyone who doesn't support independence. Or don't they matter because even if living and working here they're 'No true Scot'?

Mojo, I said upthread I had responded to your question. If you wish to ignore the response that's OK, but don't carry on with the suggestion that no-one has responded.

Trez1510 · 19/11/2022 00:02

slowquickstep · 18/11/2022 21:47

In the run up to the 2014 referendum, myself and 10 of thousands of Scot's living elsewhere were not allowed to vote in the referendum. You have double standards.

What part of my post confused you, hen?

The point of my post was that, in Scotland, all residents were entitled to vote on our constitutional matters.

Whereas, the English who designed the Brexit referendum refused to allow all residents to vote in that referendum, yet included emigrants - self-referring 'ex-pats' who are mocked worldwide for refusing to accept they are immigrants to someone else's country lol.

In fact, some may say, and I'm one of them, our EU-born residents were shafted twice. They were promised the only way for Scotland to remain in the EU was to vote NO. In good faith they did so, swinging the referendum away from the will of born-Scots. They were aided and abeted in that by rUK-born voters and temporary residents (Uni/military) also voting against the wishes of born-Scots.

Fast forward and having used EU-born residents to shackle Scotland to England, England then realised the will of the English people would easily be overridden by the wishes of EU-born residents and, in order to prevent their wishes being denied them, they excluded EU-born residents from voting.

Meanwhile, they allowed immigrants in other countries ('ex-pats' lol) to vote on matters that affect ME but do not allow those who live alongside ME to vote.

You've obviously been Stockholm Syndrome'd into believing the only way of 'democracy' is the English way i.e. exclude those who potentially will not vote as you wish, and include those who are no longer resident but who will most likely vote as you wish.

Perfidious Albion, right enough.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 23:42

Independence for Scotland is the best decision - never again will we get right wing amoral Tory Governments imposed on us despite us not voting for them

Fair point - but you could say the same about much of the north of England, outside of Cheshire. Democracy can often mean that 49% (or more, depending on how totals are arrived at) of the group of voters don't (often never) get what they want.

The only way is to do whatever it takes to exclude yourself from that group of voters - and becoming an independent country is certainly one way!

Mojoj · 18/11/2022 23:38

Still waiting......

StoneofDestiny · 18/11/2022 23:35

Independence for Scotland is the best decision - never again will we get right wing amoral Tory Governments imposed on us despite us not voting for them

StoneofDestiny · 18/11/2022 23:25

Land, castles, leisure time for the aristos.
The rest of us get to fund it Hurrah

Scotland isn't the Royal Family!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 18/11/2022 22:43

No-one, yet, has answered the question I posed in an earlier post, if we are so dependant on the rest of the UK and such a bloody drain, let us go....

I for one would be happy to let you go, if that's what a majority of you want, but up to now, that remains to be proven.

Eh you do realise hen that Spain will always veto any attempt Scotland make to join the E.U. Spain have told us this many many times, so why don't you grasp that? Do you think they are joking ? They are not, they cannot allow it, it is really that simple. The other union is NOT an option.

Somebody upthread (I can't remember who now) claimed that Spain wouldn't be 'allowed' to veto Scotland joining, as 'Germany would tell them' to vote them in! If that were indeed true, who would even want to be part of a 'democratic' union of countries where some are more democratic than others?

slowquickstep · 18/11/2022 21:55

Murdoch1949 · 18/11/2022 05:37

Cannot wait for independence. Then back in EU. Then EU passport. BRING IT ON.

Eh you do realise hen that Spain will always veto any attempt Scotland make to join the E.U. Spain have told us this many many times, so why don't you grasp that? Do you think they are joking ? They are not, they cannot allow it, it is really that simple. The other union is NOT an option.

slowquickstep · 18/11/2022 21:47

Trez1510 · 17/11/2022 23:08

@DownNative

How very undemocratic of England not allowing EU nationals etc. resident in England (and her chattels lol) to participate in the constitutional vote on exiting the European Union.

The Scottish people live in a COUNTRY, not a state, therefore we can decide to fuck-off out of this (so-called) union of equals 😂without England's permission.

In the run up to the 2014 referendum, myself and 10 of thousands of Scot's living elsewhere were not allowed to vote in the referendum. You have double standards.