Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
DownNative · 23/11/2022 14:49

Workerbeep · 23/11/2022 13:41

Thank you@DownNative really interesting and good to get the actual law.

I agree with you @SadieContrary

You're welcome, @Workerbeep !

DownNative · 23/11/2022 14:47

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 14:41

I don't disagree with the cost/disruptive side of things....But surely this is up to the people of Scotland ?

We don't wait 25years between GE's no need for that length of time scale... 10 yrs perhaps?

They consistently vote SNP.... if they wanted the referendum stuff to go away, they could vote Tory or Labour.

From what posters say on here, the SNP have made a hash of things in Scotland... so one has to wonder why they get in with a landslide every GE.... all the main parties put up candidates and Ruth Davison seems a decent politician, yet got no-where.

There is no mystery - Scottish Unionism is itself split between Conservatives, Labour and Lib Dems. Hence, it doesn't get one Unionist party in the driving seat of FM.

But this doesn't translate into increased support for secession in Scotland. At the same time "A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum".

The picture is more nuanced than you're suggesting vis a vis Scottish political parties. Polling shows No is in the lead and is usually in the lead on constitutional matters.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 14:42

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 13:05

Lol!

So once there is a vote, the electorate can never have another?

I just think that if the elected Govt of Scotland want a yearly referendum... they can bloody well have them.... if the voters of Scotland don't want that, then they can vote in a Union party as their Govt at the next GE.

Its a voluntary union, which means each and every country in it can leave at any time.

As for social problems etc etc well... all these have occurred whilst being part of the UK, plenty of smaller european countries manage perfectly well.

But its sorted now, so your safe.

It's perfectly valid to say there shouldn't be another referendum for a long time, if ever. Its not undemocratic either as the vast majority of countries prohibits secession.

And, no, the devolved administration in Scotland cannot have a yearly referendum either. Not only would it be hugely destabilising, but it is definitely ultra vires (beyond the power)!

You make the classic mistake in thinking that just because the SNP get more votes than any single party that means a majority of the electorate are in favour of independence.

"A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum." - Nicola Sturgeon

That statement was valid then and is still valid now. People are voting for the SNP to run Scotland within the UK is the very least that can be said about their voters.

Voluntary union?

The UK is a UNITARY SOVEREIGN STATE! International law is very, very clear as the Canadian Supreme Court ruling shows:

"It is clear that international law does not specifically grant component parts of sovereign states the legal right to secede unilaterally from their "parent" state....

The various international documents that support the existence of a people's right to self-determination also contain parallel statements supportive of the conclusion that the exercise of such a right must be sufficiently limited to prevent threats to an existing state's territorial integrity or the stability of relations between sovereign states...

A state whose government represents the whole of the people or peoples resident within its territory, on a basis of equality and without discrimination, and respects the principles of self-determination in its own internal arrangements, is entitled to the protection under international law of its territorial integrity."

- Canadian Supreme Court ruling on the issue of secession

Ininternational AND domestic law, territorial integrity takes precedence. Regions of unitary sovereign states can only hold a referendum with the consent of the Sovereign Government. Ergo, can only leave on that basis. But there is no obligation for any unitary sovereign state to agree to any referendum and, therefore, agree to secession in the first place!

As for social problems, these have progressively got worse the longer the SNP has been in power. Its worse under the SNP than it was under the devolved Labour administration in Scotland or during the period of direct rule. Indeed, Northern Ireland and Wales do NOT have Scotland's rate of drug deaths under the SNP. Northern Ireland's educational ranking in PISA has been higher than Scotland under the SNP too. And so on. None of these can be wholly blamed on the UK since the SNP has complete responsibility for all devolved issues in Scotland. If that flawed logic applied, why have other parts done better in various areas within the same union?

But Nationalism requires all blame to be laid at the door of the Sovereign Government. And so the SNP drive that feeling. An Irish Nationalist leader John Hume asserted that a "hallmark of fascism" is that "the Brits are to blame for everything!". His point was political actors in Northern Ireland were very much to blame since they were divided. The same applies in Scotland where the SNP has successfully Ulsterised Scottish politics.....

The union cannot be blamed for everything.

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 14:41

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 14:22

@Alexandra2001 - nowhere have I said that there should never be another vote, but the costs and consequences of such processes are massive. Diverting funds and attentions when they’re desperately needed elsewhere. I would only support another referendum if it were guaranteed that should the result be NO again then it has to be something like 25y before it’s pursued again.

I don't disagree with the cost/disruptive side of things....But surely this is up to the people of Scotland ?

We don't wait 25years between GE's no need for that length of time scale... 10 yrs perhaps?

They consistently vote SNP.... if they wanted the referendum stuff to go away, they could vote Tory or Labour.

From what posters say on here, the SNP have made a hash of things in Scotland... so one has to wonder why they get in with a landslide every GE.... all the main parties put up candidates and Ruth Davison seems a decent politician, yet got no-where.

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 14:34

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 13:15

And I wasn't suggesting that a naval base be located right in the middle of the town. It's a very large estuary, there are plenty of possible sites.

You ve not a clue have you?

I worked in Devonport for many years, the place is huge.... to build a dockyard from scratch would cost billions, then there is the rail and road networks... we are talking 100s of billions.. which, it may have escaped your attention, the UK hasn't got, not too mention the planning, the construction.. so say 20 years? How long as HS2 taken ? and thats before we get onto the environmental costs.

So we would pay Scotland to host Trident, that would help them nicely

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 14:22

@Alexandra2001 - nowhere have I said that there should never be another vote, but the costs and consequences of such processes are massive. Diverting funds and attentions when they’re desperately needed elsewhere. I would only support another referendum if it were guaranteed that should the result be NO again then it has to be something like 25y before it’s pursued again.

Workerbeep · 23/11/2022 13:41

Thank you@DownNative really interesting and good to get the actual law.

I agree with you @SadieContrary

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 13:29

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 13:05

Lol!

So once there is a vote, the electorate can never have another?

I just think that if the elected Govt of Scotland want a yearly referendum... they can bloody well have them.... if the voters of Scotland don't want that, then they can vote in a Union party as their Govt at the next GE.

Its a voluntary union, which means each and every country in it can leave at any time.

As for social problems etc etc well... all these have occurred whilst being part of the UK, plenty of smaller european countries manage perfectly well.

But its sorted now, so your safe.

Do you realise just how divisive the last referendum was? English people resident in Scotland were spat at and told to go home, some people still aren't on speaking terms. You want to inflict a repeat of that upon ordinary Scots with all the economic and social turmoil that a neverendum brings?

I agree with Brenda from Bristol who on being told that Theresa May had called a snap election in 2017 said "You're joking! Not another one!"

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 13:15

And I wasn't suggesting that a naval base be located right in the middle of the town. It's a very large estuary, there are plenty of possible sites.

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 13:10

I saw the "lol", decided that it was juvenile, and decided I'd rather have a serious debate.

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 13:05

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 12:59

Stop this. As a Scot, I implore you to quit pushing this ‘neverendum’ agenda.
It’s utterly laughable to hear deluded Yes voters thinking that oil revenues and whisky taxes will keep the country afloat. I seriously think that you must be clueless about the huge socio-economic issues that Scotland has yet the SNP government continue to throw money away on useless initiatives and projects. As for rejoining the EU, there’s not even a guarantee of acceptance.
The last referendum was billed as as ‘once in a lifetime’ so having to see such huge resources being drained on another vote less than a decade later is disgraceful and continues to polarise a nation. Scotland is not oppressed - we had a vote, we used it, we said NO!

Lol!

So once there is a vote, the electorate can never have another?

I just think that if the elected Govt of Scotland want a yearly referendum... they can bloody well have them.... if the voters of Scotland don't want that, then they can vote in a Union party as their Govt at the next GE.

Its a voluntary union, which means each and every country in it can leave at any time.

As for social problems etc etc well... all these have occurred whilst being part of the UK, plenty of smaller european countries manage perfectly well.

But its sorted now, so your safe.

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 12:59

Stop this. As a Scot, I implore you to quit pushing this ‘neverendum’ agenda.
It’s utterly laughable to hear deluded Yes voters thinking that oil revenues and whisky taxes will keep the country afloat. I seriously think that you must be clueless about the huge socio-economic issues that Scotland has yet the SNP government continue to throw money away on useless initiatives and projects. As for rejoining the EU, there’s not even a guarantee of acceptance.
The last referendum was billed as as ‘once in a lifetime’ so having to see such huge resources being drained on another vote less than a decade later is disgraceful and continues to polarise a nation. Scotland is not oppressed - we had a vote, we used it, we said NO!

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 12:49

Have you ever been to Falmouth..? its a holiday destination, with a huge university campus.

The road network, rail links the upgrade to the port, compulsory purchase of land and housing... or its built well away from the town? Yes Falmouth has suitable sea access (i believe) but either way the costs of relocation will be 100s of billions.
Devonport may have been an option but has been shrunk by selling off large amounts of it to private housing and it is in the middle of a largish city.

Faslane/Rosythe is an existing and large WW2 naval base, Falmouth never really has been & back in the 60s, there was no where else to put it.

Anyway, as i said earlier.... its done and dusted now, there wont be a vote for the foreseeable future.

The Blamoral thing was tongue in cheek... hence the lol, sorry that passed you by.

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 12:37

Alexandra2001 · 19/11/2022 09:54

50% of UK gas usage across the year comes from NSea, a great deal from what would become Scottish waters, vast areas for renewables, tide wave wind.. fishing forestry and a suitable port for Trident.

Plus were would the Royals go? lol

We also buy quite a lot of gas from Norway. We manage to do that in spite of the fact that they are a different country. Besides, fossil fuels are on the way out - aren't the Scottish Government committed to shutting down extraction? We also buy electricity from France and sell it to Ireland. Again we manage to do this without being part of the same country.

Trident only went to Faslane in order to provide jobs in marginal constituencies. There's no reason that it couldn't be relocated to Falmouth.

I'm not sure that the location of the royals' holiday home is really a reason to say that England "needs" Scotland. Wasn't Charles proposing to turn Balmoral into a museum anyway?

It would certainly be painful on both sides for the union to break up (if you thought that undoing 40 years of European integration was hard, just think how hard it would be to undo 300). It won't cause England to implode though, life would go on.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 12:22

One more thing, it's important to understand what the UK actually is.

It's often referred to as a union. Likewise the United States is referred to as union of states.

More important than that, both the UK and USA are unitary sovereign states. This is the important bit in international law!

And the bit Scottish Nationalists would rather ignore so they can mislead you into thinking we're not a unitary sovereign state. Yet they agreed to the legal power of the unitary sovereign state that brought the devolved administrations in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland into being! It speaks to a contradiction at the heart of the Nationalist argument.

Self-determination = devolution.

Sovereign Government = National Government.

This is democratic and legal. The people voted for a limited devolved government in the 1990s and have never consented to them becoming unlimited sovereign governments. That's democracy!

And law.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 12:12

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 10:25

err where is it set in stone that these companies would remain as private entities? or tax rates stay the same? or additional/existing renewables stay privately owned.... Labours plan for a Green Energy company... state owned.

...and how long would the King remain head of state?

Presumably IF Scotland ever did go independent, all this would be up in the air?

Anyway, this thread is overtaken by events, Scotland wont get another vote for many more years, which imho will turn out to be a mistake.... SNP would lose right now but in a few years time? perhaps not.

It could go the way a similar movement in Quebec has in the last few years. Into managed decline once it dawns on more people what international law actually does say about secession.

More tellingly, Scottish Nationalists hitched their wagon to Catalan independence, but support for Catalan secession has been declining also.

In years to come, people in Scotland will prefer to focus on jobs and education within the UK similar to the above. Likewise, a former Irish Government Minister has written an article on how Provisional Sinn Féin and Provisional IRA now have a significantly muted demand for a border poll.

unherd.com/2022/11/sinn-fein-has-given-up-on-a-united-ireland/

For most people, the priority isn't secession by any means.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 11:59

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 11:49

Yes I heard most of the reasoning. Well argued on here even if you got some backlash from emotive quarters.

Eh, Scottish Nationalists have nothing on Irish Republicans who you'd get far worse from! 🤣

Either way, it's water off a duck's back and I stick to logic plus evidence to support my argument.

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 11:49

DownNative · 23/11/2022 10:23

Yes, I was very much on the money with how international law views the right to self-determination and secession. It is always qualified by a right to territorial integrity by the Sovereign Parent State.

On top of that, self-determination only really applies in cases of oppression and a colonial context. Where the Sovereign Parent State has devolved limited powers to one or more of its regions, that is self-determination for that region fulfilled. Hence, Scotland, Northern Ireland, Quebec and Catalonia are not entitled to anything else under international law as the right to self-determination has NOT been infringed.

It is NOT illegal nor is it undemocratic. To claim it is, is to engage in blatant emotional manipulation of the people whilst deliberately misleading them.

See crucial parts of the UK Supreme Court judgement in my attached images.

Yes I heard most of the reasoning. Well argued on here even if you got some backlash from emotive quarters.

Michellexxx · 23/11/2022 11:18

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 10:25

err where is it set in stone that these companies would remain as private entities? or tax rates stay the same? or additional/existing renewables stay privately owned.... Labours plan for a Green Energy company... state owned.

...and how long would the King remain head of state?

Presumably IF Scotland ever did go independent, all this would be up in the air?

Anyway, this thread is overtaken by events, Scotland wont get another vote for many more years, which imho will turn out to be a mistake.... SNP would lose right now but in a few years time? perhaps not.

A company can’t just be stolen and taken over by a government.. I’m aging Westminster tried to do that!

As is stands no private company can even attempt to build wind farms etc anyway. So it’s nothing new.

Tax rates and private companies are confusing and also I thought we were aiming for Scotland being some miraculous growth without allowing private companies to aim for profits..

Anyway, as you said well maybe have another vote with next generation, as per last claim by snp!

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 10:25

Michellexxx · 19/11/2022 15:44

You do know that the oil and gas in the North Sea are owned by private companies? So they’re the ones who get the profits, not the govt. hence the windfall tax.
Also, NS has already said the the royals would remain head of state so your point is totally irrelevant re where they would go. Balmoral is also privately owned, so they can go whenever they want..

err where is it set in stone that these companies would remain as private entities? or tax rates stay the same? or additional/existing renewables stay privately owned.... Labours plan for a Green Energy company... state owned.

...and how long would the King remain head of state?

Presumably IF Scotland ever did go independent, all this would be up in the air?

Anyway, this thread is overtaken by events, Scotland wont get another vote for many more years, which imho will turn out to be a mistake.... SNP would lose right now but in a few years time? perhaps not.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 10:23

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 10:13

I know this hasn’t been posted on for a while but just heard ruling and reasons on radio

Very interesting. I think DownNative was along same lines from legal pov

Yes, I was very much on the money with how international law views the right to self-determination and secession. It is always qualified by a right to territorial integrity by the Sovereign Parent State.

On top of that, self-determination only really applies in cases of oppression and a colonial context. Where the Sovereign Parent State has devolved limited powers to one or more of its regions, that is self-determination for that region fulfilled. Hence, Scotland, Northern Ireland, Quebec and Catalonia are not entitled to anything else under international law as the right to self-determination has NOT been infringed.

It is NOT illegal nor is it undemocratic. To claim it is, is to engage in blatant emotional manipulation of the people whilst deliberately misleading them.

See crucial parts of the UK Supreme Court judgement in my attached images.

To think Scotland should become independent?
To think Scotland should become independent?
MintJulia · 23/11/2022 10:20

It would be better if they asked the question in a regular referendum once every ten years.

It would save all this arguing and court action, allow the Scots to make their own decision, and know that if they choose no this time, they will get another say in 10 years time.

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 10:13

I know this hasn’t been posted on for a while but just heard ruling and reasons on radio

Very interesting. I think DownNative was along same lines from legal pov

DownNative · 19/11/2022 16:26

Trez1510 · 19/11/2022 16:15

Excellent cut'n'paste effort. Massive kudos and all that. No, seriously, massively massive kudos.

Except .... except .... SCOTLAND is a nation where the people are sovereign, not the state.

I'll now leave this thread, echoing the words of @CapMarvel by saying 'Sure, hen.' and adding, enjoy your subjugation while it lasts.

It speaks to YOUR level of intellect that you don’t seem to grasp the importance of backing up your argument with actual facts and evidence.

Unfortunately for you, the only act of self-determination Scotland is entitled to is devolution under international law. The same holds true for Northern Ireland, Wales and Catalonia, to name three.

It is sovereign independent states that are truly sovereign and international law clearly prioritises territorial integrity over secessionist demands. The only times international law doesn't is in a colonial context and/or persecution by the parent state.

But that isn't what happens in Scotland. Your "enjoy your subjugation while it lasts" is ridiculous childish nonsense. 🤦‍♂️

Your argument has been on a shoogly peg all along and it speaks volumes you've failed at every opportunity to present evidence from international law and politics to support your argument.

Again, that suits me!

Trez1510 · 19/11/2022 16:15

DownNative · 19/11/2022 13:37

Unfortunately, you have failed to turn anything on its head!

The SNP are free to campaign for election in England, Wales and Northern Ireland. There's no law that prohibits them, you know! But they, you and I know they won't get elected in England, Wales or Northern Ireland.

Scotland is NOT separate from the rest of the UK. If it were, your campaign for independence wouldn't make ANY sense whatsoever! So, any party from any part of the UK can stand in any other part of the UK. After all, England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are INTEGRAL parts of the ONE sovereign state aka country known as the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. See above - the SNP can stand in ANY part of the UK. Not a problem!

Your attempted argument about French and German political parties standing in each other's respective sovereign territory is laughable!

That's because Germany and France are NOT part of a sovereign state called Germance! They are TWO separate, independent and sovereign states, you know.

Your attempted comparison falls flat on its face. Completely.

Scotland within the UK is far more comparable to Catalonia within Spain or Quebec within Canada. It's also comparable to Bavaria within Germany.

Yet Quebec, Catalonia and Bavaria have all been shown that they have zero democratic rights to secession from their respective parent states. You see, territorial integrity of sovereign states takes precedence.

The only way self-determination takes precedence over territorial integrity is in cases of oppression by the sovereign state or in a colonial context.

Evidence here:

"In a UN context, the right to self-determination in its external shape is applicable to people (not to national, ethnic, and religious minorities, whose rights are recognized in Article 27 of the ICCPR, 1966) or to the nations in the cases of: a) a colonial context; or b) in a situation of any foreign domination or occupation."

"Today, it may be concluded that international law bestows on all peoples the right to self-determination, but that the right to external self-determination, exercised through remedial secession, only applies in extreme circumstances, to colonized and severely persecuted peoples."

Fortunately, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Quebec, Catalonia and Bavaria are neither examples of colonialism NOR are they in any way oppressed by their parent states.

No wonder you wanted to compare Scotland to Germany and France! 🤷‍♂️

Therefore, your bogus comparison is what we call False Equivalence and falls flat on its face.

Excellent cut'n'paste effort. Massive kudos and all that. No, seriously, massively massive kudos.

Except .... except .... SCOTLAND is a nation where the people are sovereign, not the state.

I'll now leave this thread, echoing the words of @CapMarvel by saying 'Sure, hen.' and adding, enjoy your subjugation while it lasts.