Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MajorCarolDanvers · 23/11/2022 17:00

I had a good laugh and did a little dance when I heard the news today.

Now can she please focus on the state of the NHS, Schools etc?

She won't of course.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 16:57

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:42

Opinion polls when it comes to how a government legislates are largely irrelevant. You can pick and chose which poll supports your argument - which is exactly what you are doing. There are polls out there showing a majority in favour of independence - which one should we believe?

The greens and SNP are in power with a mandate, if not the legal ability, to hold another independence referendum. This is a fact.

You can argue all you like as to whether that is the true reflection of how people feel, but the fact is the SNP and greens stood on manifesto pledges and, in this case at least, are sticking to those pledges.

The SNP and Greens do NOT have the legal ability to hold an independence referendum. That YOU claimed they did demonstrates a blatant and wilful desire on your part to ignore the ruling of the UK Supreme Court.

Relevant part from the judgement highlighted in attached image.....

As for your question about which poll should we believe.....this is where a FIVE poll average tracker comes in handy. Yep, you're losing on that point too. Images attached.

To think Scotland should become independent?
To think Scotland should become independent?
To think Scotland should become independent?
Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:56

DownNative · 23/11/2022 16:50

On the contrary, no political party is obligated to carry out its manifesto at all. The The law lord Lord Diplock explicitly stated that: "Elected representatives must not treat themselves as irrevocably bound to carry out pre-announced policies contained in election manifestos."

So, since there is no legal effect that means there is no obligation on political parties. The attached image explains why this is the case.

Upshot of this is that General Election results do NOT reliably indicate support for secession. Indeed, the sole purpose of a General Election is to send representatives to the democratically elected Westminster Parliament which is the seat of sovereign power.

No, they are not obliged to carry it out.

But do explain why the SNP would not in this case or indeed why it is in any way relevant to the discussion at hand.

Workerbeep · 23/11/2022 16:50

ah but the greens are in power with the SNP and doing sweet nothing to making scotland a better country; except creating discourse and division.
We are merely treading water with this constantly hanging overhead.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 16:50

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 15:06

Well, there is also the Scottish Greens who support a second referendum.

A vote for the SNP/greens may not be strictly intended as a vote for independence, but in the absence of a referendum specifically about this (or any other issue) a party is (usually) obligated to carry out it's manifesto if they are elected to power, and in the SNP manifesto was Indyref2, front and centre.

Like it or not there is public support for another referendum going by the only measure that really matters.

On the contrary, no political party is obligated to carry out its manifesto at all. The The law lord Lord Diplock explicitly stated that: "Elected representatives must not treat themselves as irrevocably bound to carry out pre-announced policies contained in election manifestos."

So, since there is no legal effect that means there is no obligation on political parties. The attached image explains why this is the case.

Upshot of this is that General Election results do NOT reliably indicate support for secession. Indeed, the sole purpose of a General Election is to send representatives to the democratically elected Westminster Parliament which is the seat of sovereign power.

To think Scotland should become independent?
Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:44

Workerbeep · 23/11/2022 16:27

Oh course it matters.

Did all the greens get in only on proportional votes?

Look at the facts and actions not their rhetoric.

low emission zone in Dundee started in May this year apparently but will not be enforced until may 2024.
4x4 pick up trucks from 2016 will be exempt too. What a joke!

concentrate on the powers they have and make what they can, better (basic stoic philosophy and good mental health).

its not hard, better health service, better education, better infrastructure.

How many unionists got in on list seats? Answer: nearly all of them. They all have exactly the same voting power so it doesn't matter how they won it.

Again, besides the point which was merely that the SNP are not the only party in Scotland who are pro-independence.

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:42

Opinion polls when it comes to how a government legislates are largely irrelevant. You can pick and chose which poll supports your argument - which is exactly what you are doing. There are polls out there showing a majority in favour of independence - which one should we believe?

The greens and SNP are in power with a mandate, if not the legal ability, to hold another independence referendum. This is a fact.

You can argue all you like as to whether that is the true reflection of how people feel, but the fact is the SNP and greens stood on manifesto pledges and, in this case at least, are sticking to those pledges.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 16:35

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:21

Well, they did respect the result last time. Scotland didn't become independent.

The question is whether you think sufficient time and/or material change has gone by to warrant holding another one, and as I said going by the democratic marker that really matters the public thinks there is.

No, they don't. Other concerns are way, way more important to the electorate in Scotland than IndyRef2!

Polls even indicate a clear divide as to any potential timing of IndyRef2. However, just 79% of those who voted Yes in 2014 would vote Yes again - a clear drop and bigger than the Unionist drop. Essentially, it tells us there is no meaningful change in the electorate's overall attitude. The status quo is still prevailing.

To think Scotland should become independent?
To think Scotland should become independent?
Trez1510 · 23/11/2022 16:32

Bookmarked this thread for three years hence. 😊

I suggest my fellow-independentisas do likewise.

Workerbeep · 23/11/2022 16:27

Oh course it matters.

Did all the greens get in only on proportional votes?

Look at the facts and actions not their rhetoric.

low emission zone in Dundee started in May this year apparently but will not be enforced until may 2024.
4x4 pick up trucks from 2016 will be exempt too. What a joke!

concentrate on the powers they have and make what they can, better (basic stoic philosophy and good mental health).

its not hard, better health service, better education, better infrastructure.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 16:26

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 15:15

No reason to deny them the chance to put this to the test then is there?

To those equally hard of thinking, an opinion poll isn't a democratic vote... its an opinion poll... based on a very small number of people.

Bottom line is the SNP have more MSPs than both main parties put together and the SNP improved their share of the vote.

There is no reason to allow IndyRef2 in legal or political terms whatsoever. Firstly, international law asserts there is no democratic right to secession. In terms of democracy, its a right only in a colonial context and oppression from the parent state. Scotland does not meet the criteria for either.

Secondly, under international law Scotland and other regions is entitled to devolution only. And that is democracy.

There is no democratic right to secession.

Unionists value stability of the unitary sovereign state amongst other concerns. Given international law, why on earth should they agree to secessionist demands for IndyRef2?!

Attempting to counter that with "No reason to deny them the chance to put this to the test then is there?" is circular reasoning. And that is NOT a reason to grant IndyRef2.

Thirdly, opinion polls is a valid way of gauging support or lack of for secession. They're based on a representative sample of the overall population. It indicates both sluggish growth for secession and opposition against.

Fourthly, the SNP might have more MSPs than the three Unionist parties. But "A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum" uttered by Nicola Sturgeon comes back to haunt her.....and the SNP. As such, its clearly not a total endorsement of the SNP secessionist demand.

More pertinently, the SNP are far away from having as many votes in the Westminster Parliament as the Unionist parties. This matters because it is the Westminster Parliament that CAN legislate to approve IndyRef2 and is, therefore, the Supreme Legislator in the UK.

Holyrood definitely is NOT. See the attached UK Supreme Court ruling once again.....

So, Westminster is the ONLY correct place to campaign for IndyRef2. In which case the SNP need to build a coalition within the Westminster Parliament. And it is democratic for the other Westminster parties to say no and maintain the UK is a unitary sovereign state.

That IS democracy too!

To think Scotland should become independent?
Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:21

Well, they did respect the result last time. Scotland didn't become independent.

The question is whether you think sufficient time and/or material change has gone by to warrant holding another one, and as I said going by the democratic marker that really matters the public thinks there is.

MarshaBradyo · 23/11/2022 16:21

Michellexxx · 23/11/2022 15:44

I find it truly baffling that everyone who have been spouting about democracy would now support a fake referendum. That an election, to vote in representatives based on policy decisions, decisions made by our current government, would be an example of democracy in action. Apparently they could not be held accountable for other policy decisions because they’re making an election about one issue.

It is an astounding act of ignorance and arrogance combined. When will the government actually start dealing with policy decisions!

It is madness

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 16:19

@Frabbits and by all means have another referendum… but respect the outcome this time. It’s ridiculous that the Nationalists expect to keep repeating the process over and over and over in the hope they get their own way. If they were a toddler it would be a tantrum 😉

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:16

How anyone regards the greens is besides the point. The fact is that along with the SNP they won a mandate to pursue indyref2.

That's the key democratic lever in play here to determine whether the Scottish public want their government to attempt to hold another referendum.

Workerbeep · 23/11/2022 16:08

The Scottish greens are an embarrassment and a joke.
What environmental sound measures have they actually implemented in Scotland?

Bottle Deposit return scheme to come in august 2023; this is just an excuse to cut Council refuse jobs and reduce bin collections even further. You can only access council dumps in my county by car or vehicle now no pedestrian access so circular sustainable economy? Yeah right. Where’s all that critical thinking from the implementation of curriculum for excellence?

fancyacuppatea · 23/11/2022 15:49

YANBU as long as I get 6 months notice so I can move (a bit more) north.

Michellexxx · 23/11/2022 15:44

I find it truly baffling that everyone who have been spouting about democracy would now support a fake referendum. That an election, to vote in representatives based on policy decisions, decisions made by our current government, would be an example of democracy in action. Apparently they could not be held accountable for other policy decisions because they’re making an election about one issue.

It is an astounding act of ignorance and arrogance combined. When will the government actually start dealing with policy decisions!

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/11/2022 15:40

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 12:59

Stop this. As a Scot, I implore you to quit pushing this ‘neverendum’ agenda.
It’s utterly laughable to hear deluded Yes voters thinking that oil revenues and whisky taxes will keep the country afloat. I seriously think that you must be clueless about the huge socio-economic issues that Scotland has yet the SNP government continue to throw money away on useless initiatives and projects. As for rejoining the EU, there’s not even a guarantee of acceptance.
The last referendum was billed as as ‘once in a lifetime’ so having to see such huge resources being drained on another vote less than a decade later is disgraceful and continues to polarise a nation. Scotland is not oppressed - we had a vote, we used it, we said NO!

This.

With bells on.

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 15:16

@Frabbits, the Scottish Greens knew that supporting the SNP was a good way to push themselves forward - their motives are entirely questionable. Their recently published papers outlining an alternative referendum was scant on detail at best, including suggesting that Scotland would be a full member of the EU again (who can guarantee this?) and that any future oil & gas developments would be banned... Eh, isn't Scottish oil and gas the pot of gold at the end of the proverbial rainbow of pursued 'freedom'. Not to mention a proposed 4 day working week. Where is the money coming from for this?!

By all means, my fellow countryfolk should have another referendum but only if there's a firm promise to respect the outcome and work together post result. I wanted to remain in the Union. I got my wish. I wanted to remain in the EU. I didn't get my wish. That's democracy. I see zero point in harping on about Brexit. The vote was cast and we should move on and make good in our collective decisions.

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 15:15

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 23/11/2022 15:02

Exactly! Why are those I the rest of the UK so hard of thinking that they cannot grasp this! The majority of Scot’s do not want independence! Poll after poll after poll shows this!

No reason to deny them the chance to put this to the test then is there?

To those equally hard of thinking, an opinion poll isn't a democratic vote... its an opinion poll... based on a very small number of people.

Bottom line is the SNP have more MSPs than both main parties put together and the SNP improved their share of the vote.

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 15:06

Well, there is also the Scottish Greens who support a second referendum.

A vote for the SNP/greens may not be strictly intended as a vote for independence, but in the absence of a referendum specifically about this (or any other issue) a party is (usually) obligated to carry out it's manifesto if they are elected to power, and in the SNP manifesto was Indyref2, front and centre.

Like it or not there is public support for another referendum going by the only measure that really matters.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 23/11/2022 15:02

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 14:50

@Alexandra2001 - I would say that because SNP continually win because those who want independence only have the option of SNP, so have to vote in that direction, whereas the rest will vote across all the available parties leaving them without a majority.

Exactly! Why are those I the rest of the UK so hard of thinking that they cannot grasp this! The majority of Scot’s do not want independence! Poll after poll after poll shows this!

SadieContrary · 23/11/2022 14:50

@Alexandra2001 - I would say that because SNP continually win because those who want independence only have the option of SNP, so have to vote in that direction, whereas the rest will vote across all the available parties leaving them without a majority.

Laiste · 23/11/2022 14:50

They should be allowed to vote every 5 years.

Eventually there'll be a majority vote to leave.

Swipe left for the next trending thread