Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 08:25

If nothing else, doing it this way would stop the constant SNP mithering and force them to get on with governing Scotland for the benefit of the people
PS. At the 2021 election the SNP/Greens got 49.25% and Labour/Tories/Libs got 50.75% of the constituency vote

Why doesn't this logic seem to work in Westminster?

Cameron got 37% of the pop. vote but that gave him the authority to have a referendum......

Bojo got 43% and that gave him the mandate to take the UK out of the EU with a terrible hard brexit.

Truss got none of the popular vote and added 30bn to the national debt......

Or do the rules get "adjusted" to suit?

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 08:21

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 18:14

And yet we could do it if we really had to. It would cost money, though it would be a drop in the ocean compared with some of the other costs of Scexit. This idea that Scotland is propping up the rest of the UK with free oil and so on is absurd. This is a union, we work together for our mutual benefit. England does not "rely on" Scotland and Scotland does not "rely on" England.

err no we really couldn't.

Have you not seen the debacle that is/has hs2 or Heathrow expansion... there would be a huge outcry if anyone suggested turning Falmouth into Faslane.

The costs would be on par with Furlough or energy support, rail, roads, new hospitals schools housing (for all the additional workers... believe me Cornwall hasn't a surplus of nuclear dockyard workers) ... and most importantly time scales.... and on workers, what happens if the current workforce don't want to relocate?

So England would pay Scotland to keep Trident where it is.

On Scotland and independence, its supposed to be a voluntary union.. yes? So by what means can Scotland leave?

Because as i understand it, the argument is "You ve had a vote, so you cannot have another one......" (i recently heard that 40 years is a suitable timescale, as thats the period between the UK's EU votes - from a Tory minister)

That doesn't seem "Voluntary" to me.

FairyPrincess123 · 24/11/2022 07:49

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 18:19

Ah yes, "you didn't vote the right way last time so we're going to make you keep doing it until you change your mind."

It's just like the Lisbon Treaty.

The Lisbon Treaty was rejected for specific reasons, it went back to the EC and they rectified the problem and was put in front of the people again. It's almost a textbook definition of how democracy should work.

But then you knew that already didn't you?

jcyclops · 23/11/2022 20:59

SNP now wants to use an election as a de facto referendum as they now accept it is up to Westminster to grant a de jure referendum.

Perhaps the UK could grant this:
For future Scottish elections (the next is 2026), if parties wanting a referendum get more CONSTITUENCY VOTES (ie not seats and not additional votes) than those who do not, then there is a presumption that the UK will grant a referendum to be held exactly one year after the election (ie. timing not up to the SNP). A "NO" vote would mean that independence is off the table for the next two elections (ie. 15 years). A YES vote in this referendum would authorise and instruct the Scottish and UK Governments to negotiate a UK leaving treaty - which would give FACTS about leaving (plus an additional agreement with the EU giving the FACTS about what Scotland must do to join the EU). These documents would be factual and not based on political bias and dogma, so none of the people involved could later claim they were told lies. Scotland would then hold a referendum on the treaty, and a YES vote would mean Scotland becomes independent, and a NO vote would mean independence is off the table for the next two elections.

After what happened with Brexit, it would be hypocritical of the SNP not to hold a second referendum once the UK leaving treaty is agreed.

If nothing else, doing it this way would stop the constant SNP mithering and force them to get on with governing Scotland for the benefit of the people.

PS. At the 2021 election the SNP/Greens got 49.25% and Labour/Tories/Libs got 50.75% of the constituency vote.

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 18:46

DownNative · 23/11/2022 17:36

Frabbits said: "The greens and SNP are in power with a mandate, if not the legal ability, to hold another independence referendum. This is a fact."

If you meant they DIDN'T have the legal ability to hold another referendum, then the correct phrase to use was "but not the legal ability". That would then mean you're saying they don't have it. As it stands, in your construction quoted it means "and perhaps even", unfortunately.

"Then you should say what you mean," the March Hare went on.
"I do," Alice hastily replied; "at least-at least I mean what I say-that's the same thing, you know."
"Not the same thing a bit!" said the Hatter. "Why, you might just as well say that 'I see what I eat' is the same thing as 'I eat what I see'!"
"You might just as well say," added the March Hare, "that 'I like what I get' is the same thing as 'I get what I like'!"
"You might just as well say," added the Dormouse, which seemed to be talking in its sleep, "that 'I breathe when I sleep' is the same thing as 'I sleep when I breathe'!"

And no, the SNP shouldnottry to hold an IndyRef2. Or attempt to turn a General Election into a de facto one....

Out of interest, what sort of tone are you going for here? B

Because it very much comes across as pretentious, irritating and slightly ignorant. Just wondering.

What I meant was patently obvious and actually I would argue that but not/if not are pretty much interchangeable to anyone with any degree of sense.

But frankly I can't be arsed to argue with a child. Nothing you have said gets away from the basic fact:

  1. The SNP went into the election saying they would hold (or attempt to hold) a second independence referendum.
  2. They won the election.

If you understand anything about how representative democracy works none of this should come remotely as a surprise.

awaynboilyurheid · 23/11/2022 18:45

MajorCarolDanvers · 23/11/2022 17:00

I had a good laugh and did a little dance when I heard the news today.

Now can she please focus on the state of the NHS, Schools etc?

She won't of course.

Me too! absolutely delighted when I heard, now maybe NS could focus on the actual things she is in charge of, health, social care, education etc etc. She’s had enough time in power to do something but no she’d rather focus on Independence, when the country needs real help after a pandemic.

Bedazzled22 · 23/11/2022 18:23

How on earth could Scotland support itself?

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 18:22

Michellexxx · 23/11/2022 15:44

I find it truly baffling that everyone who have been spouting about democracy would now support a fake referendum. That an election, to vote in representatives based on policy decisions, decisions made by our current government, would be an example of democracy in action. Apparently they could not be held accountable for other policy decisions because they’re making an election about one issue.

It is an astounding act of ignorance and arrogance combined. When will the government actually start dealing with policy decisions!

It's interesting that Sinn Fein have now acknowledged that there's no appetite for Irish unification and have dropped the Adams/McGuinness era rabble raising in favour of campaigning on policy issues such as youth unemployment.

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 18:19

Laiste · 23/11/2022 14:50

They should be allowed to vote every 5 years.

Eventually there'll be a majority vote to leave.

Ah yes, "you didn't vote the right way last time so we're going to make you keep doing it until you change your mind."

It's just like the Lisbon Treaty.

feellikeanalien · 23/11/2022 18:16

So a vote for the SNP is not a vote for independence.www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-scotland-scotland-politics-63730653

DdraigGoch · 23/11/2022 18:14

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 14:34

You ve not a clue have you?

I worked in Devonport for many years, the place is huge.... to build a dockyard from scratch would cost billions, then there is the rail and road networks... we are talking 100s of billions.. which, it may have escaped your attention, the UK hasn't got, not too mention the planning, the construction.. so say 20 years? How long as HS2 taken ? and thats before we get onto the environmental costs.

So we would pay Scotland to host Trident, that would help them nicely

And yet we could do it if we really had to. It would cost money, though it would be a drop in the ocean compared with some of the other costs of Scexit. This idea that Scotland is propping up the rest of the UK with free oil and so on is absurd. This is a union, we work together for our mutual benefit. England does not "rely on" Scotland and Scotland does not "rely on" England.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 18:09

Aargh....."under the guise of Nationalism" is supposed to be "under the guise of democracy"!

DownNative · 23/11/2022 18:08

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/11/2022 17:38

It does all seem rather one-way, though, as I'm guessing that - were a referendum to be held with the result being a majority voting to leave the UK - nobody would then be going on about ongoing democracy and changing public opinion, especially with old folk dying off whilst differently-minded younger people reach voting age, and thus be demanding a referendum every generation/every 10 years to see if the Scottish population is happy with the status quo or whether a majority wished to rejoin the UK.

Theoretically, if there were 10 referendums where the majority voted to stay in the UK and then an 11th where a (maybe very slim) majority voted indy, could we truly proclaim it as pure democracy to go irreversibly with that one snapshot vote - and decisively never to put it to the vote ever again - whilst discounting the previous 10?

Indeed.

Scottish and Irish Nationalists and Republicans all demand multiple referendums in order to keep trying to break up the British State under the guise of Nationalism.

But they flat out deny any future attempts to rejoin the UK. In fact, a united Ireland and independent Scotland will use exactly the same argument I've made - there is no democratic right to secession.

And they'll have no issue with denying a rejoin referendum on a permanent basis which they simultaneously claim is undemocratic for the UK to do.

It's hypocrisy in action, really.

So, the UK Government should follow the lead of the Canadian Government with a Clarity Act. Yes, it would make secession harder for Nationalists and Republicans to achieve. But it is entirely legal AND democratic. After all, territorial integrity takes precedence over any claim of self-determination.

The UK Government should take note of the decline in support for Catalonian secession from their sovereign parent state, Spain, as well.

Constantly giving in to Nationalist demands for a secessionist referendum is NOT the answer.

HelloMrBond · 23/11/2022 18:05

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:06

I agree to leave the EU has massively weakened the UK.
An independent Scotland could rejoin the EU.

But I thought you wanted independence? Why would you want to be ruled by unelected Eurocrats? Sadly the EU wouldn’t have you, Scotland wouldn’t meet the economic criteria to join as you’d be a net drain.

DownNative · 23/11/2022 17:44

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:12

Ahh..... not reading properly again!

The first point was that the SNP received a mandate from the Scottish electorate to attempt to hold another referendum and yes, under normal democratic principles a political party is expected/obligated/whatever to follow their manifesto. Opinion polls, in the end, do not matter once a party has bums on seats in government.

The second point was that there is no reason why the SNP wouldn't follow it given independence is their primary aim in life, so you going on about parties not having to implement their pledges is completely irrelevant for the simple reason that it would make absolutely no sense for the SNP to do that.

Rubbish.

A party cannot enact an IndyRef2 if they don't have the legal powers to do so. Less than half the Scottish electorate vote for the SNP, so they don't have the numbers to win one.

Add that with the status of domestic AND international law.....there is zero reason to hold IndyRef2.

Indeed, the Poll of Polls tracker tells us they don't have the support.

Once again, "A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another independence referendum".

That the SNP would refuse to pursue independence is irrelevant as I said before. They cannot do it for the above reasons.

Nothing you've posted is a meaningful reason to hold IndyRef2.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/11/2022 17:41

There’s no point putting something in your manifesto that you have no right to carry out. It’s just wasting everybody’s time and taxpayers money to keep banging their heads against a brick wall like this..

Yes, it does rather bring to mind the Monster Raving Looney Party and their commensurate level of consensual 'respect' as serious candidates for government....

DownNative · 23/11/2022 17:39

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:29

Well, no, we didn't know before today's ruling, at least categorically.

And once again, it's all very well saying it's a waste of time and money etc but the bare fact is that the SNP keep getting voted in.

And, before the accusations start -> I didn't vote for them but you have to be realistic about what is happening here.

But we did know since international law has been very clear on this for some time. And domestic UK law was carefully written by Labour to make it clear too.

All the Supreme Court did was reaffirm what the legislation actually said. The SNP didn't expect to win for that reason.

The SNP keeps getting voted in since Unionists are split between three parties to Nationalists two.

Nevertheless, "A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum" still applies!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 23/11/2022 17:38

It does all seem rather one-way, though, as I'm guessing that - were a referendum to be held with the result being a majority voting to leave the UK - nobody would then be going on about ongoing democracy and changing public opinion, especially with old folk dying off whilst differently-minded younger people reach voting age, and thus be demanding a referendum every generation/every 10 years to see if the Scottish population is happy with the status quo or whether a majority wished to rejoin the UK.

Theoretically, if there were 10 referendums where the majority voted to stay in the UK and then an 11th where a (maybe very slim) majority voted indy, could we truly proclaim it as pure democracy to go irreversibly with that one snapshot vote - and decisively never to put it to the vote ever again - whilst discounting the previous 10?

DownNative · 23/11/2022 17:36

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:07

I literally already stated that the SNP do not necessarily have the legal ability to hold another referendum. If you could have the basic decency to actually read what is being typed that would be better for all involved, thanks.

I was debating the point of whether they should try to as I would have thought was perfectly clear, along with the other basic point that opinion polls are just that and are not the fundamental driver of policy. This is not hard to understand.

Frabbits said: "The greens and SNP are in power with a mandate, if not the legal ability, to hold another independence referendum. This is a fact."

If you meant they DIDN'T have the legal ability to hold another referendum, then the correct phrase to use was "but not the legal ability". That would then mean you're saying they don't have it. As it stands, in your construction quoted it means "and perhaps even", unfortunately.

"Then you should say what you mean," the March Hare went on.
"I do," Alice hastily replied; "at least-at least I mean what I say-that's the same thing, you know."
"Not the same thing a bit!" said the Hatter. "Why, you might just as well say that 'I see what I eat' is the same thing as 'I eat what I see'!"
"You might just as well say," added the March Hare, "that 'I like what I get' is the same thing as 'I get what I like'!"
"You might just as well say," added the Dormouse, which seemed to be talking in its sleep, "that 'I breathe when I sleep' is the same thing as 'I sleep when I breathe'!"

And no, the SNP shouldnottry to hold an IndyRef2. Or attempt to turn a General Election into a de facto one....

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:29

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 23/11/2022 17:24

But they have no legal route to hold an Indy ref. We knew this before today! There’s no point putting something in your manifesto that you have no right to carry out. It’s just wasting everybody’s time and taxpayers money to keep banging their heads against a brick wall like this..

Well, no, we didn't know before today's ruling, at least categorically.

And once again, it's all very well saying it's a waste of time and money etc but the bare fact is that the SNP keep getting voted in.

And, before the accusations start -> I didn't vote for them but you have to be realistic about what is happening here.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 23/11/2022 17:24

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:12

Ahh..... not reading properly again!

The first point was that the SNP received a mandate from the Scottish electorate to attempt to hold another referendum and yes, under normal democratic principles a political party is expected/obligated/whatever to follow their manifesto. Opinion polls, in the end, do not matter once a party has bums on seats in government.

The second point was that there is no reason why the SNP wouldn't follow it given independence is their primary aim in life, so you going on about parties not having to implement their pledges is completely irrelevant for the simple reason that it would make absolutely no sense for the SNP to do that.

But they have no legal route to hold an Indy ref. We knew this before today! There’s no point putting something in your manifesto that you have no right to carry out. It’s just wasting everybody’s time and taxpayers money to keep banging their heads against a brick wall like this..

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:12

DownNative · 23/11/2022 17:03

Ah.....Shifting The Goalpost Fallacy!

Frabbits said: "....in the absence of a referendum specifically about this (or any other issue) a party is (usually) obligated to carry out it's manifesto if they are elected to power...."

In response, I was able to show there is NO such claimed obligation on any party to implement any manifesto pledge under any circumstances.

That the SNP demand IndyRef2 simply because its in their manifesto is, quite frankly, irrelevant. They have no legal power and no political mandate to do it - "A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum."

Valid then and now.

It is relevant to show there is zero obligation on the SNP to follow through on its secessionist demands. Indeed, the people do not support it.

Ahh..... not reading properly again!

The first point was that the SNP received a mandate from the Scottish electorate to attempt to hold another referendum and yes, under normal democratic principles a political party is expected/obligated/whatever to follow their manifesto. Opinion polls, in the end, do not matter once a party has bums on seats in government.

The second point was that there is no reason why the SNP wouldn't follow it given independence is their primary aim in life, so you going on about parties not having to implement their pledges is completely irrelevant for the simple reason that it would make absolutely no sense for the SNP to do that.

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 17:07

DownNative · 23/11/2022 16:57

The SNP and Greens do NOT have the legal ability to hold an independence referendum. That YOU claimed they did demonstrates a blatant and wilful desire on your part to ignore the ruling of the UK Supreme Court.

Relevant part from the judgement highlighted in attached image.....

As for your question about which poll should we believe.....this is where a FIVE poll average tracker comes in handy. Yep, you're losing on that point too. Images attached.

I literally already stated that the SNP do not necessarily have the legal ability to hold another referendum. If you could have the basic decency to actually read what is being typed that would be better for all involved, thanks.

I was debating the point of whether they should try to as I would have thought was perfectly clear, along with the other basic point that opinion polls are just that and are not the fundamental driver of policy. This is not hard to understand.

Alexandra2001 · 23/11/2022 17:06

Michellexxx · 23/11/2022 15:44

I find it truly baffling that everyone who have been spouting about democracy would now support a fake referendum. That an election, to vote in representatives based on policy decisions, decisions made by our current government, would be an example of democracy in action. Apparently they could not be held accountable for other policy decisions because they’re making an election about one issue.

It is an astounding act of ignorance and arrogance combined. When will the government actually start dealing with policy decisions!

Remind me what the 2019 UK General Election was based on?

"Get Brexit Done...." does that ring any bells? or is that "different" ?

DownNative · 23/11/2022 17:03

Frabbits · 23/11/2022 16:56

No, they are not obliged to carry it out.

But do explain why the SNP would not in this case or indeed why it is in any way relevant to the discussion at hand.

Ah.....Shifting The Goalpost Fallacy!

Frabbits said: "....in the absence of a referendum specifically about this (or any other issue) a party is (usually) obligated to carry out it's manifesto if they are elected to power...."

In response, I was able to show there is NO such claimed obligation on any party to implement any manifesto pledge under any circumstances.

That the SNP demand IndyRef2 simply because its in their manifesto is, quite frankly, irrelevant. They have no legal power and no political mandate to do it - "A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another referendum."

Valid then and now.

It is relevant to show there is zero obligation on the SNP to follow through on its secessionist demands. Indeed, the people do not support it.