Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
potniatheron · 17/11/2022 10:54

I do want Scotland to go independent yes as there will then be more money for England and Wales. Scotland gets more per capita in state spending than England and Wales does and as a South Wales resident I would like that money to be spent on our deprived areas, not Scotland's.

Over half of Scottish employment relies in some way on Westminster and it would be good to get lots of those jobs for ourselves too.

The Scots clearly don't want to be part of the UK and that's fine. I don't know why the Government doesn't give them another referendum asap so we can crack on with it, as Scottish independence will be good for them and good for us too.

MigsandTiggs · 17/11/2022 10:51

I voted against independence the first time and will do the same for any future referendum. NS talks about joining the EU, keeping sterling etc, but she conveniently leaves out how that is possible and any timescale required.

Because of the Barnett formula, the Treasury provides about 85% of our total budget. From figures in 2019, Scotland continued to outspend other UK countries, except for Northern Island. (My relatives and friends in England are astonished that we get free prescriptions).

Those putting their hopes on taxes from Oil & Gas don't realise that we have ageing/depleted oil fields that are getting more difficult and expensive to work. The average age of our oil rigs is 29 years compared to 4 years in some countries. New North Sea fields require significant investment, but there are other parts of the world where the returns are higher, plus there are issues regarding the use of fossil fuels.

Regarding whisky, Japan is now producing award winning whisky, and Korean soju is the world's most consumed spirit, so the growth market for Scottish whisky is not assured.

If you already know all this OP and still feel the same about independence, then use your head a bit more. The people I have spoken to who are in favour of independence admit it's a heart over head thing because they know that independence will mean higher taxes and they are willing to accept the sacrifice.

cuteasaduck · 17/11/2022 10:50

@Americano75

Figures for other years are available. For instance 2018/19 Scotland's income including share of North Sea oil was £66b, but it received £81b. These figures are available on the Scotland Government website.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 10:48

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:46

Thanks @ILoveXmasChocsInNov
It always amazes me how much MN hate the SNP and yet in real life people keep voting for them.
Scotland will become independent.

Are you 12 OP? Seriously? You make the arguments of my 12 year old daughter! Selling water to England? Jeez!

I suggest you do some serious research, and look at the opinions of serious economists about what they think an Indy Scotland’s economy would look like. It might be an eye opener for you!

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:46

Thanks @ILoveXmasChocsInNov
It always amazes me how much MN hate the SNP and yet in real life people keep voting for them.
Scotland will become independent.

OP posts:
PearlclutchersInc · 17/11/2022 10:45

caringcarer · 17/11/2022 10:02

I live in England and wish I could vote to unload Scotland to be independent. It is a drain on the rest of our UK resources. The UK gives it a higher funding formula than England, N.I. or Wales. It is simply unfair.

Stupid woman/man; in terms of what Scotland contributes there's nothing unfair about it.

If you want to look unfairness look at what NI gets per head.

ILoveXmasChocsInNov · 17/11/2022 10:44

I live in England and I too think that Scotland should become independent. We have had 12 years of this shitshow of a government and it doesn't look like things will improve. Or they'll ever get voted out. The UK is just going to become worse in terms of quality of life and being able to access basic necessities like health care.

I'd miss you but the Scottish do seem to be more progressive, liberal and open minded so I think you deserve better.

All the best!!

Americano75 · 17/11/2022 10:43

@Redbushteaforme 💯!

My only caveat: no SNP rule in an independent Scotland. I want a fairer Scotland, with a green economy, land reform and the safeguarding of the rights of women and girls.

user1471523071 · 17/11/2022 10:39

I hope people understand that it costs more to deliver services to remote communities and in particular those on the islands. The majority of people in Scotland (around 80%) live in the central belt and they will get less spent on them per head of population compared to the remote communities. I really hope people here when complaining about the amount spent in Scotland are not saying that just because you live on an island you shouldn't get access to healthcare and education. Also, for those that like to holiday in the highlands but have a serious accident - you then tend to have to get a helicopter to rescue you and take you to hospital. This all costs much more.

BurningTheToast · 17/11/2022 10:39

I voted for independence at the last referendum. The current legistlative attack on the rights of women and girls mean that I will vote against it at the next referendum if/when that happens. There are other reasons too, but that's my line in the sand.

Contrary to what people often claim, there is no reason to believe that Scotland will simply swan back into the EU given established procedures and the right of other members states to veto it.

I'm also surprised that OP having lived here 'since the summer' feels able to confidently state that she knows what's best for the whole of Scotland, a very diverse country in terms of geography, economy and infrastructure.

Americano75 · 17/11/2022 10:38

cuteasaduck · 17/11/2022 10:35

@Americano75

These figures were released by the Chief Economic Director of the Scotland Government. They were requested under a FOI request. I'm not sure the link will work.

www.gov.scot/publications/foi-202200304871/

This jumped out at me:

Note that in particular spending was higher due to the response to the coronavirus pandemic.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:38

It beats me why you want to stay in a country - the UK - that only works to benefit the rich.
So much money wasted during covid, so much fraud by big business.
Even the current budget deficit could be halved if HS2 was scrapped.
The issue is not about money, it is about how it is spent. We need a forward-looking independent Scotland. And I think it will happen.
Life is going to get much worse, at some point people will vote for hope.

OP posts:
kingvizzytarg · 17/11/2022 10:37

If you had lived in Scotland longer you would know how good it used to be.

The SNP blame Westminster for everything and that's simply not the case. Education and Health both devolved and absolutely run into the ground. Scottish NHS may be fairing better than the English one but it won't be for long.

Tories are a shitshow but the SNP blame everyone but themselves for things that are entirely in their power.

Come back in 5 years and tell us if you still feel the same way.

Redbushteaforme · 17/11/2022 10:37

The sooner, the better. Does anyone seriously believe that the Scots are more incompetent than the crew which as been governing in Westminster for the past 12 years?

My only caveat: no SNP rule in an independent Scotland. I want a fairer Scotland, with a green economy, land reform and the safeguarding of the rights of women and girls.

And for you English thinking that you bank roll us, perhaps get yourself a big better informed.

ArcticSkewer · 17/11/2022 10:36

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:28

Grouse moors and the like are not Scottish resources. They are rich people's resources. They are for the benefit of rich people and terrible for the environment.

Of course they are. But it's basically why the English elite and noone else in England wants Scotland. Land, castles, leisure time for the aristos.
The rest of us get to fund it
Hurrah

cuteasaduck · 17/11/2022 10:35

@Americano75

These figures were released by the Chief Economic Director of the Scotland Government. They were requested under a FOI request. I'm not sure the link will work.

www.gov.scot/publications/foi-202200304871/

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 10:35

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 10:30

During 22/22 tax revenues in Scotland were £73bn. The block grant to Scotland was £97bn. For every £100 the govt spends per head in England, it spends £127 in Scotland.

I'm Scottish and even I don't think that's particularly fair.

I’d agree with you on that

AnuSTart · 17/11/2022 10:35

In fairness @MuraRocker I don't really care and already left to go to the EU so will abandon my UK citizenship before Scotland becomes independent in all likelihood. So it won't affect me but Brexit was terrible for young Scots.

But yes you're all right, Scotland has very little chance of joining the EU and it takes years- as it should. And many nations in the EU shouldn't be but that would be a whole other thread.

Cheesehamandoniontoastie · 17/11/2022 10:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

They wouldn't have you.

Americano75 · 17/11/2022 10:33

FanFckingTastic · 17/11/2022 10:31

@Americano75 I'm not sure that using the link below is the best source to demonstrate that England would be worse off financially if Scotland were independent. Although 'Chris from Moray' has a lovely website promoting Scotland and sharing his pictures, I don't think that his view of this topic is possibly the most factual....

www.livebreathescotland.com/would-england-be-richer-without-scotland/

I was just trying to find one that was a less dense read to be honest.

I can never get my head around how hard Westminster fought to keep a hold of us during the last referendum when we're supposedly such a massive drain on resources.

FanFckingTastic · 17/11/2022 10:31

@Americano75 I'm not sure that using the link below is the best source to demonstrate that England would be worse off financially if Scotland were independent. Although 'Chris from Moray' has a lovely website promoting Scotland and sharing his pictures, I don't think that his view of this topic is possibly the most factual....

www.livebreathescotland.com/would-england-be-richer-without-scotland/

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 10:31

www.deliveringforscotland.gov.uk/scotland-in-the-uk/public-spending/

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 10:30

During 22/22 tax revenues in Scotland were £73bn. The block grant to Scotland was £97bn. For every £100 the govt spends per head in England, it spends £127 in Scotland.

I'm Scottish and even I don't think that's particularly fair.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:28

Grouse moors and the like are not Scottish resources. They are rich people's resources. They are for the benefit of rich people and terrible for the environment.

OP posts:
Americano75 · 17/11/2022 10:27

MollieMarie · 17/11/2022 10:26

"In 2020-21, Scotland (including a geographical share of North Sea revenue) raised £62.8 billion in 2020-21, compared to £99.2 billion of public spending for Scotland." - Actual government figures.

Which government, Westminster or Holyrood?