Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 14:10

The once in a generation may not have been a condition but it was actually said.

Trez1510 · 17/11/2022 14:05

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 13:48

'This abundance of resources is the reason England cling to us and tell us constantly that we are too stupid, too poor, too small to succeed alone.'

The 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' bollocks has been bandied about by the SNP for years so that it's become a fact that union supporters/Westminster govt/ Tories actually said it. Which they haven't. But claim it enough and it becomes the SNP truth.

Similar to the way there was never a condition of the 2014 that it was 'once in a generation'? That sort of myth you mean?

For those saying: we said NO, and that's it. Shite. So many NO voters have died, so many young people are now eligible to vote and their voting intentions are 70/30 in favour of independence. The demograph has changed.

The thing that I did not agree with, and still do not agree with, is non-Scots being permitted to vote on our constitutional matters.

Figures released from the 2014 referendum indicated born-Scots voted in favour of independence, whilst those born elsewhere voted against independence e.g. English students at Scottish universities, European nationals, rUK-nationals, military personnel based in Scotland etc.

England simply cannot afford to let Scotland go, that's an obvious fact. They're willing to sell NI down the river. Why? They do not need NI's resources. Yet, there they are, desperately, desperately trying to deny democracy to Scots. Why? I know why, and so do you if you have any sort of critical thought process available to you.

Put it this way, if England was confident of resounding support to remain in this (so-called) union, they'd 'permit' the people of Scotland to exercise their democratic right to demonstrate that. They don't, though, do they?

As we say in Scotland the English establishment is 'Keeching its breeks.: 🙂

DownNative · 17/11/2022 14:02

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 12:48

Agreed. You would think if Scotland was such a drain England would be glad to get rid of them.

Do you understand that this is circular reasoning which is logically invalid?

Most people in England are in favour of Scotland staying in the UK as they believe we're stronger together as one. The UK Government has the same view.

Every part of the UK has a deficit except for the south east of England which is our economic driver. The City Of London and Greater London both make far more money every year than Scotland as a whole does. The idea Scotland subsidises England is fantasy, but not the other way round.

Crankley · 17/11/2022 14:00

Don't bore us to death, all you need to do is to convince the 50% of Scots who still don't want independence to vote for it.

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 13:55

derxa · 17/11/2022 13:25

Have you watched the Scottish parliament in action? Absolutely embarrassing.

And yet it still manages to be less embarrassing than Westminster!

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 13:48

'This abundance of resources is the reason England cling to us and tell us constantly that we are too stupid, too poor, too small to succeed alone.'

The 'too wee, too poor, too stupid' bollocks has been bandied about by the SNP for years so that it's become a fact that union supporters/Westminster govt/ Tories actually said it. Which they haven't. But claim it enough and it becomes the SNP truth.

Readinginthesun · 17/11/2022 13:37

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 11:49

Just returned from family visit to Scotland. Live in England now though grew up in Scotland. It’s a shadow of its former self tbh. Public services are dreadful, esp NHS. Sure the SNP give away free stuff (inc to those quite capable of paying for it themselves) but they have banjaxed a once great education system and politicised every aspect of life with their faux self righteous grievance - but a saltire and the word “Scot” plastered on every available public space.

Corruption and cronyism in government contract awarding coupled with total ineptitude and a lack of competence. The ferries scandal is just one example. Vastly over budget and years behind schedule - but hey, Nicola and pals got a lovely photo op and crowed about saving shipbuilding on the Clyde. I mean FFS THEY PAINTED WINDOWS ON AN UNFINISHED HULL OF A BOAT to make it look finished for a pretend “launch”.
Lets not even talk about the Gupta/Lochaber drama coming down the track.

Worse still is the politicisation and indoctrination in schools, growing a generation of little nationalists who think someone else (the English 🤦‍♀️) is to blame for their woes and that the government should be responsible for every aspect of their lives.

A weird acquiescence going on in what was once a nation of great engineers, explorers, thinkers. Now the highest drug deaths in Europe and some of the worst life expectancy.

Tell me how independence - with less money - will improve this.

Couldn’t have put it better myself .
People in other parts of the U.K. shouldn’t be fooled by the gimmicks like Baby Boxes ( which are very nice but not everyone needs one)

Readinginthesun · 17/11/2022 13:34

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:06

I agree to leave the EU has massively weakened the UK.
An independent Scotland could rejoin the EU.

No it would APPLY to joint the EU ! Given the state of public finances in Scotland ( where , by the way , we pay higher tax than in England) I cannot imagine the EU welcoming us with open arms !
Piece of advice - don’t listen to Sturgeon .

Escapefromcolditz · 17/11/2022 13:32

FairyPrincess123 · 17/11/2022 13:11

Not of the calibre of Johnson, Truss, Patel, Raab, Rees-Mogg, Dorries, Hancock, Braverman, Cleverly, Shapps, Gove, Coffey, Badenoch...?

Yes, they’re a bunch of idiots as well, but “the market” prices in the risk of idiots (see the mini-budget whirlwind), and the WM government has the stability (ish) of Whitehall behind it so they can weather more storms.

The Scottish government has neither competence in politicians nor in the civil service to support an economic strategy to support the ambitions they trumpet but don’t cost, relying instead on the magic money tree.

Who’d want to buy debt from a small, corrupt country with talent free politicians and a civil service as deep as a puddle? They’ll price in the risk and we’ll all pay the penalty for it (at least those of us who stay).

Trulyweird1 · 17/11/2022 13:31

So OP, please do touch on the economic / business interests Scotland does have, please?
Last go around was economically dependent on Oil. Think that ship has sailed. So what is our industry? Building ferries, paid for by the Scottish tax payer ? Frigates for the rest of the UK ? please, do tell .

derxa · 17/11/2022 13:26

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 13:12

Scotland contains 1/3rd of all UK arable land, 2/3rds of all fishing grounds, 2/3s of timber forests, 9/10ths of all fresh water, 9/10th of all remaining oil reserves, 2/3rds of all remaining natural gas reserves, and 1/4 of all of Europe's offshore energy capacity.

And this doesn't even touch on the economic/business/industries we also have within our country.

This abundance of resources is the reason England cling to us and tell us constantly that we are too stupid, too poor, too small to succeed alone.

Anyone who looks at what Scotland has at it's disposal and claims we'd be basket case failures is either corrupt, blind, or suffering from Stockholm syndrome.

The OP wants to rewild Scotland

derxa · 17/11/2022 13:25

FairyPrincess123 · 17/11/2022 13:11

Not of the calibre of Johnson, Truss, Patel, Raab, Rees-Mogg, Dorries, Hancock, Braverman, Cleverly, Shapps, Gove, Coffey, Badenoch...?

Have you watched the Scottish parliament in action? Absolutely embarrassing.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 13:13

@FairyPrincess123 Yep. The standard of politician is so high in the British government. If only Scotland could meet those high standards.

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 13:12

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 12:48

Agreed. You would think if Scotland was such a drain England would be glad to get rid of them.

Scotland contains 1/3rd of all UK arable land, 2/3rds of all fishing grounds, 2/3s of timber forests, 9/10ths of all fresh water, 9/10th of all remaining oil reserves, 2/3rds of all remaining natural gas reserves, and 1/4 of all of Europe's offshore energy capacity.

And this doesn't even touch on the economic/business/industries we also have within our country.

This abundance of resources is the reason England cling to us and tell us constantly that we are too stupid, too poor, too small to succeed alone.

Anyone who looks at what Scotland has at it's disposal and claims we'd be basket case failures is either corrupt, blind, or suffering from Stockholm syndrome.

FairyPrincess123 · 17/11/2022 13:11

Escapefromcolditz · 17/11/2022 12:22

I do indeed realise that the fastest way to get some kind of non- snp government in Scotland is to have independence but my argument is that the calibre of civil servants and politicians in this country isn’t high enough to hold any kind of credibility on the international economic stage - we’re going to end up a basket case!

Not of the calibre of Johnson, Truss, Patel, Raab, Rees-Mogg, Dorries, Hancock, Braverman, Cleverly, Shapps, Gove, Coffey, Badenoch...?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 13:02

Yanbu. The union is completely corrupt in favour of only one of the four home nations and provides no material benefit to us.

Just look at energy. Scotland produced enough electricity from renewables last year to meet 98% of it's electrical demand (yes I know there are supply and storage issues but in terms of gross consumption v generation that's the percentage) and 5 times more gas than it consumes. Yet despite being completely energy self-sufficient we are not faced with some of the highest energy bills in Europe but also get charged more to supply energy to the grid than England.

Similarly the way we are funded is shocking. Scotland is allocated a budget and cannot raise additional funds through borrowing, while also being required by law to return balanced books every year (i.e., no deficit). England on the other hand make full use of the UKs borrowing powers to fund their budget deficit and any new projects for their sole benefit (hs2 anyone), which Scotland (and the other home nations) not only have to then help pay back said borrowing with intrest but then also have their budgets reduced due to this additional borrowing.

If independence is not going to be allowed (which can't legally be done anyway) then at a minimum England needs to be stopped from abusing the powers of the UK government for their own benefit.

Scarfymcscarface · 17/11/2022 12:52

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 12:48

Agreed. You would think if Scotland was such a drain England would be glad to get rid of them.

Any views on English independence you’d care to enlighten us with?

How is the weather where you are OP? Nice day out there is it?

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 12:48

Agreed. You would think if Scotland was such a drain England would be glad to get rid of them.

OP posts:
Chickenwing2 · 17/11/2022 12:45

MollieMarie · 17/11/2022 10:16

Scotland costs the UK more than it contributes, so becoming an independent country and funding itself sounds like a great idea.

If this were true, why are the English government so reluctant to get rid of Scotland?

Scotland brings in plenty of money to the UK, eg, whisky, oil, tourism.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2022 12:45

@MuraRocker

What will you use for currency Nicola when you try to rejoin the EU?

+++

Either pounds, euros or dollars until they actually join the EU at which point it will have to be euros.

Note Panama has happily used US dollars for over a hundred years without seeing the need to have their own currency or getting "permission " to do so from the US.

1dayatatime · 17/11/2022 12:42

@x2boys

antelopevalley
I agree to leave the EU has massively weakened the UK.
An independent Scotland could rejoin the EU.

If the EU will have them

++++

The EU would accept Scotland although it would be at least a three year process.

The French would support it (to piss off England). Germany and the smaller nations would support it as they back the idea that the EU is a good thing.
Italy wouldn't care. Spain would object (over Catalonia) but then get told to shut up by Germany.

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 12:25

Escapefromcolditz · 17/11/2022 12:22

I do indeed realise that the fastest way to get some kind of non- snp government in Scotland is to have independence but my argument is that the calibre of civil servants and politicians in this country isn’t high enough to hold any kind of credibility on the international economic stage - we’re going to end up a basket case!

But, but, Emma Harper MSP and Scottish bank notes…

Escapefromcolditz · 17/11/2022 12:22

FairyPrincess123 · 17/11/2022 11:38

You do realise that the quickest way to get rid of the SNP, if that's what you want, is to get independence?

I do indeed realise that the fastest way to get some kind of non- snp government in Scotland is to have independence but my argument is that the calibre of civil servants and politicians in this country isn’t high enough to hold any kind of credibility on the international economic stage - we’re going to end up a basket case!

Pleasecreateausername13 · 17/11/2022 12:21

We already said a big firm No. Give it a rest.

PineapplePear · 17/11/2022 12:18

I think turnout was low in Scotland because no one seriously thought the vote would be for leave. In my workplace/social circle most people were shocked and angry at the result, and still are. These huge decisions, which Scotland has minimal sway over, no veto as a country, are why we need independence.

Why have other countries been able to go independent, but it’s not possible for Scotland?