Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
jcyclops · 17/11/2022 16:36

AnuSTart · 17/11/2022 10:10

Much of north of England gets their water from Scotland. UK benefits from Scottish oil fields and tax on whisky.

Also tourism.

Good luck England without all that.

England does not get water from Scotland. Scottish Water in 2018 said "I can confirm that there is currently no water supplies being diverted,
piped or channelled to England from Scotland." and in 2020 the Scottish Government said "There are no current plans to export water to England or internationally". An engineering firm (hoping to cash in) floated proposals for a "super canal" from the Southern Uplands to the Home Counties at a cost of £14bn (ie £50bn by the time it would be complete) which was rejected by both governments.

Whisky - if independent Scotland exported whisky to England it would be taxed in England - just as wines and spirits from Ireland, France, Italy etc are currently. Scotland gets its (Barnett inflated) share of these UK tax revenues, but after independence it would only get tax revenues from drinks sold in Scotland.

Tourism - Figures vary as they are all basically estimates, but Scottish Tourism generates around £12bn/year out of a UK total of around £145bn ie. about 8%. As Scotland has about 8% of the UKs population, it is broadly in line with the rest of the UK with respect to revenue per head.

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 16:33

This idea that because Scotland is running a deficit that we are propped up by the RoUK is utter nonsense, people realise.

The ENTIRE UK is running a deficit. This is a mess of the tory's making that everyone is suffering from.

Scotland has the potential to be a strong, independent country unshackled from the shitshow that is the rest of the UK. Energy, for example. Scotland is a net exporter of electricity and around 97% of it's needs are met by renewables. So, tell me why our electricity bills have shot up when the wholesale price of power is driven by the cost of gas?

It's because the RoUK is lagging behind massively so we effectively subsidise the bills of everyone in England. Who is propping up who, again?

Respectfullydisagree · 17/11/2022 16:32

I really wish in my lifetime I will see an independent Scotland. I feel it’s incredibly outdated for the English to believe they can choose countries to control. Leave us to it ffs and get over yourselves already. So what if Scotland suffers from it, at least we would be free and could choose to build the country as we want.

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 16:24

No, you're fooling nobody on that one

I guess you didn't see the post I was responding to then 😆.

Honestly, I stand by everything I said. I don't have proof, I never claimed to. I only ever said it was a fairly logical possibility. So you somehow claiming success because I haven't shown proof is moot.

Anyway, I can't be arsed with blowhards so I'm out.

AntlerRose · 17/11/2022 16:22

Well if i was scottish on scotland id probably be for independence. From a climate change perspective i think hydro and wind are good resources. I think water isnt in scarce supply and i think a lot of the country will not be underwater. I think you coukd rebt the spot for trident out to whoever keeps trident. I also think you have some actual exports.

But I live in England so i dont want you to go.

DownNative · 17/11/2022 16:17

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 16:07

At the end of the day, you have zero evidence to prove the best way to get rid of the SNP would be via independence. This is magical thinking NO Unionist should fall for....🤔

And at the end of the day, you have not evidence to suggest SNP would change how voting would work with independence. So I guess we are quits. One scenario is a fairly logical conclusion of independence however, the other is just a pro-union argument with no logic behind it other than anti-SNP rhetoric.

I wouldn't expect any unionist to change their vote based on what might happen in an independent Scotland. I'm actually talking to the pro-independence anti-SNP voters, that might change their vote on an independent referendum, entirely because it's a vote against SNP. It's not. A pro-union view will keep the SNP strong. I'm not actually trying to change anyone's mind. Just give people something to consider.

Actually we are NOT quits since I was challenging YOUR assertion in the first place.

Your only actual response was to argue with argumentum ad ignorantium which is a logical fallacy!

Here:

"The burden of proof is always on the person making an assertion or proposition. Shifting the burden of proof, a special case of argumentum ad ignorantium, is the fallacy of putting the burden of proof on the person who denies or questions the assertion being made."

Since you failed to support your own original assertion in the first place and tried to shift the burden of proof rather unsuccessfully, it logically stands to reason you have ZERO evidence.

And your assertion it'd be easier to vote the SNP out post-independence necessarily falls flat on its face.

In contrast, I successfully questioned your assertion.

I think you'll that pro-independence voters who are anti-SNP would still vote for independence. Just like those in favour of a united Ireland but anti-Provisional Sinn Féin would still vote for a united Ireland.

No, you're fooling nobody on that one.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/11/2022 16:13

AnuSTart · 17/11/2022 10:10

Much of north of England gets their water from Scotland. UK benefits from Scottish oil fields and tax on whisky.

Also tourism.

Good luck England without all that.

Here in Northumberland we have Kielder reservoir which is the biggest in Europe ( or was).

We dont get our water from Scotland. It might go further south but we have more than enough in the north.

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 16:07

At the end of the day, you have zero evidence to prove the best way to get rid of the SNP would be via independence. This is magical thinking NO Unionist should fall for....🤔

And at the end of the day, you have not evidence to suggest SNP would change how voting would work with independence. So I guess we are quits. One scenario is a fairly logical conclusion of independence however, the other is just a pro-union argument with no logic behind it other than anti-SNP rhetoric.

I wouldn't expect any unionist to change their vote based on what might happen in an independent Scotland. I'm actually talking to the pro-independence anti-SNP voters, that might change their vote on an independent referendum, entirely because it's a vote against SNP. It's not. A pro-union view will keep the SNP strong. I'm not actually trying to change anyone's mind. Just give people something to consider.

SammyScrounge · 17/11/2022 16:05

No.No No.

Goldpaw · 17/11/2022 15:59

I don't really have an opinion on this other than if Scottish people want it, then go for it. The idea that a small resource-healthy country in Western Europe couldn't fend for itself is nonsense, even if you want the UK to continue as it is.

I do like the idea of the UK being split into federal regions, for smaller areas to have their own regional parliaments, and for Westminster to deal only with the big issues such as defence.

The current set up only works for a few areas of the UK, so I do feel some sort of change is required.

Oh, and PR all round please.

DownNative · 17/11/2022 15:58

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 15:40

@DownNative there is no way they are going to get rid of proportional representation in Scotland. That's just not going to happen. And while obviously it's impossible to say how voting would go in an independent Scotland, it's clear why SNP are ahead of any other party at the moment. independence gets rid of what is currently one of the main, if not the main, reason to vote for them. It's a logical conclusion to say that their share of the vote is likely to be lower than their share of the vote whole Scotland is within the union.

It's quite funny to see someone try to deny what is likely by suggesting that the SNP might try to skew the way we would vote in an independent Scotland to make it easier for them to stay in power. It's not me that's reaching for straws here.

At which point did I suggest they'll get rid of proportional representation?

That's right - I didn't . But i am suggestingthey CAN easily lower the burden on getting elected.

As shown, the prospect of independence is NOT the only factor in their success. The other factor is a significant proportion believe the SNP are best placed to run Scotland WITHIN the UK.

At the end of the day, you have zero evidence to prove the best way to get rid of the SNP would be via independence. This is magical thinking NO Unionist should fall for....🤔

DownNative · 17/11/2022 15:53

Celia24 · 17/11/2022 15:15

Independence is normal. Finland,Denmark, Germany, Italy etc..how do you think they manage it? And then tell me why we wouldn't?

We have a country rich with resources. Most Indy supporters don't expect utopia and know it will take time to build the country we want. That is an opportunity many of us want to take. I don't want to be part of the UK - I love many people on this island but the political sphere and how it continues to affect this country is no longer tenable.

Your "independence is normal" quip is itself naively ridiculous as you're suggesting it's the only constitutional model out there.

Instead you'll find that Unionism is well established around the world. The United States of America has federalism but describes itself as a UNION. The US Embassy in UK refers to "States of the Union". Like the USA, the Federal Republic of Germany is a union of states each with its own constitution.

However, neither the US or Germany permit secession and regard it as a Constitutional violation.

The Kingdom of Denmark and the Kingdom of the Netherlands are two further examples of unions. They have forms of devolution also.

I could extend the point to various stares globally, but four examples are enough to counter your "independence is normal" slogan.

The European Union is another example although its not a sovereign union state like the examples given.

Unionism IS normal!

Likewise, a majority in Scotland do NOT want independence and prefer to work together with the rest of the British Family to improve all our fortunes. We are NOT fundamentally different from each other. 🤔

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 15:40

@DownNative there is no way they are going to get rid of proportional representation in Scotland. That's just not going to happen. And while obviously it's impossible to say how voting would go in an independent Scotland, it's clear why SNP are ahead of any other party at the moment. independence gets rid of what is currently one of the main, if not the main, reason to vote for them. It's a logical conclusion to say that their share of the vote is likely to be lower than their share of the vote whole Scotland is within the union.

It's quite funny to see someone try to deny what is likely by suggesting that the SNP might try to skew the way we would vote in an independent Scotland to make it easier for them to stay in power. It's not me that's reaching for straws here.

Celia24 · 17/11/2022 15:38

glassblowers · 17/11/2022 15:27

From a "foreign" perspective, life in some areas of the U.K. is grim, but Scotland is another level. Aberdeen anyone? If they're going independent, they'd better have a very good plan because, at present, the schools are worse, housing is worse, hospitals are worse, health is worse, the weather.... No wonder people are angry, but does NS really have the solutions?

I've lived in multiple foreign countries and Scotland is highly regarded abroad.

The country certainly has problems to overcome but to suggest it is a worse country than England is magical thinking.

Valeriekat · 17/11/2022 15:37

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 10:08

Calling me Nicola is just childish.

No it is hilarious!

glassblowers · 17/11/2022 15:27

From a "foreign" perspective, life in some areas of the U.K. is grim, but Scotland is another level. Aberdeen anyone? If they're going independent, they'd better have a very good plan because, at present, the schools are worse, housing is worse, hospitals are worse, health is worse, the weather.... No wonder people are angry, but does NS really have the solutions?

DownNative · 17/11/2022 15:21

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 15:14

@DownNative of course they would be very involved at the start.

But honestly, the Scottish government is designed to make a majority role difficult - and I strongly suspect that the only reason the SNP keep achieving it is because of the prospect of independence. Even if they still have a strong showing in votes post independence, should it happen, they are much less likely to have overall control.

Their involvement would give the SNP every advantage over every other party.

You're speaking of the CURRENT devolution arrangements put in place by Blair's Labour Government which was meant to be a perpetual advantage for Scottish Labour. And supposed to "kill Nationalism stone dead" - it did the opposite.

An independent Scotland led by the SNP can decide to do away with the devolution arrangements designed to make a single party majority difficult to achieve for one that makes it easier.

There is nothing to suggest it would be easier to keep the SNP out of government post-independence. Mere rhetoric without evidence claiming it'll be harder just won't fly.

Celia24 · 17/11/2022 15:15

Independence is normal. Finland,Denmark, Germany, Italy etc..how do you think they manage it? And then tell me why we wouldn't?

We have a country rich with resources. Most Indy supporters don't expect utopia and know it will take time to build the country we want. That is an opportunity many of us want to take. I don't want to be part of the UK - I love many people on this island but the political sphere and how it continues to affect this country is no longer tenable.

Mummieslncorporated · 17/11/2022 15:14

@DownNative of course they would be very involved at the start.

But honestly, the Scottish government is designed to make a majority role difficult - and I strongly suspect that the only reason the SNP keep achieving it is because of the prospect of independence. Even if they still have a strong showing in votes post independence, should it happen, they are much less likely to have overall control.

shash1982 · 17/11/2022 15:11

Not this again! What happened to the previous 'once in a lifetime vote yada, yada, yada....?'
Originally I preferred for Scotland to stay within the union but after so much vitriol and anti English bashing from some Scots the time of the last referendum, including friends and family, I'm now just thinking go away or stop with all this bullshit!

DuchessDandelion · 17/11/2022 15:11

Dontaskdontget · 17/11/2022 10:05

Europe needs more unity, not less. Particularly now that Putin’s gone insane.

Caledonia, the Vacomagi, Essex, Wessex, Kent etc - Britain used to be nothing but lots of powerless tribes constantly arguing with each other. They were highly vulnerable to invasion. The unity of the United Kingdom makes us all safer and stronger.

Britain’s exit from the EU was a Putin plot that took decades to succeed and that has massively weakened both the EU and Britain. Right now in Russia there are government officials whose entire job it is to blog on Twitter trying to create division in the West. This isn’t paranoia, news organisations like The Atlantic have exposed many of the Russian Twitter accounts.

Help Putin create division and weakness in the UK if you like, but you’re a fool if you do.

Well said about the UK.

Although I think brexit was driven more by rich people looking to get richer and abolish employment rights etc. Russia saw an opportunity in destabilisation but they weren't the driver.

theskywasallviolet · 17/11/2022 15:11

Yes yes yes!

The thought of an independent Scotland gives me a glimmer of hope after many, many years of things getting worse and worse in the UK. Let's try something different cos England sure as hell isn't going anywhere good.

And so many people missing the point here when slagging off Nicola Sturgeon and the SNP, it's not about that.

If we were independent we can start again with a new political system (no gross, out of touch, old money Tories!) and we can get rid of the SNP if we want.

And yes agree Scotland has waaaaay more valuable resources (wind/sea power, water - which will become very valuable as global warming increases -, oil and tourism to name a few!) than England so yeah I think we'll be fine thanks...

AngelicaElizaAndPeggy · 17/11/2022 15:05

I used to like this idea but I don't like the snp very much anymore.

And also England needs Scotland because with Scotland it will all go to shit with a massive, permanent tory majority in perpetuity.

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 15:05

Also please show me your costings and how it will work and not the we will join the eu again , which will take ages and how you propose to build a border etc as a hard border will be needed

healthadvice123 · 17/11/2022 15:03

Off you pop then but last time I looked life for many in Scotland js not too great either

Swipe left for the next trending thread