Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 18:42

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 18:34

😂😂😂this thread is going exactly the same way these threads always do.

A bunch of predominantly English unionists - who lack the ability to differentiate between the SNP's governance of Scotland within a restrictive and corrupt Union and the debate about the independence of Scotland as a nation - jump on their high horses and lecture the people who call Scotland home on all the terrible things about their country and current government.

Worse they do so without a shred of irony despite them being responsible for keeping one if the most contemptible and corruption government in living memory in power for 12 years.

The fact that the SNP, who consistently stand on a manifesto that supports independence, have maintained an overwhelming majority for over 12 years in a system specifically designed to stop that from happening should tell you all you need to about the feelings of those of us who live here.

Talking of irony, the OP, who has lived in Scotland for, ooooh, all of 5 months, has seen fit to tell Scots on the thread that Scotland should be independent.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 18:42

Happylittlechicken · 17/11/2022 18:33

So if Scotland did become independent, would we need to have checkpoints on all roads from England to Scotland? Would they block some off and just have major ones or would we have free movement?

Have you ever been to other countries with long land borders? They usually have official borders at main roads, but nowhere else. I have lived in other countries and when out for a walk realised I had walked to another country. I did not realise until I saw signposts to local villages. Britain is unusual in being an island. Most countries have land borders with other countries, including NI.

OP posts:
Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 18:41

PineapplePear · 17/11/2022 12:18

I think turnout was low in Scotland because no one seriously thought the vote would be for leave. In my workplace/social circle most people were shocked and angry at the result, and still are. These huge decisions, which Scotland has minimal sway over, no veto as a country, are why we need independence.

Why have other countries been able to go independent, but it’s not possible for Scotland?

What huge decisions?
We have devolved health and education as well as some powers over taxation.

Reading the news about the freeze on income tax thresholds in England makes me laugh- we’ve been stuck with millions being dragged into higher thresholds for years and no one has had as much of a go at Nicola.

I wouldn’t vote for a nationalist party and I would rather not have Nicola in charge. You wouldn’t vote for a Tory govt either. But that’s democracy. We have to live it with. As it stands, you actually have one person who you would be happy with (NS) making decisions for you. And yet I will struggle to have anyone representing me at all because of the insane obsession with the SNP.

ProfessorFusspot · 17/11/2022 18:40

As you're in Scotland, you'll know that (1) the Scottish Parliament voted to hold a second independence referendum (2) the UK government turned down the Scottish government's request for a Section 30 for a referendum to be held in July 2022 (3) the matter has now gone to the Supreme Court (UK) to determine whether Scotland can hold an independence referendum without formal approval from the UK government/parliament and (4) the new tentative date for the proposed referendum is 19 October 2023.

I'd keep an eye on the courts; what happens next depends on their verdict. I don't think MumsNet have much influence (no offence, MumsNet) although I bet they can find out which type of biscuit the Lord Advocate prefers. As for whether a referendum would lead to independence, that's purely up to the people of Scotland, as it should be.

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 18:39

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 18:34

😂😂😂this thread is going exactly the same way these threads always do.

A bunch of predominantly English unionists - who lack the ability to differentiate between the SNP's governance of Scotland within a restrictive and corrupt Union and the debate about the independence of Scotland as a nation - jump on their high horses and lecture the people who call Scotland home on all the terrible things about their country and current government.

Worse they do so without a shred of irony despite them being responsible for keeping one if the most contemptible and corruption government in living memory in power for 12 years.

The fact that the SNP, who consistently stand on a manifesto that supports independence, have maintained an overwhelming majority for over 12 years in a system specifically designed to stop that from happening should tell you all you need to about the feelings of those of us who live here.

Exactly!
If you went by views on MN the SNP would have two Councillors in the whole of Scotland!

OP posts:
Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 18:36

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 11:38

There is a fundamental difference between individual constituencies and an entire country.

Not one region in Scotland voted for Brexit. Not a single one, and yet here we are suffering the inevitable from the inevitable disaster it has been.

And secondly, in Scotland we've managed to adopt a proportional electoral system so - although it's far from perfect - most people do actually get a voice. Westminster is never going to move away from FPTP.

I find this attitude the hardest to understand.

You are upset about brexit, and so you want to leave another Union and so, likely, suffer similar (if not worse) economic woes.

You are upset about the divide from Europe, and so want to leave the uk. It has been horrid, and yet somehow this will be better? Using the pound for 10 years and having the Bank of England set I interest rates and control the value of the currency we’re using, but we would have no influence over any of this as an independent nation.

It’s just so blind and naive, and incredibly wishful.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 18:34

Scarfymcscarface · 17/11/2022 14:48

thankfully this thread isn’t going the way OP wanted it and is highlighting the shitshow that Scotland has to endure due to the idiots who continue to vote SNP.

“Independence” being the very last thing they want, they’d hate to lose out on their Westminster salaries and an ability to blame everything on the English.

but I suspect the OP was hoping to channel this towards “health” provision anyway ammirite?Hmm

😂😂😂this thread is going exactly the same way these threads always do.

A bunch of predominantly English unionists - who lack the ability to differentiate between the SNP's governance of Scotland within a restrictive and corrupt Union and the debate about the independence of Scotland as a nation - jump on their high horses and lecture the people who call Scotland home on all the terrible things about their country and current government.

Worse they do so without a shred of irony despite them being responsible for keeping one if the most contemptible and corruption government in living memory in power for 12 years.

The fact that the SNP, who consistently stand on a manifesto that supports independence, have maintained an overwhelming majority for over 12 years in a system specifically designed to stop that from happening should tell you all you need to about the feelings of those of us who live here.

Happylittlechicken · 17/11/2022 18:33

So if Scotland did become independent, would we need to have checkpoints on all roads from England to Scotland? Would they block some off and just have major ones or would we have free movement?

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 18:32

'So what if Scotland suffers from it, at least we would be free and could choose to build the country as we want.'

You get to make that decision for yourself but not for anyone else. Not for me. Not for my kids and in all probability my grandkids.

silverclock222 · 17/11/2022 18:30

No, we voted No and that should be the end of it. Get rid SNP first and you might change the minds of many.....

Americano75 · 17/11/2022 18:28

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 18:20

You do know that you’re just linking an incredibly biased website?

No! Really? Shut the front door!

Americano75 · 17/11/2022 18:28

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 18:20

You do know that you’re just linking an incredibly biased website?

No! Really? Shut the front door!

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 18:28

Respectfullydisagree · 17/11/2022 16:32

I really wish in my lifetime I will see an independent Scotland. I feel it’s incredibly outdated for the English to believe they can choose countries to control. Leave us to it ffs and get over yourselves already. So what if Scotland suffers from it, at least we would be free and could choose to build the country as we want.

You see it is this attitude that irritates me. “So what if we’re poor?” So you don’t mind if pensioners can’t afford food? That teachers teach in a class of 50 kids? That hospitals have to cut staff by 20%? Cause this is the sort of things you face when you cut your budget by 15% by leaving the Barnett formula behind.

Mojoj · 17/11/2022 18:25

PurpleButterflyWings · 17/11/2022 10:01

Then start an online position for Scotland to have the right to vote (AGAIN) to leave the UK @antelopevalley if you're THAT keen to leave. I'll sign it! And I am sure most other people in England will sign it too.

Promise?

DownNative · 17/11/2022 18:23

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 16:33

This idea that because Scotland is running a deficit that we are propped up by the RoUK is utter nonsense, people realise.

The ENTIRE UK is running a deficit. This is a mess of the tory's making that everyone is suffering from.

Scotland has the potential to be a strong, independent country unshackled from the shitshow that is the rest of the UK. Energy, for example. Scotland is a net exporter of electricity and around 97% of it's needs are met by renewables. So, tell me why our electricity bills have shot up when the wholesale price of power is driven by the cost of gas?

It's because the RoUK is lagging behind massively so we effectively subsidise the bills of everyone in England. Who is propping up who, again?

Misleading claptrap regarding the claim that "around 97% of it's needs are met by renewables" for Scotland!

Here's the facts as set out by FullFact:

"The Scottish National Party (SNP) leader and Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon has claimed that almost all electricity used in Scotland is from renewable sources. This is not correct....."

And:

"Suggesting that near 100% of electricity used in Scotland is from renewable sources would be true if Scotland used all its renewable electricity and only exported non-renewable.

But that’s not how electricity systems work.

In fact, the Scottish Government estimates that, in 2020, 56% of the electricity consumed in Scotland came from renewable sources, 30% from nuclear and 13% from fossil fuels.

Renewables still account for far more of Scotland’s electricity consumption than in England and Wales.

But to suggest it's almost 100% is misleading."

In fact, the Scottish Government backtracked on that and basically said they didn't mean to mislead anyone!

Here:

"The Scottish Government told Full Fact the First Minister was referring to Scotland’s gross electricity consumption and it was not her intention to suggest otherwise."

FullFact went on to say:

"We deserve better than bad information.

After we published this fact check, we contacted the SNP to request clarification regarding this claim.

They added text underneath the video on their website but this did not explain that Nicola Sturgeon made an incorrect claim in the video.

They did not add any information to their social media pages where the video was shared.

It’s not good enough."

fullfact.org/environment/scotland-renewable-energy/

Don't ye know the SNP have form for misleading people in order to further their independence agenda?!

I'm afraid your attempted argument cannot stand on its own feet....

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 18:20

Americano75 · 17/11/2022 10:18

You do know that you’re just linking an incredibly biased website?

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 17/11/2022 18:17

If/ when Scotland becomes independent, the % of Scots voting SNP will certainly decrease. Many people are only voting for them now to send a pro-independence message. As soon as that's happened, they will feel more able to vote for other candidates.
Personally, I hope that means more independent candidates, as none of the existing political parties are very appealing. The Greens in Scotland have lost the plot (i.e. an ecological/ land rights focus) and the Scottish Socialist Party pretty much got destroyed by Tommy Sheridan's shenanigans.

Happylittlechicken · 17/11/2022 18:15

AnuSTart · 17/11/2022 10:10

Much of north of England gets their water from Scotland. UK benefits from Scottish oil fields and tax on whisky.

Also tourism.

Good luck England without all that.

But hasn’t NS just had to go asking for more money for NHS Scotland, if Scotland is independent, there won’t be any of that will there. How will Scotland fund all the great schemes NS wants to put into place?

DownNative · 17/11/2022 18:12

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 16:49

This doesn’t tally with a pp

Every part of the UK has a deficit except for the south east of England which is our economic driver. The City Of London and Greater London both make far more money every year than Scotland as a whole does.

Unshackling from an economic driver doesn’t sound wise.

It definitely isn't wise from an economic standpoint. London is still the number one European financial centre, after all. Its successes have an impact on the UK overall.

Edinburgh and Glasgow can never compete with London.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 18:11

MugginsOverEre · 17/11/2022 17:55

Whisky - if independent Scotland exported whisky to England it would be taxed in England - just as wines and spirits from Ireland, France, Italy etc are currently. Scotland gets its (Barnett inflated) share of these UK tax revenues, but after independence it would only get tax revenues from drinks sold in Scotland.
And let's not forget who owns those Scottish distilleries and earns the profits. Around 70 percent of whisky distilleries are owned by foreign companies. That profit money is headed off to Japan, America, France....

Well that led down an interesting rabbit hole.......

who owns Scotland's distilleries

DownNative · 17/11/2022 18:08

balalake · 17/11/2022 18:00

I want to see Scotland as an independent nation. I don't want a referendum in 2023 or 2024 though, as the answer will be no, and then you cannot argue for a material change or something similar for one in the early 2030s.

If you wait until the early 2030s you can argue a generation has passed, and more chance I think then of a yes vote.

The comments some have made re the SNP I agree with, hence my comment made to some that the best argument against independence is the SNP.

On the contrary, the best argument against independence is still the ECONOMICS, including currency amongst other things.

The SNP performance in administering devolution in Scotland (badly!) is just another argument against.

balalake · 17/11/2022 18:00

I want to see Scotland as an independent nation. I don't want a referendum in 2023 or 2024 though, as the answer will be no, and then you cannot argue for a material change or something similar for one in the early 2030s.

If you wait until the early 2030s you can argue a generation has passed, and more chance I think then of a yes vote.

The comments some have made re the SNP I agree with, hence my comment made to some that the best argument against independence is the SNP.

MugginsOverEre · 17/11/2022 17:55

Whisky - if independent Scotland exported whisky to England it would be taxed in England - just as wines and spirits from Ireland, France, Italy etc are currently. Scotland gets its (Barnett inflated) share of these UK tax revenues, but after independence it would only get tax revenues from drinks sold in Scotland.
And let's not forget who owns those Scottish distilleries and earns the profits. Around 70 percent of whisky distilleries are owned by foreign companies. That profit money is headed off to Japan, America, France....

HouchinBawbags · 17/11/2022 17:50

Naw, Git tae fuck way that pish.

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 16:49

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 16:33

This idea that because Scotland is running a deficit that we are propped up by the RoUK is utter nonsense, people realise.

The ENTIRE UK is running a deficit. This is a mess of the tory's making that everyone is suffering from.

Scotland has the potential to be a strong, independent country unshackled from the shitshow that is the rest of the UK. Energy, for example. Scotland is a net exporter of electricity and around 97% of it's needs are met by renewables. So, tell me why our electricity bills have shot up when the wholesale price of power is driven by the cost of gas?

It's because the RoUK is lagging behind massively so we effectively subsidise the bills of everyone in England. Who is propping up who, again?

This doesn’t tally with a pp

Every part of the UK has a deficit except for the south east of England which is our economic driver. The City Of London and Greater London both make far more money every year than Scotland as a whole does.

Unshackling from an economic driver doesn’t sound wise.