Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 21:00

ShandaLear · 17/11/2022 20:50

Depends. If you believe that:

Countries should have the power to determine their own destinies
They should be able to make all their own laws and determine how they are applied
They should be able to raise and spend all their own taxes without interference in how they are spent.
Everyone who is elected is directly accountable to the electorate on how the country is governed and run

Lets face it, the UK is an absolute bag of shite and I can’t work out why anyone, least of the Scottish and Northern Irish want to be governed by that absolute bag of dicks in power. Why are English people making laws that Scottish people have to follow? Laws that aren’t necessarily in their interests and don’t benefit them.

But a lot of Scottish people would call themselves British, as would English people. And so, your personal nation isn’t distinction isn’t felt by the majority of people.

DownNative · 17/11/2022 20:56

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 20:07

I'm not missing that at all.

The point is that unionists are opposed to asking the question, not just independence itself. If they are so confident they can make a good case for not breaking up the uk they should be chomping at the bit, yet they aren't. Funny that.

You are since you framed it as "Why are some people so keen to deny a country the right of self-determination?" implying Scotland as a whole is in favour.

Not only are people divided on the question of the constitution, but they're very divided on when such a referendum might be held too.

As for the rest of your post, that's just ridiculous circular reasoning and it's completely logically invalid. On the contrary, it's up to the Nationalists to persuade enough people to support IndyRef2.

Not for the Unionists to do so. Unionists are well within their rights to refuse to support such a move.

Remember, there is no right to secession in international law and politics.

ShandaLear · 17/11/2022 20:50

Depends. If you believe that:

Countries should have the power to determine their own destinies
They should be able to make all their own laws and determine how they are applied
They should be able to raise and spend all their own taxes without interference in how they are spent.
Everyone who is elected is directly accountable to the electorate on how the country is governed and run

Lets face it, the UK is an absolute bag of shite and I can’t work out why anyone, least of the Scottish and Northern Irish want to be governed by that absolute bag of dicks in power. Why are English people making laws that Scottish people have to follow? Laws that aren’t necessarily in their interests and don’t benefit them.

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 20:40

amp.theguardian.com/uk-news/2022/oct/17/independence-will-rid-scotland-of-uk-economic-chaos-says-nicola-sturgeon

Nicola Sturgeon heard confirmed in the economic prospectus that sterling would have to be used for as long as necessary..
As in, she doesn’t really know and so it’s a leap of faith. Great.

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 20:31

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 19:10

You mean the majority of voters in 2014, it's an important distinction to make.

Demographics change, people change, opinions change. And speaking of change there have been material changes to the union since the 2014 vote. If you really are respectful of democracy then you should fully support the question of Scottish independence being put to people again.

The only reason I can see you would object to this is if you are a unionist and you fear the outcome will be different this time.

I’m guessing you’re trying to say there’s a younger demographic. But if you look at our new world population graph you will see the issues of an aging population. Although Tbf in Scotland our terrible record on health might not be on par with others..

And yet social care and the issues that come with, a lack of growth or centre for business in Scotland doesn’t seem to matter. It seems it will be magically sorted by the pure hopefulness that all of us who voted no have been blinded by.

Notonationalism · 17/11/2022 20:30

Have a read and see if you still think Scotland is funding England and if the snp have any kind of credible offering.

www.these-islands.co.uk/publications/i377/gers_2021_a_deep_dive.aspx

www.these-islands.co.uk/publications/i374/scottish_politics_in_the_grip_of_a_fact_denial_epidemic.aspx

Michellexxx · 17/11/2022 20:28

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 18:47

Yes, I'm upset (and angry) about brexit which anyone with half a braincell could see would be an absolute disaster.

But what I'm more angry about is that Scotland voted not to leave the EU and yet, here we are. That makes me fucking furious. The uk is a broken, abusive relationship that I want out of.

But before this Scotland voted to remain part of the uk. Then voted in the brexit referendum.

So the majority of people still wanted to be part of the uk and the brexit vote stands because of that. We could break down regions in England and have them whining that they didn’t get what they wanted and so want to have an independent govt away from the other area who did.

You’re arguing against democratic voting, just because you don’t like the outcome.

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 20:13

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 20:07

I'm not missing that at all.

The point is that unionists are opposed to asking the question, not just independence itself. If they are so confident they can make a good case for not breaking up the uk they should be chomping at the bit, yet they aren't. Funny that.

I didn’t want Brexit but I can see why the campaign was successful. Promising change for the better based on emotion not economics is a strong pull. It’s only after the division and difficulty becomes a reality.

CrappyJob · 17/11/2022 20:10

Sunak and Truss both said no to another!

Only because there has been a huge number of people calling for another one... Of course the person at number 10 won't want another when the polls are not in their favour!

Paracetamol · 17/11/2022 20:08

willithappen · 17/11/2022 20:04

Howling laughing at those saying scotland costs more to have in UK
Wonder where people pick their facts up from

Not exactly fair we have to put up with this shit Tory government that the majority of England seems to continue voting for

Scotland DOES cost the UK more than it puts in. People have literally provided facts and statistics on this thread to back it up.

Funny how the people claiming Scotland DOESN'T take more money than it brings in don't seem to have any evidence or proof of their statements.

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 20:07

DownNative · 17/11/2022 19:54

The point you're missing is that the people living in Scotland are divided on how to exercise self-determination.

Any lead Nationalists had was relatively short and certainly nowhere near as long as the longest Unionist lead.

Brexit has not delivered a hoped for surge in support for independence.

Oh, and self-determination is balanced against the right of sovereign states to have security over its territorial integrity.

I'm not missing that at all.

The point is that unionists are opposed to asking the question, not just independence itself. If they are so confident they can make a good case for not breaking up the uk they should be chomping at the bit, yet they aren't. Funny that.

ProfessorFusspot · 17/11/2022 20:04

Michellexxx: You are upset about brexit, and so you want to leave another Union and so, likely, suffer similar (if not worse) economic woes. You are upset about the divide from Europe, and so want to leave the uk. It has been horrid, and yet somehow this will be better?

Independent Scotland in the EU makes sense and is desirable to many people and not only for economic reasons. The issue isn't JUST that Scotland didn't get something most of its people wanted, it's that whenever Scotland's needs and goals are different from those of the larger UK there is no way for Scotland to progress or even be heard. Back in 2016, a Scottish MP requested a discussion on the floor of the HoC about a potential amendment to the EU Referendum bill addressing what would happen if the different constituent countries of the UK voted differently on Brexit. He was summarily refused on the grounds that the referendum was advisory only and there was no need to plan for something that couldn't happen. In retrospect, people understandably see that as bad faith. After the Brexit vote, the Scottish Government convened a panel of experts to brainstorm and research ways for the UK to stay in the single market after leaving the EU, and ways for Scotland to stay in or associated even if the UK left. Everyone thought the UK government completely ignored this, as they never acknowledged even having received it, until the ideas started popping up in their plans ... for NI.

Using the pound for 10 years and having the Bank of England set I interest rates and control the value of the currency we’re using, but we would have no influence over any of this as an independent nation.

Who has suggested this course of action? The most likely scenario in 2014 was to continue to use the local Pound as a separate currency (as Ireland did until it joined the Eurozone in 2000), initially pegged to Sterling but able to be floated once stability permitted. Using Sterling unilaterally was never a good option, now it is unworkable as Scotland intends to apply to join the EU and if it is treated as a potential new member and the current requirement to commit to joining the EZ stands, it cannot use a non-EU currency long-term.

HappyLittleChicken: So if Scotland did become independent, would we need to have checkpoints on all roads from England to Scotland? Would they block some off and just have major ones or would we have free movement?

Ahead of the 2014 referendum, the plan was for (a hypothetical independent) Scotland to join the Common Travel Area (CTA), so borders would be open in a similar way as the land border between the UK and Ireland. It was assumed there would also have been Freedom of Movement with iScotland eventually in the EU or at least in the Single Market, likely with some temporary arrangement at the beginning. UK and Ireland have (mostly) managed this in spite of Brexit.

Marshabradyo: If Remain had won I’d expect Leave to accept it as I have the Brexit vote. Farage went on record before the vote saying he'd have begun campaigning immediately for another vote to leave the EU. Had the UK stayed in the EU, any UK party could have put an EU referendum in its election manifesto at any time, as the Conservatives did in 2015 and as the SNP put an independence referendum in their manifesto for the Holyrood elections of 2016 and 2021.

Scarfymcscarface: the majority of Scottish people voted to stay in the union and that tells you all you need to know about the feelings of those of us who live here. Self-determination of people is a process, not a one-time event. While there's no law or agreement to govern Scotland's use of independence referendums, the Good Friday Agreement sets out timescales and conditions for a(nother) Irish reunification referendum and states that there must be a full seven years between votes. Why should Scotland be held to a different standard?

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit: no-one in Scotland voted for Brexit at all... Plenty of people in Scotland (1,018,322) voted to leave the EU, just not a majority. No one in Scotland voted to leave the Single Market, which has happened purely at the whim of a Westminster government.

CrappyJob: There have been three general elections since 2014. Three. Why are people not saying no to another because the decision has already been made? Sunak and Truss both said no to another! But multiple referendums on the same general question have precedent; Scotland and Wales each voted twice before opting for their own national parliaments/assemblies, for example.

willithappen · 17/11/2022 20:04

Howling laughing at those saying scotland costs more to have in UK
Wonder where people pick their facts up from

Not exactly fair we have to put up with this shit Tory government that the majority of England seems to continue voting for

DownNative · 17/11/2022 19:54

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 19:35

Perhaps, but this time that "control" isn't the fantasy of farage et al.

Why are some people so keen to deny a country the right of self-determination?

The point you're missing is that the people living in Scotland are divided on how to exercise self-determination.

Any lead Nationalists had was relatively short and certainly nowhere near as long as the longest Unionist lead.

Brexit has not delivered a hoped for surge in support for independence.

Oh, and self-determination is balanced against the right of sovereign states to have security over its territorial integrity.

derxa · 17/11/2022 19:51

Scotland used to produce great politicians. John Smith, Donald Dewar, Gordon Brown, Charles Kennedy, Margo McDonald, Jim Sillars, Jimmy Reid...
Now we have this rubbish

CrappyJob · 17/11/2022 19:46

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 19:27

You do realise elections are not referendums on one topic don’t you

If Remain had won how many more Brexit votes would you want? Until Brexit got the result it wanted?

I’d expect Leave to accept the vote and the ‘voice of the people’ as we have with Leave.

I think three elections from 2015 to 2019 is excessive, don't you? They are supposed to last four or five years.

So another referendum when there has been a significant change (Scotland was told time and time again that the only way to stay in the EU was to stay in the union. Look how well that turned out), after ten years can't be unreasonable, surely?

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 19:43

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 19:17

I fear we are going to have two separate but ongoing conversations in a second as I've just quoted you in a previous post.

But no it's not short hand for that at all. It's simply a statement of fact. If you think the future should be bound to the past with no room for reflection and change, fine but I certainly don't think that's the right way to live or govern.

I didn’t mean 2014, I meant 2014 and all
subsequent polling. There has never been a consistent majority that want to leave the UK - ever.

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 19:42

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 19:35

Perhaps, but this time that "control" isn't the fantasy of farage et al.

Why are some people so keen to deny a country the right of self-determination?

It’s a similar fantasy built on feelings not economics.

But if you do win all that anger you feel will just be reversed and internalised. Whatever Brexit delivered in terms of division will be greater in your own country. People who said no and still want no won’t be happy.

It’s like Brexit on steroids. The costs will be greater too. The plus side is the blame won’t be on us anymore - you’ll have that with each other. The downside is the costs will impact us too.

RedAppleGirl · 17/11/2022 19:39

Yes take Wales with you too.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 19:38

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 19:36

Which would be a point on which you could build an argument for staying in the union at the next referendum.

It is not a point that should be used to deny a referendum taking place.

I should have added there that the brexit referendum is one of the changes. There are several promises or vows made by the union that have also been broken.

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 19:36

Because the unionist know there is a very real chance that the would lose a second referendum. Its as simple and anti-democratic as that.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 19:36

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 17/11/2022 19:18

So, Scotland being forced out of the EU, the UK's biggest trading partner, by Brexit vote (because no-one in Scotland voted for Brexit at all) is the material change to push for another independence referendum which will mean Scotland is no longer in a union with it's biggest trading partner.

And Scotland's trade with Ruk is a far bigger chunk of it's export trade than the UK's export trade with the EU.

Which would be a point on which you could build an argument for staying in the union at the next referendum.

It is not a point that should be used to deny a referendum taking place.

CapMarvel · 17/11/2022 19:35

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 19:01

Take Back Control

Same old. Leave the nasty controllers behind like Brexiteers did to the EU

Perhaps, but this time that "control" isn't the fantasy of farage et al.

Why are some people so keen to deny a country the right of self-determination?

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 17/11/2022 19:34

Scarfymcscarface · 17/11/2022 19:15

i cba arguing with such idiotic comments suffice to say the majority of Scottish people voted to stay in the union and that tells you all you need to know about the feelings of those of us who live here.

*The majority of those who voted in 2014. Not the majority of Scottish people full stop.

If you're that confident the outcome will be the same then there's no reason to object. Hell, we could even add some clauses to this referendum such as "this is the last one for X years" or "any vows, pledges or promises made by the union are legally binding".

MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 19:27

CrappyJob · 17/11/2022 19:20

There have been three general elections since 2014. Three.

Why are people not saying no to another because the decision has already been made?

You do realise elections are not referendums on one topic don’t you

If Remain had won how many more Brexit votes would you want? Until Brexit got the result it wanted?

I’d expect Leave to accept the vote and the ‘voice of the people’ as we have with Leave.

Swipe left for the next trending thread