Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Scotland should become independent?

487 replies

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:55

As life continues to get worse in the UK, it is time for Scotland to go independent. We need to build a forward-looking country that invests in its future, rather than the backward-looking country the UK has become that prioritises the rich. It is time for Scotland to separate from the UK and become that country.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
13
MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 19:16

DownNative · 24/11/2022 19:14

Have you read the Supreme Court's 35 page document outlining their whole reasoning?

Some excellent stuff in there that will be added to my already extensive collection of international law facts on the issues of secession and self-determination rights.

The judges eyes must've been on stalks when they read the SNPs written submission! They made the kind of argument their own Scottish Lord Advocate wouldn't go anywhere near....

No I just tuned into a statement on Times Radio from the court and the wording and reasoning was excellent, I was very impressed, I’ll check it out though

I was a bit annoyed after actually as the presenter said to his reporter you just encapsulated his 8 minutes in one. I can’t stand dumbing down and they are usually better than that

DownNative · 24/11/2022 19:14

MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 18:55

It’s getting a bit personal attack but imo the legal side is interesting. I caught the end of the Supreme Court reasoning and it was very good.

Have you read the Supreme Court's 35 page document outlining their whole reasoning?

Some excellent stuff in there that will be added to my already extensive collection of international law facts on the issues of secession and self-determination rights.

The judges eyes must've been on stalks when they read the SNPs written submission! They made the kind of argument their own Scottish Lord Advocate wouldn't go anywhere near....

DownNative · 24/11/2022 19:10

BlueBellsArePretty · 24/11/2022 18:25

@DownNative

You do know that your smug style of posting does more for the independence movement than anything else?

You really do come across as a pompous pita.

And yes I'm fully aware it an ad hominem argument, so no need to use your superior intellect to tell me that. Ad hominem are not always fallacies. Someone's contempt can be far clearer than their (copied and pasted) arguments. 👍

Dear me....you give me far, far too much influence on the Scottish independence movement! Ridiculous statement.

And it'd be just as ridiculous if I said your behaviour strengthens the pro-union argument!

Sorry, but Ad Hominems are ALWAYS logical fallacies precisely because they do NOT attempt to debate the issue at hand. Ad Hominems are intended to divert from the debate.

Socrates was spot on....

To think Scotland should become independent?
To think Scotland should become independent?
MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 18:55

It’s getting a bit personal attack but imo the legal side is interesting. I caught the end of the Supreme Court reasoning and it was very good.

BlueBellsArePretty · 24/11/2022 18:25

@DownNative

You do know that your smug style of posting does more for the independence movement than anything else?

You really do come across as a pompous pita.

And yes I'm fully aware it an ad hominem argument, so no need to use your superior intellect to tell me that. Ad hominem are not always fallacies. Someone's contempt can be far clearer than their (copied and pasted) arguments. 👍

DownNative · 24/11/2022 18:08

PineapplePear · 24/11/2022 16:33

Down native, you seem to be a very black and white thinker, and quite patronising to boot 😂😂😂

If you ask anyone across the uk, lots would define ‘England’ ‘Scotland’ etc as countries - it might not be the law, but that’s how people feel. Even a lot of unionist supporters would struggle with Scotland isn’t a country.

Completely ignoring how people feel, their identity/culture with a smirk isn’t going to tempt people to give up on independence and see the value of being in the UK.

Why is is being part of the uk best for Scotland? the only argument you ever see comes down to money. Personally I feel Scotland has had to sacrifice key things which impacts its current earnings e.g. oil revenues invested in London, for the benefit of the uk. Fine, but then to be complained at for contributing less than London? How different would Scotland be if that money had been invested here. How about the Edinburgh stock exchange which had to give way to London?

Hence, unilateral declarations of independence is completely illegal in international law as well as domestic law.

Think about that for a minute.

The economy is a major part of the Unionist argument, but it is clearly NOT the only one. There are social, familial and cultural bonds right across the UK. We can see it in our buildings as well as history - Belfast, Glasgow, Manchester and Sheffield are very similar to each other including historically. These bonds are worth keeping.

Now, the UK can go ahead over the coming years to do a Canada-esque Clarity Act. I trust you've seen what's happened to Quebec and Catalan independence movements over the last few years?

DownNative · 24/11/2022 18:03

PineapplePear · 24/11/2022 16:33

Down native, you seem to be a very black and white thinker, and quite patronising to boot 😂😂😂

If you ask anyone across the uk, lots would define ‘England’ ‘Scotland’ etc as countries - it might not be the law, but that’s how people feel. Even a lot of unionist supporters would struggle with Scotland isn’t a country.

Completely ignoring how people feel, their identity/culture with a smirk isn’t going to tempt people to give up on independence and see the value of being in the UK.

Why is is being part of the uk best for Scotland? the only argument you ever see comes down to money. Personally I feel Scotland has had to sacrifice key things which impacts its current earnings e.g. oil revenues invested in London, for the benefit of the uk. Fine, but then to be complained at for contributing less than London? How different would Scotland be if that money had been invested here. How about the Edinburgh stock exchange which had to give way to London?

Law is pretty black and white, you know. Funny how those who have no credible argument against the legal case simply attempt to personalise a debate(!)

You'll notice I don't do that.

No, people informally acknowledge England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are countries. I sometimes refer to Northern Ireland as "our wee country" informally.

But we say Constituent countries of the UK and non-sovereign when we need to be precise as well as specific in a political and/or legal sense.

But countries are NOT necessarily or automatically sovereign ones, you know. At the end of the day, it is independent sovereign countries that really matter and it is they who hold the current international order together.

PineapplePear · 24/11/2022 16:33

Down native, you seem to be a very black and white thinker, and quite patronising to boot 😂😂😂

If you ask anyone across the uk, lots would define ‘England’ ‘Scotland’ etc as countries - it might not be the law, but that’s how people feel. Even a lot of unionist supporters would struggle with Scotland isn’t a country.

Completely ignoring how people feel, their identity/culture with a smirk isn’t going to tempt people to give up on independence and see the value of being in the UK.

Why is is being part of the uk best for Scotland? the only argument you ever see comes down to money. Personally I feel Scotland has had to sacrifice key things which impacts its current earnings e.g. oil revenues invested in London, for the benefit of the uk. Fine, but then to be complained at for contributing less than London? How different would Scotland be if that money had been invested here. How about the Edinburgh stock exchange which had to give way to London?

DownNative · 24/11/2022 16:04

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 14:22

No but i do think your completely OTT on this issue.. esp as the SC has decided and its highly unlikely there will be another vote this side 2050.

which is what i said a few pages back but still u go on....... and i agreed with you on "voluntary" but still you bang on ... & on...

As for Germany France Spain etc do these countries have sports teams representing their devolved regions... what was the score when Catalonia played Croatia in a WC qualifier?

Anyhow enjoy having another burst blood vessel, i'm out.

You kept on mentioning the whole voluntary thing so I responded to it.

Football teams now, hey?! 🤣 Football has zero relevance to international law, secession and the UKs status as a unitary sovereign state.

England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland only compete still as they do for historical reasons. England and Scotland held the first international match. Northern Ireland invented the penalty spot kick.

But.....irrelevant to international law. Clutching at straws!

Oh, and I don't personalise debates. But you evidently do.....very poor show from you.

DdraigGoch · 24/11/2022 15:39

however, i do think that as Scotland continually votes SNP

@Alexandra2001 all of Scotland votes for the SNP do they? Ok, not all - how about a majority? Still no.

The balance between votes for unionist parties and separatist parties in Scottish elections is basically on a knife edge. Even if every single vote for the SNP was a vote to leave, that still wouldn't be a majority to leave. Elections aren't single issue votes, people will vote for the SNP even if they don't want to leave the UK.

DdraigGoch · 24/11/2022 15:34

chocolatemademefat · 24/11/2022 12:01

So much hate for Scotland on here. A lot of Scot’s want to stay in the union - and voted to do so last time. It’s sad that so many people find us a drain on the economy.

I don't see any "hate".

Unless you're using "hate" in its current parlance to mean "anything I disagree with".

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 14:22

DownNative · 24/11/2022 14:13

Why exactly are you hung up on the "voluntary" aspect when it comes to the UK yet say diddly squat when it's demonstrated this is exactly the same as in every country in Europe?

If you have a problem with one and not the other, that's called hypocrisy.

Captive?! Give your head a wobble! Westminster is the sovereign power and CAN say no forever if it wants to in the same way the USA, Germany, Spain and France have.

Yet the UK hasn't said that! It's merely said "now is not the time" which us highey reasonable!

USA, Germany, Spain and France do NOT go to that extent.

Given this and the fact there IS a mechanism, Scotland is so far from "captive" its not funny. Do you have a problem with the UK Government having total control over any border poll in Northern Ireland?!

You'd be wrong if you did.

Under international law, the UK and other sovereign states are entitled to full protection in law of territorial integrity. So, no, devolution is not pointless. It's the limit of self-determination Scotland et al is entitled to. The SNP should concentrate on running devolved affairs and not independence. Not pointless.

"A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another independence referendum." - Nicola Sturgeon

For someone who isn't bothered, you sure do post quite a bit on the issue!

No but i do think your completely OTT on this issue.. esp as the SC has decided and its highly unlikely there will be another vote this side 2050.

which is what i said a few pages back but still u go on....... and i agreed with you on "voluntary" but still you bang on ... & on...

As for Germany France Spain etc do these countries have sports teams representing their devolved regions... what was the score when Catalonia played Croatia in a WC qualifier?

Anyhow enjoy having another burst blood vessel, i'm out.

DownNative · 24/11/2022 14:13

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 13:55

So its not voluntary? again fair enough... i was under the impression it was, Scotland is captive, bound by Westminster, glad that is cleared up.

Seems that devolution is a complete and utter waste of time & money then... why have it? seems pointless and mechanism for trouble.

You seem particularly invested in Scotland remaining part of the Union, i'm not particularly bothered either way.. however, i do think that as Scotland continually votes SNP, they should have a means to leave, other than once in a life time.

Why exactly are you hung up on the "voluntary" aspect when it comes to the UK yet say diddly squat when it's demonstrated this is exactly the same as in every country in Europe?

If you have a problem with one and not the other, that's called hypocrisy.

Captive?! Give your head a wobble! Westminster is the sovereign power and CAN say no forever if it wants to in the same way the USA, Germany, Spain and France have.

Yet the UK hasn't said that! It's merely said "now is not the time" which us highey reasonable!

USA, Germany, Spain and France do NOT go to that extent.

Given this and the fact there IS a mechanism, Scotland is so far from "captive" its not funny. Do you have a problem with the UK Government having total control over any border poll in Northern Ireland?!

You'd be wrong if you did.

Under international law, the UK and other sovereign states are entitled to full protection in law of territorial integrity. So, no, devolution is not pointless. It's the limit of self-determination Scotland et al is entitled to. The SNP should concentrate on running devolved affairs and not independence. Not pointless.

"A vote for the SNP is not a vote for another independence referendum." - Nicola Sturgeon

For someone who isn't bothered, you sure do post quite a bit on the issue!

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 13:55

So its not voluntary? again fair enough... i was under the impression it was, Scotland is captive, bound by Westminster, glad that is cleared up.

Seems that devolution is a complete and utter waste of time & money then... why have it? seems pointless and mechanism for trouble.

You seem particularly invested in Scotland remaining part of the Union, i'm not particularly bothered either way.. however, i do think that as Scotland continually votes SNP, they should have a means to leave, other than once in a life time.

RunAwayTurnAwayRunAwayTurnAway · 24/11/2022 13:48

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

I don't give a shite about what Scotland do regarding independence, but fully agree Nicola Sturgeon is a huge, flapping disappointment with regards to womens' rights.

She could have been a major voice for women but has chosen to seek woke head pats instead. Traitor.

DownNative · 24/11/2022 13:42

Does NOT say that was meant in my first sentence above.

DownNative · 24/11/2022 13:41

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 13:04

@DownNative Don't dispute any of that but then can the UK Govt stop saying its a voluntary union of equals?

Because (as you so eloquently put it) clearly isn't.

Perhaps the mistake here was granting a ref in 2014.... another Cameron screw up.

Doesn't sound like a mechanism.... more an ad-hoc decision ...based on who happens to be in power and their "generosity"

Which Government said its voluntary?

International law as well as domestic certainly does say that.

The first article of the Treaty of Union reads:

"That the Two Kingdoms of Scotland and England, shall upon the 1st May next ensuing the date hereof, and forever after, be United into One Kingdom by the Name of Great Britain."

That applies to Northern Ireland as well. Exactly the same political reality as in every country in Europe, in fact!

The reason why the UK is a partnership of equals aka Union Of Equals is because every constituent citizen has one vote for one MP.

A citizen in London, Edinburgh, Cardiff and Belfast all have exactly one vote each which is the definition of equal.

If you're seriously suggesting that Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland should have exactly the same voting power as a bloc as England, well that would definitely be inequal. That's because the 15% bloc would have the same power as the 85% bloc. Its logically unequal.

That's why 1:1 is the definition of equal and why citizens in every part of the UK has the same number of votes to cast however they see fit. And this is very important because the UK is a UNITARY SOVEREIGN STATE! You, on the other hand, are talking as though each part of the UK is completely separate from each other. That's clearly false.

We have the same rights, same opportunities, same consular protection and, by and large, the same laws as each other. We even have the same Monarch. That's equal.

The equals in the union are the people and NOT the constituent parts we call England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. Each person in the U.K. has the same identical democratic power. No more, no less.

To claim anything else is to engage in distortion and aim to deliberately mislead the people.

We ARE a union of equals within a single UNITARY SOVEREIGN STATE known as the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

England, Scotland, Wales were all abolished as separate independent and sovereign countries.

And replaced with the United Kingdom of Great Britain. Northern Ireland came later.

Oh, and the UK does have a mechanism as seen in Scotland and Northern Ireland's Good Friday Agreement. The unitary sovereign state itself does NOT have to lay out the full criteria for secession either. This, too, is settled law....

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 13:04

@DownNative Don't dispute any of that but then can the UK Govt stop saying its a voluntary union of equals?

Because (as you so eloquently put it) clearly isn't.

Perhaps the mistake here was granting a ref in 2014.... another Cameron screw up.

Doesn't sound like a mechanism.... more an ad-hoc decision ...based on who happens to be in power and their "generosity"

DownNative · 24/11/2022 12:56

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 08:25

If nothing else, doing it this way would stop the constant SNP mithering and force them to get on with governing Scotland for the benefit of the people
PS. At the 2021 election the SNP/Greens got 49.25% and Labour/Tories/Libs got 50.75% of the constituency vote

Why doesn't this logic seem to work in Westminster?

Cameron got 37% of the pop. vote but that gave him the authority to have a referendum......

Bojo got 43% and that gave him the mandate to take the UK out of the EU with a terrible hard brexit.

Truss got none of the popular vote and added 30bn to the national debt......

Or do the rules get "adjusted" to suit?

You're not comparing like for like here in that Holyrood is NOT the sovereign power whereas Westminster actually is.

It is the uncodified UK constitution and settled international law that gives the UK Government the authority to do things such as legislate for a referendum on the EU, hold that referendum and even implement the result.

Westminster IS the Supreme Legislator and Authority in the UK. Just like in other countries because the UK is a unitary sovereign state.

The First Ministers are NOT equivalent to the Prime Minister.

You'll find the unitary sovereign states in Europe are even more prohibitive than the UK.

"In the Federal Republic of Germany, which is a nation-state based on the constituent power of the German people, states are not ‘masters of the constitution’.

Therefore there is no room under the constitution for individual states to attempt to secede. This violates the constitutional order.”

- Ruling from the Constitutional Court of the Federal Republic of Germany.

As it stands, the UK does provide for a mechanism for IndyRef2 as we saw in 2013. However, I'm in favour of and the UK is perfectly entitled to follow the German, Canadian, French, Spanish, etc, examples.

Yes, this is both legal and democratic.

MarshaBradyo · 24/11/2022 12:16

chocolatemademefat · 24/11/2022 12:01

So much hate for Scotland on here. A lot of Scot’s want to stay in the union - and voted to do so last time. It’s sad that so many people find us a drain on the economy.

I think it’s just economic facts rather than any dislike. Although I think we’re better staying together for various reasons - facing international threats and not being poorer overall the hate against England gets a bit wearing at times.

But in the spirit of being nice, I think good things about Scotland.Not the SNP though who is driving further division.

chocolatemademefat · 24/11/2022 12:01

So much hate for Scotland on here. A lot of Scot’s want to stay in the union - and voted to do so last time. It’s sad that so many people find us a drain on the economy.

Jaffacakeorisitabiscuit · 24/11/2022 11:55

The UK govt actually said now is not the time , not never. And tbh, that is probably correct - COVID and it's aftermath, cost of living crisis etc (and these issues apply to many countries around the world, not just the UK.)

Alexandra2001 · 24/11/2022 11:47

Scots voted to stay in the UK in 2014. There is no evidence that they have changed their minds since

Well, that still doesn't answer "how can Scotland leave, should it wish?"

There appears to be no mechanism, even the EU had a way of leaving.......

The UK Govt has made it very clear there will be no vote, ...regardless of polling or who Scotland elects.

Logically, that means its not "voluntary"

DdraigGoch · 24/11/2022 10:06

On Scotland and independence, its supposed to be a voluntary union.. yes? So by what means can Scotland leave?

Because as i understand it, the argument is "You ve had a vote, so you cannot have another one......" (i recently heard that 40 years is a suitable timescale, as thats the period between the UK's EU votes - from a Tory minister)

That doesn't seem "Voluntary" to me.

@Alexandra2001 Scots voted to stay in the UK in 2014. There is no evidence that they have changed their minds since.

DdraigGoch · 24/11/2022 10:02

FairyPrincess123 · 24/11/2022 07:49

The Lisbon Treaty was rejected for specific reasons, it went back to the EC and they rectified the problem and was put in front of the people again. It's almost a textbook definition of how democracy should work.

But then you knew that already didn't you?

Well the UK didn't even get a vote so democracy was clearly not functioning that well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread