Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To finally want Scotland to now LEAVE the UK

168 replies

Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 07:40

Am looking at this new gender bill being debated in Scotland in shock and horror. I just think it is a barbaric attack on women's safety and rights plus kids safeguarding. What on earth is happening Scotland?

Men being allowed to identify as women with no medical assessment and after only 3 months of ‘living as a woman’ - whatever that means. Wearing high heels and lipstick? Certainly they will still have their tackle intact.

Then being able to enter our changing rooms and bathrooms, take our company board places and sports prizes, skew the gender pay gap data and crime data, give intimate care to our vulnerable disabled daughters and elderly mothers. No surprise which type of men will be attracted using this new law to identify as women. Let me spell it out - the violent depraved ones who want to access women and girls.

And voted through yesterday - allowing convicted male rapists to identify as women and enter womens prisons.

And on top of all this - lowering the age of transition from 18 to 16… where is this age lowering coming from I wonder….surely not something more sinister…

To top of off Scotland has deliberately ignored the Cass Report and NHS England on safeguarding teenagers and so is carrying on giving vulnerable teenagers irreversible puberty blockers and breast binders behind parents backs.

And the icing on the cake - when a woman dares to speak out and wear a scarf with the colours of the suffragettes - she gets thrown out of parliament. I feel Scotland has gone back 100 years.

I am scared now this Scottish loophole in law will enter the UK as a whole.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 12:41

ResisterRex · 17/11/2022 12:37

There's been a concerted effort in parts of academia for years, to change our definition to a different one. I used to just think that was bonkers (as well as wrong) but now I think it's sinister and being pushed on purpose.

It's also unnecessary as if a woman does commit a crime it is the sexual offence of penetration by assault which has the same sentencing guidelines as the offence of rape.

lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 12:37

I dunno what the answer is, but there was once a time people were revolted at the thought of black people sharing the same space as them

I can't stop thinking about how racist I feel this is.

Imagine comparing the rights of males to consider themselves women, which is biologically completely impossible, with the right of a black person to be treated as equal.

ResisterRex · 17/11/2022 12:37

Daisychainsx · 17/11/2022 12:27

@ResisterRex fair enough. I suppose it depends where you are in the world.. www.justice.gov/archives/opa/blog/updated-definition-rape
Clearly I watch too much American TV.

But in the context of the UK I stand corrected!

There's been a concerted effort in parts of academia for years, to change our definition to a different one. I used to just think that was bonkers (as well as wrong) but now I think it's sinister and being pushed on purpose.

Daisychainsx · 17/11/2022 12:27

@ResisterRex fair enough. I suppose it depends where you are in the world.. www.justice.gov/archives/opa/blog/updated-definition-rape
Clearly I watch too much American TV.

But in the context of the UK I stand corrected!

lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 12:22

kittensinthekitchen · 17/11/2022 12:19

@maddy68

You missed my question.

She also failed to comment on the fact that women are being sexually assaulted in prisons transwomen and that Scotland has stated that it has no intention to place dangerous transwomen in separate units.

kittensinthekitchen · 17/11/2022 12:19

@maddy68

You missed my question.

Somanysocks · 17/11/2022 11:53

Unfortunately I'm not surprised that men would throw women and children under the bus but other women doing so is appalling, including some posters here, should be ashamed.

I'm becoming more terfy as the days roll by.

BrokeAsABone · 17/11/2022 11:48

Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:45

@Daisychainsx you can’t make a parallel here with black and white sharing spaces! The vast vast majority of violence is from men on women. 98% of it. It’s a completely different thing. Black people don’t have some kind of biological strength over white people. There was zero reason why they shouldn’t share spaces. This is very very different.

Ten years ago not one person had a problem with women having single sex spaces. Not one person! In fact, everyone knew it was entirely right and proper. Now because some loud, manipulative men decide they want access, people have lost their fucking minds and can't even appear to remember why we had them in the first place!

lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 11:48

I dunno what the answer is, but there was once a time people were revolted at the thought of black people sharing the same space as them and now we are horrified that humans could have been so cruel and closed minded, and I reckon in 50 years time people will probably look back on this and say the same thing... Society and the leaders of the world just need to do it in a way which allows everyone to feel respected.

Speechless.

There is NO comparison.

What society & women like Nicola Sturgeon is doing is respecting everyone except women. Welcome to the brave new world where everyone is respected so long as they are male.

It's mind blowing that you can't see this.

Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:45

@Daisychainsx you can’t make a parallel here with black and white sharing spaces! The vast vast majority of violence is from men on women. 98% of it. It’s a completely different thing. Black people don’t have some kind of biological strength over white people. There was zero reason why they shouldn’t share spaces. This is very very different.

OP posts:
BrokeAsABone · 17/11/2022 11:43

Please tell me I didn't read someone comparing prevention of men accessing spaces where women and girls are vulnerable and undressed, to segregation?

For goodness sake! Women and girls have been exploited and abused by men for millennia on the basis of our biology. That is why we NEED single sex spaces. To try to prevent, even in a little way, men exploiting and abusing us at times when we are most vulnerable!

Men will NEVER have our biology so they have absolutely no need of our spaces. They want in for awful, exploitative reasons - to intimidate, encroach, dominate and abuse - and it never fails to amaze that women are actually helping them!

NO. We say no and our no is not the starting point of negotiation.

ResisterRex · 17/11/2022 11:43

Let's not forget there are female rapists too

No. This is the Sexual Offences Act and what it says about rape. Women do not have penises so they cannot commit rape:

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/part/1/crossheading/rape

Sexual assault is different as it can be committed with an object:

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2003/42/part/1/crossheading/assault

Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:42

@CovertImage thing is. Scottish women keep voting this shitshow in. So yes it’s great to stand by women but not when they throw others eg the rest of the UK under a bus.

OP posts:
Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:40

@maddy68 thats great you feel safe and don’t mind if a boy takes your daughters sports prizes, board places and changes in front of her. But others do.

OP posts:
maddy68 · 17/11/2022 11:40

Daisychainsx · 17/11/2022 11:35

I'm scottish but don't live in Scotland and don't really keep up with politics at all. What is it, they're trying to pass a law that will make it OK to identify as whatever gender you like without medical assessment?

Don't people do that anyway?

Realistically, if someone wants to use a female/male changing room or toilet they're unlikely to be stopped. They certainly don't need to whip out a card that states whether they're medically xx or xy. Having a ♀️ sign on a door protects nobody from anything.

I do think women, especially young women just starting their periods etc, need a toilet space that is free from boys and men. But maybe in newbuilds we should just have individual changing rooms and toilet cubicles with no shared sink area and floor to ceiling doors, that can be used by anyone regardless of whether they identify as a man, woman or a mythical unicorn fairy.

Questionnaires and data collection forms could be adapted to ask 3 things 'sex at birth, current sex (ie has surgery happened), gender'.

Maybe there should be laws which state if you commit a crime that can only be committed by a man, such as rape with a penis, then you must serve any future time in a male prison regardless of gender identity. (Let's not forget there are female rapists too)

Instead of allowing trans athletes to blend in with single sex sports, celebrate them for being trans and have separate event for trans athletes at the Olympics or whatever.

Women should be celebrated for being women, men for being men, and trans women and men for being trans women and men.

I disagree with the changes in medical and scientific language such as erasing mother and replacing it for person with child or whatever it is... you can't change science. If you're a human carrying a fetus inside you then you're a mother.

I dunno what the answer is, but there was once a time people were revolted at the thought of black people sharing the same space as them and now we are horrified that humans could have been so cruel and closed minded, and I reckon in 50 years time people will probably look back on this and say the same thing... Society and the leaders of the world just need to do it in a way which allows everyone to feel respected.

This *

Daisychainsx · 17/11/2022 11:35

I'm scottish but don't live in Scotland and don't really keep up with politics at all. What is it, they're trying to pass a law that will make it OK to identify as whatever gender you like without medical assessment?

Don't people do that anyway?

Realistically, if someone wants to use a female/male changing room or toilet they're unlikely to be stopped. They certainly don't need to whip out a card that states whether they're medically xx or xy. Having a ♀️ sign on a door protects nobody from anything.

I do think women, especially young women just starting their periods etc, need a toilet space that is free from boys and men. But maybe in newbuilds we should just have individual changing rooms and toilet cubicles with no shared sink area and floor to ceiling doors, that can be used by anyone regardless of whether they identify as a man, woman or a mythical unicorn fairy.

Questionnaires and data collection forms could be adapted to ask 3 things 'sex at birth, current sex (ie has surgery happened), gender'.

Maybe there should be laws which state if you commit a crime that can only be committed by a man, such as rape with a penis, then you must serve any future time in a male prison regardless of gender identity. (Let's not forget there are female rapists too)

Instead of allowing trans athletes to blend in with single sex sports, celebrate them for being trans and have separate event for trans athletes at the Olympics or whatever.

Women should be celebrated for being women, men for being men, and trans women and men for being trans women and men.

I disagree with the changes in medical and scientific language such as erasing mother and replacing it for person with child or whatever it is... you can't change science. If you're a human carrying a fetus inside you then you're a mother.

I dunno what the answer is, but there was once a time people were revolted at the thought of black people sharing the same space as them and now we are horrified that humans could have been so cruel and closed minded, and I reckon in 50 years time people will probably look back on this and say the same thing... Society and the leaders of the world just need to do it in a way which allows everyone to feel respected.

BomboChipolata · 17/11/2022 11:35

I’m not firing any wrath at you, just shaking my head.

CovertImage · 17/11/2022 11:32

Flairmaine · 17/11/2022 08:14

I don't think Scotland leaving the UK is the answer. We need to stand in solidarity with Scotland and be glad they have different laws over there, as opposed to saying 'sorry Scottish women, you're on your own now'. I agree though, it's awful.

Totally agree. "Fuck off Scottish women" isn't very feminist, is it?

Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:31

They also don’t seem to have any care about democracy.

OP posts:
Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:30

@BomboChipolata and by the way yes women and girls safety IS important enough for more to cut loose on a country who’s ruling party (and my do they rule) is passing misogynistic laws. May not be so important to you but it is to me.

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 11:30

maddy68 · 17/11/2022 11:26

In prison anyone who self identified as a different sex to that of the prison would be segregated they would be classed as "vulnerable"

But that doesn't happen.

Karen White - www.theguardian.com/society/2018/oct/11/karen-white-how-manipulative-and-controlling-offender-attacked-again-transgender-prison This as actually in England not in Scotland.

And Scotland has REJECTED transgender wings in prisons.

www.heraldscotland.com/news/16861416.scottish-prison-service-rejects-call-transgender-wings-jails/

ResisterRex · 17/11/2022 11:28

Zosime · 17/11/2022 11:17

They have passed good laws such as free bus travel for under 22s and free Uni tuition

Free to users, but someone somewhere is paying for them.

Exactly. And someone somewhere will be paying for the compensation inevitably owed to the women raped by males in prison and other spaces, as well as the children mutilated and harmed by the fast tracking to irreversible AND TOTALLY AVOIDABLE damage being pushed.

maddy68 · 17/11/2022 11:26

lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 11:25

Personally I could give a flying fuck how anyone dresses or feels and there should be safe spaces for all

Accept women, women don't need safe spaces even in prison?

Merely wanting them is transphobic.

In prison anyone who self identified as a different sex to that of the prison would be segregated they would be classed as "vulnerable"

Ndd135632 · 17/11/2022 11:26

@BomboChipolata I would fire your wrath in the direction of the SNP and the Green Party making these harmful laws rather than me

OP posts:
lifeturnsonadime · 17/11/2022 11:25

Sorry that should have said EXCEPT women.

Swipe left for the next trending thread