Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still buy clothes from charity shops?

154 replies

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2022 07:37

Been discussed on MN before but would appreciate some help getting my head around a heated debate last night.

I’ve bought clothes from charity shops ever since I started work over 30 years ago. Couldn’t afford a full work wardrobe, discovered charity shops and never looked back.
I am now financially very comfortable. I still browse the charity shops, and still buy from there If I see something that looks like new that I really like. I also buy books and other things eg an old fashioned trifle bowl and some unusual vases.
Somehow the conversation came round to charity shops at my book club last night. I know from previous discussions that most of them wouldn’t dream of buying second hand clothes. A few of us do - the need to spend money wisely never leaves you and I’ll admit to loving the thrill of finding a bargain.
So we revisited that old discussion but with the added very vocal suggestion that it is incredibly wrong of us to continue buying clothes from charity shops in the current economic climate, as we are taking away the opportunity for people struggling financially to buy those clothes.
I was taken aback at the strength of feeling about this, quite vitriolic.
I’d accept it more if we were rinsing the shops and if the shops were short of stock. But between us I think we had bought 10 items this year; we have at least 7 charity shops in our small town centre (all well stocked) and the next town similar.
While I appreciate the charity benefits whoever buys from them, I am now conflicted. I honestly can’t see that buying a few bits from a charity shop is taking stuff away from those that need it (on the basis that there is plenty of stock in the shops, of which there are many). On the other hand maybe they have a valid point. But then if those clothes didn’t get bought the charity would lose out.
I’ve been going round and round on this since I woke up, hence posting. Re-reading this it does sound like I am making something out of nothing but the accusations became quite unpleasant, and I found myself unusually shaken by them so am just trying to process it.
Thank you for reading, sorry it got so long!

OP posts:
FloorWipes · 17/11/2022 08:35

I think if you’re in a relatively good financial position then you’re likely the kind who every time they buy something, they’re also donating a few “quality” items - not donating primark or selling them on eBay.

There is nothing wrong with donating Primark clothes to a charity shop. Some of the are good quality - I had a fantastic cotton dress for years that I think I must have donated in the end - and I’ve more recently bought a great Primark top from the charity shop. It’s made of a sort of viscose that really maintains its feel and appearance.

There also isn’t anything wrong with selling on eBay/Vinted, which I also do. It wouldn’t be fair to say that I’m poor but I can certainly use the money. It supports the circular economy. People make money in far less moral ways than that through their regular work a lot of the time.

I also donate to charity and work on behalf of charity in a number of ways.

I know of a person who actually buys things from charity shops and sells them on on eBay in a curated way adding value. I can see this being more controversial but he is open about what he does, gives a further cut to charity seems to have a good relationship with the local shops as he is one of their best customers! If he didn’t do this, the shop still probably wouldn’t be able to do it. Some try - I have experience it and I used to volunteer as an Oxfam online lister but it wasn’t especially successful so there’s a balance to be had between that and just bulk selling as much as possible at a lower price.

downanduppy · 17/11/2022 08:34

charity shops near us sell Primark T-shirts for £3 so they are struggling but that’s their issue to fix. Two charity shops I’ve visited this week have had signs up saying no to donations as their stock was full so there’s plenty to go round.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2022 08:30

SheWoreARaspberryBeret123 · 17/11/2022 08:22

Why are you even asking?!

Because I could partly see their point, and my thoughts kept going round in circles on it.

OP posts:
HenBob · 17/11/2022 08:30

Gosh your friends... Actually getting mixed up between a charity shop and a clothes bank. Never heard of anything so stuck up, and the fact they were being vitriolic about it just shows that they are angry with you for doing it as they feel it's beneath them, not because of any other reason.

Keep supporting these worthwhile shops. Retail is a difficult time right now and as you say, you don't buy loads a year anyway - that's because you can go every week and not find something that fits or suits you. Unless there is another person in your town that is exactly the same taste and size as you , but very poor, it's unlikely you are taking from anyone. That would make a great film 🤣

dottiedodah · 17/11/2022 08:29

I would keep shopping. Just yesterday I got a lovely glass fruit bowl from the charity shop for 2.50.amazing .lots on w bay with huge postal fees. I love a bargain and there is no guarantee that people on benefits will buy these clothes. Also recycling better for environment.

BlueWalnut · 17/11/2022 08:29

Maybe suggest a clothes swap to your group if they want to refresh their wardrobes for free. Some people love a bargain and are angry because charity shopping was a cheap hobby that is moving out of reach, rather than being about putting essential clothes on their backs.

Another perspective is that most of us have enough clothes. A friend recently returned from long term back packing. She owns just three outfits, a swimsuit and a winter coat, which she insists is enough. I need a few more items because clothes take longer to launder in winter without using a tumble dryer, but I think she’s right that it’s surprising how little you need.

Comedycook · 17/11/2022 08:29

HeraldicBlazoning · 17/11/2022 08:25

Charity shops seem to be run like a business,

As opposed to being run like a.... farm? circus? cafe?

As in they seem to exist to purely make a profit...which is fine and the point of them. I just mean the charitable element does not seem to extend to potential customers. Charity shops could have a two fold element whereby they make money for the charity but also help poorer people in the local community afford goods, but it appears to be solely about profit.

MissBattleaxe · 17/11/2022 08:26

Your friends are wrong to buy brand new every time. It's bad for the planet. I use charity shops as a kind of clothes library. I buy something, if I get bored of it and it's still in good shape I give it back and buy something else. It's much less wasteful than cheap, mass produced stuff that just gets binned after a few wears. Your friends are wrong. Income doesn't matter one bit.

HeraldicBlazoning · 17/11/2022 08:25

Charity shops seem to be run like a business,

As opposed to being run like a.... farm? circus? cafe?

Comedycook · 17/11/2022 08:24

Charity shops aren't for poor people. They're for middle class people who want the thrill of a bargain. Charity shops seem to be run like a business, not a way to help individuals buy cheap goods. Primark and other cheap shops are usually cheaper than charity shops anyway. Shop where you want

SheWoreARaspberryBeret123 · 17/11/2022 08:22

Why are you even asking?!

WonderingWanda · 17/11/2022 08:21

Ignore them, ethically it is wrong not to buy second hand due to the climate crisis and carbon footprint of all the humans on our planet. There's plenty to go around, you can't move for people giving stuff away on Facebook around here.

dizzydizzydizzy · 17/11/2022 08:21

Your friends are bonkers! Just keep doing what you're doing and ignore them .

whatwasIgoingtosay · 17/11/2022 08:20

This is why I don't belong to a book club.

FloorWipes · 17/11/2022 08:18

@HeraldicBlazoning yes perhaps it is that!

HeraldicBlazoning · 17/11/2022 08:16

FloorWipes · 17/11/2022 08:07

Your friends are wrong and I think quite out of touch but I’m pretty curious about where their vitriol is actually coming from and if they are upset or jealous about something else.

I wouldn't read it as vitriol tbh.

There are a lot of people who are deeply uncomfortable with second-hand and struggle to articulate exactly why. We're all told we should be reusing, recycling and people who struggle with that concept and would deep down prefer everything brand new latch onto the "leave it for people who are more deserving" as a get-out clause.

PermanentTemporary · 17/11/2022 08:15

I do find that discussion at my book club can escalate unexpectedly because we all drink there - could that have been a factor?

There is a huge unspoken class/cultural divide on second hand clothing in the UK if you live here and it can bring out odd views. I love a charity shop, mainly because of the unexpected nature of what you can find, but also it makes me feel virtuous- when in fact you could argue it's better to support high street shops and jobs ( i don't argue this, just saying there's more than one way to look at it).

Starlightstarbright1 · 17/11/2022 08:14

romdowa · 17/11/2022 07:58

With some of the pricing in charity shops these days , the less well off can't afford to shop in charity shops . Our local ones are extortionate. Definite cheaper to shop in primark etc

This i my opinion too.

Years ago charity shops were cheap clothing. Samecas jumble sales were great for bargain clothing Primark is cheaper than most local charities

twentytwentythree · 17/11/2022 08:14

Your friends are wrong. You're helping the circular economy, and helping a charity. People buying new clothes should feel more guilty as the impact on the environment is horrendous. They shouldn't be trying to shame you like this.

Soffana · 17/11/2022 08:12

Usually charity shops get's more clothes donated than they can actually sell. I remember one shop had such a big problem that they filled a room with clothes they just wanted to get rid of and you could buy it per kg.

So buy buy buy! I think you don't have to donate to buy.

BiscuitLover3678 · 17/11/2022 08:11

These ‘friends’ are being stupid because they want an excuse to buy new clothes 😂

BiscuitLover3678 · 17/11/2022 08:10

Oh ffs this kind of snobbery would actually make me leave the book club 😂

of course you should still buy from charity shops!! It reuses clothes which is way better for the environment and reduces landfill, gives money to the shop which gives to a charity and saves you money which you are entitled to do. I’ve worked in charity shops they often have TOO MUCH and throw stuff away. Definitely keep buying from them and keep them open!!

SirMingeALot · 17/11/2022 08:09

People are making good points that there's hardly a shortage of second hand clothes!

Lcb123 · 17/11/2022 08:08

I’ve never even thought about your friends opinion. I buy almost all my clothes second hand (charity shop, Vinted, eBay), I probably could afford new but I’d have to buy cheaper brands so would rather look for quality brands second hand, this is from an environmental perspective as well. There are so many clothes in our local charity shops, there’s plenty to go around. They exist to fundraise and in fact some of their prices you might find cheaper in primark

FloorWipes · 17/11/2022 08:07

Your friends are wrong and I think quite out of touch but I’m pretty curious about where their vitriol is actually coming from and if they are upset or jealous about something else.