Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To still buy clothes from charity shops?

154 replies

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2022 07:37

Been discussed on MN before but would appreciate some help getting my head around a heated debate last night.

I’ve bought clothes from charity shops ever since I started work over 30 years ago. Couldn’t afford a full work wardrobe, discovered charity shops and never looked back.
I am now financially very comfortable. I still browse the charity shops, and still buy from there If I see something that looks like new that I really like. I also buy books and other things eg an old fashioned trifle bowl and some unusual vases.
Somehow the conversation came round to charity shops at my book club last night. I know from previous discussions that most of them wouldn’t dream of buying second hand clothes. A few of us do - the need to spend money wisely never leaves you and I’ll admit to loving the thrill of finding a bargain.
So we revisited that old discussion but with the added very vocal suggestion that it is incredibly wrong of us to continue buying clothes from charity shops in the current economic climate, as we are taking away the opportunity for people struggling financially to buy those clothes.
I was taken aback at the strength of feeling about this, quite vitriolic.
I’d accept it more if we were rinsing the shops and if the shops were short of stock. But between us I think we had bought 10 items this year; we have at least 7 charity shops in our small town centre (all well stocked) and the next town similar.
While I appreciate the charity benefits whoever buys from them, I am now conflicted. I honestly can’t see that buying a few bits from a charity shop is taking stuff away from those that need it (on the basis that there is plenty of stock in the shops, of which there are many). On the other hand maybe they have a valid point. But then if those clothes didn’t get bought the charity would lose out.
I’ve been going round and round on this since I woke up, hence posting. Re-reading this it does sound like I am making something out of nothing but the accusations became quite unpleasant, and I found myself unusually shaken by them so am just trying to process it.
Thank you for reading, sorry it got so long!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
PinkSyCo · 19/11/2022 00:27

You can afford to buy clothes from the charity shop? Stealth boast.

xsquared · 18/11/2022 22:01

Yes, you should keep shopping in charity shops a d buying second hand where possible.

Better for the charity and better the environment.

Charity shops don't exist for those who can't afford brand new.

Bettybooboo13 · 18/11/2022 20:14

As someone on a very limited budget I’ve always shopped second hand and always will. I would much rather buy a better quality second hand item than something from say primark that 5000 people also have. Keep shopping in charity shops. Even a lot of their stuff ends up in landfill. If we can reduce this then job well done.

JoelyJoe · 18/11/2022 20:11

I love shopping in charity shops... you never know what you'll find, and you can't beat the thrill of finding a label you can't normally afford. I also but things like wine glasses as I'm a bit clumsy and keep breaking them, and I have a huge stack of white china charity shop plates that I bring out at parties! With clothes I have a personal "rule" that I'm not allowed to buy a brand I can easily afford new - like F&F or Tu for example.. however this is just to stop myself buying piles of tat, rather than for social reasons.
As many others have posted, the point of charity shops are to raise money for the charity. The ones I go to are always rammed with stock, and sometimes have signs asking people not to leave donations, so I hardly think I am taking from others. I also donate used clothes, especially children's wear.
Plus there is the reduction of wastage inherent in charity shopping. I think those who object so strongly are just trying to show their own positions as "caring, socially aware individuals", and trumpeting it to all. Is this what is called "Virtue Signalling"? I'm not 100% sure it's the right terminology!!

Sennelier1 · 18/11/2022 17:34

Charity shops have and always will have a few more expensive items that would never be bought by those in need. On the other hand the shops need the income from selling the better pieces. So yes, do continue to buy those items from your local charities. We (my husband and I) are comfortable, just like you and just like many people, not rich but doing fine. Doesn't mean you have to buy everything new! I still like to browse and buy secondhand!

RudsyFarmer · 18/11/2022 17:30

It’s just more virtue signalling bullshit. You are entitled to shop anywhere that accepts your money. Just stop talking about it and then you won’t hear the words of idiots.

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 18/11/2022 17:27

Thank you everyone, I feel much better about it now.

OP posts:
N84 · 18/11/2022 17:17

As someone who has worked in sustainability for the last couple of decades, please please continue to buy secondhand goods. The planet simply cannot support our rate of consumption. Plus, charity shops are often over stocked, and a lot of goods get sent to to the global south, and impede their economies. Ignore those who tell you otherwise!

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 18/11/2022 16:59

You're right of course - I just meant donate if you can, rather than chuck stuff out.

VollywoodHampires · 18/11/2022 16:27

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 17/11/2022 07:44

I regularly shop in charity shops, and I regularly donate to them. I can afford to buy new but it's more environmentally friendly, plus I can put together a more unique style that way.

I think as long as you donate (decent quality) items as well, it's fine.

Absolutely no need to donate. Just buy what you need or want OP.

StarlightLady · 18/11/2022 16:21

As others have said, the whole point of charity shops is to support the named charity, not to provide charity to those buying, although hopefully they will get a bargain too.

Buying from these shops is also more sustainable. You carry on OP.

slashlover · 18/11/2022 15:57

anon2022anon · 18/11/2022 07:12

@CakeCrumbs44 but if it's not selling quickly, it's costing you in space and time. Pricing say a Debenhams jumper at £10 might mean it's left there for a month or two, til the right buyer comes along. Pricing it at £5 might mean it goes in a week, as does the item you're replacing it with, and everything else henceforth. Also, I don't tend to try on in the shop, so at £8 I'll take a chance on a dress, and donate it again if it doesn't fit. At £17, which is about the difference in price between a couple of the shops, I won't bother taking the risk.

We have several charity shops in the local town. The YMCA prices competitively (this week we paid £6 for trainers, £4 for a Jaeger sweatshirt). As a result, this is the one that I go to, if I've only got time for a quick look. It's the one I've taken my teenage daughter to, and then she's gone with her friends. It's the one I drop stuff at myself, and I reckon that's true of a few more people my age, as the brands I've got from there have been upper high street brands, rather than the boohoo/ Asda/ new look that the other shops down the street seem to get.

We know the local area and what prices things will sell for. So we know that leading up to Christmas, we might get £10 for that Debenhams jumper (although it would depend on several factors - some sizes sell better, if it has tags etc.) but come July it might be priced at £2.

barskits · 18/11/2022 14:42

RockingMyFiftiesNot · 17/11/2022 08:30

Because I could partly see their point, and my thoughts kept going round in circles on it.

Charity shops aren't like jumble sales where everything is 10p-50p, they are no cheaper than Primark for basic clothing; and places like Lidl and Aldi sell budget clothes as well. You are not depriving a poor person from being able to clothe themselves, and your book club friends are being ludicrous for suggesting it.

It's far more likely that they wouldn't dream of buying anything from a charity shop themselves, and look down their noses at the people who do. But of course they can't say that to your face, so they have trumped up this idea instead.

LieInsAreExtinct · 18/11/2022 14:28

The comments are coming from those who don't get it at all! They're not like food banks, some of the clothes are quite expensive, especially smart work and designer wear. (Some too expensive for me, for things I would like, but don't really need)
I have rarely bought new for myself myself, or my children when they were young. I donate just as much as I buy too. Keep going, OP!

SafferUpNorth · 18/11/2022 13:52

I reckon your sanctimonious book club pals are simply casting around for a justification as to why they're still buying exclusively new.

HeraldicBlazoning · 18/11/2022 13:42

They never were "for the poor". 🙄

orbitalcrisis · 18/11/2022 13:26

I rarely buy from charity shops, they're too expensive. You can buy new clothes for cheaper in the sales or online. A friend who volunteers in a charity shop says their stock is now priced for middle class customers who want to feel they're doing their bit for charity. They're no longer for the poor to get cheap items.

uncomfortablydumb53 · 18/11/2022 13:17

I buy most of my clothes from charity shop/ eBay/ Vinted for environmental and budgetary reasons.
Charity shops are for everyone who has time to go in
They don't means test at the door!
Perhaps your friends are jealous of your bargains and wouldn't use one as they are snobs!
Their loss, and the environments loss too

Stravaig · 18/11/2022 13:13

Your greater contribution is in donating high quality clothing in good condition for the charity to sell to others. Only those with money and spare resources can do this, whereas anyone can buy.

So if you want to lean on 'supporting the charity' as a justification, then donations are by far the most effective way for someone in your position.

BruceWaynettaSlob · 18/11/2022 13:05

IglesiasPiggl · 17/11/2022 07:48

Sounds like they are hiding behind being offended on the behalf of others to justify the fact that they think they are above buying in charity shops. I bet lots of people who they think "should" shop in charity shops don't actually want to. Crack on - it's better for the environment and raises money for the charity.

This. It sounds like their virtue-signalling is just a cover for their snobbery.

Featheryboa · 18/11/2022 13:04

I buy from charity shops. Currently wearing a nice warm jumper from a chazza.

A couple of work colleagues have looked at me as though I've sprouted an extra head, after learning that I bought clothes from charity shops. Presumably because they think I'm well off enough to buy everything new (I am). I don't care , I enjoy seeking things out.

Changeismine · 18/11/2022 13:03

I shop in charity shops because I like the idea of re-using/re-gifting/recycling and less waste. I recently bought a beautiful, ornate, velvet box just because it is the perfect gift for a colleague - nothing to do with clothes! I don't 'need' to buy in charity shops but I do 'need' to set an example to my children and they see shopping in charity shops and second-hand goods as the best option! Success!

MangoBiscuit · 18/11/2022 13:03

I think your friends are being ridiculous.

Firstly there's no guarantee that anyone else would buy the items you did. Which would leave the charity short, and the item would be wasted, so worse for the environment too.

Secondly, the charity is going to need the extra support given the current climate. Some who donate regularly will have had to cut back on that.

All the shops local to me seem to be full to the brim, and there's always new stock. I very much doubt you're leaving the shelves bare for anyone, and you say you've donated clothes too.

Please keep on as you are, and keep supporting your local charity shops. If you feel at all uncomfortable about it, then add an extra donation when you pay.

BruceWaynettaSlob · 18/11/2022 13:02

People struggling financially can't afford to shop in most charity shops. Your friends need to get out of their privileged little bubble and learn about the real world and be less sanctimonious and insufferable.

Casperroonie · 18/11/2022 12:57

This sounds like a GREAT opportunity for reading up on the benefits of reusing and recycling.....🤭 I'm sure there are lots of books out there on this topic.