Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that austerity will hit the south the hardest this time ?

133 replies

Effiebriest · 16/11/2022 22:28

Most research suggests that the North and its cities were hit the worst by austerity.
www.theguardian.com/society/2019/jan/28/deprived-northern-regions-worst-hit-by-uk-austerity-study-finds
www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/north-south-divide-tory-austerity-conservatives-government-cameron-recession-a8667666.html
www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/austerity-cuts-twice-as-deep-in-england-as-rest-of-britain
www.localgov.co.uk/Englands-poorest-areas-hit-hardest-by-austerity/54120
Looking at my local town there is nothing left to cut. Anecdotal maybe but we lost 5 out of 15 libraries during austerity, well used ones as we are a fairly deprived town and not everyone has access to PCs. Last year our council was due to make £35 million pounds in cuts with the loss of a hundred jobs. Austerity never stopped but
apparently it's starting all over again. I really cannot comprehend how yet more services in our delapidated little town can be cut. Anyone think that Sunak and Hunt will have to move on to the more prosperous home counties as many places up here have already been squeezed financially dry and just don't have the same resilience.

OP posts:
blanketseverywhere · 17/11/2022 11:03

bubblicious3 · 17/11/2022 06:59

Er Croydon council is bankrupt. Croydon town centre is filthy, full of boarded up shops and knife crime. Not exactly awash with public funds. And this is not only South, but Greater London. Everywhere is suffering to a degree.

I grew up in Croydon and then moved to Thanet. Both areas have lovely 'pockets' within them, but overall the levels of poverty, neglect and deprivation are eye-watering. Thanet is one of the poorest areas of the whole country, and it shows.

Generalisations about the north/south divide are unhelpful and just do this fucking govts shameful, divisive work for them. The truth is that they don't give a toss about any of us.

Dggrs45 · 17/11/2022 10:56

The reality is that austerity, inflation and rising energy prices hit poor people - all across the country. In London and parts of South East this is in part visually masked by having some rich people going to nice expensive restaurants. But thats private cash being spent by rich people on other rich people's things - the poor are cut out of it whether they live in London or the North of England.

TitsInAbsentia · 17/11/2022 10:48

I live within the M25, the streets aren't paved with gold, if you think austerity isn't already here then you are wrong. Yes there are pockets of wealth as elsewhere in the country but in many boroughs the child poverty level is way above the average, so if the children are in poverty what do you think the parents are in? citymonitor.ai/economy/poverty/uk-census-tower-hamlets-has-the-worst-child-poverty-rates-in-the-uk

slowquickstep · 17/11/2022 10:26

There is London then the rest of the U.K. Every area has the rich, the doing ok and the struggling. Although London has many deprived areas, as a whole more money is thrown at London, the rest of us get chicken feed.

Effiebriest · 17/11/2022 10:17

@Itsokay2020 move up north then ? But not to Harrogate or Ilkley but to Rochdale or Oldham. Prices are great there.

OP posts:
rrrrrreatt · 17/11/2022 10:11

The people making policy decisions around austerity cuts don’t care about the north/south divide. It’s numbers on a sheet to them and the reality of deprived areas anywhere in the UK is often far removed from their own lives.

Cuts hit deprived areas the hardest because they can’t generate much revenue in other ways and there’s more demand for services. There was also more services (Surestart centres, etc) to cut in deprived areas when austerity started. The North has more deprived areas so the North is hardest hit but it’s not a targeted conscious decision to protect the south.

Alexandra2001 · 17/11/2022 10:10

The Tories will fuck over everyone... look we are ALL going to pay almost 2k extra for energy next year than last year.

More Council Tax, lower wage rises, higher inflation will hit all struggling families

They could put in more CT bands so expensive properties pay more, a dividend tax, wealth taxes on billionaires and multi millionaires.
Nationalise UK energy production so we control the price of energy produced here... if they wont do that, targeted energy support & tier it too.... Sunak will pay the same for his energy (per unit) as a nurse... How is that right????

What we will see today is a political farce, deferring the big cuts until after the GE.. making it (probably) Labours problem (as they did in 1990s)

Its not being done to help the UK but to help the Tory party.... yet again.

Dggrs45 · 17/11/2022 10:07

As others have said, I think the reality is that anything to do with the state has been decimated everywhere - the difference is whether you have sufficient amount of private money to make things look ok ish or a wealthy enough local population to subsidize. In London - yes, we have transport but inflation/rent increases is really hitting public sector jobs and anything connected with the state. I havent seen any council run leisure centers in years. Local libraries are volunteer run. Schools and gp surgeries are really hit with recruitment - schools are struggling to even recruit headteachers. So you get stark differences between state schools in wealthy areas where parents can fundraise for stuff or give their time to do stuff. But soon there wont be any policeman, teacher, nurse, retail workers left in lots of areas of London. So this recession is hitting people in different ways but it's bad all over.

Yes, London has well paid jobs but thats not the majority. If you work in any public sector, retail etc etc job - your life is miserable. Fine you can go to a museum - but you will pay 2k for a tiny flat for your two kids indefinitely. Their school will have a shortage of teachers, your gp surgery will have a shortage of doctors, the streets are not being cleaned or repaired all over. My friends who live up North in public sector jobs are doing much much better than us.

The decimation of the state has touch all areas but in subtly different ways.It is scary. The UK is now and has been for over a decade quite a poor place and only getting worse.

Itsokay2020 · 17/11/2022 10:01

I live within 50 miles of London (albeit outside of the M25) and the notion that the south have it better than the north is utter tosh! Our roads are in an appalling state, local hospitals can’t cope with demand so invariably you’re treated elsewhere. Many empty shops and units, homelessness, deprivation, much reduced bus services, library closures and so on.

Yet, a new build three bedroom semi-detached house has just sold for £450k in my village. It may be a prime commuter area, but an annual season ticket is £4,480 to Liverpool Street, but you’d also need to add on parking fees/bus fares too.

My relatives, who live in the north west, could not believe that we pay £16.50 to have 10 windows/doors cleaned every four weeks by our window cleaner - and that’s cheap, one quoted £24. I’m all for levelling up if I can pay northern prices down south!!

Effiebriest · 17/11/2022 09:54

Above link is in Basingstoke apparently.

OP posts:
Effiebriest · 17/11/2022 09:53

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/video/2022/oct/26/how-deep-in-crisis-is-britain-this-tory-heartland-knows-the-answer-video
Actually this pretty much says what plenty on here have said. But sadly despite this I suspect they'll continue to vote the same way or not at all.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 09:52

I am now in Scotland. I used to live in the Midlands. The government had been promising to improve public transport there for years. It still has not happened.

Effiebriest · 17/11/2022 09:47

@JassyRadlett agree. The level of investment up here is abysmal (although we have plenty of NMW jobs working in Amazon warehouses with literally hundreds of applicants).
There 's a great series (Vlog?) by John Harris and John Domokos 'Anywhere but Westminster'. Eye opening and admittedly not northern centric in it's tales of the UKs decline.
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/video/2021/jun/25/anywhere-but-westminster-10-years-in-10-minutes-video

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 17/11/2022 09:27

Tiredalwaystired · 17/11/2022 07:33

London doesn’t vote Tory. It’s predominantly red.

Good point

PeeJayDay · 17/11/2022 09:26

"How many shops there are and restaurants and how they appear is nothing to do with austerity cuts or councils, they are private businesses"

😂 I don't know where to start with that one.

oakleaffy · 17/11/2022 09:24

Phrenologistsfinger · 17/11/2022 00:30

The south is not a homogenous rich people zone, it houses massive areas of deprivation too. The contrasts may be more stark which causes its own issues.

Absolutely.
Notting Hill. West London.
Extraordinary wealth a few metres from deprivation.

Meadowbreeze · 17/11/2022 09:12

@JassyRadlett exactly, well explained. 👏👏👏

JassyRadlett · 17/11/2022 09:09

I think you've got it a bit backwards, OP, though the impact is the same.

It's not that the cuts are actually targeted so much at the north as a whole (though there has definitely been some nakedly political shifting of funds). It's as much that some places are less prosperous already, with less private sector employment and therefore more reliant on public sector employment, so when public sector cuts happen the impact on the local economy is much greater. And so the shops and restaurants close, etc.

Until we tackle our woeful productivity performance outside London and pockets of the SE (by no means all of it) the pattern will continue. I saw a horrifying study recently that looked at productivity in European cities - while London's per worker output is near the top, all of our other big cities' productivity are way below average. That then hits satellite towns and rural areas.

That's not saying the people in Leeds, Sheffield, Bristol, Newscastle etc don't work hard. They do. But there is a huge and chronic lack of business and industrial investment in those places that would raise output. And that's not just about straight government spending, it's about our total lack of any kind of industrial strategy, proper long term plans to support and build strategically important industries (look at the semi-conductor issue and how the Dutch had a long term strategy, and saw it through even though they were losing money in the short term, now they're raking in the cash, employing huge numbers, exporting everywhere and paying lots of tax), proper investment in skills and automation. And yes there are spending elements to that but much more important is how that spending is targeted and sticking to a long term plan.

We are at the natural result of a dedication to the wisdom of markets and free market economics. Markets turn out to be dreadful at building and supporting thriving communities. They're not always right. But unfortunately nearly 30 of the last 43 years, we've been run by people who have blind faith and devotion to markets over economic planning, and its led to concentrations of productivity and prosperity, and screw the rest.

Meadowbreeze · 17/11/2022 09:02

@ScentOfSawdust I agree with you on the transport end. The lack of investment up north is criminal. London has so far managed to protect the u18s free travel but it's likely not going to go on much longer. As for it being affordable for the rest, surely you're joking. Aside from a few cheap super off peak tickets, most people can't afford train travel down here. People working NMW jobs in the city can't afford the tube. So many people in our community spend hours in traffic on busses just to save a few pounds.
I live in a very close community. So many families are moving up north. 3 have moved to Doncaster. I've visited it. Their quality of life has improved massively. They all work in supermarkets, AO/EO level civil service or TA type jobs. They no longer live in bedsits, can afford to go on days out with their families. Their kids have finally got braces after waiting 3 years in london. As for how run down it is, it's no different to our part of London.
It is a sad situation everywhere.
And a lot of the points being made about access are rural or small town areas. The same lack of facilities exists in the south east.

Justthisonce12 · 17/11/2022 08:51

So having read all about how shit it is up north and how shit it is down south I was just wondering what anybody was planning to do about it ?

Letsgetreadytoblackcurrantcrumble · 17/11/2022 08:51

Scotland here. I hear moaning that the higher rate (40% in rUK) income tax band is due to be frozen at £50,271, dragging more into the higher rate band. I empathise but would like to point out that the higher rate income tax band here was frozen here many moons ago. We pay 41% on earnings over £43,662. For worse services and a government systematically destroying woman’s rights. Allowed to do this as they make up all sorts of unicorn nonsense about independence and the thick-as-mince-gullible believe it and vote SNP. Its shite.

ScentOfSawdust · 17/11/2022 08:38

Agree with all those saying it’s a London v the rest of the UK issue. And yes, of course there are people living in desperate poverty in London, but that’s got nothing to do with the amount of funding received.

I live in London with close connections to the rural SE and it is a hell of a lot easier to be poor here; free public transport for under-18s, good, cheap public transport for the rest of us. Better schools, more hospitals and other health facilities, easier access to cheap food, free museums…. And don’t get me started on the inequality in rail funding between London and the North. It’s an absolute disgrace.

But YABU, OP, in expecting anything to change.

Meadowbreeze · 17/11/2022 08:36

@WrongWayApricot It seems the only businesses in our borough that can afford the retail rent are casinos in the poor areas and estate agents in the rich ones. Otherwise it's all boarded up shops, a chicken shop here and there and an off-licence.
@FancyFanny we did this in my London borough. Yes London. Had to call it guerilla gardening so we don't all fall into a depression over where our massive council taxes go. Our library is open 2 hours a day but that's only because it's fully self service and the building is open for the council customer service. 2 hours a day you've got if you need to sort anything out. Nothing running in the children's library anymore.

Dragonsgreen · 17/11/2022 08:31

FancyFanny · 17/11/2022 07:26

I am in a small Yorkshire borough. This summer residents had to clear the paths and trim the overgrown weeds, the grass verges and remove the leaves from the streets themselves so that we could walk properly to our houses. The swimming pool has been closed since 2020, the leisure centre is closed with a view to redeveloping it and that project has now been shelved indefinitely, the local library is closed. When questioned the council say all money is spent on social care. I don't know where any more cuts can be made.

We do this in my small town in the South East!

WrongWayApricot · 17/11/2022 08:30

I'm sure there are very clear examples of how the North have it much worse, but libraries? We've had loads of libraries and leisure centres closed down. Some were able to turn into community volunteer libraries and some like self service. But I don't think libraries are a good example, definitely not 10 libraries in my area, not that we ever had 15 to begin with.

We have huge divide from street to street. Now people on rich streets get to increase their house prices and health through LTNs. Meanwhile, on the poorer streets house prices drop and children get ill because of concentrated fumes. All made by our wonderful council. They say to use the great public transport instead of drive but the buses get cancelled in grid lock.

We go to a school further away because there are so many shootings and so much gang crime in our area. Police station after police station is shut down and left as an empty boarded up building.

Rent for commercial property is staggeringly high meaning we can only have high streets either full of big business chains or a constant turn over of pop up shops.

I imagine people think we all live in the glittering glass towers near the river. The majority of us don't.