Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel deep guilt?

28 replies

Rainfull091 · 16/11/2022 22:19

My neighbour had a cat who was an absolute darling. For 10 years she has come to visit me and has become a rock in many ways especially as I have been through such a tough patch over the past few years. The other neighbours all adored the cat also but she used to come to me all the time and of course I got incredibly attached. I don't think my neighbour liked that she did that and he always seemed a bit off with me when I texted concerns about the cat such as it came round with a limp one time so I sent a text just saying that I'm sure he already knew but the cat was limping. As I said, the responses when I texted on these rare occasions either seemed to be a bit off or confusingly friendly.
Anyway, a fortnight ago, the cat came round with a swollen eye. I didn't mention it to the owner as thought he would already know and not appreciate me telling him. A few days later it seemed to get better slightly. But then the cat in the past week was extremely tired, quiet and eye seemed quite bad again as well as looking really dirty round the nose and mouth/breathing seemed laboured etc. I made her comfortable with a blanket and then I watched her go home. I was reassured she would be cared for. Didn't see her for 3 days and then this morning was told by another neighbour that she had died. They didn't say much else but now I feel intense guilt. I know she wasn't my responsibility but I feel I let her down. I can't get past the last image I have of her all dirty and exhausted in my garden. I'm embarrassed to say that I've been in tears throughout the day. Please be kind to me with your replies. Feel bad enough as it is. Before anyone accuses me of trying to take over her care it was never like that. She kept coming to me and I always knew she was not mine but it didn't stop me really loving her. She was just a beautiful cat and such a light in my life.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Rainfull091 · 18/11/2022 13:25

Thank you. Today is a rough day, missing her a lot.
I always used to feel guilty that she spent so much time with me and always tried to encourage her to go home more. It did worry me what she would be like in the winter. I just hope that her hanging around outside hasn't done this to her. 😞
I adored her and there will never be another like her. I just hope she didn't feel I let her down and that she felt loved. But mainly, that she is happy and at peace now.

OP posts:
Gemmanorthdevon · 17/11/2022 23:06

Please try and be kinder to yourself about it.

Tbf, I would have been super upset if one of mine were to choose another house. But I would have tried to be kind about it, whilst being quite cross! which may explain such mixed responses from owner, I'm sure the owner did their absolute best.

You don't know 100% what was going on with this cat. It sounds very much like FHV. which my cat suffers from. ( acquired from mother pre vaccination ) it effects the eyes, and respiratory system. He can go from looking healthy as ever one week, to having dripping swollen eyes the next having completely stopped grooming. He can look a right state, and he is the most loved and adored boy. We are well aware that one day, he might not " tell" us early enough for us to isolate him and treat him. We know he isn't going to get " old" and we know that one day there is going to be an acute infection that takes hold quicker and harder than the previous ones, that we can't make better before it takes him.

This cat had over 10 years of love from 2 houses. A good full life. That knew full tummies, warmth and comfort. I'm afraid what you are feeling is the price we pay for what these gorgeous creatures provide us with.

I'm sorry. Please consider another as soon as u can, there's so many others that need you xx

PinkRiceKrispies · 17/11/2022 22:21

So sorry OP. Can feel your pain in your words.

Rainfull091 · 17/11/2022 18:22

She was with me so often that I worry she wasn't going home as much as she should. I know I need to stop this anxiety. It doesn't help but just overwhelming me right now but I know it's early days.

OP posts:
WindUpPenguin · 17/11/2022 14:16

The cat's owner will have seen exactly what you have seen - the swollen eye, and deterioration into not being able to care for herself. I am sure they sought veterinary attention. They will likely have noticed other things as well (such as being off her food, or not wanting to go out as much). You pointing out the obvious would not have added anything, so please stop feeling guilty. As others have said, these will likely have been symptoms of the cat's decline, not the cause.

Our neighbour also loves our cat, gives her strokes and feeds her when we are away. I would imagine she would not point out any obvious health concerns, but might ask after the cat if she had seen her limping, for example.

Buteverythingsfine · 17/11/2022 14:12

Op, I've just googled the average lifespan for a cat, it's 12-14 years and some go earlier. So, given you knew this cat for 10 years, and it was possibly a few years old when you met them (or even just a kitten), they didn't do badly in the lifespan stakes. I think you are just grieving for this cat.

Buteverythingsfine · 17/11/2022 14:09

Cats when ill do go manky, our old cat had horrible lank fur and runny eyes as well as snotty from cat flu (which he'd had for years). He was beautiful in his prime, but once over a certain age, they just lose it a bit. I like the idea of writing a card for the owners, would you feel you could do that OP?Or buy yourself some flowers and have a remember, like a little celebration of their life? It doesn't matter what others thing, he was 'your' little cat for the time he was with you (I absolutely adored the cat we 'borrowed').

Rainfull091 · 17/11/2022 14:09

Thank you x
I may write the owner a card, just not sure if it would be welcomed.
Does help to read the replies here, somehow I have to try and think of happier times and that she received so much love and cuddles. Just really hard at the moment what with the guilt and feeling like I let her down when she needed me most.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 17/11/2022 13:46

Sorry for your loss, losing pets is hard and while she wasn’t your own cat she clearly loved you. Would it help to process your grief and guilt if you wrote the owners a card? Maybe just say how sorry you are and that as a regular visitor she brought you joy. Cats do indeed look pretty neglected when they approach the end of their lives. My poor old girl was permanently covered in snot and gooey eyes despite vet care- she wasn’t suffering she was just ancient.

I hope you can find another feline friend in time but in the meantime be kind to yourself.

Rainfull091 · 17/11/2022 13:43

It started off with a swollen eye which then seemed to get better but then got worse again. Almost like she had some type of flu as she was struggling to clean herself and so had a dirty mouth and fur. I wish my last image of her was a happier one. I will never know if I could have done more. Somehow I am going to have to try and stop feeling guilty but not sure how.
I think family and friends just think I should get over it as she wasn't mine. They don't understand.

OP posts:
Buteverythingsfine · 17/11/2022 13:32

OP, presumably the owner did see the cat in that week, so it's more that likely the cat had care, but that it was older and had something wrong with it that couldn't be fixed. It doesn't sound just like an eye infection on its own (which my cat gets a lot). What you are experiencing is very common when you grieve, you relive the last days, you feel guilty- over time hopefully this will stop and you will remember the happy times you had together. Would it help to talk with someone or write out your memories? Unfortunately I don't think you can hurry grief and you probably will feel sad for a little while.

Rainfull091 · 17/11/2022 12:52

I think I'm just tormenting myself wondering that if I had contacted the owner when the poorly eye first showed up, would she have made it?
Just worry I let her down. Feel embarrassed as I am a grown woman and have cried everyday at least once over this. The guilt is just horrible as is the sadness and missing her.

OP posts:
Slanty · 16/11/2022 23:25

I meant to add- cats tend to appear to go downhill very quickly but often they’ve been ill for a while and have been masking it. Lots of animals like rabbits do too; it’s a defense mechanism.

It’s very likely that the cat was quite sick for a while and nobody could have noticed and, by the time that you did, it was too late. Sadly, there’s nothing you could have done.

Buteverythingsfine · 16/11/2022 23:21

Oh, Op, as everyone has said, you gave that cat so much love and that's an amazing thing. We also had a neighbour who very kindly shared their cat with us when we couldn't have one due to being in rented and it was just wonderful to have this little being trotting in and out. That last time the cat was obviously very ill, unfortunately that can happen and there would be nothing you could have done. Take comfort you had this lovely little friend for ten years, and remember all the happy times.

Slanty · 16/11/2022 23:21

I lost my beloved dog last year. She was old but went downhill very quickly and it nearly killed me to see her unable to keep herself clean. She became incontinent in her final days. For a dog that was always so prim and shiny looking, it was very hard to see her like that.

(Every time it got to the stage where I knew she needed to be put to sleep, she’d rally and I’d convince myself she was on the mend but then she’d deteriorate again. This cycle went on for a few days).

I try to remember the happier times, though.

Do you have a photo of the cat in happier times, @Rainfull091? Maybe looking at that when you’re upset might help?

Rainfull091 · 16/11/2022 23:15

I just wish that last image would go from my head of her. Because there were so many lovely times that we had together which I wish was at the forefront of my mind but it's not. Just the last horrible image where she was really distressed and dirty. She was always so clean and had gleaming fur so it was heartbreaking to see her in this state.
She had so many happy and lovely years but the guilt is there weighing heavily. I know she wouldn't want that for me but hard to think that way at the moment.
I do have a lot of love to give an animal. Maybe should look into sponsoring a cat or volunteering when things have hopefully settled a bit.
I so hope she is at peace now. The last 2 mornings on the way to work a Robin has jumped out at me, I like to think it was her but probably just coincidence.
Thanks again for all the understanding. Was worried about posting but shouldn't have been.

OP posts:
Jux · 16/11/2022 23:01

I'm sure her owner had taken her to the vet and ensured that everything that could be done for her was done. I doubt there was anything else you could do, she sounds like she was in charge of her life and was dirty and tired because that was a side effect of nearing the end. Rejoice that she must have loved you too to have made the trip to say goodbye to you. Remember her in her prime. Be kind if you see your neighbour, he'll be devastated too.

Slanty · 16/11/2022 22:59

The poor cat, and poor you, OP.

I know you said you’re not in a position to have a pet cat of your own, but would you consider fostering or maybe volunteering at a rescue?

Sounds like you have a lot of love to give, and that could really make a difference to all the cats out there who need it.

beccahamlet · 16/11/2022 22:53

It's quite natural that you feel guilty. You're suffering from bereavement, even though the cat wasn't yours you loved it. You did nothing wrong. You're obviously a kind person and helped the cat have a happy life.

NoSquirrels · 16/11/2022 22:50

Ah, I’m so sorry, OP. A cat doesn’t need to be your cat - or any animal, come to that - to feel loss and grief at its passing. Don’t feel guilty. The likelihood is that an elderly cat won’t always be served by intervention anyway, so there was probably nothing you could have done. Try to be reassured the cat isn’t in pain any longer. Flowers

moonmoon123 · 16/11/2022 22:48

Rainfull091 · 16/11/2022 22:46

Thank you for being kind everyone.
I think I just feel I let her down and I can't get that last image of her out of my mind. It broke my heart to see her so dirty and struggling. Crying now as I write this.
I know she was deeply loved and I showed her that for many years. Just feel I let her down when she needed it most but it was as someone said upthread, a difficult situation. Doesn't make the guilt easier to bear though. Am beating myself up a lot which I know is pointless but just feel terrible and miss her so much already.

so so sorry! be kind to yourself. x

Rainfull091 · 16/11/2022 22:46

Thank you for being kind everyone.
I think I just feel I let her down and I can't get that last image of her out of my mind. It broke my heart to see her so dirty and struggling. Crying now as I write this.
I know she was deeply loved and I showed her that for many years. Just feel I let her down when she needed it most but it was as someone said upthread, a difficult situation. Doesn't make the guilt easier to bear though. Am beating myself up a lot which I know is pointless but just feel terrible and miss her so much already.

OP posts:
tunnocksreturns2019 · 16/11/2022 22:45

autumnleavesontheground · 16/11/2022 22:39

Aww this is sad. You mustn’t feel guilty. You contributed to her happy life. How lovely that you cared for her so much.

This. Bless you x

autumnleavesontheground · 16/11/2022 22:39

Aww this is sad. You mustn’t feel guilty. You contributed to her happy life. How lovely that you cared for her so much.

PoseyFlump · 16/11/2022 22:38

Cats choose humans. You were in a very difficult situation but you shouldn't feel guilty. Think of those ten years you showed her love.

Swipe left for the next trending thread