Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

very angry about the changes of Amazon prime! losing on-demand playback of songs.

188 replies

happyfishcoco · 16/11/2022 17:49

would you quit Amazon prime because of it?
YABU= you have/will quit Amazon prime because of this
YANBU = you will not quit.

I don't need a much larger music catalogue!!
I only want to hear some favourite song I choose.
I used to use amazon to play nursery song for my 3 years old DC who already like to choose songs.

I already have a google dot, it was a gift, but I can't play songs on demand.
so I bought a kid echo because of it last year.
now I can't do this anymore!!
The kid echo can do nothing now!
really angry.

mostly I like amazon prime for the next-day delivery and the music.
I am not using other things.

I am thinking to quit Amazon prime. saving £9 per month!

I am not very into song listening but would like to know if other companies with a reasonable price for on-demand songs. I use it mainly for nursery songs. lol
and able to download some songs for offline use, ie in underground.
Thanks

OP posts:
NippyWoowoo · 17/11/2022 08:20

I just live chatted amazon to ask, and they said that if you request a specific song, it will play that first, but then shuffle similar songs in after that first song.

They are wrong.

cakeorwine · 17/11/2022 08:15

SquirrelSoShiny · 17/11/2022 02:41

I'm not trying to be stupid but what has actually changed? I tend to play the same song on repeat or an amazon playlist so I'm not clear what has changed.

I would ask it play a band I like.

It would play one of their tunes and then think, sod that, I am going to play other music that I think is similar to that band.

And if I ask it to play a song, it may play that song, or now it may not. Just a similar song.

Or if I ask it to play an album, it would play one of those songs from that album and then play other random songs. From other albums.

UthredofBattenberg · 17/11/2022 07:29

I didn't use the free amazon music, basically because the song I wanted was never available. That seems to have changed now as they've expanded their catalogue (2 million to 100 million I think?)

So now if I ask it to play a song, it does. It then plays similar songs afterwards of that genre. That doesn't bother me if I don't want to listen, I turn it it.

If people have bought an album and it now won't let you play in order, that must be extremely annoying.

The change works for me. I'm obviously in the minority here, but I didn't use it before as every time I asked for a song it was only available through amazon music at an additional cost. Now I'm more likely to get the song 🤷‍♀️

Unless I'm missing something and Alexa has signed me up to something additional because of an errant yes!

Namechangeforthis88 · 17/11/2022 07:14

I cancelled prime a few weeks ago. Hardly ever find something I want to watch on Prime video, on the rare occasion we do it costs extra and I try to have Amazon delivery only as a last resort anyway. I feel a little queasy to think I've been lining Jeff Bezos' pockets for no real benefit to me.

QuebecBagnet · 17/11/2022 06:58

I’ve had Prime for ever. Looked at prime music on day 1 and thought it was rubbish and never used it. Always had Spotify. For me it’s a delivery service and tv channel.

mummyh2016 · 17/11/2022 06:53

Same! I used to pay for Amazon music unlimited but cancelled it when I was on maternity leave. I pick up my first back to work wage the end of this month so was going to sign back up. Out of principle I'm going to Spotify instead. It's a pisstake.

Chihuahuapower · 17/11/2022 06:45

Have you thought of a yoto player? I have one for my 2 year old and use it all the time to play her favoutite songs and stories.

Feel free to message me if you have questions about them (I'm a superfan 😂)

I also have a discount link too

ScarlettSunset · 17/11/2022 06:38

I personally wouldn't quite because of it, but that's because that's not why I use prime. If it's a major reason why you have it and now you can't use it, then yes, definitely cancel and tell them why.

ABBAsnumberonefan · 17/11/2022 06:36

mashh · 17/11/2022 05:03

I don't understand the outrage. Maybe it's a mindset thing? I am early 20s so am used to premium subscription services...

Amazon do offer the features you want - it's bundled in their unlimited package so you have to pay extra to upgrade now.

Which isn't that unusual. As far as I'm aware, Spotify do the same thing with their premium subscription where you can select individual songs without shuffle.

It's just a standard subscription model at this point

I agree

TallGreenTrees · 17/11/2022 06:16

Skala123 · 17/11/2022 05:36

Has anyone else found that prime tv also now charge extra for a lot of the films and shows they have? Not sure if it's because I now live in Europe but it's driving me mad

Yes, this, and all I seem to see free are made for TV really bad movies now

TallGreenTrees · 17/11/2022 06:15

bobkate · 16/11/2022 18:57

My daughters' are so cross. They want to be able to skip, shuffle, etc. Is there a reasonable alternative?

Spotify, Alexa will play my Spotify tracks

taliaG · 17/11/2022 05:59

The issue is that they've changed the service they are offering and made it worse, whilst advertising it as an improvement. So it's not really a surprise that people are pissed off about that.

Skala123 · 17/11/2022 05:36

Has anyone else found that prime tv also now charge extra for a lot of the films and shows they have? Not sure if it's because I now live in Europe but it's driving me mad

user16480478 · 17/11/2022 05:29

mashh · 17/11/2022 05:03

I don't understand the outrage. Maybe it's a mindset thing? I am early 20s so am used to premium subscription services...

Amazon do offer the features you want - it's bundled in their unlimited package so you have to pay extra to upgrade now.

Which isn't that unusual. As far as I'm aware, Spotify do the same thing with their premium subscription where you can select individual songs without shuffle.

It's just a standard subscription model at this point

I'm in my 60s and must say I agree, I think people are expecting a subscription service like Spotify or Apple Music for a free add on, bundled in with delivery and prime video, I pay £99 a year to play what I want on Apple Music, I have Prime for delivery and TV and think that it is good value as I order a lot and watch some of the TV series.

There are so many different subscriptions around now that people need to sort out what is best for them, obviously if people only order half a dozen things from Amazon and don't watch much of the TV then it isn't really worth buying Prime, then they would be better paying the Prime subscription money to a decent music streamer instead if the music is the important thing to them.

mashh · 17/11/2022 05:03

I don't understand the outrage. Maybe it's a mindset thing? I am early 20s so am used to premium subscription services...

Amazon do offer the features you want - it's bundled in their unlimited package so you have to pay extra to upgrade now.

Which isn't that unusual. As far as I'm aware, Spotify do the same thing with their premium subscription where you can select individual songs without shuffle.

It's just a standard subscription model at this point

Dalooah · 17/11/2022 04:46

Ugh I HATE the new prime music. Like someone upthread has said, I'd rather have fewer songs and listen to what we actually want to! I use it almost exclusively for the kids and we are all HATING the new model. It's certainly no upgrade as their tried to sell it.

If you've not updated your app you may still be lucky enough to not have been affected by the changes- my advice would be don't update it!

I'm cancelling but have already paid for the year so can't even get a refund. Have complained to customer service x3 to be told 'we'll look into it". So much for being the most customer centric company!!

I really did think I was the only one being ever so frustrated with the changes. The fact that the changes took place with no warning really angered me! And then a pathetic email 'announcing' said 'upgrade'. 🙄🙄🙄

Initially I was under the impression that you could create playlists but they'd play in shuffle mode not that you literally couldn't listen to the music in the playlist. What is the point?!

RichardMarxisinnocent · 17/11/2022 04:44

I've just realised I have a free trial of Amazon music unlimited so perhaps that's why it's playing individual songs. Once the trial is over will it really refuse to play a song I've pressed play on? Or will individual songs just not have a play button?

RichardMarxisinnocent · 17/11/2022 04:28

SquirrelSoShiny · 17/11/2022 02:41

I'm not trying to be stupid but what has actually changed? I tend to play the same song on repeat or an amazon playlist so I'm not clear what has changed.

I'm also a bit confused about what has changed. I've read this thread and done some googling, am I right in understanding that the issue is that if you go into Amazon music, search for an artist or album or song, then press play on a specific song, then it won't actually play that song, it will play something different? But I've just searched for an artist, pressed on them, chosen a song and pressed play and it played. Then I searched for a song title, pressed play on the song and it played. So I don't seem to have the issue?

I don't actually use Prime music much. The vast majority of the time I listen to music on my digital audio player, where I have digital versions of all the CDs I own, plus some albums more recently bought in mp3 format. When I do listen to Prime music it's either a playlist someone else compiled which I use to run to, or an album I'm thinking of buying. The playlists seemed to work fine at the weekend, will listening to an album not work in future?

taliaG · 17/11/2022 03:11

Yep it's really annoying and shit. I was thinking of quitting prime anyway but this has pushed me over the edge.

SquirrelSoShiny · 17/11/2022 02:41

I'm not trying to be stupid but what has actually changed? I tend to play the same song on repeat or an amazon playlist so I'm not clear what has changed.

NickEccles · 17/11/2022 01:53

I am curious..........

Someone mentioned Napster from the 'Good old days' of file sharing!

Now I began downloading & filesharing from around 1999 & still have my original d/loaded files from that time right up to the present day!

Same folder on my separate media hard drive kept that way so all my home devices, phone & car media player will always continue to play newly added songs etc....

All my old records cd's & audio cassettes I converted to digital years ago so all music resides in the same place - SO convenient & very easy to compile playlists which I do all the time as well as modifying existing pl's anytime I want!

So the question here is: Why on earth did you all not save/keep all your downloaded tracks over the years instead of junking them & switching to just streaming services instead?? My digital media has been collected over the years & all other media formats converted to one playable format! You lost all your previous d/loaded music paid for or otherwise for the thread topic thereby losing all you had previously acquired!

If you're a serious music lover then why let the greedy corps dictate the way you enjoy your music? I have never subscribed to ANY streaming service or Apple based music platform - Why would I want to after collecting & collating my 1000's of songs?? I abhor all of them esp Apple/Amazon etc! They are in it for YOUR MONEY, no other reason!

I backup all my media very often & also host all my music online for others to share & me to be able to d/load wherever I am on the planet! Now many of you can u/stand why I do this while many of you are now fucked off with streaming services which will never replace having the actual file in your possession! The same applies to DVD & video files too! Keep what you acquire over the years then this will not be able to happen to any of you! 😊

Glitteratitar · 17/11/2022 01:22

Yep, we cancelled. I found the changes annoying as if I want to listen to an artist, I want that artist, not other similar ones. We already had Spotify so just linked that to the Alexa instead.

etulosba · 17/11/2022 01:13

I can’t get it play the song I want either. Amazon Music is completely useless now, as far as I am concerned. They recently increased the price for Prime too. The problem is that I actually use Amazon quite frequently, so cancelling Prime would be akin to cutting off my nose to spite my face.

Until I saw this thread, I thought it was some kind of setting that I had inadvertently turned on.

happyfishcoco · 17/11/2022 00:35

CaptainMerica · 16/11/2022 22:31

I just live chatted amazon to ask, and they said that if you request a specific song, it will play that first, but then shuffle similar songs in after that first song.

I think I'll need to set up my echo and test how well it works, and see whether to send it back.

if you request a specific song, it will play that first.
hmm....my Echo dot cannot play the specific song that I asked.
please do tell if you can, and if need some setup??

OP posts:
LuckyPaisley · 16/11/2022 23:07

@CaptainMerica I'd be interested to know if you do test out your echo dot, as to whether its useful. I'm about to buy one for DD's birthday but if this is how it is, I need to quickly find alternatives.

Does anyone know if Spotify will work normally on the kids Echo Dot instead?