Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

very angry about the changes of Amazon prime! losing on-demand playback of songs.

188 replies

happyfishcoco · 16/11/2022 17:49

would you quit Amazon prime because of it?
YABU= you have/will quit Amazon prime because of this
YANBU = you will not quit.

I don't need a much larger music catalogue!!
I only want to hear some favourite song I choose.
I used to use amazon to play nursery song for my 3 years old DC who already like to choose songs.

I already have a google dot, it was a gift, but I can't play songs on demand.
so I bought a kid echo because of it last year.
now I can't do this anymore!!
The kid echo can do nothing now!
really angry.

mostly I like amazon prime for the next-day delivery and the music.
I am not using other things.

I am thinking to quit Amazon prime. saving £9 per month!

I am not very into song listening but would like to know if other companies with a reasonable price for on-demand songs. I use it mainly for nursery songs. lol
and able to download some songs for offline use, ie in underground.
Thanks

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DorritLittle · 10/12/2022 09:22

I pay for Amazon Music and don't have Prime. DD likes it. At some point though, I am going to move her to another platform to reduce my reliance on Amazon (I also use Kindle and Audible). It's really crap about the paid for songs. That would bother me a lot.

HowDoWeDoThisPlease · 10/12/2022 09:18

I only realised last night that skips are limited. WTF? You insist I listen to your shit song choices, and then won’t let me skip over them to something decent??😔 Not impressed.

HarleyQ2 · 10/12/2022 09:15

Hi - WTF?!? I’m pissed as all hell! I can’t imagine why Amazon thinks it’s a good reason to limit 6 skips in an hour. If anything - it is turning many folks to another service. I pay an assload for Amazon - this is a greedy, immoral & just plain stupid for a business model! Why? Why? Why?

Neverendingwashingpile · 21/11/2022 12:43

I cancelled yesterday because of this! So annoying. Think we're going to get Deezer for kids to use on their Alexa's.

taliaG · 21/11/2022 12:30

@user374698 It's not free. None of it is free!

1001Daffodils · 21/11/2022 10:58

YomAsalYomBasal · 21/11/2022 09:57

It's a little unreasonable to be "very angry" and "absolutely furious". It's annoying but it's how things work these days. Pay or cancel, whatever suits you best but maybe save the ire for something a bit less trivial?

How is it trivial to be angry about the loss of something you've legitimately paid for?

The changes haven't just been made to people using Amazon Music as a streaming service for the 'free' tracks they get with Prime. It's also been forced onto people who foolishly in hindsight, and this includes me bought digital music via Amazon on the basis they could stream it via the app at their leisure.

I'm no longer able to access music I've bought because Amazon have changed the entire way their music platform works. I think anger is a perfectly legitimate response to this.

YomAsalYomBasal · 21/11/2022 09:57

It's a little unreasonable to be "very angry" and "absolutely furious". It's annoying but it's how things work these days. Pay or cancel, whatever suits you best but maybe save the ire for something a bit less trivial?

user374698 · 21/11/2022 08:14

I got my Echo Dots to listen to music upstairs and to use as an alarm as they were cheap, I have them defaulted to Apple Music though as I subscribe to that as main music player downstairs is a HomePod so I haven't really used the free Amazon Music, maybe not many people used the free one as most people I think have Spotify

cakeorwine · 21/11/2022 08:04

I am trying to think why I got my Amazon Echo.

I know I had Prime. We watched some TV programmes on it and films. I am not sure if I got my Echo so I could listen to music through it - and if that was a 'selling point' of the Echo.

taliaG · 21/11/2022 07:43

Perhaps Amazon thought that people didn't care about the music, that they could fuck around with it without pissing their customers off, but as evidenced by this thread, they were wrong!

taliaG · 21/11/2022 07:40

They gave you a shoe though, just not the one you wanted Smile

Gumreduction · 21/11/2022 06:49

taliaG · 20/11/2022 21:38

Gumreduction said When it comes to anything free, I’m never complacent!

In their contract, they may have technically described it in this way, but it would be akin to a shoe shop writing in their terms and conditions that you're paying for the left shoe and the right shoe is free, and so can be changed without notice after purchase.

As a customer, I am paying for the pair; I don't want one shoe and wouldn't have paid if there were only one shoe on offer. If they send me the left shoe I wanted, but a right shoe that's the wrong style and size, not only will I cancel my subscription, but I'm also entitled to feel annoyed and to complain publicly and privately.

I don't have to just smile and and shrug my shoulders and say, "oh well, the right shoe was free so I have no reason to complain!"

I was responding to a PP who regards it as “free”.

And I don’t think the shoe analogy works. Because for many people, such as myself and as evidenced on this thread, this music feature is irrelevant to why we buy prime.

whereas no one doesn’t require both the left and right shoe (well, unless you have suffered an awful accident or condition)

taliaG · 20/11/2022 21:38

Gumreduction said When it comes to anything free, I’m never complacent!

In their contract, they may have technically described it in this way, but it would be akin to a shoe shop writing in their terms and conditions that you're paying for the left shoe and the right shoe is free, and so can be changed without notice after purchase.

As a customer, I am paying for the pair; I don't want one shoe and wouldn't have paid if there were only one shoe on offer. If they send me the left shoe I wanted, but a right shoe that's the wrong style and size, not only will I cancel my subscription, but I'm also entitled to feel annoyed and to complain publicly and privately.

I don't have to just smile and and shrug my shoulders and say, "oh well, the right shoe was free so I have no reason to complain!"

GelatoQueen · 20/11/2022 16:28

For me the prime music offering was a bit of an extra that made my Amazon prime membership better value. I actually think Prime is a bit shit really - there's nothing really I watch (I have Disney+), the music service has gone down the pan (am considering paying for apple music instead), the Morrisons grocery service was good 2 years ago but it now awful and I don't use it and frankly most of the stuff available via prime is same price / cheaper elsewhere and there is less and less I need the next day.

Gumreduction · 20/11/2022 15:58

I never ever said it was “free”.

i said it was listed as a benefit rather than the core service. And the benefit can be withdrawn or amended at any time, and the consumer can cancel their subscription if they so wish.

taliaG · 20/11/2022 11:40

No it was to gunreduction, sorry.

DuchessDandelion · 20/11/2022 11:26

taliaG · 20/11/2022 02:47

It's not bloody "free" if you have to pay money to access it is it? It's part of the package that you're paying for and you don't get a discount if you don't use it.

I'm sure they're legally within their rights to do what they have done. but like I say, if they piss off enough of their customers then it's a stupid business decision.

I wouldn't pay for prime for deliveries alone. It's not worth it.

I paid for the package of delivery, prime reading, TV and music. I rarely read the books or watch the included TV. I have other TV subs that are better.

Like others, I don't need access to millions of songs and couldn't justify paying for a separate music sub.

I was happy with the small selection that I could play and repeat at will through Alexa.

Because of having free delivery, I buy more things on a whim from Amazon. So they'll be losing out even more.

Was that to me?
I didnt say prime music was free

inappropriateraspberry · 20/11/2022 09:07

@Gumreduction I don't think anyone has claimed it contravenes what they signed for, but it's quite misleading to change it in such a way that it is now unusable for many, and people have bought Amazon devices (recently) for specific reasons that now don't work. They are perfectly within their rights to complain that they do not now serve the purpose they were intended for.

Fenneloup · 20/11/2022 07:58

Mine says previously downloaded songs are no longer available. But where are all the mp3s I bought from amazon in the past?

Gumreduction · 20/11/2022 07:00

inappropriateraspberry · 19/11/2022 22:56

@Gumreduction We all know they are within their rights to change how it works, and we are within our rights to complain.
Individually, of course our dislike of the changes are nothing, but it appears that many people aren't happy with the so called 'improvements,' and Amazon may well end up losing Prime customers because of it.
If it ain't broke, don't fix it comes to mind. I can't download playlists to listen offline, I can't play a straightforward album or just one track. It has now become a glorified radio station, with little customisation or usefulness.

I have never responded to any poster saying they don’t like it. And leaving it at that. Of course you can like or dislike what the hell you like.

My point has been to respond to those saying they have complained to Amazon to say that it contravenes what they signed up to (it doesn’t), or to post that Amazon have reneged on terms and conditions (they haven’t).

Is it disappointing? Yes
Did you Amazon do anything wrong? No

Gumreduction · 20/11/2022 06:58

NippyWoowoo · 19/11/2022 21:52

Why are you so annoying? Are you sleeping with Jeff? Are you Jeff?

People can complain about a service, you are looking for a fight.

Go fuck Jeff.

😂

Pretty sure I would fuck Jeff if it meant it threw any of his money my way!

taliaG · 20/11/2022 02:47

It's not bloody "free" if you have to pay money to access it is it? It's part of the package that you're paying for and you don't get a discount if you don't use it.

I'm sure they're legally within their rights to do what they have done. but like I say, if they piss off enough of their customers then it's a stupid business decision.

I wouldn't pay for prime for deliveries alone. It's not worth it.

I paid for the package of delivery, prime reading, TV and music. I rarely read the books or watch the included TV. I have other TV subs that are better.

Like others, I don't need access to millions of songs and couldn't justify paying for a separate music sub.

I was happy with the small selection that I could play and repeat at will through Alexa.

Because of having free delivery, I buy more things on a whim from Amazon. So they'll be losing out even more.

DuchessDandelion · 20/11/2022 01:18

The point is that Amazon Prime music was a great alternative to Spotify. Now, I'm paying for the privilege of the (virtually*) same service I get with a free Spotify account.

*I don't think amazon have introduced ads at twice the volume...yet.

AllLopsided · 19/11/2022 23:59

I agree it's rubbish. It's particularly rubbish for classical music. Who wants to listen to a symphony, oratorio or opera with the tracks out of order, or interspersed with tracks from another work?

We have Amazon prime and use it enough for deliveries to justify it so won't cancel. DH had a separate subscription to Amazon music which I used to piggyback on. We actually cancelled that due to a problem with the bank card (DH has a bank account that's not in his country of residence because he's a cross-border worker). He had a lot of frustrating 'chats' with Amazon about it with no solution. When we cancelled it I bought the two albums and 5 tracks that I listen to most for a total of less than £15 on iTunes. I still have plenty of stuff on there anyway. So for the cost of two months' subscription I've got the things I really want forever. Music streaming is a rip off, I've decided, though I guess it depends how you listen. Sounds like you too might be better spending on a few chosen albums to own, OP.

I don't think iTunes is infallible though - some albums I downloaded or copied from CD ages ago have disappeared from my library during various changes of computer/back up drive over the years.

Doingtheboxerbeat · 19/11/2022 23:31

Literally just cancelled YouTube music for this. I carefully downloaded my music into categories - took ages and they have dicked around with them 🤬 .

I'll keep my £9.99 a month and suffer the ads.