Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think the advice on being excluded on mn or being confrontational is highly unrealistic

38 replies

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 17:22

Does anybody else think that the advice on mn when people get left out by a social group as to confront the host is pretty unrealistic advice? Like yea in theory we could do it but it's pretty impossible to do and even humiliating/desperate to do in reality. Yet the consensus on so many threads is to 'ask why you weren't invited' or if no invite comes '' ask were you supposed to be invited''.

In reality nobody I Know would actually do this but on mn it sounds like it's standard.

I also see people saying stuff like ''why didn't you call her/them out'' when an op posts about being mistreated when yes we often would like to do this but in reality it is often much harder to call people out on their behaviour especially when it is a group dynamic. It takes a lot of courage to call people on things like this, especially when you know they are likely to ridicule you for it and minimise your concerns. Yet mn make it sound like standing your ground to others is a walk in the park.

AIBU to think that posters are unrealistic when they give such advice?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
polio999 · 18/11/2022 20:42

Many posts about workplace complaints (even sometimes what seems to be just a personal disagreement or staff not getting along) get loads of responses telling them to get HR involved as if the are, as you put it, the tea and sympathy department/independent arbiters. In reality they would not be remotely interested in a lot of the issues posted about and even where there's a legitimate complaint their first priority will be protecting the business not the employee

yes I agree with this but there's also a dogma on mn that if everybody is not 100 percent professional at work report them or confront them. That just would be be bad practice and could really make your life hell.

I;ve heard and seen mgmt and people over me being totally unprofessional but as if I'd actually confront them. I worked in a school too any my headmaster could be totally unprofessional but going to report them would be career suicide for me. That's how the real world works.MN is quite too idealistic.

lovelypidgeon · 17/11/2022 13:47

Metabigot · 16/11/2022 22:24

Er, who do you think HR work for?

They are not impartial they work for the directors and CEO.

They're there to cover the organisation's ass not to act as the welfare/tea and sympathy department for staff. No matter what it says on the tin.

And thank god too as a HR person I can think of nothing worse than being the tea and sympathy department.

Yes, that's basically what I meant. Many posts about workplace complaints (even sometimes what seems to be just a personal disagreement or staff not getting along) get loads of responses telling them to get HR involved as if the are, as you put it, the tea and sympathy department/independent arbiters. In reality they would not be remotely interested in a lot of the issues posted about and even where there's a legitimate complaint their first priority will be protecting the business not the employee.

determinedtomakethiswork · 16/11/2022 22:52

Given most people here don't seem to even answer their own front door or telephone, it's very very unlikely they're going to challenge someone if they're not invited to an event.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 16/11/2022 22:50

Some of the advice on here is absolutely shocking though. And it makes me cringe for the person advising it, like you’d ever even dream of making a scene in the playground where your child goes to school

Piseog · 16/11/2022 22:49

Mn is dominated by posters who struggle with friendships and have poor social skills — see the plethora of regular threads about school run ‘cliques’, not answering the door, ever, and not having friends because they’re ‘too much drama’.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/11/2022 22:39

I also agree with the HR thing. Unless you are well respected have been working there a long time and aomeone has done something overtly awful infront of a load of witnesses...even in places with proper and impartial HR it can often turn into a he said / she said situation and result in gossip and being labelled a troublemaker etc

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 16/11/2022 22:37

I do agree, where the OP has made clear their 'friends' have lied. Eg OP asks what friends are up to at the weekend, friend says a quiet one, then OP finds out that friend had a big party with a load of mutual friends.

If they lied to the OPs face, they are not going to come out and tell them the truth behind the reason. They will do the whole 'oh I thought I asked you, so sorry!'.

And there have been threads where the OP has politely and reaonsably confronted their friend (eg friend who lied about not being able to come to an event, turned out they CBA, the OP told them that they felt very disappointed as it's the 10th time in a row and their kids are upset), and the friend goes mad and accuses the OP of having no respect for their mental health etc

Having said that, I would ask the blokes I know directly, and have done so before and it has gone ok

Metabigot · 16/11/2022 22:24

lovelypidgeon · 16/11/2022 20:43

Yes, the general consensus on every thread about workplace concerns (especially a bad manager) is invariably to report someone to HR. The posts make it sound like every company have an independent, objective HR department. In reality, everywhere that I've worked the HR department would (other than in the case of a very very serious complaint) just pass the matter on to the line manager of that person, who would invariably back the more senior person. The HR department were very aware that the directors could hire and fire them as well so it would have to be a very extreme complaint for them to go against what the directors said. In many industries there are a small number of employers in the area and the 'bosses' all know each other so there's also a fear that if you make a complaint against one employer the others will be told that you are a trouble causer so it will be harder for you to move on. Plus most smaller businesses don't have an HR department. The reality is that even where a complaint is probably justified, most people will put up with minor issues and leave it they are unhappy.

Er, who do you think HR work for?

They are not impartial they work for the directors and CEO.

They're there to cover the organisation's ass not to act as the welfare/tea and sympathy department for staff. No matter what it says on the tin.

And thank god too as a HR person I can think of nothing worse than being the tea and sympathy department.

OoooohMatron · 16/11/2022 22:18

A lot of the advice on here is what people would like to do, not what they would actually do. It's very easy to advise to tell your overbearing MIL to fuck off, for example, but would you actually? I think not, unless you are completely socially inept.

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 22:11

I posted something the other day, very similar about being excluded by a group and was told to 'man up' or to 'get over it'. Difficult when you come here for general decent advice and get knocked down

yes there is alot of ''you viewed the friendship differently to them....move on'' advice which is never really helpful. People seem to totally lack empathy.

OP posts:
FlipFlop0 · 16/11/2022 21:43

@Classical24 Yes people are just horrible x

Classical24 · 16/11/2022 21:38

@FlipFlop0 Ditto to this, I posted something the other day, very similar about being excluded by a group and was told to 'man up' or to 'get over it'. Difficult when you come here for general decent advice and get knocked down.

I very much keep myself to myself now.

Chelsea26 · 16/11/2022 21:27

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 20:21

I was just thinking this. If I heard any of my close friends were having a party that the rest of us were invited to and I wasn’t I would definitely ask about it.
BUT my asking would come from the “I’m assuming this is a mistake mate” not “I can’t believe you purposely didn’t invite me and I’m really hurt” because my friends are not dicks and don’t generally do horrible things, so I would assume the best not the worst of them until proved wrong

but that's easy to say from an outside view. When these things happen we are usually so blindsided and shocked we can freeze and not know what to do. Any many ops who were excluded would have had the view you had before the exclusion.

Well I did say until proven wrong, but I haven’t been yet.

If, when I said, “I’m assuming this is a mistake mate” they said “no, no mistake - I don’t like you and you’re not invited” then that’s a whole different board game.

But your OP was about not confronting/asking at all, which just would never happen!

InPraiseOfBacchus · 16/11/2022 21:17

People love to watch drama unfold from a safe distance. I guarantee most people offering confrontational "advice" would never do anything of the sort. They want to vicariously agitate the situation and watch for updates with some popcorn.

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 20:59

In many industries there are a small number of employers in the area and the 'bosses' all know each other so there's also a fear that if you make a complaint against one employer the others will be told that you are a trouble causer so it will be harder for you to move on...The reality is that even where a complaint is probably justified, most people will put up with minor issues and leave it they are unhappy

this, I agree with this in spades. I've seen racist/homophobia/inappropriate sexual comments and harassment, double standards etc. in the workplace. But on mn I'd be urged to go and report it. Doing so would mean going against my superiors etc and they'd know it was me as I'd be reporting it to their friends.

I can't think of anything more dangerous for me. You are right in reality many of us know it's safer to keep our heads down and turn a blind eye. I'm not saying that's right but it's the way it is. To think just because you have a justified complaint in the workplace you should report it and justice will be served is a mn fantasy.

OP posts:
lovelypidgeon · 16/11/2022 20:43

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 17:33

Another 1 I'd add to the list is going to HR or report staff for doing x, y and z or anything not pc correct. Yes in theory we should but in reality in the workplace is a complex jungle and by reporting colleagues and superiors we can make life much harder for ourselves and have our card marked.

Yes, the general consensus on every thread about workplace concerns (especially a bad manager) is invariably to report someone to HR. The posts make it sound like every company have an independent, objective HR department. In reality, everywhere that I've worked the HR department would (other than in the case of a very very serious complaint) just pass the matter on to the line manager of that person, who would invariably back the more senior person. The HR department were very aware that the directors could hire and fire them as well so it would have to be a very extreme complaint for them to go against what the directors said. In many industries there are a small number of employers in the area and the 'bosses' all know each other so there's also a fear that if you make a complaint against one employer the others will be told that you are a trouble causer so it will be harder for you to move on. Plus most smaller businesses don't have an HR department. The reality is that even where a complaint is probably justified, most people will put up with minor issues and leave it they are unhappy.

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 20:21

I was just thinking this. If I heard any of my close friends were having a party that the rest of us were invited to and I wasn’t I would definitely ask about it.
BUT my asking would come from the “I’m assuming this is a mistake mate” not “I can’t believe you purposely didn’t invite me and I’m really hurt” because my friends are not dicks and don’t generally do horrible things, so I would assume the best not the worst of them until proved wrong

but that's easy to say from an outside view. When these things happen we are usually so blindsided and shocked we can freeze and not know what to do. Any many ops who were excluded would have had the view you had before the exclusion.

OP posts:
Miss03852 · 16/11/2022 20:02

Well some obviously do because I'm one of them.

If you read my post I did use the word “probably”, I didn’t say it applied to ALL posters who said that.

Chelsea26 · 16/11/2022 19:08

@WallaceinAnderland I was just thinking this. If I heard any of my close friends were having a party that the rest of us were invited to and I wasn’t I would definitely ask about it.

BUT my asking would come from the “I’m assuming this is a mistake mate” not “I can’t believe you purposely didn’t invite me and I’m really hurt” because my friends are not dicks and don’t generally do horrible things, so I would assume the best not the worst of them until proved wrong.

I’ve also asked to come to things that I know I haven’t been invited to because I’m at a loose end/interested in it/not interested but haven’t seen some people for a while, which I appreciate is a bit weirder but still no one seems to mind!

If it was a neighbour or a friend of a friend or someone less close then I wouldn’t say anything, but I don’t think I’d be massively hurt either…

WallaceinAnderland · 16/11/2022 18:40

Miss03852 · 16/11/2022 17:41

They probably wouldn’t. Easy to be tough behind a keyboard.

Well some obviously do because I'm one of them. I might not be as abrasive as some of the suggestions, but I would certainly speak up. Many of those posters are talking about a good friend leaving them out, for example. If you can't talk honestly to your 'good friend' then they are not a good friend are they.

In fact, many of them won't even tell their own partner they don't want to do something, like that '12 relatives for Christmas thread'. Again, if you can't be honest with your partner then your relationship is pretty bad tbh.

FlipFlop0 · 16/11/2022 17:54

I nose on here, and 95% of the time I think what a massive bunch of toxic fuckers! I can't imagine ever actually asking for advice on here because people get mobbed and everyone just becomes so nasty!

ShirleyPhallus · 16/11/2022 17:47

90% of that kind of advice on here is crap and most MNers that make that advice wouldn’t say boo to a goose

The best one was someone whose child had been told off by another parent at soft play and someone responded that if a parent did that to them, they’d do a flying karate kick to the throat. No you wouldn’t mate.

OldPhoto · 16/11/2022 17:43

WallaceinAnderland · 16/11/2022 17:24

Because people are all different and those posters are saying what they would do.

I don't think they are. They might be saying what they think they'd like to say, but I suspect very few would actually say it.

That goes for most of the suggested smart responses, whatever the situation, TBH

Miss03852 · 16/11/2022 17:41

WallaceinAnderland · 16/11/2022 17:24

Because people are all different and those posters are saying what they would do.

They probably wouldn’t. Easy to be tough behind a keyboard.

nickytjj · 16/11/2022 17:40

What I find quite unusual, is the amount of advice saying that someone was awful to exclude the OP, but over on another thread when someone doesn't want to extend an invite then they are fair and reasonable to do so

yes agreed I'd also say on this theme that there was a thread on a mum who's child told another girl ''we don't want to play with you'' and many on the thread were supportive of the op's daughter for being assertive. I was horrified by this and can't imagine the posters would be saying the same if the excluded child was their child.

OP posts: