Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do rich people know that they have it better than a lot of other people?

244 replies

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 14:40

I just think this is really interesting Im in a book club. In the book club is the poshest man I've ever met. Let's call him alan. He has told me his back story. His father owns a massive, massive farm. His father is also a chief director of another organisation, at the same time.
Alan went to private school. Alan plays rugby. Alan has a good job.
He is a nice enough man. But what strikes me is he is always,always complaining about his life.
And his problems are so trivial - when I know myself and alot of other people in the book club, had a far, far worse life than he did. Yet he complains the most

For example, one time he was complaining about how his father didn't help him get a job, when other peoples parents help them to get a job.

I was thinking "I didn't have a father at all", but I didn't say it. My father walked out on us when I was 3 and had nothing to do with me. I bit my tongue!

Next week Alan was complaining about the private school that he went to.

I was thinking "I grew up in total poverty, I cant feel like shedding a tear about your private school".

I don't know. He just doesn't seem to realise that he had a better life than most people I know .

Maybe really privileged people are not aware of how privileged they are? As it is all they have ever known? But surely you would know that you are better off than other people.

Maybe he just doesn't care. ?

OP posts:
Cherryblossoms85 · 16/11/2022 16:45

He sounds awful. But I suppose people would probably say the same about me. Depressed about everything, worried about everything, but I have a perfectly nice life and earn far more than my parents ever did, but all I do is mourn the past and fear the future.

FallopianTubeTrain · 16/11/2022 16:44

I think the good thing about books is that nobody reads the same story, all our personal history and our own experiences shape and interpret the words we read. To then discuss a book with a group of people you need to present them with a degree of your own interpretive backstory to make your viewpoint make sense.

I don't think it's tone deaf to bring up privileged moans in this context. Yes people are worse off than you but you couldn't read a book from anyone's viewpoint but your own so censoring yourself in this context would be pointless and stifle discussion.

I know some quite intimate things about the lives of the members of my book group and I never really discuss anything other than books with them. I like learning about people's lives in this way (even our very own moany Malcolm).

Youdoyoutoday · 16/11/2022 16:42

gwenneh · 16/11/2022 14:47

Maybe really privileged people are not aware of how privileged they are? As it is all they have ever known? But surely you would know that you are better off than other people.
Maybe he just doesn't care. ?

Maybe being privileged doesn't mean you forfeit your right to complain about anything, ever, in case someone might have it worse than you?

But surely its better to know who you are complaining to in the first place.
Common sense is not to complain in front of those who may be worse off than you, you wouldn't start complaining about a leak in your roof to a homeless person who has no roof.

It's one thing to have a bit of moan to your mates, quite another to complain to a stranger at book club that your rich daddy didn't help you get a job!

TabithaTittlemouse · 16/11/2022 16:42

Dh is jealous because I grew up in a city, I’m jealous because Dh grew up in the country. Neither had a better life, it was just different.

It really doesn’t matter what his upbringing was. He’s allowed to moan just as much as everyone else.

Are only the less well off entitled to a moan? (On here that’s definitely the case!).

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 16:38

I think a lot of people at heart have pretty poor social skills. And Op is talking about an example of that.

Bonheurdupasse · 16/11/2022 16:37

Swedishmeatball · 16/11/2022 14:42

I appreciate things I have now because I did not grow up with them. However, my dh grew up with the lifestyle we currently enjoy and I don’t think he truly appreciates it.

Same here.
If I start thinking about the living standard of some people in my home country I can feel suicidal.
And yet on a rational level I'm fervently anti-communist.

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 16:37

sadiewt · 16/11/2022 16:27

I think not having things growing up can make you more grateful (a good thing.) But it can also make you think rich people don't have problems (a not so good thing.)

No one is that stupid. But having to deal with getting someone in to repair something broken is not the same as not being able to afford a roof over your head.

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 16:35

GoodnightGentleBoris · 16/11/2022 15:47

So what? Most people are strangers to other people, you can still feel sorry for them that they’ve had something upsetting happen to them. It doesn’t cost you anything or take anything away from your own issues to feel sorry that someone else is upset about something.

I think a sense of perspective is important when communicating with strangers and acquaintances.
I would not go to a refugee camp and complain I could not afford a holiday.

Oysterbabe · 16/11/2022 16:33

There is always someone worse off. I can (and do) complain about my awful, soul destroying job while also appreciating that many people wish they had a job that paid the bills.

Meadowbreeze · 16/11/2022 16:32

@sadiewt I agree. I grew up very poor and see this a lot with kids I grew up with. I blame this on the constantly perpetuated idea that money= no problems or solves all problems. That's what was drilled to is in school, and is drilled in the media. Voila.

IDontWantToBeAPie · 16/11/2022 16:32

While I understand what you mean - your worse off life doesn't mean he can't resent his dad or have hated his school.

Legallypinkish · 16/11/2022 16:29

I disagree. It’s a very sweeping generalisation. We are ok financially. We never grew up with money. We don’t have to worry about bills or anything but do have to worry constantly about our disabled child.

everyone has their own issues to deal with whether they are rich or not. There is always someone worse off.

sadiewt · 16/11/2022 16:27

I think not having things growing up can make you more grateful (a good thing.) But it can also make you think rich people don't have problems (a not so good thing.)

NumberTheory · 16/11/2022 16:27

Having said the above, someone who has something to o moan about every time you meet up for a book club sounds annoying as fuck.

NumberTheory · 16/11/2022 16:25

I think people judge their own lives, for the most part, based on their peers and aspirations. You are more likely to notice what you want and haven’t got than other people wanting things you have got.

For instance, in the UK almost no one is so badly off they’d be considered poor compared to the world population. Even those struggling to pay bills are almost all housed one way or another, get some money from the government, have access to health care, and education for their children, etc. Have a standard of living that is higher than the majority of people in the world. I doubt they are thinking about that (and I don’t particularly think they should be) when they are ranting about how long it take to get a GP appointment or that they have to get up an hour earlier to get the bus when Jane down the road can afford a new car.

NewYorkLassie · 16/11/2022 16:25

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 16:12

Just to say some people are saying he may have had a hard childhood because he went to to boarding school.

He didn't go to boarding school.

He went to a private school. But he was a day pupil at that private school. He went home every night.

Doesn’t mean he wasn’t horrifically bullied.

And there really aren’t many wealthy farmers around nowadays.

Lopilo · 16/11/2022 16:22

Most people born in this country are more privileged than a huge number of people in the world. That doesn’t stop them complaining about their lives.

NoNameNowAgain · 16/11/2022 16:16

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 16/11/2022 15:54

Wouldn't it be worse from him to somehow make assumptions about everyone elses 'hardship ranking' and try to tailor his conversation.

No.

Exactly! Starting with the assumption that someone else is bound to have worse problems than you is a good idea.

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 16:12

Just to say some people are saying he may have had a hard childhood because he went to to boarding school.

He didn't go to boarding school.

He went to a private school. But he was a day pupil at that private school. He went home every night.

OP posts:
Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 16:10

Thehonestbadger · 16/11/2022 16:01

Did you grow up in total poverty in the U.K. though? Because if you did then realistically you’ve still had it FAR better than those born into poverty in the third world. I wonder if you even appreciated having running water, free vaccinations/healthcare and an education.

…. It’s a vicious circle OP. I appreciate my current life much more because of the challenges I’ve faced getting here BUT I don’t invalidate others struggles just because their life has been easier in comparison. There is ALWAYS someone who has had it much worse than you and it’s just toxic to compete. You never know if you’re getting the whole story and I also think people from poverty backgrounds (myself included) don’t actually understand the emotional struggles of things like being dumped in boarding school or made to constantly compete with other materialistic emotionally void rich kids. There’s loads of substance abuse, sexual abuse, eating disorder and general misery in a lot of private schools. I used to work with many privately educated people and it really opened my eyes tbh.

But your post was well written. Thanks.

OP posts:
Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 16:09

Thehonestbadger · 16/11/2022 16:01

Did you grow up in total poverty in the U.K. though? Because if you did then realistically you’ve still had it FAR better than those born into poverty in the third world. I wonder if you even appreciated having running water, free vaccinations/healthcare and an education.

…. It’s a vicious circle OP. I appreciate my current life much more because of the challenges I’ve faced getting here BUT I don’t invalidate others struggles just because their life has been easier in comparison. There is ALWAYS someone who has had it much worse than you and it’s just toxic to compete. You never know if you’re getting the whole story and I also think people from poverty backgrounds (myself included) don’t actually understand the emotional struggles of things like being dumped in boarding school or made to constantly compete with other materialistic emotionally void rich kids. There’s loads of substance abuse, sexual abuse, eating disorder and general misery in a lot of private schools. I used to work with many privately educated people and it really opened my eyes tbh.

He didn't go to boarding school. He was a day pupil at a private school

OP posts:
WhatTeaspoon · 16/11/2022 16:03

MIL can be a bit tone deaf about poverty, she isn’t poor yet but her money is running out. She grew up in a huge house with servants and then married well and remained privileged having a housekeeper and children inc my DH go to really expensive private schools. She divorced about 25 years ago. So the housekeeper went and she did do some private tutoring but she also received a couple of decent inheritances.

Even the thought of not being able to have her private dentist and medical care and not shop exclusively at Waitrose organically means she thinks she is really poor. It is a circumstance change but you would think it’s the end of the world.

readingismycardio · 16/11/2022 16:03

Hmmm... I read something really interesting in a book written by an Auschwitz survivor who became a psychotherapist after. She said that 2 clients who she has seen one after another had 2 v different types of problems (first had a v ill DD and the second got a different shade of yellow in her new Ferrari), however their brain perceived the same amount of pain/distress.

I remember having a v rich mate at uni, you should've heard his problems and the drama.

Thehonestbadger · 16/11/2022 16:01

Did you grow up in total poverty in the U.K. though? Because if you did then realistically you’ve still had it FAR better than those born into poverty in the third world. I wonder if you even appreciated having running water, free vaccinations/healthcare and an education.

…. It’s a vicious circle OP. I appreciate my current life much more because of the challenges I’ve faced getting here BUT I don’t invalidate others struggles just because their life has been easier in comparison. There is ALWAYS someone who has had it much worse than you and it’s just toxic to compete. You never know if you’re getting the whole story and I also think people from poverty backgrounds (myself included) don’t actually understand the emotional struggles of things like being dumped in boarding school or made to constantly compete with other materialistic emotionally void rich kids. There’s loads of substance abuse, sexual abuse, eating disorder and general misery in a lot of private schools. I used to work with many privately educated people and it really opened my eyes tbh.

GasPanic · 16/11/2022 15:59

Everyone has problems. It's just that your reference point moves.

It's like earnings. People on low wages look at people on high wages and think wouldn't it be great to earn that. But generally your lifestyle just expands to accommodate the amount extra you're paid, and you still have the same issues juggling things to make everything add up. It's just the things you have to juggle are stuff like pony lessons rather than whether you are going to have enough to eat.

There are people who have much more money than they need, but they are few and far between.

Swipe left for the next trending thread