Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do rich people know that they have it better than a lot of other people?

244 replies

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 14:40

I just think this is really interesting Im in a book club. In the book club is the poshest man I've ever met. Let's call him alan. He has told me his back story. His father owns a massive, massive farm. His father is also a chief director of another organisation, at the same time.
Alan went to private school. Alan plays rugby. Alan has a good job.
He is a nice enough man. But what strikes me is he is always,always complaining about his life.
And his problems are so trivial - when I know myself and alot of other people in the book club, had a far, far worse life than he did. Yet he complains the most

For example, one time he was complaining about how his father didn't help him get a job, when other peoples parents help them to get a job.

I was thinking "I didn't have a father at all", but I didn't say it. My father walked out on us when I was 3 and had nothing to do with me. I bit my tongue!

Next week Alan was complaining about the private school that he went to.

I was thinking "I grew up in total poverty, I cant feel like shedding a tear about your private school".

I don't know. He just doesn't seem to realise that he had a better life than most people I know .

Maybe really privileged people are not aware of how privileged they are? As it is all they have ever known? But surely you would know that you are better off than other people.

Maybe he just doesn't care. ?

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 17/11/2022 00:18

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 23:35

I am not in the U.K.

You have internet access, have the leisure time to join a book club, have had the opportunity to be educated so are literate and able to read, and you live where there are public libraries….so check your privilege.

Sparklybutold · 17/11/2022 00:14

I struggle with this too. I know objectively that mental health doesn't discriminate but it is difficult.

IfOnlyOCould · 17/11/2022 00:14

Maybe he was trying to make himself more relatable in a slightly misguided way. People will,have assumed his parents will have helped him get a job and people will have assumed he had a wonderful privileged time at his posh school. So, maybe, he is just trying to point out what happened.

Having money makes lots of life's problems disappear but the thought that because some people have money they don't have things to complain about is ridiculous. I wish it were true but it isn't.

Money doesn't protect you from health issues, relationship issues, self esteem issues and MH issues.

2greenroses · 17/11/2022 00:03

"Maybe really privileged people are not aware of how privileged they are? As it is all they have ever known? But surely you would know that you are better off than other people."

OP have you eaten today? Do you have access to drinking water? Do you have access to a flushing toilet? Do you sleep in a bed? Do you have electricity?

Aren't you aware how privileged you are? Cos it is all you have ever known? But surely you would know that you are better off than other people?

Maybe he just doesn't care. ?

  • *Maybe you just don't care
antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 23:54

NumberTheory · 16/11/2022 23:37

Where do you get that from, antelope?

I haven’t been involved in a few years, but it always used to be the case that older, higher socio-economic status and female were the demographic markers. Poorer people didn’t give or volunteer as often or as much.

Read it in an article in the Guardian. Older poor people give proportionately more of their income than anyone else. Well-off people may give a larger amount, but a much smaller proportion of their income.
It is the Widow

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 23:52

@audeloquipalam Very poor social skills then.

audeloquipalam · 16/11/2022 23:48

In my experience most people are focused on their own problems and give little or no thought to the “relativity” to the problems of others. Nothing to do with privilege. And these days it seems people are more self righteously self important than ever.

Mummadeze · 16/11/2022 23:44

Maybe his parents didn’t show him love or affection and this has messed him up. Being wealthy does not equate a happy upbringing.

NumberTheory · 16/11/2022 23:37

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 23:00

Older poor people are the most likely to give to charity.

Where do you get that from, antelope?

I haven’t been involved in a few years, but it always used to be the case that older, higher socio-economic status and female were the demographic markers. Poorer people didn’t give or volunteer as often or as much.

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 23:35

whumpthereitis · 16/11/2022 23:19

It’s all relative to your environment, and your own frame of reference. He’s not you, he never lived your experiences in order to understand them as ‘worse’ than his, no more than you can understand his.

it’s also not a race to the bottom. The poorest in this country could be seen as whiny and privileged, relative to the poverty experienced by someone in South Sudan, yet I’m sure they wouldn’t appreciate being told to check their privilege.

I am not in the U.K.

OP posts:
MuraRocker · 16/11/2022 23:25

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

whumpthereitis · 16/11/2022 23:19

It’s all relative to your environment, and your own frame of reference. He’s not you, he never lived your experiences in order to understand them as ‘worse’ than his, no more than you can understand his.

it’s also not a race to the bottom. The poorest in this country could be seen as whiny and privileged, relative to the poverty experienced by someone in South Sudan, yet I’m sure they wouldn’t appreciate being told to check their privilege.

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 23:00

picklemewalnuts · 16/11/2022 21:54

I was in a meeting recently where people complained that younger people were not as generous as older people, and as the older people were dying off it was getting harder to keep the charity running. I'm pleased to say the chair made a spirited defence of the pressures young people, especially those with families, can be under.

I was so cross at the entitlement of that older person, and their obliviousness to the comfort of their own position with a paid off mortgage and a pension.

#NotAllPensionersetc...

Older poor people are the most likely to give to charity.

picklemewalnuts · 16/11/2022 21:54

I was in a meeting recently where people complained that younger people were not as generous as older people, and as the older people were dying off it was getting harder to keep the charity running. I'm pleased to say the chair made a spirited defence of the pressures young people, especially those with families, can be under.

I was so cross at the entitlement of that older person, and their obliviousness to the comfort of their own position with a paid off mortgage and a pension.

#NotAllPensionersetc...

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 21:18

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/11/2022 19:29

That's not what's being said at all. Everyone can have a moan, but there's a time, a place, and a company to do it.

Moaning about your oh so tough life around people who have experienced genuine hardship is at best inconsiderate. If you don't know a person well enough to know their background I'd argue you shouldn't be moaning about your life to them at all. And if you do know them well enough you should know what sort of thing might be considered inappropriate/insensitive.

Yes! Thank you

OP posts:
Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 21:17

undernotover · 16/11/2022 18:27

Why shouldn't he get to complain just like everyone else? It's all relative

You might've grown up without a father but atleast you had a mother OP, some people are orphaned at birth.

You might've grown up poor in the UK but that's nothing compared to poverty in third world countries, do you realise how privileged you are
Hmm

It's not a race to the bottom. You don't need to compare, just make polite sympathetic noises and move on.

And fwiw I went to a private day school. It was fantastic in some ways in that it pushed me to get top grades and fulfil my academic potential. However I was bullied relentlessly, by students and some staff, it was very elitist in many ways and If you weren't one of the 'in crown' or 'favourites' you missed out on countless opportunities, and it left me with some real emotional scars. Am I never allowed to complain about any of that just cause we weren't in poverty? Or perhaps everyone's experiences deserve recognition and sympathy for crap they're dealing with even if they're privileged in other ways.

I am not in the U.K.

Why do people assume that everyone is? This is a global website.

OP posts:
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/11/2022 19:29

undernotover · 16/11/2022 18:52

It's not silencing OP at all, it's reminding OP that everyone is allowed to moan even if she had it worse by comparison. OP is the one trying to silence people by saying privileged people can't complain.

That's not what's being said at all. Everyone can have a moan, but there's a time, a place, and a company to do it.

Moaning about your oh so tough life around people who have experienced genuine hardship is at best inconsiderate. If you don't know a person well enough to know their background I'd argue you shouldn't be moaning about your life to them at all. And if you do know them well enough you should know what sort of thing might be considered inappropriate/insensitive.

undernotover · 16/11/2022 18:52

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 18:43

@undernotover I hate the phrase, race to the bottom. It is used to silence people who are poor all the time.

It's not silencing OP at all, it's reminding OP that everyone is allowed to moan even if she had it worse by comparison. OP is the one trying to silence people by saying privileged people can't complain.

NoNameNowAgain · 16/11/2022 18:48

Why shouldn't he get to complain just like everyone else? It's all relative

There’s no evidence everyone else is complaining. If the OP’s post had been “I mentioned my father left when I was three and nobody in my book group wanted to know and in fact one of them said I must have a chip on my shoulder” what would you have said? @undernotover

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 18:43

@undernotover I hate the phrase, race to the bottom. It is used to silence people who are poor all the time.

undernotover · 16/11/2022 18:27

Why shouldn't he get to complain just like everyone else? It's all relative

You might've grown up without a father but atleast you had a mother OP, some people are orphaned at birth.

You might've grown up poor in the UK but that's nothing compared to poverty in third world countries, do you realise how privileged you are
Hmm

It's not a race to the bottom. You don't need to compare, just make polite sympathetic noises and move on.

And fwiw I went to a private day school. It was fantastic in some ways in that it pushed me to get top grades and fulfil my academic potential. However I was bullied relentlessly, by students and some staff, it was very elitist in many ways and If you weren't one of the 'in crown' or 'favourites' you missed out on countless opportunities, and it left me with some real emotional scars. Am I never allowed to complain about any of that just cause we weren't in poverty? Or perhaps everyone's experiences deserve recognition and sympathy for crap they're dealing with even if they're privileged in other ways.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 16/11/2022 18:25

In my experience people who are children of wealth tend to have existed in a bubble and rarely understand the struggles of those less fortunate.

I've also found that there are a surprisingly large number of people who have become well off through their own work who do not consider themselves to be privileged, like that guy on question time who refused to believe £80k a year was a top 5% salary, and again don't seem to be able to understand how others struggle.

The latter are the one's that annoy me more.

Pythonese · 16/11/2022 18:18

FloydPepper · 16/11/2022 15:03

There’s always someone doing better than us, and always someone doing worse. It doesn’t mean your problems don’t matter or you’re not allowed to be unhappy about something.

Totally agree.

goosegrease789 · 16/11/2022 18:15

antelopevalley · 16/11/2022 18:09

Beyond a certain level yes. Many of us have not reached that level.
And it is not about new cars or anything like that. It is about choices.

Absolutely agree that financial stability brings freedom. And not everyone is at the level where they feel secure. What I was saying was, beyond a certain level where basic needs are met, it is the quality of relationships that contribute most to happiness. Whether you feel loved or not.

AHelpfulHand · 16/11/2022 18:15

I think people can only know how privileged they are, if they have been much worse off in the past.

i remember many years ago when i were at college and i needed some black trousers for a work placement thing. I didn't own any black trousers, the tutor couldn't understand why i couldn't just go and buy some.

i was walking to college and back because the bus fair was too much, could i hell as afford some black trousers. It really annoyed me.

When the schools closed for covid, there were some of us still sending our children. I was one of them, one of the PTA put on the school facebook group about how we really have to think about if we can manage at home with the children, how we were risking the staffs health sending our children in. She had her 70 year old mother arriving at hers every morning to help her daughter with her school work and how we all have to do our bit.

i remember saying to her that most of us don't have family to help and what a tone deaf post it was ect.

I grew up on a council estate and now i have a very privileged life. I appreciate it, simply because i remember what we didn't have growing up.

i do think people are very oblivious to how the other half live.