Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Do rich people know that they have it better than a lot of other people?

244 replies

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 14:40

I just think this is really interesting Im in a book club. In the book club is the poshest man I've ever met. Let's call him alan. He has told me his back story. His father owns a massive, massive farm. His father is also a chief director of another organisation, at the same time.
Alan went to private school. Alan plays rugby. Alan has a good job.
He is a nice enough man. But what strikes me is he is always,always complaining about his life.
And his problems are so trivial - when I know myself and alot of other people in the book club, had a far, far worse life than he did. Yet he complains the most

For example, one time he was complaining about how his father didn't help him get a job, when other peoples parents help them to get a job.

I was thinking "I didn't have a father at all", but I didn't say it. My father walked out on us when I was 3 and had nothing to do with me. I bit my tongue!

Next week Alan was complaining about the private school that he went to.

I was thinking "I grew up in total poverty, I cant feel like shedding a tear about your private school".

I don't know. He just doesn't seem to realise that he had a better life than most people I know .

Maybe really privileged people are not aware of how privileged they are? As it is all they have ever known? But surely you would know that you are better off than other people.

Maybe he just doesn't care. ?

OP posts:
Thurst · 17/11/2022 09:13

What many people are saying about relative poverty is correct but the OP isn't going to a book club with a load of Afghan refugees and complaining about her council house.
Alan sounds like he is unaware of his privileges. However, you on dodgy territory if you try and tell wealthy people who are abused or bereaved that it’s not as hard for them because of the practical aspects that money can help with. I’ve been poor and relatively wealthy in my life and sometimes the daily grind of surviving can be a distraction.

LisaJool · 17/11/2022 09:04

No one is saying rich people can't have a moan, but if I ever become rich I hope I have the self awareness to read the room and not hysterically cry about a broken stone Eagle and tell a person who is perhaps needing to choose between food or heat that I'm so incredibly exhausted because of it. Save it for your fellow Manor House resident who might be able to empathise.

ChessieDarling · 17/11/2022 09:02

Interesting that you use the fact he wasn’t a boarding pupil but rather a day student as some kind of further proof he had an easy time of it. You never know what goes on behind closed doors.
He does, admittedly, sound a bit of a drain, as is anyone who complains a lot, but this race to the bottom thing is never ending surely? You yourself are far more privileged than many could ever imagine being, and I know that without knowing a shred of information about you. You, also, have had your struggles in your life, as has everyone else. Where do you draw the line?
I grew up skiing every school holiday, with my own horses at home, I moved in the richer crowds and altho I didn’t go to private school, I had a good educational foundation and experience. I’m now happily married with DC, a nice home and our own successful business. Easy peasy life right? Of course I should probably mention, my father used to beat me and my siblings, and abuse my mother in every way a person can be abused. I haven’t seen him since they parted when I was 12. My mother then remarried and he was sexually abusive toward my sisters and I. I then myself got into an abusive relationship.. and subsequently left it of course. I consider myself to be lucky to have the life I have now and rarely complain, or even talk about, my childhood and adolescence. It achieves little and that is what you must focus on.
This post has got a little longwinded but the gist, I hope, is there.

NoNameNowAgain · 17/11/2022 08:32

Walkaround · 17/11/2022 08:13

It doesn’t sound like he’s asking for therapy, though - although joining a book group is seeking some kind of social connection for 100% of the people going, since it’s perfectly possible to read books without joining groups to talk about them.

It sounds to me like he’s joining in with group whingeing sessions, as the OP says he “complains the most,” not that he is the only one doing it 🤣.

I had missed that. It sounds as though others sometimes complain but he does it noticeably more. It doesn’t sound like a group whingeing session. In fact it sounds as though a lot of it he’s just telling the OP. I don’t think he’s asking for therapy just being unaware of his audience.

nickytjj · 17/11/2022 08:18

He is a kind and generous man but simply doesn’t understand the abject poverty that many people live in. He will completely wave off £50, £100 as ‘not a lot of money’…with zero understanding that people are trying to feed their families on that amount per month

how many people in the UK do you know have 50 to 100 quid to feed their family on each month?

dottiedodah · 17/11/2022 08:17

I think money while it helps obv ,doesn't just instantly wipe all problems and worries magically away.we knew a friend with a huge house with a tradesmen entrance, still got very depressed in the winters. If Alan didn't feel good about himself he will still have issues. It's not possible to compared like to like

2greenroses · 17/11/2022 08:14

I've worked as domestic help for some mega- millionaires - their children have had horrible lives, my children, with 1% of their income, have had it better

Walkaround · 17/11/2022 08:13

NoNameNowAgain · 17/11/2022 08:07

It’s a book group not group therapy. All this about everyone’s problems being trivial compared to someone else’s is true, but the conclusion that that means it’s always ok to moan about them is weird.

It doesn’t sound like he’s asking for therapy, though - although joining a book group is seeking some kind of social connection for 100% of the people going, since it’s perfectly possible to read books without joining groups to talk about them.

It sounds to me like he’s joining in with group whingeing sessions, as the OP says he “complains the most,” not that he is the only one doing it 🤣.

nickytjj · 17/11/2022 08:12

I've met other wealthy people and unless they come from nothing and work their way up they genuinely don't seem to grasp the concept of how the rest of 'us' live.
I've also found with MIL and her partner they ate NEVER content, a grand Sense of entitlement and boredom means always wanting something else

yes but the same can be said for all of us and people living in the 3rd world in dire poverty.

NoNameNowAgain · 17/11/2022 08:07

It’s a book group not group therapy. All this about everyone’s problems being trivial compared to someone else’s is true, but the conclusion that that means it’s always ok to moan about them is weird.

nickytjj · 17/11/2022 08:05

it's like asking do healthy people know they have it better than plenty of others. The answer is generally no because we genuinely can't understand our blessings until they are taken away.

We can't understand unhappiness either until something terrible comes along and it's only then when we realise what we had before was actually happiness. We are all guilty of it.

NoNameNowAgain · 17/11/2022 08:00

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Quite right too! That’s the reward for having said nothing at the time.

abmac95 · 17/11/2022 06:41

Money dosen't equal happiness. The poorest people can be happiest in some circumstances.

Squirrelvillage · 17/11/2022 06:31

Who says Alan has it better than everyone else? He had challenges and difficulties in his younger years which are different to yours but not easier to handle. Flowers

FluffyPancake · 17/11/2022 06:25

I’m only being devils advocate here so no flaming please! For Alan, his world is his reality so if his mates were being helped with a job when it would seem unfair. The fact is, he went to private school so why would he talk to you about the local comprehensive? Private schooling has its problems too. Money helps a lot in life but Alan probably isn’t the happiest guy you know, not from the description you’ve given anyway.

AgentJohnson · 17/11/2022 06:14

It's all relative.

There are people in Afghanistan who have to do an entire days hard labour just to buy a single loaf of bread.

This

whumpthereitis · 17/11/2022 05:58

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 23:35

I am not in the U.K.

No, you’re in Ireland, which isn’t comparable to South Sudan either.

JamieFrasersBigSwingingKilt · 17/11/2022 03:05

I'm rich. I'm the daughter of a self-made millionaire and I was brought up with all the privileges that brings. I've done well for myself- but it'd be surprising if I didn't, given the leg up I've had in life and the fact that I'm academically bright too.

People don't know just how wealthy I am as I don't rub it in their faces. I don't tell people where I go and what I do to avoid them feeling uncomfortable.

I'm not from another planet. The OPs post is so 'othering'. It speaks of two things: Alan being an idiot (which anyone can be regardless of financials) and OP's lack of ability to put herself in others' shoes - which is what she accuses Alan of.

In short then, wouldn't it be good if everyone had the emotional intelligence and imagination to see things from others' point of view?

BigChesterDraws · 17/11/2022 02:47

You’re in Ireland. Still very privileged compared to a large majority of the global population.

It seems you think “a good childhood” can only be achieved with money and that rich people can’t have bad childhoods. Alan may not have felt the love that you felt in childhood, may not have had a loving family. He may have been abused either by his parents or teachers at the school. He may have struggled with severe illness as a child - just because he hasn’t told you things, doesn’t mean they didn’t happen. In short, you have no idea what he went through emotionally or physically.

I pity you that you place so much importance on material things and money. How sad.

Coyoacan · 17/11/2022 02:38

I remember meeting a very privileged old woman and her fifteen-year-old daughter. They had had horrible lives, very similar to the lives of my neighbours in one of the roughest parts of Dublin. The mother had married an older man at 16, the daughter had married a coke-head at 16. The mother had become an alcoholic. But all set in a world of nannies and chauffeurs.

stormywhethers321 · 17/11/2022 02:28

It's interesting.

I used to teach at a school for children of the super-wealthy (in Russia. so mostly the children of oligarchs). And honesty, their lives were... not great. Yes, they had a lot of stuff. Yes, they could always pay the bills and they could afford some very cool experiences. But so many of them were just not happy people. A lot of older men married to younger women knowing that they were only in it for the money, a lot of dissatisfied young wives who knew they were disposable the second someone prettier came along. Kids who HATED their parents or didn't even know them. I had one student have a breakdown in class because her mother came back from Spain overnight and then left again for another country in the morning without waking her up or saying goodbye. There was an eight year old who lived alone in an apartment with paid servants - his parents didn't want to live with him. The saddest of all was the teenaged girl who just openly told me "I know my mother is a whore; I know she only married my dad for his money. So why should I listen to her?"

IMissVino · 17/11/2022 01:47

Deemarie11 · 16/11/2022 23:35

I am not in the U.K.

You keep saying this like it’s some sort of gotcha. I’ve read your other posts. You’re in Ireland. Everything posters are saying about you being more privileged than people in a lot of the world is still the case. Do you appreciate this?

Noname99 · 17/11/2022 01:42

Dontaskdontget · 16/11/2022 14:53

Everyone has stuff in their life that annoys them, and everyone complains about it. Everyone.

People on Mumsnet complain. They don’t constantly think “Thank goodness I don’t live in North Korea where I’d get sent to a concentration camp for life if my dad defected to the West so I’d better be grateful for my lot, or thank goodness I don’t live in Malawi where life expectancy is age 30, how lucky I am I’d better not complain about my DH problems on Mumsnet I mean some people have Ebola/cancer so how can I possibly do anything except celebrate every detail of my life. We complain about parenting troubles instead of thinking “Some people have no children so I’d better not complain about mine.”

Let him complain, or avoid him, but don’t sulk about his problems unless you’ve never complained about anything yourself. And just because his school was private doesn’t mean there wasn’t bullying, sexual assault etc.

This
Being rich or growing up rich doesn’t mean that you can’t have some dreadful challenges and difficulties in your life

Being poor or growing up poor doesn’t mean you get to disregard everyone else’s struggles because yours are alway worse.

LydiaBennetsUglyBonnet · 17/11/2022 01:35

FGS what is it with a race to the bottom these days?! People bursting with pride that they have it harder than others.

Having an unsupportive father can be crushing. Other people having no dads is not a comfort.

My DD is in private school and is being bullied terribly. It’s not as simple as private school = better and anyone who went should be glad they had a horrific experience.

Wanting to be in competition about having had the shittest time is a seriously unhealthy place to be in, and completely narrow minded to assume money means you should STFU about your experiences.

Princes William and Harry lost their mum in sudden and tragic circumstances as children and had to tolerate crying loons in their face in the days following. I certainly don’t think “Well at least she wasn’t poor” when I think of that

antelopevalley · 17/11/2022 00:25

Sparklybutold · 17/11/2022 00:14

I struggle with this too. I know objectively that mental health doesn't discriminate but it is difficult.

It does. If you are part of an oppressed group or in poverty, you are at a higher risk of mental health problems.