Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people should stop comparing older infertility to younger.

209 replies

Laneyy · 16/11/2022 11:22

Preparing to be flamed It's very sad when someone cannot conceive aged 40+ but to compared to someone in their 20s/30s isn't fair. Especially when the infertility is secondary It's very likely if the 40+ year old would have tried 5-15 years ago they wouldn't have problems conceiving. So many people try to deny the biological clock but sadly fertility does decline in people in their 40s. I understand people do get naturally pregnant in their 40s but stasticially it's rarer than people in their 30s and 20s.

OP posts:
Laneyy · 16/11/2022 15:37

Cuppasoupmonster · 16/11/2022 15:21

There’s also the issue of donor eggs. It seems to be a natural progression from unsuccessful IVF now. But it brings huge ethical and emotional complexities. It’s confusing that on MN women are urged to reconsider or think through pregnancies because they’re from a one night stand, or because the dad is an arsehole - ‘How do you think the baby will feel about that growing up?’. But ask the same question about donor conception, even respectfully, and it’s all ‘Biscuit’ or ‘ODFOD’.

I do find that weird why is a ONS so unacceptable on here but a donor perfectly fine even encouraged? My OH is my DDs father so not relatable but I could see women would choose to continue a pregnancy from a ONS.

OP posts:
EndlessRain · 16/11/2022 15:34

Laneyy · 16/11/2022 15:18

I'm not being smug if I had listened to society or MN I would have probably ended up childless or with a long battle . I have a good career , a owned home , go on multiple holidays. My life turned out fine despite having my DD young, it didn't ruin my life. You never know what's round the corner. I don't think there's ever a 100 percent perfect time to have a baby.

At my consultation with gynaecology when asked if I wanted more children. I said I wouldn't be utterly heartbroken because I already have been blessed with one.

So it is an "I told you so"/ "I was right you were wrong point"? Well done for making a decision that was right for you. It still comes across smug to essentially say "I did it when I was young - even though everyone told me not to - and therefore I am not childless. You didn't therefore you are and I don't feel sorry for you. I was right you were wrong".

DarkShade · 16/11/2022 15:30

I really really doubt that this is a good faith thread.

Nothing1234 · 16/11/2022 15:24

I'm 40 and currently TTC. Am I aware it probably won't work due to my age? Yes. Would I have preferred to have done this earlier? Yes.

I wanted children for as long as I can remember. But I never met anyone to have them with when I was younger. Should I have had unprotected sex with a random? Someone I didn't like and knew i wouldn't be with? Should I have had it while I was earning minimum wage living with parents?

I was with someone at 29 who said they loved me and wanted a family with me. I got pregnant accidentally and he turned on me. I miscarried anyway but that relationship was over. I found it hard to find and trust someone for a long time after that.

I have a lovely house and well paid career. Would I say to someone who didn't have those things at 40 because they had children young "well what did you expect by doing that?" No I wouldn't.
I find it horrible that people judge older women TTC. I'm sure there are some people out there who don't realise at 40+ it'll be hard/ wont work. But I can guarantee you that the majority know. And they wish they could done it younger.

Saying that it hurts more when younger is bollocks. It hurt in my 20s that I never met anyone and that when I did i miscarried and he left. It hurt in my 30s that I still hadn't found anyone. It's hurting now I have found someone but it's likely too late.

I'd have given anything to have had children younger. But life didn't work out that way. So I'm trying now. Whether it will work or not who knows.

Cuppasoupmonster · 16/11/2022 15:21

There’s also the issue of donor eggs. It seems to be a natural progression from unsuccessful IVF now. But it brings huge ethical and emotional complexities. It’s confusing that on MN women are urged to reconsider or think through pregnancies because they’re from a one night stand, or because the dad is an arsehole - ‘How do you think the baby will feel about that growing up?’. But ask the same question about donor conception, even respectfully, and it’s all ‘Biscuit’ or ‘ODFOD’.

Laneyy · 16/11/2022 15:18

Cuppasoupmonster · 16/11/2022 14:50

No, I think she has a point. It’s never really the right time to have a baby, but I feel some people who look disparagingly on ‘younger’ (under 30 these days) mums because ‘they didn’t have the perfect man/job/house that I’m waiting for’, may not feel the same way some years down the line.

Out of 100 women who were in my year group at school (grammar, very middle class), I think only 10% of us have children. We’re in our early 30s. Many of my friends still ‘feel too young’ or ‘wouldn’t have time’ for a baby. Which is fine - but I don’t think they’re actually aware of what’s going on with their ovaries. They think because they wear fashionable clothes and feel 22 that their bodies are the same. They’re not.

Of course for most of them things will work out and they will have a baby or two. But they will run a much higher risk of miscarriages, stressful high risk pregnancies, emergency caesareans and no luxury of time afterwards to decide if they want another. All the late 30s new mums I know started trying again when the baby was 6 months old ‘because time isn’t on our side’.

I know a few people disapproved when I got pregnant with DD in my mid 20s, but she’s now over 3 and I feel I’ve really enjoyed her younger years rather than rushing to have another. Now nearly 20 weeks pregnant with number 2 and feel ready to do it all again.

And it isn’t ‘smugness’ any more than somebody in a great career or relationship recommending what worked for them. I don’t want my friends to miss out on something because society was too busy ‘not being judgemental’ to be honest with them.

I'm not being smug if I had listened to society or MN I would have probably ended up childless or with a long battle . I have a good career , a owned home , go on multiple holidays. My life turned out fine despite having my DD young, it didn't ruin my life. You never know what's round the corner. I don't think there's ever a 100 percent perfect time to have a baby.

At my consultation with gynaecology when asked if I wanted more children. I said I wouldn't be utterly heartbroken because I already have been blessed with one.

OP posts:
sneezingpandamum · 16/11/2022 15:16

I do agree OP but it's an inconvenient truth that many don't want to hear

I don't think if you are struggling to conceive over age 40 that you are "infertile"....you are just old (in fertility terms) and I don't think it can be compared to someone decades younger who is also struggling to conceive

There is a reason why IVF isn't funded by the NHS in women in their 40s it's because the success rates are woeful because they are biologically past peak fertility

BarbiesDreamHouse · 16/11/2022 15:14

Obviously wanting children and not being able to have them is awful at any age and some level of struggle to conceive at a more advanced age is an expectation rather than a surprise to most people.

ghostyslovesheets · 16/11/2022 15:13

I hate the phrase ‘women are choosing’ like they could do it at 20 but couldn’t be arsed

i didn’t meet a man I wanted to HAVE children with until I was 30

but it just feeds into the sly narrative that’s it’s all about ambitious career driven harpies putting it off for financial gain tut tut - nasty stuff

Rosethorne66 · 16/11/2022 15:12

In biological terms, fertility decreases significantly at 40+. The responses by women here seem to be be very specific to their own situations, however looking at it from a general perspective and not in isolation, the facts are that biological reproduction decreases as age increases. Its sad regardless of when someone is infertile, but it shouldn't be a surprise for someone who is older if they struggle to conceive. This doesn't negate their pain, but I think more education should be given to women who think fertility is a guarantee or easy when they wish to start trying etc. Moral of the story us, if you can have kids younger, and you want them, then have them sooner rather than later. Of course, before anyone says what about if I don't have partner etc, then that's just the way it goes, again, this is a majority perspective not individual circumstances.

WhatNoRaisins · 16/11/2022 15:02

Our society has real issues with the concept of aging. It's almost like we think we can ward it off with the right attitude and staying hip and cool.

LizzieW1969 · 16/11/2022 15:02

Dreamingcats · 16/11/2022 12:18

Nasty thread. I didn't start trying until my late 30s because I hadn't met anyone. Had years of being single which I also found painful. Not everyone who leaves it later had a choice of timing.

Fertility troubles are always heartbreaking. Why is it difficult to sympathise with anyone going through it?

I agree. I went through a very similar journey to you, though I married younger than you, at 33. I was infertile, no eggs; whether it would have been different if I’d met my DH sooner who can tell? I suspect not, though. (We’ve since adopted and have 2 DDs of 13 and 10.)

Why make comparisons? Infertility is always very painful whatever the age!

HollaHolla · 16/11/2022 15:01

I tried to get pregnant from the age of 34. I didn't try before then, because I hadn't met someone I wanted to have kids with. By the time I was 43, we'd tried pretty much everything - NHS and private. I had two miscarriages, but never a pregnancy that lasted beyond 14 weeks.

In what way would you think I was/am ok with that? It didn't get easier as I got older; it got worse... Y'know, because of the added pressure of knowing that time was running out....

Oh, and my relationship broke up because of all of the pressures/stresses on trying to have a baby.

Sparklesocks · 16/11/2022 14:58

Infertility is painful at any age, I don’t think it’s anyone else’s place to dictate who is more worthy of feeling pain based on their age. I don’t see how anyone could possibly benefit from saying stuff like this unless they just enjoy being contrary for their own amusement.

ancientgran · 16/11/2022 14:54

emptythelitterbox · 16/11/2022 14:41

Agree. The subject of human biology isn't being taught well.

It's a shame as it's one of the most interesting fields of science.
Not just reproduction but how all the systems work, organs, blood, bones, etc.

I think the way that people are taught about contraception does make it seem like getting pregnant is the easiest thing in the world when it often isn't.

GingerKombucha · 16/11/2022 14:51

I would be very careful about telling your daughter to freeze eggs. I froze my eggs at 32, defrosted them to use at 37 and they all died, couldn't be used at all. Infertility at any age is heartbreaking. Being cheated on and then dumped by a long term partner and fiancee, then having to recover from this meant I was 35 before I met my partner. I know people who haven't manged to conceive in their late 30s because they've been trying since their 20s, because their husband has died, because relationships fell apart and all sorts. Give everyone sympathy and compassion rather than try to compare suffering.

Cuppasoupmonster · 16/11/2022 14:50

EndlessRain · 16/11/2022 14:01

IT sounds like you just want to be smug that you continued with the pregnancy. A kind of "told you so" to prove you were right to make the decision you did.
And you probaby were. For you. But that doesn't give you any kind of entitlement to judge other women and their age or fertility. Which is exactly what you are doing.

No, I think she has a point. It’s never really the right time to have a baby, but I feel some people who look disparagingly on ‘younger’ (under 30 these days) mums because ‘they didn’t have the perfect man/job/house that I’m waiting for’, may not feel the same way some years down the line.

Out of 100 women who were in my year group at school (grammar, very middle class), I think only 10% of us have children. We’re in our early 30s. Many of my friends still ‘feel too young’ or ‘wouldn’t have time’ for a baby. Which is fine - but I don’t think they’re actually aware of what’s going on with their ovaries. They think because they wear fashionable clothes and feel 22 that their bodies are the same. They’re not.

Of course for most of them things will work out and they will have a baby or two. But they will run a much higher risk of miscarriages, stressful high risk pregnancies, emergency caesareans and no luxury of time afterwards to decide if they want another. All the late 30s new mums I know started trying again when the baby was 6 months old ‘because time isn’t on our side’.

I know a few people disapproved when I got pregnant with DD in my mid 20s, but she’s now over 3 and I feel I’ve really enjoyed her younger years rather than rushing to have another. Now nearly 20 weeks pregnant with number 2 and feel ready to do it all again.

And it isn’t ‘smugness’ any more than somebody in a great career or relationship recommending what worked for them. I don’t want my friends to miss out on something because society was too busy ‘not being judgemental’ to be honest with them.

ancientgran · 16/11/2022 14:46

Breadcrumbsforall · 16/11/2022 12:54

I think you're misunderstanding the term 'precious pregnancy'. It doesn't mean your baby is any less or more important than any other; it simply refers to how long it's taken TTC, any medical problems etc. My pregnancy was classed as 'precious' after many years of infertility, but that was down to my medical history.

I had a 15 year gap, it is still an unpleasant thing to say when someone is going through a threatened miscarriage or a miscarriage. What does precious imply?

The other woman was in the bed next to me, she'd have been at school 15 years earlier so I don't think how long she'd been trying was the issue.

Softplayhooray · 16/11/2022 14:44

dinnertonightt · 16/11/2022 11:25

Mumsnet isn't going to like this one.

However I do agree with you.

Me too I agree with you OP.

Of course, both are painful, and I wouldn't minimise either. But yes I think they aren't the same.

emptythelitterbox · 16/11/2022 14:41

Ponesta · 16/11/2022 14:15

I think we need to ensure that young women are educated on how fertility decreases with age and that it is much harder to get pregnant in your forties than in your twenties. I know three women in their 40s who have recently tried to have children. One had no problems, another had IVF and the third has not been able to conceive. She has had an amazing life, with a great career and lots of wonderful holidays, and she just saw this as the next stage of her life. She's been told that her age is against her and she's absolutely heartbroken. It never occurred to her that it would be a problem. She just wishes she could turn the clock back. I am so sorry for her, as it's devastating.

We do need to ensure that women are educated on this. When I was born in the late 1960s my mother was the oldest mother (by a long way) in the maternity ward. She was 36.

Agree. The subject of human biology isn't being taught well.

It's a shame as it's one of the most interesting fields of science.
Not just reproduction but how all the systems work, organs, blood, bones, etc.

Onnabugeisha · 16/11/2022 14:37

SarahAndQuack · 16/11/2022 14:32

This just strikes me as really silly. You can't draw comparisons without being aware of contrasts.

The act of comparing is to consider or describe two things as similar, equal, or analogous; to liken. The act of contrasting is to set in opposition in order to show or emphasize differences.

You are not comparing when you note differences, you are contrasting.

You can't draw comparisons without being aware of contrasts. this is beside the point as in yes your brain automatically does both, but the question wasn’t asking for both, just comparing.

GabriellaMontez · 16/11/2022 14:35

Who does compare? This op is the first time I've seen a comparison. I think it's crass.

SarahAndQuack · 16/11/2022 14:32

Onnabugeisha · 16/11/2022 14:27

I think I have understood the question opposite to the majority of people on MN.
I am a very literal person though

To think people should stop comparing older infertility to younger.?

I voted YABU.

Because comparing is to look at two things and focus on their similarities. So what’s wrong about looking at infertility at any age and saying they have way more similarities than differences and so deserve same compassion?

Everyone seems to be interpreting the question as is it wrong to contrast (not compare) older infertility to younger? Which is the look at two things and focus on the differences between them in order to justify different reactions/levels of compassion that everyone seems to be understanding the question as asking, even though in the literal sense; it isn’t asking that.

This just strikes me as really silly. You can't draw comparisons without being aware of contrasts.

Onnabugeisha · 16/11/2022 14:28

AryaStarkWolf · 16/11/2022 12:01

Yes I think there is something wrong with comparing the two, I mean for what reason would you do that? To tell an older woman her pain isn't as bad as a younger womans? Why?

That’s not what compare means, that would be contrasting, not comparing, see my longer explanation above.

Onnabugeisha · 16/11/2022 14:27

I think I have understood the question opposite to the majority of people on MN.
I am a very literal person though

To think people should stop comparing older infertility to younger.?

I voted YABU.

Because comparing is to look at two things and focus on their similarities. So what’s wrong about looking at infertility at any age and saying they have way more similarities than differences and so deserve same compassion?

Everyone seems to be interpreting the question as is it wrong to contrast (not compare) older infertility to younger? Which is the look at two things and focus on the differences between them in order to justify different reactions/levels of compassion that everyone seems to be understanding the question as asking, even though in the literal sense; it isn’t asking that.