Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being honest, if it didn't hurt anyone would you want this?

314 replies

Blubba · 16/11/2022 09:45

I was thinking about this last night and although I absolutely love my husband, if I knew it wouldn't hurt him, I'd love to have a more open relationship and I wondered how many people would also prefer that if they knew it wouldn't cause upset / hurt to their spouse or partner?

In reality, my husband would never agree and so I'd never bring it up as I know it would cause an issue the fact I'd even brought it up but in an alternate universe where it wouldn't cause any upset, I think I'd prefer it to a complete monogamy.

Anyone else?

YABU - Even if I could do so without causing any problems in my relationship, I still wouldn't.

YANBU - I would prefer a more open relationship IF it didn't affect my current relationship/marriage.

OP posts:
CantFindTheBeat · 16/11/2022 14:07

@Pleasecreateausername13

I'm 100% monogamous and so is my DH (some might say we are a bit dull, even!) but I have to challenge you on your emphatic statement.

Of course some people enjoy open relationships of varying sorts whilst still loving their partners. We are not all the same.

I think its a bit silly if you to claim to know how the entire human race thinks.

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 14:04

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/11/2022 13:59

No, it sounds bleak.

And I can’t help thinking of that swinging couple in ‘Benidorm’.

Grin I must admit Alan Partridge keeps popping in my head "they're sex people, Lynn"!

There's a difference between swinging and an open relationship isn't there? The former being more "partner/ wife swapping, group sex as part of a couple" the other meaning having one or more sexual relationships outside the marriage.?

Pocketfullofdogtreats · 16/11/2022 14:04

The time to play the field is before you make those vows to one person. Sex within a relationship with someone you've made a commitment to is special, even if it's not the same most amazing sex you've ever had. I expect to keep my vows and I expect DH to keep his.

JaneFondue · 16/11/2022 14:04

Lost my love for Neil Gaiman a bit. Not because he had an open marriage but because he wouldn't stop talking about how much better it made them than anyone else. Then they had a weird public breakdown and divorce

DesignerRecliner · 16/11/2022 14:02

I absolutely adore flirting with men and women. It makes me feel confident and can help with work matters going in my favour (zero shame - some men are easy to manipulate!) but it absolutely stops there.

My DH is my world, my partner and my best friend. It would destroy me to hurt him and I'm fairly confident he feels the same way. DH knows I'm only interested in him. So no; I wouldn't be interested in this.

littlepeas · 16/11/2022 14:00

LovelyBitOfSquirrel69 · 16/11/2022 10:10

God no, I can barely be arsed with one man, never mind more.

I'm in this gang!

BigMandsTattooPortfolio · 16/11/2022 13:59

No, it sounds bleak.

And I can’t help thinking of that swinging couple in ‘Benidorm’.

IfOnlyLifeCameWithAManual · 16/11/2022 13:58

To be honest if it didn't hurt anyone then, yes, I would. But in my experience it hurt everyone, my husband, my other partner and her husband. Absolute nightmare.

peachgreen · 16/11/2022 13:57

I’ve done both. Monogamy (with my late DH) was better. More contentment, less anxiety and better sex.

HedgehogB · 16/11/2022 13:57

This is very interesting. DH had an open relationship with full consent on both sides, during his first marriage. They carried on like this for ten years. As long as the other knew what was happening it was fine. Until he took it too far with somebody a lot closer to home (a sort of relative of hers) and they split up. Fair enough he was in the wrong. But they’d been blurring the boundaries for a long time IMO. Now open relationships are completely not ok with me, and DH and I are agreed. He feels he is older for a start and part of his initial problem had been that she was his first sexual partner and he hadn’t sown any wild oats. Also, she never orgasmed (with him) despite their so called adventurousness. He didn’t feel particularly loved. The fact that I do enjoy our sex life , he likes a lot. He says he loves me and could never ever contemplate sharing me like he did before. I trust him (tbh he works at home and I always know where he is. I was freaked out in the early years but the trust grew) Only with years of hindsight (which is where I’m going with this) he realises they had an open relationship because they were not sexually compatible and not in love . OP you may not love him. Don’t do this .

NiceParkingSpotRitaThanksJanet · 16/11/2022 13:51

OoooohMatron · 16/11/2022 13:34

Came on to say exactly this! Sounds exhausting.

Agreed!

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 13:50

There are people, male and female, who go into swinging for the wrong reasons - to keep their relationship, to fix their sex lives, to control their partner, but they’re not genuine swingers.

They’re no different to the people who have a sticking plaster baby when they know the relationship is doomed, or who get married after 20 years to try and fix things.

They’re absolutely not the norm though. They’re very much in the minority, and they don’t tend to be around the lifestyle for very long because it simply doesn’t work (in the same way other desperate measures don’t work).

ComtesseDeSpair · 16/11/2022 13:44

I think “your own experience” and what you suspect based on your own thoughts is an absolutely fine way to approach the choices you make for your own relationships. All power to you for making relationship choices which are right for you. Your experience doesn’t reflect how I feel or have ever felt, though.

The more than one child is a good comparison. I’ll be honest: for a long time I assumed that’s why people had more than one child, because they were a bit disappointed with the first one. Why bother going through the stress and pain and tiredness and all the crap a second time if you truly loved your first child?

However, enough parents readily say that this is not their experience. That they had a second child because it enhances their family, and because love expands rather than diminishes. And I believe them. I don’t tell them that they’re kidding themselves, because I can’t conceive of what they say being how they feel. And I’d appreciate their acknowledgement in return that, whilst they can’t imagine feeling the same way, for me having more than one sexual partner enhances my life in the way having more than one child does theirs.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2022 13:40

@ComtesseDeSpair

I can’t think of anything worse than pushing a small human out of my vagina, possibly destroying my body in the process, and then having to be responsible for it for the next two decades. But it clearly brings many people great joy, so all power to them. And I don’t wander onto threads in the childbirth section and post “Ewwwww!” in response to posters planning a vaginal birth; or the IVF section to tell posters their infertility is god’s way of telling them to be childfree; or TTC section to tell people planning their second baby that I think it’s a shame their first child isn’t enough for them, that they clearly don’t love it enough if they feel the need to have a second child, how sad etc.

Fair enough. I'm pretty sure I've never gone "ewww" at the prospect of non monogamous relationships. Each to their own and I've said several times it's not a moral standpoint from me.

My point is rather than I suspect that a lot people who think a lot about sex with people other than their partner actually deep down don't really want to be with their partner at all any more but haven't fully allowed themselves to acknowledge this. I'm sure there is a subset of people who genuinely love person A but think about shagging persons B, C and D a lot. And I'm prepared to be shot down as a misogynist but based on my own experience and a lot of anecdata based on conversations with my friends over the years, I think very few women actually really want this.

In my experience wanting to have sex with a lot of people who aren't your partner is often an early warning sign from the subconscious that your official partner is no longer cutting it for you. But then I'm also someone who believes in getting out when the going is good, I don't believe in "in sickness and in health" or "working through problems" or any of that guff. Make hay while the sun shines, leave when it stops.

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 13:39

We’ve been swingers for the vast majority of our relationship (I was before we met, he wasn’t).

You’re very right not to bring it up if you know it’ll hurt your husband OP. We’ve seen many couples split up, or come very close to doing so, over the years because one of them has agreed to it without really wanting to. It’s a very quick way to destroy a relationship if it’s not a mutual thing, and even if it is mutual then when people have different ideas and boundaries it can be really problematic.

OoooohMatron · 16/11/2022 13:34

LovelyBitOfSquirrel69 · 16/11/2022 10:10

God no, I can barely be arsed with one man, never mind more.

Came on to say exactly this! Sounds exhausting.

Lockheart · 16/11/2022 13:33

Not for me but if everyone is happy, consenting, and of age, and as long as all rules and boundaries are clearly communicated then go nuts. None of my business as far as I'm concerned.

No need for the childish "ewwww" or pious spouting about God or morality. It doesn't affect anyone else but those involved.

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 13:31

Ivylight · 16/11/2022 12:50

We do, because we can without negatively affecting our relationship. It simply isn't true that people who do this don't really love each other or don't really want to be together. Maybe that's the case for some people but it isn't always. My husband and I are committed to each other and love each other, and intend to stay together forever. We've been together 18 years and open for 5.

I feel genuinely pleased for him when he has a nice experience elsewhere which is something I never expected before we did this. He feels the same for me. I used to be a fairly jealous person and still can be in some respects - but not in this one. Which is still fascinating to me. I think if he is seeing someone I know exactly what it's about which negates the insecurity. So for me I've learnt my insecurities are around fear of hidden desires and impulses. When I know about them, they disappear.

There are also many layers and for us it is not just about sex, sex is probably somewhat down the list.

It sounds like bullshit but it's not for me. It's been something we done very carefully with very high levels of honest communication though. Looking at many other relationships around us, being strictly monogamous appears to be barely protective against cheating/betrayal/lying at all.

From your description, it sounds as though you find some security in knowing who your husband is shagging, and it being on agreed terms?

you seem to be under the assumption that he’d cheat anyway so you’d rather this way? I mean you say you used to feel jealous and insecure, you think most men cheat so this is your way of coping with that?

i feel a bit sad reading it ☹️

ComtesseDeSpair · 16/11/2022 13:29

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2022 13:22

@ComtesseDeSpair

Is it because it’s about sex and so many women are still conditioned to think of sex as a bit dirty and disgusting but just about acceptable to them if they have to have it at all in the particular construct of a monogamous relationship? Is it good old fashioned slut shaming towards women admitting they enjoy sex and will have it on their terms, in a way they choose? Why does it enrage some people so much?

I can't speak for others and there may be an element of this for some people.

but from my perspective its mainly bemusement at the idea that you would want to maintain an official LTR with one person if you want to shag others.

It's not out of some moral objection, it's just that the whole business of maintaining a relationship is so burdensome at the best of times, even if its a good relationship, I can't see for the life of me why anyone would have the energy to do this and also have several others on the go at the same time.

Relationships can be hard work and a lot of them are really pretty over-rated. I believe most people, deep down, are happier on their own than in LTRs but remain in them out of a combination of financial and social expediency and habit with a heavy veneer of thinking that's what everyone should do.

The only possible reason (other than financial dependence) that I can see for remaining in one would be that the person you are with enhances your life so much that you can't imagine being without them. If you have the desire to sleep with others outside that relationship it sort of negates the point of all the other grief. But that's just me.

I think it’s fine to have a viewpoint from your own perspective and to acknowledge that having more than one partner wouldn’t work for you, because you find maintaining relationships burdensome; but it’s insulting and odd to insist that others must feel the same way as you do, even if they tell you otherwise.

I can’t think of anything worse than pushing a small human out of my vagina, possibly destroying my body in the process, and then having to be responsible for it for the next two decades. But it clearly brings many people great joy, so all power to them. And I don’t wander onto threads in the childbirth section and post “Ewwwww!” in response to posters planning a vaginal birth; or the IVF section to tell posters their infertility is god’s way of telling them to be childfree; or TTC section to tell people planning their second baby that I think it’s a shame their first child isn’t enough for them, that they clearly don’t love it enough if they feel the need to have a second child, how sad etc.

encantorerun · 16/11/2022 13:28

Posted too soon

I don't think I've ever been in the presence of a man wishing I could just rip his clothes off.

It's the falling in love part that drives the desire - for me anyway, understand that everyone is different.

I wasn't a virgin when I met DH but every partner I'd had before was one where significant feelings and a relationship had been involved.

Benes · 16/11/2022 13:27

Yes.
I'm a member of a club for bi-sexual /bi-curious women.
They organise the most amazing parties but a group of us also meet up for nights out a few times a year either as a group or on a 'date' with one other woman.

I've met some wonderful women along the way

EndlessRain · 16/11/2022 13:26

I was talking about this with my sister who likes the idea of this. She likes the idea of a main partner to live and raise a family with, and then someone to have sex with without the worries, burdens and connections of family life.

I can objectively see the appeal if everyone is happy but (1) I think very rarely is everyone genuinely happy, very often I think on some level someone would rather be in a monogamous relationship but there is a an element of keep the other(s) happy and (2) subjectively I think I would struggle not to create a main bond with one partner and go off the other. I am a bit of an "all in" type of person and have never been able to have a "just sex" relationship (I either go off the person or develop feelings for them). So it wouldn't work for me.

encantorerun · 16/11/2022 13:25

I was never interested in sleeping around before I met DH - so nothing has changed for me. I dont think it's anything to do with monogamy - I just never did it, and I never wanted to do it.

I don't think

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2022 13:22

@ComtesseDeSpair

Is it because it’s about sex and so many women are still conditioned to think of sex as a bit dirty and disgusting but just about acceptable to them if they have to have it at all in the particular construct of a monogamous relationship? Is it good old fashioned slut shaming towards women admitting they enjoy sex and will have it on their terms, in a way they choose? Why does it enrage some people so much?

I can't speak for others and there may be an element of this for some people.

but from my perspective its mainly bemusement at the idea that you would want to maintain an official LTR with one person if you want to shag others.

It's not out of some moral objection, it's just that the whole business of maintaining a relationship is so burdensome at the best of times, even if its a good relationship, I can't see for the life of me why anyone would have the energy to do this and also have several others on the go at the same time.

Relationships can be hard work and a lot of them are really pretty over-rated. I believe most people, deep down, are happier on their own than in LTRs but remain in them out of a combination of financial and social expediency and habit with a heavy veneer of thinking that's what everyone should do.

The only possible reason (other than financial dependence) that I can see for remaining in one would be that the person you are with enhances your life so much that you can't imagine being without them. If you have the desire to sleep with others outside that relationship it sort of negates the point of all the other grief. But that's just me.

JaneFondue · 16/11/2022 13:22

Benes · 16/11/2022 13:20

Honestly who has the fucking time to put up with yet another man?

I don't want another man. I like meeting up with other women though.

For sex?

Swipe left for the next trending thread