Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being honest, if it didn't hurt anyone would you want this?

314 replies

Blubba · 16/11/2022 09:45

I was thinking about this last night and although I absolutely love my husband, if I knew it wouldn't hurt him, I'd love to have a more open relationship and I wondered how many people would also prefer that if they knew it wouldn't cause upset / hurt to their spouse or partner?

In reality, my husband would never agree and so I'd never bring it up as I know it would cause an issue the fact I'd even brought it up but in an alternate universe where it wouldn't cause any upset, I think I'd prefer it to a complete monogamy.

Anyone else?

YABU - Even if I could do so without causing any problems in my relationship, I still wouldn't.

YANBU - I would prefer a more open relationship IF it didn't affect my current relationship/marriage.

OP posts:
Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2022 15:42

@ComtesseDeSpair

It’s also more accurate to say that monogamy has rarely, until relatively recently, been expected of men. That men would have courtesans, mistresses, visit prostitutes and generally just, you know, boys will be boys sowing their wild oats, was the accepted norm in virtually every society globally for centuries; despite those societies expecting (and indeed, often enforcing) monogamy of women.

This is very true and very relevant.

I guess a lot of these "models" for committed relationships which allow for some sexual openness seek in some ways to replicate this in a more equitable way. Which is understandable.

The problem is that I think in the days when men were not monogamous and women were, very little emotional fidelity was expected of either men or women. The woman's job was not to shag around and to raise the offspring of the marriage competently (guaranteeing the man a healthy and pure bloodline). The man's job started and ended with providing for the woman and offspring. That was where the responsibility ended on both sides. No one gave a flying fuck about whether the partners satisfied their respective emotional needs.

It seems to me that the polyamory model seeks to allow sexual freedom within a framework of emotional fidelity but I'm not sure it quite works. I'm no particular fan of marriage: I think very often it uses a sledgehammer to crack a nut and the intertwining of financial dependency with sexual fidelity is toxic in many cases. But I am not convinced that long-term emotional dependence can coexist with multiple sexual partners.

ComtesseDeSpair · 16/11/2022 15:40

toomuchlaundry · 16/11/2022 15:39

@InPraiseOfBacchus I assume if someone goes to a swingers party and gets pregnant then it would be some random at a party.

And @CloseYourEyesAndSee the majority of pregnancies on MN seem to be down to contraception failures!

But like many women who find themselves pregnant in a far from ideal situation of any type, they’d have an abortion, surely?

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 15:40

Crazykatie · 16/11/2022 15:34

A group of 4 school mums were in a swinging group it lasted about 4 months and one by one divorce followed, it really is not a smart move, there is always someone it doesn’t work for.

They clearly weren’t actual swingers. No-one with an ounce of sense would actually do that.

toomuchlaundry · 16/11/2022 15:39

@InPraiseOfBacchus I assume if someone goes to a swingers party and gets pregnant then it would be some random at a party.

And @CloseYourEyesAndSee the majority of pregnancies on MN seem to be down to contraception failures!

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 15:38

I get the impression that swinging is a lot of work; in establishing boundaries, getting a balance right and the fact that one partner might change their mind and so on. I can see a lot of potential pitfalls.

A poster up thread said they met their husband whilst swinging. I thought swinging was defined as seeking sex from others while being in a committed relationship so I guess sometimes people meet their soul mate “accidentally “whilst swinging and decide to leave their current relationship?

Kitcaterpillar · 16/11/2022 15:37

Crazykatie · 16/11/2022 15:34

A group of 4 school mums were in a swinging group it lasted about 4 months and one by one divorce followed, it really is not a smart move, there is always someone it doesn’t work for.

I mean, this is clearly mental?

And also the reason I won't justify myself. I'm not being lumped in with these lunatics!

ReneBumsWombats · 16/11/2022 15:34

BigSkies2022 · 16/11/2022 15:29

Marriage is a financial contract.

I'm not saying it's a good idea to marry someone you don't love or don't want to sleep with, but it's not at all unusual to marry for security.

Sorry, don't know how to put PP into quotes.
Yes, I agree there are financial rights and obligations attached to marriage. But I know of several couples who specifically didn't want to marry (gay, straight, mostly second wave feminists/left-leaning sorts from the sixties and seventies), who nevertheless made their own arrangements to ensure that property, pensions, life insurance, etc were all organised so that each partner would be secure financially in the event of break-up/death, and who extended their sex lives to additional partners. They wanted a non-monogamous relationship, they wanted NOT to be married, but to provide lifelong emotional and practical support and security to each other, while remaining open to other sexual partners.

So there are other models available for relationships. I'm suggesting that the OP might choose that path, and put in the work to create such a relationship with a willing partner. Rather than opt for marriage, as it's 'off the peg', so to speak, and then go, 'Oh, but I don't want that part of it.'

Civil partnerships are the best option if you want to remove all elements of sexuality from the legal aspects of the relationship.

However, you cannot fully duplicate marriage/CPs outside of having one. You may set up your affairs in a way that works for you, but it won't be the same. There are various rights and protections unique to them.

It isn't always the best option for people for various reasons. But you can't duplicate it without doing it.

Crazykatie · 16/11/2022 15:34

A group of 4 school mums were in a swinging group it lasted about 4 months and one by one divorce followed, it really is not a smart move, there is always someone it doesn’t work for.

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 15:32

Thanks for your honesty. 😁

InPraiseOfBacchus · 16/11/2022 15:32

@toomuchlaundry

I'd give an answer, but, be honest, that wasn't really a question, was it? It was an implicit statement of "poly people are gross and have broods of unplanned, confused, illegitimate children", wasn't it?

It's not the gross generalisations that get me - it's the assumption that people like us are easy targets that I find really exhausting.

ReneBumsWombats · 16/11/2022 15:31

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 15:27

Imo it’s no different.

To other people it’s akin to child abuse.

On that thread there was a definite suggestion, by more than one poster, that swingers/anyone poly were sex craved morons who’d ultimately inevitably end up inviting predators to their home and endanger their neglected children.

Yeah, I've seen that. Also an assumption that they're OW who clearly shag married men behind the wives' backs and even if they aren't, they obviously wouldn't care if they were.

BigSkies2022 · 16/11/2022 15:29

Marriage is a financial contract.

I'm not saying it's a good idea to marry someone you don't love or don't want to sleep with, but it's not at all unusual to marry for security.

Sorry, don't know how to put PP into quotes.
Yes, I agree there are financial rights and obligations attached to marriage. But I know of several couples who specifically didn't want to marry (gay, straight, mostly second wave feminists/left-leaning sorts from the sixties and seventies), who nevertheless made their own arrangements to ensure that property, pensions, life insurance, etc were all organised so that each partner would be secure financially in the event of break-up/death, and who extended their sex lives to additional partners. They wanted a non-monogamous relationship, they wanted NOT to be married, but to provide lifelong emotional and practical support and security to each other, while remaining open to other sexual partners.

So there are other models available for relationships. I'm suggesting that the OP might choose that path, and put in the work to create such a relationship with a willing partner. Rather than opt for marriage, as it's 'off the peg', so to speak, and then go, 'Oh, but I don't want that part of it.'

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 15:27

EBearhug · 16/11/2022 15:20

my children were obviously unsafe (because DH and I go to swingers clubs) around such disgusting people and if they could work out my identity they’d report to social services.

Surely, as long as you've got a babysitter sorted, it's no different from going out to a non-swinging party or the theatre or a harvest supper with the church or whatever.

Imo it’s no different.

To other people it’s akin to child abuse.

On that thread there was a definite suggestion, by more than one poster, that swingers/anyone poly were sex craved morons who’d ultimately inevitably end up inviting predators to their home and endanger their neglected children.

ComtesseDeSpair · 16/11/2022 15:25

Torunette · 16/11/2022 15:11

Long-term monogamy with the same partner is not "natural", but that statement has caveats.

As a rule, people have never historically been in long-term monogamous relationships because spouses died from illness, disease, in childbirth, from violence, and from infection. The average Victorian marriage lasted about seven years because of these reasons. Folk just died (or ran off and were presumed dead or missing).

So it would be more accurate to say that serial monogamy is what is more "natural" from a historical perspective. It was certainly not unknown for people to have been married twice during their lives prior to the 20th century; life practically demanded it.

It’s also more accurate to say that monogamy has rarely, until relatively recently, been expected of men. That men would have courtesans, mistresses, visit prostitutes and generally just, you know, boys will be boys sowing their wild oats, was the accepted norm in virtually every society globally for centuries; despite those societies expecting (and indeed, often enforcing) monogamy of women.

Kitcaterpillar · 16/11/2022 15:24

@SmileyClare I just choose not to justify myself
but for FWIW, sometimes it's a bit shit and we argue. More interesting than arguing over who puts the bins out though 🤷🏼‍♀️

CloseYourEyesAndSee · 16/11/2022 15:24

toomuchlaundry · 16/11/2022 14:56

What happens if you get pregnant, what do you tell your child who their father is, not your husband but some random you shag occasionally at a party

I've managed to not get pregnant by accident through my entire 23 years of shagging and if somehow it happened I wouldn't be having a baby so this is a really stupid question

ComtesseDeSpair · 16/11/2022 15:20

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 15:05

Ive never seen a frank (honest?) warts and all account on threads like these from people claiming to be swingers/ in an open marriage.

Its always gushing about how fantastic swinging is, what an amazing relationship they have (better than non swingers!) how enriched their life is, how mind blowing the sex is etc.

It makes me suspicious, like they’re protesting too much 😂
I mean like anything it must have downsides, bring up uncomfortable emotions, even just acknowledging that you had a really crap night at your local sex party last week when the sex with Dave and Angela was a terrible letdown .

Why would people want to post something like that, after they’ve read dozens of posts being critical, insulting, rude, or questioning their love for their partner?

But I’ll bite. We’ve never had a bad experience of being open. Mostly, I imagine, because most of the people we play with are our close friends so there’s already a good baseline of being comfortable around each other, love, trust, care, mutual respect, and a shared sense of humour for when you inevitably knock heads at some point. Yes, occasionally I’ve had sex with somebody at a play party and it’s been a bit meh - that’s just how it goes sometimes. You grin about it and move on. Yes, very occasionally I’ve had an emotional blip and I’ve developed the emotional literacy to be able to know that what I have a problem with is if he wants to have sex with a woman who I dislike and wouldn’t want to be friends with. That’s my line in the sand. And it’s good that we’ve established it. If I think a woman is a bit of a dick, I don’t want my husband putting his dick in her! This stuff matters.

DH and I do have an amazing relationship, not because we’re open but because we’re compatible, we have a lot of great sex, we’re good at communication, we don’t argue, we care about each other more than we care about being right, we’re naturally gregarious, and we just get on. I don’t think non-monogamy is better than monogamy; although it is definitely better for us.

EBearhug · 16/11/2022 15:20

my children were obviously unsafe (because DH and I go to swingers clubs) around such disgusting people and if they could work out my identity they’d report to social services.

Surely, as long as you've got a babysitter sorted, it's no different from going out to a non-swinging party or the theatre or a harvest supper with the church or whatever.

Joystir59 · 16/11/2022 15:18

No, I like simplicity.

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 15:15

Ok JustLyra that’s fair enough. 🙂

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 15:13

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 15:05

Ive never seen a frank (honest?) warts and all account on threads like these from people claiming to be swingers/ in an open marriage.

Its always gushing about how fantastic swinging is, what an amazing relationship they have (better than non swingers!) how enriched their life is, how mind blowing the sex is etc.

It makes me suspicious, like they’re protesting too much 😂
I mean like anything it must have downsides, bring up uncomfortable emotions, even just acknowledging that you had a really crap night at your local sex party last week when the sex with Dave and Angela was a terrible letdown .

Everything has downsides. Swinging is just life - sometimes it’s fucking amazing and other times it doesn’t go as planned. Sometimes it’s completely frustrating because you have fun plans and they get stuffed by childcare, unexpectedly heavy period, work etc. Just as any other thing.

You may find people very reluctant to be open on here because of the replies it gets. I was quite open on a thread before and someone replied that my children were obviously unsafe (because DH and I go to swingers clubs) around such disgusting people and if they could work out my identity they’d report to social services.

I’ll happily chat to anyone who wants to ask anything by PM but I won’t ever be truly open on here after that level of vitriol.

Torunette · 16/11/2022 15:11

Long-term monogamy with the same partner is not "natural", but that statement has caveats.

As a rule, people have never historically been in long-term monogamous relationships because spouses died from illness, disease, in childbirth, from violence, and from infection. The average Victorian marriage lasted about seven years because of these reasons. Folk just died (or ran off and were presumed dead or missing).

So it would be more accurate to say that serial monogamy is what is more "natural" from a historical perspective. It was certainly not unknown for people to have been married twice during their lives prior to the 20th century; life practically demanded it.

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 15:09

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2022 14:29

@ComtesseDeSpair

Yeah totally. It's my perspective and it isn't applicable to everyone's situation. I know that some people decouple their sexual and romantic lives much more than others.

I do think what @JustLyra says holds a fair bit of truth though.

In every scenario that I've ever known of open relationships or swinging, its always been instigated by one party and grudgingly gone along with by the other, often on the understanding that it will "spice things up" or "keep things exciting" (but with a clear threat of "if we can't do this in a sanctioned way I'll just do it anyway behind your back".) In every single scenario the less enthusiastic partner has become jealous or resentful and the relationship, sooner or later, has ended in recriminations about how the enthusiastic partner basically wanted out. I think in the majority of cases the bottom line is that one person wants out but doesn't quite have the balls to do it.

This may be a very jaded perspective and I'm sure that in scenarios where this agreement is entered into willingly and even-handedly it doesn't have to be like that. I've just encountered very few such scenarios and I'm always sceptical of people's motives for wanting this.

It’s understandable that’s your experience of it.

When it’s not an equal thing it’s bound to end in disaster - just in the same way anything else done to try and keep/save a relationship will eventually.

One thing to keep in mind though is that you have no idea if you know happy swingers. I’ve been a swinger since my teens and only one of my friends knows. There are people I’ve known 20+ years who have zero idea it’s something I’m into. It’s just not something I share with people other than those in clubs and other swingers I know. That is something that’s very, very common in my experience. Very few people, especially those with children, are open about their choices with everyone because it’s just not necessary imo.

So it’s also quite probably a lot like the nightmare MIL/ lazy husband thing as well - we hear a lot more about the situations where there are problems are brought up and talked about a lot more than the people who just quietly get on quite happily.

Thepeopleversuswork · 16/11/2022 15:08

EBearhug · 16/11/2022 15:03

In every scenario that I've ever known of open relationships or swinging, its always been instigated by one party and grudgingly gone along with by the other

Depends how you meet, though, doesn't it? Some couples meet through swinging.

Not in my experience. I know the theory is that if you're upfront from the outset and clear on the parameters and rules its different but in every case I've known there's always been a power imbalance and jealousy has crept in.

Multiple couples I have known have met and begun the relationships as very "open" and gone into it in the understanding that it's all good as long as everyone is transparent and open. In every single case one partner has become possessive over time and wanted monogamy or something approaching monogamy and its always become a sticking point.

Maybe the people I know are the exception and I'm fully prepared to believe some people can pull it off but I've yet to come across an open relationship that genuinely works over the long term.

ReneBumsWombats · 16/11/2022 15:08

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 15:05

Ive never seen a frank (honest?) warts and all account on threads like these from people claiming to be swingers/ in an open marriage.

Its always gushing about how fantastic swinging is, what an amazing relationship they have (better than non swingers!) how enriched their life is, how mind blowing the sex is etc.

It makes me suspicious, like they’re protesting too much 😂
I mean like anything it must have downsides, bring up uncomfortable emotions, even just acknowledging that you had a really crap night at your local sex party last week when the sex with Dave and Angela was a terrible letdown .

Its always gushing about how fantastic swinging is, what an amazing relationship they have (better than non swingers!) how enriched their life is, how mind blowing the sex is etc.

I'm seeing that in spades on this thread from both sides of the debate.

Swipe left for the next trending thread