Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being honest, if it didn't hurt anyone would you want this?

314 replies

Blubba · 16/11/2022 09:45

I was thinking about this last night and although I absolutely love my husband, if I knew it wouldn't hurt him, I'd love to have a more open relationship and I wondered how many people would also prefer that if they knew it wouldn't cause upset / hurt to their spouse or partner?

In reality, my husband would never agree and so I'd never bring it up as I know it would cause an issue the fact I'd even brought it up but in an alternate universe where it wouldn't cause any upset, I think I'd prefer it to a complete monogamy.

Anyone else?

YABU - Even if I could do so without causing any problems in my relationship, I still wouldn't.

YANBU - I would prefer a more open relationship IF it didn't affect my current relationship/marriage.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Pantal1985 · 23/01/2023 12:06

Yes exactly this, just a kink but one I don't think he'd actually enjoy if it came to it. It doesn't bother me talking about it, in fact it's quite fun, but don't think it would be good for our relationship to act on it.

QueefQueen80s · 23/01/2023 12:02

I suggested this in a long relationship because I didn't feel "that way" anymore and wanted freedom to feel, while keeping the family together.
It just gets messy, and usually hard for one partner who still has strong feelings (as my ex did for me) Better to split up, which we have, stayed best friends and kids are happy.

The man I loved after.. NO CHANCE would I have an open relationship.
So to me it indicates lack of romantic love when you want this.

NalaHadItEasy · 23/01/2023 11:40

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:30

Pantal1985 · Today 08:33
My husband very much encourages me to flirt with other men and always talks about me having sex with someone else“

That doesn’t bother you?

It's a kink I believe, being turned on by the idea of being cuckolded. My ex-girlfriend's husband was the same and they'd discuss which of his friends were suitable. But in reality, even her having sex with me, a woman, was a mental struggle for him. The reality of it drove him mad.

NalaHadItEasy · 23/01/2023 11:37

Lana10 · 23/01/2023 02:55

I don't think we'd ever know the truth as it's not like people are registered and you can ask. LOL I've read so much over the years and secure relationships may help but certainly has many problems also.

It will always come to personal bias, you believe the results that you want to believe,

Very true. As is the case for many things; you find the article/person/therapist that agrees with you.

MrsSkylerWhite · 23/01/2023 09:30

Pantal1985 · Today 08:33
My husband very much encourages me to flirt with other men and always talks about me having sex with someone else“

That doesn’t bother you?

Pantal1985 · 23/01/2023 08:33

My husband very much encourages me to flirt with other men and always talks about me having sex with someone else.
But when it's become a remote possibility, he gets funny about it so I think the fantasy outweighs the reality. He's not interested in other women though and I'd never accept an open relationship for him so I think for fairness it's a no go for us but I can understand the appeal.

EBearhug · 23/01/2023 07:25

PermanentTemporary · 23/01/2023 06:20

@ClockingTime obviously I don't know you and AFAIK haven't seen you naked, but it's that sort of thing that casual sex helped me with, at the age of 49 and quite overweight, post pregnancy belly etc. I'm no looker but I got lavish amounts of appreciation from lots of men that way. Sure they were doing it because they wanted a shag, but they were quite specific about what they liked. It gave my physical self esteem the most incredible boost. Men who fancy women REALLY fancy women.

I agree.

PermanentTemporary · 23/01/2023 06:20

@ClockingTime obviously I don't know you and AFAIK haven't seen you naked, but it's that sort of thing that casual sex helped me with, at the age of 49 and quite overweight, post pregnancy belly etc. I'm no looker but I got lavish amounts of appreciation from lots of men that way. Sure they were doing it because they wanted a shag, but they were quite specific about what they liked. It gave my physical self esteem the most incredible boost. Men who fancy women REALLY fancy women.

ClockingTime · 23/01/2023 05:46

Chance would be a fine thing. They would take one look at my knackered naked body and run off screaming.

Lana10 · 23/01/2023 02:55

I don't think we'd ever know the truth as it's not like people are registered and you can ask. LOL I've read so much over the years and secure relationships may help but certainly has many problems also.

It will always come to personal bias, you believe the results that you want to believe,

NalaHadItEasy · 22/01/2023 17:23

That's an interesting statistic. I wonder if that high failure rate is due to couples that are struggling already being more likely to try the open relationship style than couples in a secure relationship.

From personal experience, I tried it because I was missing intimacy in my marriage, and my girlfriend was lonely with her husband working long hours. It nearly broke both marriages and in hindsight would have been better if we'd just addressed the issues in our marriages.

I'd be interested to see the statistics if they compared couple who felt secure before opening than those who didn't.

Lana10 · 22/01/2023 05:09

A recent NY university research conducted by people not in the lifestyle to avoid any bias presented a 92% failure rate for open couples. Even the good ones have more trouble than what they are willing to publicly state,

I not long ago read a post from a guy who said after 5 years of pain, heartache, stress, fighting, a divorce and the loss of his home and kids said it was the best thing he ever did and does not regret it, Maybe some people are addicted to the drama.

RabbitSocks · 17/11/2022 22:10

Yes, you’ve hit it on the head @LikeMindedLady i wouldn’t want another primary relationship but I would like a girlfriend.
I would also like to try things in the swinging realm with my partner - but that’s a little way off for us.
I’ve found the swingers on this thread how I always experience them - thoughtful, honest and welcoming. I hope the scene is like that if I dip a toe in at some point .

LikeMindedLady · 17/11/2022 10:31

@IfOnlyLifeCameWithAManual I agree, I think f/f sex can be wonderful and it is (for me) a completely different experience.

I have experienced 3somes, both as part of the couple and as a single woman joining a couple and I personally don't enjoy that dynamic anywhere near as much, especially once feelings are involved. I think you have to be into swinging/ group encounters on their own merit to enjoy 3somes and I'm not.

I enjoy seeing my female lover 1:1 and we have our own relationship, I wouldn't want to involve my partner in that!

IfOnlyLifeCameWithAManual · 17/11/2022 09:59

LikeMindedLady · 17/11/2022 09:04

An open relationship would be my ideal scenario now that I'm older. I definitely couldn't have handled it when I was younger but now I can see how hard it is to have one person meet all your needs for all of your adult life.

Not loads of casual partners, I'd want a primary 'nesting' partner and a female lover to balance things out! I'd be happy for my OH to have other lovers so long as he was still around to put the bins out at home!

Saying that though, having another female lover later in life was amazing and like a beautiful world I had never experienced before.

IfOnlyLifeCameWithAManual · 17/11/2022 09:58

One thing I'd consider is making sure the third party is comfortable and not feeling used. Having experienced couples privilege and a married couple treating me like a toy and as disposable, if you're going to do this, remember the other person has feelings too and should be treated as another human being not just an experiment. Make sure you're all on the same page. I guess if it's just swinging with an agreement that it's just for fun, fine, but anything akin to another relationship, is just that, you now have two people's feeling to consider and treat respectively.

LikeMindedLady · 17/11/2022 09:04

An open relationship would be my ideal scenario now that I'm older. I definitely couldn't have handled it when I was younger but now I can see how hard it is to have one person meet all your needs for all of your adult life.

Not loads of casual partners, I'd want a primary 'nesting' partner and a female lover to balance things out! I'd be happy for my OH to have other lovers so long as he was still around to put the bins out at home!

Sunnidaze · 17/11/2022 07:29

YABU - how could it not cause problems in your marriage?

PermanentTemporary · 17/11/2022 07:28

Yes I'd like this in some ways. I've tried bits of it and the problem I had was that I wanted one person much more than the other, and I didn't like mentally ranking them in that way. Also he kind of caught feels (i think only because I wasn't fully available) whereas I kind of caught feels for the other guy. So a classic mess tbh.

A nice threesome or foursome though - I'd do more of that.

In general I'd infinitely rather have sex than go to the gym, and I am useless at craft things so it's my main hobby.

Prenticetideisout · 17/11/2022 07:21

InPraiseOfBacchus · 16/11/2022 22:15

Yes, MN can be bitey on a lot of subjects, but there's a BIG difference between someone being bitchy about my decision to wear shoes indoors/not have a bathroom bin, and someone implying that a core part of my lifestyle is gross to society, cruel to my partners, and dangerous to children.

Some of us are tired of having to have a thick skin because of the constant negativity. That's why we might seem defensive.

Well actually I was more thinking about the regular victim blaming (what do you mean you are being abused by your DP - stop being so selfish and think about the children! and the things like "ASD doesn't exist - it's poor parenting!). I am resolutely monogamous but I read this thread for thoughts on alternative lifestyles, and I just had a moment of frustration and was a bit unpleasant in my post - so I apologise to @JustLyra and yourself. I was the poster I don't like for a minute!

I just think that some posters don't really have a true opinion about a subject and they only want the reaction of someone to feel judged. No one can tell you that your lifestyle is abusive in situations like this when they know so little about your life.

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 22:53

TheVolturi · 16/11/2022 21:16

Love and sex can be seperate but they also cross over in my opinion, so the danger of falling in love with someone else would be there. And where would the line be drawn? Are you allowed to text the other lovers, see them regularly? Or just meet up and have sex? I don't think it would work in reality. But you can dream op!

It wouldn’t work for you.

You draw your boundaries where you and your partner are happy with.

I know people who text their swing partners daily, are in and out of each other’s house regularly and done even go on holidays together. Others meet up very occasionally at clubs with little to no contact between times.

It all depends on the people, their lives and their boundaries.

JustLyra · 16/11/2022 22:50

SmileyClare · 16/11/2022 20:58

Yeah that’s unfair to say. I would think there’s no guarantee of sex regardless of how much you’ve paid to attend an event.

The documentary I watched, there were lots of singles and couples who didn’t get invited to join anything and just milled about trying to disguise their disappointment 😂

Most documentaries about swinging should be seen in the same light as documentaries about benefits - they tend to show the dramatic/extreme sides of things rather than the average experience.

RoseAndGeranium · 16/11/2022 22:23

huniepop · 16/11/2022 10:06

I always hear this but I think it's nonsense. It's not more natural, there are many Anaximander that are monogamous, usually the most intelligent ones

Glad I’m not alone in rolling my eyes almost out of my head every time someone trots out the ‘monogamy is unnatural’ line. Hardly any animals have recreational sex. (Far fewer than are monogamous.) Does that mean it’s unnatural for humans to do so? No other animals cook their food. Should we stop doing that too? Ridiculous line of argument.

Snugglemonkey · 16/11/2022 22:20

I don't believe that monogamy is the be all and end all. I have been in open relationships and absolutely would again. My DP is monogamous and would not be comfortable with that at all, so it is not an option. I respect that and so would not ever ask. I would not want to run the risk of him not feeling enough.

InPraiseOfBacchus · 16/11/2022 22:15

Prenticetideisout · 16/11/2022 19:03

All very "Woe is me!" Tell me a subject you CAN talk about on mumsnet without getting criticism. It comes with the territory unfortunately. If you silence yourself because you can't cope with some posters who have negative opinions then that's on you.

Yes, MN can be bitey on a lot of subjects, but there's a BIG difference between someone being bitchy about my decision to wear shoes indoors/not have a bathroom bin, and someone implying that a core part of my lifestyle is gross to society, cruel to my partners, and dangerous to children.

Some of us are tired of having to have a thick skin because of the constant negativity. That's why we might seem defensive.