Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tutoring for A'levels how many do it

115 replies

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 07:40

I was just wondering how often do people get tutors for A'levels. My kids are still a few years away but I do teach undergrads at a top London uni and was wondering how frequent that is.

OP posts:
BabbleBee · 16/11/2022 13:40

DD1 went to a local college for a levels, teaching during covid was almost non-existent so she had a tutor to fill in the gaps. Even without Covid she may have needed extra support, the standards were less than impressive even once they were back to full time teaching.

DD2 goes to a sixth form, completely different to the college. She is well taught, well supported and tutoring for her hasn’t crossed my mind as it’s not needed.

livinthedreamnot · 16/11/2022 13:40

MolliciousIntent · 16/11/2022 07:47

As with all these things, it's not a great plan, long-term, in my opinion.

You get your child a tutor so they get 3A* and they get accepted into their course of choice. BUT it's a level they're not actually capable of, the grades were inflated by the extra input, and so they end up demoralised/dropping out/getting a lower grade than they would have if they'd got ABB and gone to a different uni.

Thank you for this reasoning. I will try explaining that to my DD and hope she takes it on board. She attends a small school and has small class sizes but is still asking for extra tuition which I don't think is a good idea, I just couldn't think how to put it to her without causing upset.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 13:39

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 11:16

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees does that mean A'level students are supposed to spend 45hrs per week on their study?

I can understand tutoring for A'levels but surely with 10GCSES people cant be tutoring for all 10 of the, right?

Some tutored for gcse. But not all 10. Mainly languages or maths/science if struggling. Covid provision was very patchy and hit some subjects more eg no foreign language assistants.

Pinkittens · 16/11/2022 13:35

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

MichaelFabricantWig · 16/11/2022 13:33

MolliciousIntent · 16/11/2022 07:47

As with all these things, it's not a great plan, long-term, in my opinion.

You get your child a tutor so they get 3A* and they get accepted into their course of choice. BUT it's a level they're not actually capable of, the grades were inflated by the extra input, and so they end up demoralised/dropping out/getting a lower grade than they would have if they'd got ABB and gone to a different uni.

Yes I know people who have been in this situation.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 13:31

DC in yr12 at a grammar 6th form and not heard of anybody being tutored yet. But staffing doesn’t appear to be an issue - they prioritise staff for sixth form. Entry requirements are highest in area - think they want a 7 minimum for maths. If scenario is no specialist teacher for months as I have heard happen at a local college then I can see why.

TortugaRumCakeQueen · 16/11/2022 13:27

My DD needed a tutor for her English Higher. The tutor worked wonders and she got an A. She really needed that to get in to Uni, so it was worth every penny. She did one hour every Sunday morning, for about 6 months at a cost of £27 an hour. The tutor actually was a paper marker, so she was able to explain to DD what she needed to do to pick up points on questions.

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 13:24

Yes, I think Covid has a lot to answer for in recent years. Not being a parent of an A'level child, it must have been really tough for everyone. We certainly found it incredibly tough to make sure that all our university students dont fall behind and still get enough out of our material

OP posts:
gogohmm · 16/11/2022 11:53

Quite a few, especially in languages I discovered - we didn't but found out dd was the only non native speaker without a tutor

EducatingArti · 16/11/2022 11:53

I am a tutor ( though only up to GCSE). The two main issues my students experience which make them want a tutor are these:

Specific learning difficulties. Bright students with dyslexia, ADHD etc can often experience difficulties with processing information in subtle ways. This means that what the teacher said in a lesson is not what the student actually "hears". Tutoring one to one is useful to identify and unpick these misunderstandings and "reteach" in whatever way plays to the student' strengths (may be using diagrams, charts, mind maps or whatever). These students can still be bright as once the material is properly understood they can use it effectively in novel situations and for solving complex problems.

Pace of lessons. Teachers in school are very constrained over how much time they can spend on a topic because of having to get through the entire syllabus etc. There's a subset of students (anacdotally, this includes a proportion with no diagnosed specific learning difficulties but who were born very prematurely or had difficulties at birth) who are perfectly capable of understanding and working with the material but need more time to consolidate than they are given at school. Sometimes their school experience has been that of never quite understanding a topic before moving onto the next and this can lead to a massive lack of confidence. Tutoring gives them extra time to understand and helps build confidence.

By A level, I would expect students to be more self motivating and there are masses of online video tutorials that can be accessed for free but I still think there is an advantage to having additional time with a real live teacher where you can ask questions and the teacher can identify the specific issue that is causing the problem

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/11/2022 11:53

my school’s entry requirements are probably too low,

Noble don't you get a say in it as one of the teachers? The 6th forms round here seem to all need at least a 7 in maths GCSE to study it at A level (I hasten to add that DD has no intention of studying it at A level!)

noblegiraffe · 16/11/2022 11:48

Lots of kids have tutors for maths at GCSE, obviously because it’s such an important subject to get a good grade in, but v difficult to study without support.

Increasing numbers have tutors for maths A-level, because it’s difficult, my school’s entry requirements are probably too low, and now they only take 3 subjects dropping it isn’t an option if they struggle.

hoooops · 16/11/2022 11:47

in normal times I don't think it should be necessary

Completely right, everyone should be getting consistently good teaching at school from teachers who are specialists in the subject. But this is not the case.

Aleaiactaest · 16/11/2022 11:40

We do know some people who have been tutoring all the way through… Start in Year 3/4 for 11 plus, then have a break in Year 7 or 8 but the kids miss it. So then parents get tutors involved to supplement weaker teachers for whichever subject or supplement weaker subjects for the DC.

We never tutored, not for 11 plus nor after that. I have seen a huge difference in teaching standards for my 4 DC though over the years. So I can see why people tutor. However, the danger is the DC get used to being spoon fed rather than finding the answer themselves. Which with the internet and multiple revision books available for all subjects should not really be a problem.

I remember one DC had a Cambridge PHD Physics teacher one year who never gave them many notes etc and DC always complained. Still can’t work out if said teacher was just lazy or wanted them to find out for themselves. DC had to work much harder in this subject to find information in textbooks themselves. This would not have worked if all teachers had taken this approach at GCSE level as there would not have been the time to figure it all out themselves. However, it was good for DC to have to figure it out themselves and put in the hours.

The best schools and best teachers teach children to learn and not be spoon fed and think on their own two feet (but in a supportive way) so they are ready when they get to university. In reality though, state school teachers are rushed off their feet, have far too many students, lots of disruption to contend with too and middle class parents know the importance of good grades for long term outcome. So hiring a tutor in the current state school environment is more common to plug the gaps and give the child some comfort.

W0tnow · 16/11/2022 11:35

Tutoring for some GCSE subjects seems sensible. A solid grade in math, for example is a good idea if you’re not taking it in A level and math isn’t your forte. In fact don’t some courses require it?

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/11/2022 11:32

I do think that tutoring because of covid disruption is completely understandable but in normal times I don't think it should be necessary.

cptartapp · 16/11/2022 11:28

DS1 had a tutor for A level maths from year 13 as due to Covid he only ever spent two days f2f in the classroom every week from half way through year 12. The remaining three days every week for eighteen months was online which made learning far more difficult.
He needed AAB for uni and found maths much his hardest subject.
He got the B he needed and secured his uni place. Not sue he would have achieved that with 3/4 of the whole course learnt remotely.

hoooops · 16/11/2022 11:25

does that mean A'level students are supposed to spend 45hrs per week on their study?

Surely 5 hours of lessons per week plus 5 hrs of independent study would be 10 hours total per subject per week, so 30 hours of study per week for those doing three A levels.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/11/2022 11:24

Everyone I know round here only does 3 A levels (4 if with Further Maths) so only 30 hours a week.

Goodness knows what people do regarding tutoring for GCSEs. I only know people who tutored their children to get into selective secondary schools plus one friend who has a maths tutor for her GCSE daughter because she's worried that she may not pass and will have to redo it in 6th form.

hoooops · 16/11/2022 11:22

I think getting on and doing the work without help is an important part of the A level process.

Of course. But so is good teaching an important part of the process. Lucky people get taught well at school. Unlucky ones don't and look elsewhere.

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 11:16

@Sweetpeasaremadeforbees does that mean A'level students are supposed to spend 45hrs per week on their study?

I can understand tutoring for A'levels but surely with 10GCSES people cant be tutoring for all 10 of the, right?

OP posts:
Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/11/2022 10:48

Seems weird to get a tutor for A level. Surely you choose A level subject that you're good at, so wouldn't need a tutor?
And if you need a tutor to get a good enough grade for uni, won't the university course also be too hard? So you'd have to get a tutor for that too...

I would agree with this. DD is currently applying to Sixth forms and the view tends to be 5 hours a week lessons per subject plus 5 hours a week independent study (per subject). I think getting on and doing the work without help is an important part of the A level process.

RedWingBoots · 16/11/2022 10:30

I should have added I've tutored students before both peers and those younger.

If the student doesn't know and understand the basics then they can't tackle questions, especially styles of questions, they haven't seen before.

W0tnow · 16/11/2022 10:21

Mine are taking a language and they have extra lessons for that. Not so much tutoring in the A level Spanish curriculum, just grammar, vocabulary etc via a tutor over Skype. They’ve had her for a couple of years now as they took up the language a bit late.

Our school also has pretty good support lessons during lunch for math, biology and chemistry etc and my kids sometimes attend if they want. If they needed a tutor I’d happily pay for one. Sometimes certain topics can be tricky (statistics, I’m looking at you) and a tutor short term can be good idea.

RedWingBoots · 16/11/2022 10:19

Three of my nephews had tutors for A level Maths. They all went on to get firsts in their degrees which were in STEM subjects.

To be fair it was me, one of their aunts, who has degrees in STEM, who went through what their schools/colleges where not teaching them an alerted their parents to the poor teaching.

I've alerted other parents, including my DP, to the poor teaching in subjects but particularly Maths with younger children. Not all of them had tutors at A level but did have additional tutoring before hand.