Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tutoring for A'levels how many do it

115 replies

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 07:40

I was just wondering how often do people get tutors for A'levels. My kids are still a few years away but I do teach undergrads at a top London uni and was wondering how frequent that is.

OP posts:
Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 15:22

Frlrlrubert · 16/11/2022 14:56

I tutor for sciences and at the moment a lot of my A level students have missed massive chunks of prior GCSE knowledge due to covid. Practicals we're removed from exams, etc, so the basics are missing in a lot of cases.

Others have come from schools where they only did combined science and are now in a cohort of peers who did three separate GCSEs, so again, missing content that the teacher may cover quite quickly if 95% have already done it.

Others have been excessively spoon-fed at GCSE and have found A-level a massive jump. Got a shock that they have gone from getting 8s to Ds. These need a confidence boost and guidance on how to become independent learners.

Still others just don't 'get it' the way they are taught it. The subject might have been something they were good at at GCSE, and they took the A level but maybe it's the wrong fit. They might not specifically need that subject to do their degree, but they do need ABB, or whatever, and it's too late to switch. So they get a tutor, scrape a B, and never use most of it again.

Also, students seem much more isolated that when I was at college, so some of them just want someone to bounce ideas off while they do their homework, just an hour a week of discussion using the vocabulary can make a big difference to a lot of them.

My yr 12 had most of her gcse science lessons in a none science room as they were running a Covid bubble system confining each yr group to a block and she wasn’t ever in the science block. She’s not doing science A levels but I don’t think she did any practicals. I wouldn’t think less of any of her peers wanted a catch up with a tutor.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 15:14

Some subjects may also need catch up as way gcse was examined 2022 was to cut swathes of syllabus (as they couldn’t teach full syllabus due to Covid) But all schools and exam boards cut different bits.
If it’s a subject like science that builds on past knowledge it must be hard work for A level teachers. I know DDs school still tried to cover none assessed work in sciences as lots do science in sixth form but not all kids in sixth form go to lower school. If you missed a whole topic but A level syllabus expected you to have covered it then again a few face to face lessons to bring you up to speed seems sensible.

noblegiraffe · 16/11/2022 15:08

You get your child a tutor so they get 3A*

Most kids who have a tutor get nowhere near an A*. Getting a tutor isn’t buying a top grade, it’s extra support for a student who is struggling.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 15:07

A level is part self study but also 4 or 5 hours taught a week. It’s only a 2 year course and some subjects only have one teacher. If that teacher leaves and not replaced mid course (as they can’t recruit a replacement) or goes on long term sick then having a tutor simply replaces that face to face teaching.
My dcs school prioritises sixth form so eg will give lower school class a supply and send their teacher to 6th form class but not all schools can do that. Their Classics teacher has been very ill with Covid and off, he’s the only one teaching that so no classes offered at all.
I’ve heard stories from friends about local college - no teacher for large part of course or no suitably qualified teacher. I wouldn’t criticise a student for having a tutor if they want some face to face teaching same as peers at other schools and colleges.

caringcarer · 16/11/2022 15:06

My dd had a Maths tutor for A level Maths.

RedWingBoots · 16/11/2022 15:05

@livinthedreamnot I had similar at university e.g. small class with most qualified lecturer but couldn't lecture for toffee. Luckily being older I knew how to deal with it.

RedWingBoots · 16/11/2022 15:00

livinthedreamnot · 16/11/2022 13:40

Thank you for this reasoning. I will try explaining that to my DD and hope she takes it on board. She attends a small school and has small class sizes but is still asking for extra tuition which I don't think is a good idea, I just couldn't think how to put it to her without causing upset.

Just because you are in small classes doesn't mean the teacher is any good.

I did Chemistry A level where I had 3 teachers. The teacher for one part of the syllabus was useless. Luckily after lots of complaints, during the time some students went and got tutors as nothing was happening, another one of the teachers covered part of his lessons but at lunch times.

Oh and that useless teacher who was the one who was most highly qualified in the subject and had gone to Cambridge.

formulatingAresponse · 16/11/2022 14:58

Sciences and maths are bloody hard at A Level

The jump is enormous

Lots of grit and determination from the student is required to work it all out, catch up from where they are etc to do well

Frlrlrubert · 16/11/2022 14:56

I tutor for sciences and at the moment a lot of my A level students have missed massive chunks of prior GCSE knowledge due to covid. Practicals we're removed from exams, etc, so the basics are missing in a lot of cases.

Others have come from schools where they only did combined science and are now in a cohort of peers who did three separate GCSEs, so again, missing content that the teacher may cover quite quickly if 95% have already done it.

Others have been excessively spoon-fed at GCSE and have found A-level a massive jump. Got a shock that they have gone from getting 8s to Ds. These need a confidence boost and guidance on how to become independent learners.

Still others just don't 'get it' the way they are taught it. The subject might have been something they were good at at GCSE, and they took the A level but maybe it's the wrong fit. They might not specifically need that subject to do their degree, but they do need ABB, or whatever, and it's too late to switch. So they get a tutor, scrape a B, and never use most of it again.

Also, students seem much more isolated that when I was at college, so some of them just want someone to bounce ideas off while they do their homework, just an hour a week of discussion using the vocabulary can make a big difference to a lot of them.

formulatingAresponse · 16/11/2022 14:55

I absolutely understand though that if a DC has missed a class or hasn't quite understood some part then they need to contact their teacher at school.

Failing that then yes a tutor is always going to be great to talk things through at the pupils oen pace to catch up and understand a point

However A Levels are all about teaching yourself to work these things out for yourself

They have videos and PowerPoints giving them everything they could possibly need.

So if they can't work it out from that then they're in trouble tutor or no tutor.

Sheer hard work and determination is required

emptythelitterbox · 16/11/2022 14:43

livinthedreamnot · 16/11/2022 13:40

Thank you for this reasoning. I will try explaining that to my DD and hope she takes it on board. She attends a small school and has small class sizes but is still asking for extra tuition which I don't think is a good idea, I just couldn't think how to put it to her without causing upset.

But their reasoning is wrong.

What subjects is she wanting help with?

hoooops · 16/11/2022 14:27

I just don't think it's sustainable and clearly is the wrong choice as an A Level if a tutor is required

Again this only makes sense if the child is getting good consistent teaching at school and doesn't have any other difficulties affecting their learning, like dyslexia, illness etc. Otherwise it just displays a lack of understanding of the huge disparity in students' circumstances and in what different schools can offer.

I don't think you can blame a child for choosing an A level they are interested in and good at, and need for their choice of degree, if they then find that their teacher is not a specialist in the subject, or if their school can't recruit and they end up with a succession of supply teachers, or if they or their teacher is off with covid for large chunks of the course. A levels are quite intense and there isn't a lot of wriggle room if things are disrupted.

emptythelitterbox · 16/11/2022 14:27

MolliciousIntent · 16/11/2022 07:47

As with all these things, it's not a great plan, long-term, in my opinion.

You get your child a tutor so they get 3A* and they get accepted into their course of choice. BUT it's a level they're not actually capable of, the grades were inflated by the extra input, and so they end up demoralised/dropping out/getting a lower grade than they would have if they'd got ABB and gone to a different uni.

There's a huge difference between a tutor and a proxy.

I think you're talking about a proxy who does the work for them. Some will take exams for them.

A tutor teaches the concepts but doesn't do the work for them.

mondaytosunday · 16/11/2022 14:21

It seems quite common to have GCSE tutor, especially in math as you have to get at least a 4. Plus the wide variety of subjects means a child might be weak in certain areas and not others.
But A levels you normally have already demonstrated the ability in the subject, so it's less likely to need a tutor.

emptythelitterbox · 16/11/2022 14:21

1 to 1 focused teaching is almost always better.
Explain concepts in multiple ways. Instant feedback.
More short focused exercises on weak areas.

I got a language tutor for myself as an adult 2 x per week 1 hour each time.
Made very rapid progress in a few months.

There are some YouTube channels and others set up like this.
One example is Kahn Academy for Maths.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/11/2022 14:13

We did for a dd who was struggling with Economics, but a couple of hours were enough to sort out what she hadn’t understood. She ended up with the grade she needed.

Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 14:02

If child has missed a topic due to illness either their own or a teacher being off then I can understand wanting face to face teaching to plug gap from a tutor. Or if you’ve got a Teacher who isn’t a specialist in that subject only teaching it as school can’t fill role and is doing a barely ok job. That student having a tutor is on same footing as a student at a school with a teacher with the correct degree and experience.

fiftiesmum · 16/11/2022 14:02

A friend is an A level tutor - most students are from fee paying or selective schools and are applying for courses where A/A* is required. Most have tutors in other subjects so paying £100 each week for extra tuition.

It is more common than you realise.

formulatingAresponse · 16/11/2022 13:58

My DS is taking A Level maths and further maths and has to do tons of homework - hours of it - I don't know how a tutor would fit in if he needed help with it.

I just don't think it's sustainable and clearly is the wrong choice as an A Level if a tutor is required

Students are expected to put in a lot of work for A Levels and self teach and regulate

It's not handed to them on a plate like GCSEs

Beamur · 16/11/2022 13:55

His weakest subject for a couple of months.
My DD is yr11 and has had a handful of lessons with a tutor for specific topics (teacher had been ill a lot at school)

theseed · 16/11/2022 13:54

I had an English tutor for A-levels for a few months, but this was targeted at perfecting exam technique rather than understanding the subject material.

Beamur · 16/11/2022 13:51

I know lots of people who have been tutored at A level.
Mostly just around filling knowledge gaps or helping to secure target grades. My DSS asked for some extra help with his when it became clear to him he wasn't going to get the grades needed - he was clever but had slacked off. He was tutored in his

FlyingSquid · 16/11/2022 13:47

And although we have never yet coughed up for a tutor, DS booked one himself before university to catch up on some aspects he'd missed.

FlyingSquid · 16/11/2022 13:46

gogohmm · 16/11/2022 11:53

Quite a few, especially in languages I discovered - we didn't but found out dd was the only non native speaker without a tutor

But where does the divide fall between dedicated teaching and tutoring (apart from extra expense, I mean)? DD's remarkable A-level language teacher was willing to spend extra hours with keen students, for free, drilling them on grammar points and having extra conversation sessions.

newtb · 16/11/2022 13:43

Went on a cookery course once. Loads of ladies who lunch from Wilmslow. Without exception their children all had tutors to get places at Manchester High/Grammar and had continued, no doubt up to 'A' level. Didn't see the point, myself.