Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tutoring for A'levels how many do it

115 replies

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 07:40

I was just wondering how often do people get tutors for A'levels. My kids are still a few years away but I do teach undergrads at a top London uni and was wondering how frequent that is.

OP posts:
Myjobisanightmare · 16/11/2022 19:18

My dd got seven 9s one 8 and one 7 in her teacher assessment GCSE and a D* in her BTEc and thought the world was her oyster that she was good at everything and could choose the A levels she wanted wrong by the end of the first term she was managing one doing badly in another and completely failing the third and it was too late to do anything about it so the following term we got her a tutor for the one she was failing

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 18:56

Ultimately the students that do well are the ones with self-discipline, a good work ethic, and being receptive to advice of their subject teachers.

I tend to agree.

JellyfishandShells · 16/11/2022 18:54

We did for the second year of one subject that was being very erratically taught at 6th form college ( cover teachers, then a non specialist ) We weren’t the only parents who did this - so lucky have a very qualified neighbour available. Was not a subject she was going to take further or related to her intended degree subject. Rest of subjects fine and it helped to destress her hugely. It was the B requirement of an AAB offer and she got an A .

Other daughter had done GCSE French a year early ( school decision ) so A level French was a year early too. I can’t remember the rationale. It was a subsidiary subject and had no effect on her uni offer ( which required 3 subjects taken at same time) A French friend who tutored younger children gave her conversation practice, more to help with shyness than anything, and they discussed French papers and current affairs.

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 18:54

"Tutoring is generally about filling in the gaps , building up confidence .

A conscientious and resourceful A level student should, with suggestions from his/her teacher, should manage to fill those gaps themselves.

Who fills those gaps at University for them?!

mymysweetthing · 16/11/2022 18:49

ThrallsWife · 16/11/2022 18:11

Maybe I'm getting too cynical at my age now, but I am currently teaching A-level and I share the subject with a colleague 50/ 50, so he teaches 50% of the content and I the other 50%. He is new to teaching this stuff, I have a few years behind me now.

The kids constantly try to tell me they "dont get" Mr X's teaching. He's working hard, preparing well, does everything I do, though we have our own styles, of course.

The kids that have shit grades with him also have shit grades with me, the ones who get As consistently do so with him, too. Only one currently has a tutor, because they're disabled and often unable to attend lessons.

I have had two kids ask me how they could improve their grades. I have made a huge list of suggestions, from the amount of time they should spend studying outside of my lesson time (which they currently spend on social media - I have seen evidence), the type of revision they should do and the suggestion of study groups, including names of students who get it right at the moment.

The response I got was "I'll just get a tutor", as if that was the magic solution to all their troubles.

I honestly believe that the current crop of A-level students still expect the same spoonfeeding they got for their GCSEs, be it precise lists of what will come up in their exams, help with exams like being given formulae rather than learning them or just being given all of my time and effort (that they got at GCSEs because my pay at the time depended on it).

I also believe that because of the covid disruption (no exams, or heavily dumbed-down ones) students have, for the most part, not yet gained the study skills they need for A-levels, but even as an A-level form tutor I cannot give them all the time they need or physically force them to get off TikTok for 5min and use their phones to, you know, actually study.

Couldn't agree more. Am a HOS and the default position amongst students and parents is to just get a tutor rather than actually follow our advice about a) the amount of independent study hours required b) the types of tasks they should be doing to both consolidate and extend their understanding.

It would be impossible to meaningfully track the progress of students with tutors and compare their outcomes to non tutored students, but anecdotally, the students who I know have tutors, especially in my own classes, never really seem to perform better than expected, especially in subjects like History or English Literature where so much is dependent on the syllabus requirements. Ultimately the students that do well are the ones with self-discipline, a good work ethic, and being receptive to advice of their subject teachers.

alwayslearning789 · 16/11/2022 18:35

@user68901 you summed it up brilliantly:

"Tutoring is generally about filling in the gaps , building up confidence . it won't ever turn someone into a genius but it can help someone fulfill their potential."

user68901 · 16/11/2022 18:20

We eventually got dd a biology tutor as she had months of online lessons due to covid which were not very satisfactory so she found it hard to keep up with biology . She got her grades for uni and was 1 mark off getting a first in her 1st year exams (obviously not biology !)
Tutoring is generally about filling in the gaps , building up confidence . it won't ever turn someone into a genius but it can help someone fulfill their potential.

ThrallsWife · 16/11/2022 18:11

Maybe I'm getting too cynical at my age now, but I am currently teaching A-level and I share the subject with a colleague 50/ 50, so he teaches 50% of the content and I the other 50%. He is new to teaching this stuff, I have a few years behind me now.

The kids constantly try to tell me they "dont get" Mr X's teaching. He's working hard, preparing well, does everything I do, though we have our own styles, of course.

The kids that have shit grades with him also have shit grades with me, the ones who get As consistently do so with him, too. Only one currently has a tutor, because they're disabled and often unable to attend lessons.

I have had two kids ask me how they could improve their grades. I have made a huge list of suggestions, from the amount of time they should spend studying outside of my lesson time (which they currently spend on social media - I have seen evidence), the type of revision they should do and the suggestion of study groups, including names of students who get it right at the moment.

The response I got was "I'll just get a tutor", as if that was the magic solution to all their troubles.

I honestly believe that the current crop of A-level students still expect the same spoonfeeding they got for their GCSEs, be it precise lists of what will come up in their exams, help with exams like being given formulae rather than learning them or just being given all of my time and effort (that they got at GCSEs because my pay at the time depended on it).

I also believe that because of the covid disruption (no exams, or heavily dumbed-down ones) students have, for the most part, not yet gained the study skills they need for A-levels, but even as an A-level form tutor I cannot give them all the time they need or physically force them to get off TikTok for 5min and use their phones to, you know, actually study.

Zanatdy · 16/11/2022 18:06

My sons just started his A levels and didn’t need any tutors but some of his friends did. Some did miss out though on some content with covid restrictions at the start of their A levels

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/11/2022 18:04

what I mean is that there's no reason a student should struggle in uni if they get a place because grades 'inflated' by tutoring.

I'm not sure about that. I agree with Gummibär. Drop out rates from university have increased massively over the last few years and some institutions have said that they believe it is because the students just aren't academically suited to university. Plus there are all the mental health problems associated with students not coping with their courses. It seems to have worked fine for many of the children described on here but overall I'm not sure it does.

I agree, I'm shocked at the level of tutoring. Perhaps it should be declared on the UCAS form.

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 16/11/2022 17:56

Argh, apologies for the typos!!

JustHereWithMyPopcorn · 16/11/2022 17:55

I started with one for Eng Lit with my DS in the beginning of year 12 as the essays were completely different to GCSE (and also they missed they GCSEs). It was one hour a week online but the advise they gave was really sketchy and we realised he did better without the help so stopped after a couple of months. That was the only tutoring he had for any of his subjects.

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 17:55

Unless of course these students continue to use a tutor throughout University... Confused

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 17:53

what I mean is that there's no reason a student should struggle in uni if they get a place because grades 'inflated' by tutoring.

Im afraid i do not agree.

There's quite a lot of evidence to the contrary.

"Students who get a head start or upper hand during the early stages of learning do not retain this advantage long-term. In some cases, they do even worse than their peers.

We don’t know exactly why this is, however one of the prevailing theories is that this ease of learning prevents the student from developing their ability to think through the material and cope with difficulty"

twelly · 16/11/2022 17:52

Many students have A level tutors for many different reasons. I don't agree that it is means students over perform and therefore end up at universities where they can't cope or find it stressful. Education is not a level playing field, some schools have good teachers some not so good - and this varies from subject to subject. In addition some students attend private schools some don't. Private tuition may allow a student to access the degree they are aiming for.

It all depends upon the individual student and the current circumstances.

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 17:47

Wow, I'm shocked at how much tutoring is going on! Confused

I wonder how these students will fare at University when they attend a few lectures and perhaps some tutorials - they could struggle..?!

My ds has just started at Imperial College and the pace of teaching is much faster than at school with A levels! He's managing fine but I wonder how he'd fare if if hadn't managed his 4 A levels by himself (and the school obviously?!

DiscontinuedModelHusband · 16/11/2022 17:41

to those saying that tutoring is self-defeating - are you mad?

how is that?

the tutors are generally helping to provide more time for questioning/reassuring pupils about their own knowledge - they don't write the assessments or sit the exams on the pupil's behalf!

DD1 had a chemistry tutor for a-level, as she lacked confidence in her ability, and was anxious about putting her hand up in class. with a tutor she was able to check her understanding much more easily, and found in most cases that her understanding was fine - it really built her confidence.

greater confidence in your subject knowledge at a-level will only be a benefit at university or later.

to suggest it's harmful is ludicrous.

ZaZathecat · 16/11/2022 17:37

Sweet peas what I mean is that there's no reason a student should struggle in uni if they get a place because grades 'inflated' by tutoring. They have just learnt more, just the same as if they had more hours of the subject at school

Allywill · 16/11/2022 17:36

my daughter had a tutor for A level biology. she got her from a grade D in the mock to a B (borderline A) in the actual exam. didn’t mean she struggled at uni. she got a first and is now half way through a doctorate. grades are just the currency you use to buy your way into the course. in most cases (although not all ) they bear little relation to the course of study at uni.

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 16/11/2022 17:32

I don't see how tutoring 'inflates people's grades'.

Then why on earth are people willing to pay for it? Confused

ZaZathecat · 16/11/2022 17:26

I don't see how tutoring 'inflates people's grades'. If you got more hours of a subject at school you'd do better in that subject, so tutoring is no different except that one to one teaching can be more intense.

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 17:20

@Unicorn1919 do you know whether they get a tutor for each subject or just say Maths or MFL?

OP posts:
Parker231 · 16/11/2022 17:14

No - all teaching was done during the school day including homework club for revision time.

Unicorn1919 · 16/11/2022 17:12

I am a tutor and A level tutoring is more popular than anything else. I occassionally get a Common Entrance student or GCSE but most of them want A level tutoring.

cptartapp · 16/11/2022 16:16

Dixiechickonhols · 16/11/2022 15:14

Some subjects may also need catch up as way gcse was examined 2022 was to cut swathes of syllabus (as they couldn’t teach full syllabus due to Covid) But all schools and exam boards cut different bits.
If it’s a subject like science that builds on past knowledge it must be hard work for A level teachers. I know DDs school still tried to cover none assessed work in sciences as lots do science in sixth form but not all kids in sixth form go to lower school. If you missed a whole topic but A level syllabus expected you to have covered it then again a few face to face lessons to bring you up to speed seems sensible.

DS2 didn't even finished his GCSE triple science syllabus due to Covid, and went on to do two science A levels and try and play catch up.
This is why this year 13 as the last of the four COVID affected exam years should have allowances made when grading A levels next year. Maybe not as much as in previous years, but certainly as they've also never sat public exams before they're at more disadvantage which should be compensated for.

Swipe left for the next trending thread