Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Tutoring for A'levels how many do it

115 replies

Dggrs45 · 16/11/2022 07:40

I was just wondering how often do people get tutors for A'levels. My kids are still a few years away but I do teach undergrads at a top London uni and was wondering how frequent that is.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Reugny · 21/12/2022 23:10

I forgot to add myself, family and friends have tutored people.

It's to ensure the person covered the syllabus and understand the subject due to the teaching they have had in most cases being poor or not extensive enough. The levels have been from primary school to degree level.

Some of this tutoring in my family and friends cases has been on schemes and been free for the recipients.

PinkPanther57 · 21/12/2022 22:39

@Purplemagnolias was thinking more of a school setting with the untutored getting disheartened or being perceived as less quick on uptake (not good).

In selective school odds are all are pretty smart & some families see tutoring as being able to improve performance, confidence etc & there’s no set limit on IQ. The Asian concept of ‘enrichment’, where the real learning & stretching comes after school & can develop the mind. If you get the grades & have intellectual curiosity, want to study & have a growth mindset your abilities don’t have a ceiling (?)

Purplemagnolias · 21/12/2022 22:26

This can skew the view of who is naturally able and who isn't.

I feel very sorry for those that are accepted onto super competitive courses based on these skewed 'abilities'

Aleaiactaest · 21/12/2022 20:58

Lots of kids in our grammars have tutors -plenty to get edge for Oxbridge or med school applications, but also to help with fluency in languages or a particular subject they may struggle with or lack confidence in. Also, one DC had a terrible teacher in one subject one year and literally half the class used the same tutor in small groups to cover the ground the teacher was meant to cover. They shared notes with the rest of their set to help them too. Most DC were extensively tutored for 11 plus so it is just an extension of that.
Small group or 1 to 1 can be immensely helpful. I have also seen older kids in the school eg in Lower Sixth offer tutoring online to younger years now for quite a reasonable price. Good for them to make some money and help the younger kids.

Lampzade · 21/12/2022 16:48

I tutored my own dcs in maths , English and Chemistry up to GCSE.
They had an external tutor for languages.

DD1 and DD2 did not have any tutors for A level . DD1 just signed up to an online company that provided tailored examination questions .
DD2 didn’t have a tutor for A level and achieved top grades. She basically self taught ( STEM) subjects

PinkPanther57 · 21/12/2022 16:31

IME it's quite common, esp at the top independent schools. It's also not uncommon for students to be taught a year in advance so for some, especially in subjects like Maths A level, & Economics, what is 'new' material for some is consolidation for others and not unfamiliar. This can skew the view of who is naturally able and who isn't.

The top tutors command 100-200 pounds (even) an hour and some parents seem happy to pay even on top of school fees. For some it continues at University over the summers etc. There's a market for residential tutors for GCSE and A level etc. The best make an enormous difference esp at GCSE I hear where purposeful practice and honed exam technique can have more of an impact.

It's seen as intellectual enrichment by many and this approach common in Asia etc. There's also a certain amount of legitimate 'gaming of the system', semi native speakers/native speakers taking the relevant A level language exam, etc.

unknownMillennial · 21/12/2022 15:32

I agree that A level students should not really have extra tutoring, because it just means they may be doing a qualification that is over their head and not suited for them. However, there are a lot of ambitious and persevering students out there and some are about to improve with the additional support. I personally don't think there is anything wrong is looking for additional support but of course it does not guarantee anything, like most things in life.

YetAnotherNameChange52 · 16/11/2022 23:14

We haven't yet, but we'd consider it if DS (dx with ASD) was struggling - he can't always deal with his classes so might need some 1:1 to get through A levels. This is obviously gambling a bit that he could cope with the next step, but one step at the time.

FacebookPhotos · 16/11/2022 21:56

I sometimes tutor A level students. In most cases it is a confidence booster. And the vast majority do not need my subject specifically, but it one they picked over a year beforehand and they need a particular grade to get on an unrelated course.

In my subject a smaller proportion of student are awarded top grades than almost all other subjects. University offers don't acknowledge that (and ofqual refuse to change it), so students taking my subject as their third subject are (imo unfairly) disadvantaged by the system. I think the tutoring for these kids levels an unfair system.

I prefer tutoring gcse kids though. For that, it is usually kids who messed around in year 9 and 10 before realising in year 11 that they want good grades and have massive gaps.

DrMadelineMaxwell · 16/11/2022 21:32

Dd has a tutor for one aspect of one subject. In A level maths she got an A* level mark at AS last year but in another she came out with a C. Even though overall she still achieved an A, for the sake of her confidence and to avoid stress next May, she has an hour a week to support just that area.
Most of her cohort seem to have done badly in that paper and are resitting it.

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 21:15

So you are saying all the covid kids.....stuff them they should be able to work it all themselves.

Not at all. I have two dc who were due to take A levels and GCSEs in 2020 so they lost a huge amount of teaching.

That is why grades were very generous in 2020 - 2022, to take into account the lack of teaching.

EducatingArti · 16/11/2022 20:59

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 17:53

what I mean is that there's no reason a student should struggle in uni if they get a place because grades 'inflated' by tutoring.

Im afraid i do not agree.

There's quite a lot of evidence to the contrary.

"Students who get a head start or upper hand during the early stages of learning do not retain this advantage long-term. In some cases, they do even worse than their peers.

We don’t know exactly why this is, however one of the prevailing theories is that this ease of learning prevents the student from developing their ability to think through the material and cope with difficulty"

You are assuming that a tutor doesn't teach the student how to cope and think through a difficulty. Just been teaching exactly that with a GCSE student this evening. We have been deconstructing a recent test, getting him to make notes on what the issues are and discussing ideas ( his and mine) on how to address them!!

MissFancyDay · 16/11/2022 20:51

Last year my son was doing maths, physics and computer science at A level. He was fine in the first year, even though covid really interfered with the time spent in school.

In his second year the physics teacher changed and the whole class struggled. D's was stressed, hated physics, said he just didn't understand what they wanted in the exam questions. He was floundering and very much wanted to do his chosen course at university.

We got him a tutor for his last 5 months, so from about this January. We paid £35 for one session a week, going up to two a couple of months before the exams. The difference in Ds was astounding, he gained confidence, was sleeping better. We still weren't sure he would pick up all the ground he had lost.

He got the marks he wanted, the other two subjects were fine. He just needed help with physics. He did his sessions with the tutor online and it was brilliant, we are so grateful.

pompei8309 · 16/11/2022 20:30

livinthedreamnot- if she’s asking for a tutor it means she’s not confident or struggling with certain things, if you can afford it, why don’t you help her ?

pompei8309 · 16/11/2022 20:25

Mine had tutors for all subjects, started almost a year before the exams, same for GCSE’s . Very bright child but a bit lazy when it came to revision etc and I was not in the position to help with that so it gave her the extra help and guidance and got brilliant results. Pricey though 😢

ShepherdMoons · 16/11/2022 20:01

I have a friend whose son is tutored for all his A'level subjects. He was tutored at GCSE too. Generally he does very well and is bright anyway but the extra tuition seems to give him confidence.

My dcs are still very young so not at that stage yet. My own experience though was that I grafted, spent hours revising and had no extra help. I did very well. I am not sure if I would have felt the same sense of achievement if I'd have been tutored.

Lordofmyflies · 16/11/2022 19:55

DS in yr 13 has a tutor for one of his A level subjects. His school teacher went on sick leave 8 months ago and has been substituted with supply teacher. Its not a level playing field so if I can give him extra help to fill in the gaps in his education I will.

Popplebop · 16/11/2022 19:35

Well one of my Yr 13 twins has a maths tutor. Different teachers; time tabling issues and lack of teachers ; cover teacher for a lesson. And it is making a big difference to their understanding. Not a case of trying to boost up several grades but to make sure they get what they are able to. Not expecting to need the tutor all year but the single focus has made a significant difference. My twins are at a mid-level city comprehensive.

whiteroseredrose · 16/11/2022 19:32

I think the assumption that if you have a tutor for a while means that you will struggle without one afterwards is bobbins. We've used tutors intermittently for our DC and they haven't suffered as a result.

Both had a tutor once a week in Y5 for the 11+. They were absolutely fine at Grammar School.

DS had a tutor for a few weeks prior to his Physics Admission Test for Oxford. He absolutely loved it and came away from each session absolutely buzzing. It filled in some gaps and taught him a different way of thinking.

And DD had a Maths tutor for GCSE because she had a student teacher in Y12 and panicked. Didn't stop her succeeding at A Level Maths and Further Maths.

You do what you can to support your DC if you have the means to do so, surely.

lbnblbnb · 16/11/2022 19:29

Also, there is a teacher shortage. If one student is being taught by a subject specialist and another not, there will be a difference. Yes students need to show initiative but it isn't a level playing field.

user68901 · 16/11/2022 19:26

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 18:54

"Tutoring is generally about filling in the gaps , building up confidence .

A conscientious and resourceful A level student should, with suggestions from his/her teacher, should manage to fill those gaps themselves.

Who fills those gaps at University for them?!

So you are saying all the covid kids.....stuff them they should be able to work it all themselves. So why do kids bother to go to school for lessons when, hey, they can just look it up and teach themselves.

EssexCat · 16/11/2022 19:26

formulatingAresponse · 16/11/2022 14:55

I absolutely understand though that if a DC has missed a class or hasn't quite understood some part then they need to contact their teacher at school.

Failing that then yes a tutor is always going to be great to talk things through at the pupils oen pace to catch up and understand a point

However A Levels are all about teaching yourself to work these things out for yourself

They have videos and PowerPoints giving them everything they could possibly need.

So if they can't work it out from that then they're in trouble tutor or no tutor.

Sheer hard work and determination is required

Good luck with learning further maths that way….

EssexCat · 16/11/2022 19:23

formulatingAresponse · 16/11/2022 13:58

My DS is taking A Level maths and further maths and has to do tons of homework - hours of it - I don't know how a tutor would fit in if he needed help with it.

I just don't think it's sustainable and clearly is the wrong choice as an A Level if a tutor is required

Students are expected to put in a lot of work for A Levels and self teach and regulate

It's not handed to them on a plate like GCSEs

But if the teaching is not there then however bright they are they’re not going to be able to learn it.

Lots of people commenting may be unaware of just how desperate staffing issues and how much teaching is being missed because of that.

user68901 · 16/11/2022 19:23

Gummibär · 16/11/2022 18:54

"Tutoring is generally about filling in the gaps , building up confidence .

A conscientious and resourceful A level student should, with suggestions from his/her teacher, should manage to fill those gaps themselves.

Who fills those gaps at University for them?!

ummm I just said she was 1 mark off a first in her 1st year exams.

lbnblbnb · 16/11/2022 19:23

I tutor A level students. There is a variety of reasons. Sometimes the students has had disruption to their learning for various reasons, sometimes there has been staff absence etc. Some students don't seem to have had guidance on how to structure their answers. I avoid the last minute trying to boost grades ones - if they weren't willing to work for it initially, I am not interested. I have a waiting list. Ultimately, they have to be able to produce the work themselves in exam conditions.