Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

55k cost to raise a child to school age?

33 replies

User135792468 · 15/11/2022 21:44

Is this a realistic amount? Current debate with Dh as we’re debating if we can afford another dc. The cost of living is biting and with previous Dc, we didn’t really plan financially as (very luckily), we didn’t need to as we absorbed the cost.

Breakdown as follows:

  • 15k loss of earnings during mat leave (different for everyone but based on difference between part time earnings and mat pay)
  • 25k - childcare 3 days a week from age 1 to starting school (will vary based on birth month)
  • 15k - everything else (nappies, wipes, formula, clothes, equipment)

I would say this is a very conservative amount as for some families it could be much more with working parents but for some it would be less as a sahp (loss of potential earnings still applies though).

Please let know your thoughts on the amount and if you would say more or less, how you calculated it and the breakdown.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Kite22 · 16/11/2022 21:04

DragonMovie · 16/11/2022 16:38

I think this is a strange way to think about the affordability of a child though. surely you don’t pay for them as a lump sum? Wouldn’t it be better to calculate a. Can you afford mat leave and b. Can you afford the monthly cost once back at work. Plus considering aside from that whether you need a new car (can’t get 3 car seats in a standard car) and whether you need to move. Overall cost until school age isn’t that useful surely?

I agree.
Surely any "affordability test" is about if you can afford the extra costs incurred each month, not some plucked from the air total of how much more you will be paying out over a number of years.
If you want to know how much a child costs you until they stop costing you anything, I've got news for you, you will need to be thinking about 25 years rather than 5. But it is just such an odd way to look at a decision that is surely also about love and family and the whole emotional side, not a purely financial thing.

BelleMarionette · 16/11/2022 20:02

Given this is only 3 days a week of nursery, what daily rate are you using? In my nursery, this would be free once a child turns 3 other than food costs, due to the 30 free hours.

While the equipment cost is very high, I would add a separate 'entertainment' cost. Admission to places on days out, activities etc. This can be reasonably significant depending on the family.

trying29 · 16/11/2022 17:06

That wouldn’t cover it in SE London. I calculated with our first born full time nursery for him alone was 55k

LBFseBrom · 16/11/2022 17:01

I suppose it is expensive but we don't pay it out all at once. Does it matter?

Having children is a choice, most of us like it and don't count the cost.

DragonMovie · 16/11/2022 16:38

I think this is a strange way to think about the affordability of a child though. surely you don’t pay for them as a lump sum? Wouldn’t it be better to calculate a. Can you afford mat leave and b. Can you afford the monthly cost once back at work. Plus considering aside from that whether you need a new car (can’t get 3 car seats in a standard car) and whether you need to move. Overall cost until school age isn’t that useful surely?

DragonMovie · 16/11/2022 16:36

Jealous of your childcare costs!! It’s almost exactly half mine

RedWingBoots · 16/11/2022 16:33

15k loss of earnings during mat leave (different for everyone but based on difference between part time earnings and mat pay)

Would you not get a pay rise?

25k - childcare 3 days a week from age 1 to starting school (will vary based on birth month)

Under estimate in London and SE? Also even outside these areas childcare providers are putting up their fees to cover the increase in energy and food costs. So that cost is unpredictable.

15k - everything else (nappies, wipes, formula, clothes, equipment)
That's 3K per year. As it is your 3rd child you would spend less as you would reuse clothes and equipment. Also depending on whether your friends have finished their families they may give you items they can't sell on plus as PPs said you can get second hand stuff.

Q2C4 · 16/11/2022 16:12

User135792468 · 15/11/2022 22:46

Thanks for the replies. To answer a few questions and comments.

We wouldn’t have any additional housing or car cost.

The mat leave figure is the difference between my mat leave pay and salary. We wouldn’t be entitled to child benefit.

It would be dc 3 - there are things that could be reused but things are looking worn now they have been used by 2 dc. Clothing would depend on gender and season. Plus toys, books etc.

I calculated the childcare based on our current nursery fees, taking into account the different price per age and then deducting tax free childcare and then the reduced cost when 30 hours kicks in. We also only need childcare in term time for 3 days a week. For those saying it’s high, that is the minimum cost without taking into consideration fee increases which are inevitable.

The 15k includes everything from prams, bedroom furniture, day to costs, nappies, wipes, formula, car seats and every other thing going. I think 3k a year is very conservative and is easily surpassed.

To those wondering why we’re having the conversation, dh is saying that for a third baby, he wants to plan financially and have the childcare costs and mat leave salary difference in additional savings before baby is born so these aren’t taken out of salary. He is basically saying that he doesn’t want our lifestyle to change as he doesn’t think it’s fair to our current dc and he enjoys nice holidays, days out etc. Our day to day costs will naturally go up with an additional family member. It’s hard as I do understand where he’s coming from but I don’t look at it so clinically. He’s a planner, I’m more of a, it’ll be fine kind of person.

Re the £15k budget, I can see how things could add up if you bought everything new but you can get some very good quality furniture / clothing etc second hand via eg eBay, Facebook market place. My local FB freebay page is very handy! That's the one part of your budget I think you could flex.

RandomCatGenerator · 16/11/2022 00:30

ISeeTheLight · 15/11/2022 22:19

We once calculated how much DD had cost us as she asked us (never asked again, ha!)
Nursery fees alone the first 3 years were more than your £55k. But that was full time and in London (8 to 5 years ago). If we hadn't had nursery fees and one of us had quit our job in lost earnings it would have been a lot more than £55k too.

God I wish I hadn’t done this calculation.

MerculesHorse · 15/11/2022 23:39

Oh right. I have three and the third child is the cheapest so far as we were quite well set up. We've only really needed to spend a few hundred getting set up with new maternity gear where old bits had worn out and a couple of repairs to previous gear for the baby. Unless you have a massive gap you'll be able to reuse loads anyway. I've also been amazed how much we've been handed down by people who are done having kids so gender and season makes less of a difference.

Kite22 · 15/11/2022 23:34

The 15k includes everything from prams, bedroom furniture, day to costs, nappies, wipes, formula, car seats and every other thing going.

If this is dc3, then you will already have all this.

If money is tight, you don't need to take such a long maternity leave.

I think you are wildly over estimating the cost of consumables.
I know the child benefit balanced out formula and nappies when mine were babies, then once on to 'normal food', you just stretch things a bit further - it doesn't increase your food bill by 1/4 to squeeze a 3rd dc in.

Itisbetter · 15/11/2022 23:13

everything from prams, bedroom furniture, day to costs, nappies, wipes, formula, car seats and every other thing going. but surely you have most of this?

User135792468 · 15/11/2022 22:46

Thanks for the replies. To answer a few questions and comments.

We wouldn’t have any additional housing or car cost.

The mat leave figure is the difference between my mat leave pay and salary. We wouldn’t be entitled to child benefit.

It would be dc 3 - there are things that could be reused but things are looking worn now they have been used by 2 dc. Clothing would depend on gender and season. Plus toys, books etc.

I calculated the childcare based on our current nursery fees, taking into account the different price per age and then deducting tax free childcare and then the reduced cost when 30 hours kicks in. We also only need childcare in term time for 3 days a week. For those saying it’s high, that is the minimum cost without taking into consideration fee increases which are inevitable.

The 15k includes everything from prams, bedroom furniture, day to costs, nappies, wipes, formula, car seats and every other thing going. I think 3k a year is very conservative and is easily surpassed.

To those wondering why we’re having the conversation, dh is saying that for a third baby, he wants to plan financially and have the childcare costs and mat leave salary difference in additional savings before baby is born so these aren’t taken out of salary. He is basically saying that he doesn’t want our lifestyle to change as he doesn’t think it’s fair to our current dc and he enjoys nice holidays, days out etc. Our day to day costs will naturally go up with an additional family member. It’s hard as I do understand where he’s coming from but I don’t look at it so clinically. He’s a planner, I’m more of a, it’ll be fine kind of person.

OP posts:
Notthetoothfairy · 15/11/2022 22:27

If it always did cost that much, many, many people would never have children. It doesn’t sound like you are massively struggling and you only have one DC at present. Some decisions just have to be made by the heart ❤️

SavingsThreads · 15/11/2022 22:24

Child care costs are not too high. OP will get 30 free hours (unless exceptionally high earner) and tax free childcare

MerculesHorse · 15/11/2022 22:23

We added up lost career potential too so getting the next promotion a couple of years later. If you're really going for it don't forget reductions to pensions and savings interest.
There is an offset on childcare too - while I'm on mat leave my older kids don't need so much paid childcare which is saving us about £500 a month.

WinkOnlyCellophane · 15/11/2022 22:22

Ah yes but age 3, you get the 30 free hours as long as neither of you are earning over £100k pa. This will really cut the cost down - potentially by half or two thirds depending on how your childcare provider calculates the hours.

Plus £87 per month child benefit as long as neither of you are earning over £60k pa.

PeppermintyPatty · 15/11/2022 22:22

I think that’s not an unreasonable estimate, not least because I used loads more heating on mat leave and when feeding babies overnight

ISeeTheLight · 15/11/2022 22:19

We once calculated how much DD had cost us as she asked us (never asked again, ha!)
Nursery fees alone the first 3 years were more than your £55k. But that was full time and in London (8 to 5 years ago). If we hadn't had nursery fees and one of us had quit our job in lost earnings it would have been a lot more than £55k too.

WinkOnlyCellophane · 15/11/2022 22:17

BabyShaark · 15/11/2022 22:02

Childcare looks low for SE. DDs nursery charges £75 per hour (Herts)

£15k for ancillary costs seems high.

Agree.

You can expect £15-20k childcare costs per year per child if sending them five days a week.

£15k for other stuff is very high I think. And there’s a good resale market for a lot of stuff too especially some very expensive items like prams.

JamMakingWannaBe · 15/11/2022 22:16

Are you including the extra child benefit you'll receive?

Puddywoodycat · 15/11/2022 22:13

Plus unexpected expenses like Sen needs .

Puddywoodycat · 15/11/2022 22:12

I think if you want to calculate it out you need to factor in how long you want to work for , retirment, contingency for illness, divorce etc.

Some people saying they lost thousands being at home, are they able to work for two years more at the other end of caarer.

DayInBed · 15/11/2022 22:12

If it is £64 pound a week for all costs as a PP says - I think that sounds about right. There will be less costs involved if the older child is closer in age as a lot of items can be reused and also a lot of activities can be shared. When you add up the costs involved in travel and participation in day trips and holidays, birthdays and Christmas, educational toys and even the added fuel to travel to childcare etc it will add up (I live rurally!). Food will be a relatively low cost as you already have DC. Babysitting (if you use this in the evenings) will go up.

Also, I'm assuming you have suitable space to house the child? You wouldn't need to move to a bigger home - Because that could be a significant cost? I'm also assuming you wouldn't need to purchase a bigger car?

It is hard to predict all the costs as some people will naturally spend more on their kids than others - but the amount seems reasonable.

gogohmm · 15/11/2022 22:08

£15k for nappies, clothes etc seems very high. I'm not that out of touch!

Personally I used cloth and breastfed so expenditure was low