Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

General election tomorrow - who do you vote for?

534 replies

IaminRome · 15/11/2022 19:12

I'm so sick of this government and reading a lot of the posts on here, it feels like on the one hand, so are lots of people, but there are also lots of other people who are very sceptical about labour or lib dem or greens. Added to which, there are so many issues at the moment, I know there's a lot of GC and what makes a woman, that is particularly important at the moment, and cost of living, private rentals, the environment, etc etc

So knowing what you know about the parties, if there was a general election tomorrow, who would you vote for..

YABU - Tories
YANBU - Labour
Comment for a third option

I used to be green, but I'm so not sure any more. So I think I'd vote labour, to stand best chance of keeping Tories out. (What I'd really like to vote for is a more representative government)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 12:07

TheHoover · 30/05/2023 10:46

MargotBamborough · Today 10:00
It's really telling that some posters keep saying, "But the Tories don't protect women's rights either!" and refusing to answer the question about why Labour won't protect women's rights.

the point is that women’s rights is about so very much more than the trans issue. Eg the threat of eroding maternity rights due to divorcing uk law from EU law (which the hard brexiteer business leaders are pushing for). The shocking numbers of Pro life senior tories who are voting against or abstaining from pro choice votes in parliament. The disgusting misogynistic methods of policing in this country and absence of proper legislation to come down hard on perpetrators of domestic violence. Not to mention health and welfare for the poorest in society.

I agree that women's rights is broader than just the trans issue.

But I simply don't trust a party which refuses to even name the group of people affected because it upsets some other people (who are not actually oppressed, just spoilt and self obsessed) to fight for any women's rights.

How are women supposed to make an equal pay claim if we no longer actually have words in the English language or the legal system to clearly distinguish between the two sexes?

Stella Creasy banged on incessantly about MPs not getting maternity leave and not being allowed to breastfeed in the House of Commons, and then she said that not only are trans women women, they are also female! Sorry, Stella, are you really saying that we don't need a word for the group of people who experience barriers to entering and progressing in politics because they don't get paid maternity leave and their employer doesn't facilitate them breastfeeding their very young babies? She knows exactly what a woman is and what female means when she personally finds herself on the sharp end of sex discrimination, but when it's only other women affected, such as female prisoners and female athletes and female rape survivors, trans women are female, apparently, and we don't need a word for the group of people who used to be female when the word female still meant the same thing in humans as it does in all other animals.

Ultimately, there is no good reason why Labour doesn't agree that women should have the language to clearly identify and describe themselves in a way that excludes the opposite sex, and to have our own single sex spaces and sports.

You can bleat, "But what about the evil nasty Tories!" all you like, but you cannot actually come up with a good reason why Labour supports the erasure of the female sex in law and language, and their sex based rights.

And I doubt we will see a "female" Labour leader until Eddie Izzard has got a gender recognition certificate.

pointythings · 30/05/2023 11:53

@TheHoover this. I find the view of women's rights being 100% about gender ID to be dangerously narrow. The picture is so much bigger.

TheHoover · 30/05/2023 10:46

MargotBamborough · Today 10:00
It's really telling that some posters keep saying, "But the Tories don't protect women's rights either!" and refusing to answer the question about why Labour won't protect women's rights.

the point is that women’s rights is about so very much more than the trans issue. Eg the threat of eroding maternity rights due to divorcing uk law from EU law (which the hard brexiteer business leaders are pushing for). The shocking numbers of Pro life senior tories who are voting against or abstaining from pro choice votes in parliament. The disgusting misogynistic methods of policing in this country and absence of proper legislation to come down hard on perpetrators of domestic violence. Not to mention health and welfare for the poorest in society.

MargotBamborough · 30/05/2023 10:00

It's really telling that some posters keep saying, "But the Tories don't protect women's rights either!" and refusing to answer the question about why Labour won't protect women's rights.

AnarchoTyrannosaurus · 30/05/2023 08:33

CabernetSauvignon · 30/05/2023 07:57

How dreadful to be under a government which will protect women's and children's rights so much better than the current one does and will.

Labour won't protect women's rights. I'm not voting for a party who doesn't know what a woman is. If the word woman loses its meaning then women have no rights or safeguards. The Tories started this. Labour will go even further with it. If anyone out there actually cares about women's rights and safeguards voting for labour would be a very self destructive move.

CabernetSauvignon · 30/05/2023 07:57

AnarchoTyrannosaurus · 29/05/2023 20:31

Women and girls will suffer the consequences of labours policies, should we ever be unfortunate enough to see them in power.

How dreadful to be under a government which will protect women's and children's rights so much better than the current one does and will.

CabernetSauvignon · 30/05/2023 07:54

will spoil my ballot with a feminist sticker as I did last time.

But what's the point of that? No-one will know or care. Better to stand as a candidate yourself, surely, if there are none whose views align with yours.

SherbetDips · 29/05/2023 23:24

I’ll vote Conservative

babybythesea · 29/05/2023 23:22

Lib Dem.

  1. It’s the only party that even comes close to Tory here.
  2. The Lib Dem candidate has been doing the rounds since before he was even a candidate, knocking on doors, asking what people think. I’ve never even had a reply to emails I’ve sent the current Tory MP. I love that someone is so invested they go out and about talking to people before they are even elected to be the candidate for their party.
So Lib Dem works for me on both a local and national level.
ilovesooty · 29/05/2023 23:15

TinyTopknot · 29/05/2023 22:48

If this is such an extreme position can you please explain why we have single sex facilities? It is to keep women and girls safe because SOME men are predatory but we do not know which so we treat ALL men as potentially predatory to keep us safe. It is called safeguarding.

Not that extreme is it?

I think it's extreme to assume that all men are predatory by default.

I don't know anyone in real life who thinks like that. I only see it on here.

TinyTopknot · 29/05/2023 22:48

ilovesooty · 29/05/2023 21:45

Very.

If this is such an extreme position can you please explain why we have single sex facilities? It is to keep women and girls safe because SOME men are predatory but we do not know which so we treat ALL men as potentially predatory to keep us safe. It is called safeguarding.

Not that extreme is it?

Blossomtoes · 29/05/2023 22:43

TinyTopknot · 29/05/2023 19:56

And yet it is the vulnerable women and girls who will/already are suffering the consequences of the LP pretending that males can be women.
How about the female prisoners incarcerated with male rapists? It's happening.
Vulnerable ill woman on a female ward raped by a transwoman? Happened already.
Teenage girls getting infections because they daren't used the school loos because the loos are mixed sex to appease the militant trans lobby? Happening every day.
Vulnerable elderly women denied same sex carers as this is deemed transphobic?
And on and on it goes - and this is BEFORE self id. WTF happens when the LP make it law?

Which party has been in power while those things have happened. “Knowing what a woman is” is just words. Why hasn’t the party that trumpets this put its money where its mouth is? It’s just empty rhetoric.

SwordToFlamethrower · 29/05/2023 22:25

No idea. Until starmer makes it clear he is for protecting women's rights and spaces, I've got no one to vote for.

MargotBamborough · 29/05/2023 21:48

RafaistheKingofClay · 29/05/2023 20:51

So who are you going to vote for that isn’t going to throw women under the bus? Because it certainly isn’t the Tory Party and what is any single issue party going to do about the myriad of other problems in this country that the Tory party has caused which are also adversely affecting women.

No good knowing what a woman is if that woman is having to go without meals to ensure her children have food. Or is unable to access healthcare. Or is burnt out juggling work and caring responsibilities (let’s face it it will be women taking on more) because the social care system is underfunded and short staffed. Or is burnt out because she works in health or social care and is essentially trying to do the work of more than one person because the huge recruitment issues. Or waits years for a rape case to get to trial (if it gets that far) because the justice system is fucked. Or welfare cuts and benefits sanctions which I’d guess disproportionately affects women, particularly single parents. And that’s before you even get onto more general things like cuts to legal aid, reduced employee rights and increased food poverty, increased fuel poverty under the Tories.

If people are happy to vote for the Tories over labour on the basis that labour say trans women are women then you don’t really give a fuck about women because you are quite happy for them to be thrown under all the other buses. Just not the gender ID one.

I WOULD REALLY FUCKING LOVE THERE TO BE A PARTY WHICH ISN'T GOING TO THROW WOMEN UNDER THE BUS AND DON'T UNDERSTAND WHY YOU AREN'T MORE ANGRY THAT THERE ISN'T ONE, AND THAT LABOUR ISN'T THAT PARTY.

Jesus.

MargotBamborough · 29/05/2023 21:47

pointythings · 29/05/2023 20:52

No, a GC extremist is someone who sees all transwomen as inherently predatory by nature and isn't who makes unfounded assumptions about what a political party might do once they are in power. I have no argument about biological sex - what makes the extreme is what is done with that argument.

I only hope that people who will spoil a ballot solely on this issue are so small in numbers that they won't put the Tories back in power and condemn millions - very many of them women - to 5 more years of austerity, exploitation and yes - the same policies they're professing to be so worried about.

Unfounded assumptions? Labour have been very clear that they intend to introduce self ID.

I don't see all trans women as inherently predatory any more than I see all men as inherently predatory.

We still keep all men out of women's spaces, because there's no way of distinguishing, in either fact or law, between the predatory ones and the safe ones. That remains true regardless of whether the person in question has any kind of gender identity.

ilovesooty · 29/05/2023 21:45

pointythings · 29/05/2023 21:36

I see all men as inherently predatory.

That is a very extreme position indeed.

Very.

MargotBamborough · 29/05/2023 21:45

ilovesooty · 29/05/2023 21:27

@TinyTopknot so you're a GC extremist then.

Gender critical feminists simply believe in the importance, immutability and binary nature of biological sex.

There is no such thing as being a gender critical extremist, the same way there is no such thing as being a "the earth is spherical and orbits around the sun" extremist.

MargotBamborough · 29/05/2023 21:43

pointythings · 29/05/2023 20:27

And yet it is the vulnerable women and girls who will/already are suffering the consequences of the LP pretending that males can be women.

How can vulnerable women and girls be suffering the consequences of the LP's policies when Labour are not in power?

Honestly, some GC extremists aren't just blinkered, they have a bucket on their heads.

Labour think the Tories are terrible transphobes who haven't gone far enough!

Are they going to be the ones to wrestle the gender borg under control and put this shit back in its box where it belongs?

I do not think so.

pointythings · 29/05/2023 21:36

I see all men as inherently predatory.

That is a very extreme position indeed.

TinyTopknot · 29/05/2023 21:29

😂😂

ilovesooty · 29/05/2023 21:27

@TinyTopknot so you're a GC extremist then.

TinyTopknot · 29/05/2023 21:17

pointythings · 29/05/2023 20:52

No, a GC extremist is someone who sees all transwomen as inherently predatory by nature and isn't who makes unfounded assumptions about what a political party might do once they are in power. I have no argument about biological sex - what makes the extreme is what is done with that argument.

I only hope that people who will spoil a ballot solely on this issue are so small in numbers that they won't put the Tories back in power and condemn millions - very many of them women - to 5 more years of austerity, exploitation and yes - the same policies they're professing to be so worried about.

I see all men as inherently predatory. We set up safeguarding of girls and women because of this and the good guys don't complain because they understand safeguarding.
Transwomen are men and so women and girls should be safeguarded from them in the same way that we do for all other men - they are not some sacred caste. Making certain groups of men in to a sacred caste is extremely dangerous.

The Party has TOLD YOU what they will do if they get in to power - wake up!

TinyTopknot · 29/05/2023 21:13

RafaistheKingofClay · 29/05/2023 20:51

So who are you going to vote for that isn’t going to throw women under the bus? Because it certainly isn’t the Tory Party and what is any single issue party going to do about the myriad of other problems in this country that the Tory party has caused which are also adversely affecting women.

No good knowing what a woman is if that woman is having to go without meals to ensure her children have food. Or is unable to access healthcare. Or is burnt out juggling work and caring responsibilities (let’s face it it will be women taking on more) because the social care system is underfunded and short staffed. Or is burnt out because she works in health or social care and is essentially trying to do the work of more than one person because the huge recruitment issues. Or waits years for a rape case to get to trial (if it gets that far) because the justice system is fucked. Or welfare cuts and benefits sanctions which I’d guess disproportionately affects women, particularly single parents. And that’s before you even get onto more general things like cuts to legal aid, reduced employee rights and increased food poverty, increased fuel poverty under the Tories.

If people are happy to vote for the Tories over labour on the basis that labour say trans women are women then you don’t really give a fuck about women because you are quite happy for them to be thrown under all the other buses. Just not the gender ID one.

Why do you assume that not voting Labour means that people will vote Tory? I am an ex LP member ashamed of what the LP has become and will spoil my ballot with a feminist sticker as I did last time.

pointythings · 29/05/2023 20:58

@RafaistheKingofClay well said.