Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

General election tomorrow - who do you vote for?

534 replies

IaminRome · 15/11/2022 19:12

I'm so sick of this government and reading a lot of the posts on here, it feels like on the one hand, so are lots of people, but there are also lots of other people who are very sceptical about labour or lib dem or greens. Added to which, there are so many issues at the moment, I know there's a lot of GC and what makes a woman, that is particularly important at the moment, and cost of living, private rentals, the environment, etc etc

So knowing what you know about the parties, if there was a general election tomorrow, who would you vote for..

YABU - Tories
YANBU - Labour
Comment for a third option

I used to be green, but I'm so not sure any more. So I think I'd vote labour, to stand best chance of keeping Tories out. (What I'd really like to vote for is a more representative government)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 11:14

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 11:12

I think you're contradicting yourself here @MargotBamborough

You say, "Have people like David Lammy, Lisa Nandy, Nadia Whittome and Stella Creasy apologised? No. Have they admitted they were wrong? No." Then you say Keir Starmer has admitted that Labour has learned its lesson.

This is a humble admission and an honest one. Maybe not the apology you wanted, but apologies are words not deed.

I hope Keir Starmer and Labour continue to listen to people and adapt. If you see that as spin then that is entirely your take and you are entitled to it.

I'm not contradicting myself at all.

I don't believe Keir Starmer actually believes Labour are wrong about this. All he has learned is that "women can have penises" goes down like a cup of cold sick with most of the electorate because they are bigoted and he needs to tone down the rhetoric a bit in order to win. Once he's won, he'll go full steam ahead with self ID.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 11:13

deeds - dammit.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 11:12

I think you're contradicting yourself here @MargotBamborough

You say, "Have people like David Lammy, Lisa Nandy, Nadia Whittome and Stella Creasy apologised? No. Have they admitted they were wrong? No." Then you say Keir Starmer has admitted that Labour has learned its lesson.

This is a humble admission and an honest one. Maybe not the apology you wanted, but apologies are words not deed.

I hope Keir Starmer and Labour continue to listen to people and adapt. If you see that as spin then that is entirely your take and you are entitled to it.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 11:07

@MargotBamborough you are so entrenched in your view that the Labour Party is actively damaging to women that no amount of evidence is going to change your mind.

Single issue people like you aren't going to change their views on things

Other people don't operate in a single issue world - and I'm thankful that there are people with a wider perspective on what is important for wider society.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:58

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:36

Lisa Nandy's comments were made in February 2020. A whole world of learning and experience has happened since then.

Here is a more recent view from Labour " Steve Reed, the Labour shadow Justice Secretary, gave a good example on Good Morning Britain this morning, declaring clearly: ‘Women’s prisons are for biological women.’ Reed was setting out his view that a transwoman who is convicted of sexual crimes should not be housed in female prisons. "

If you are wanting change @MargotBamborough then it is happening.

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/so-what-is-labours-position-on-transwomen-in-prisons/

Honestly? I think the only thing they have learned is that the "female penis" doesn't go down well from a comms perspective and they need to dial down their rhetoric a bit before the election.

So the people who have previously said completely insane things on this subject are shutting up a bit, and people whose reputations aren't quite so tarnished are being wheeled out to say more nuanced things in some sort of damage control exercise.

Have people like David Lammy, Lisa Nandy, Nadia Whittome and Stella Creasy apologised? No. Have they admitted they were wrong? No.

Keir Starmer has moved from saying it's wrong to say that only women have a cervix (presumably his excuse for throwing Rosie Duffield to the wolves) to saying that 99.9% of women don't have a penis. Meaning that when they say they will protect women's spaces and women's rights, they are including the 0.1% of "women" they believe DO have a penis. And that our changing rooms and rape crisis groups must also include that 0.1%.

He has said that Labour has learned its lesson and needs to bring the public with them on this. To me that says he believes Labour are right and the public are wrong but he still needs their votes so Labour will tone it down a bit until they're safely in power. He's also said that self ID isn't a priority, not that they won't do it.

Sorry, but that gives me no comfort at all. Promise me you won't do it, Keir, because it's a really terrible idea, and maybe I'll consider voting for you.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:38

The Spectator article is dated February 2023.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:36

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:25

Yes they do.

Did you hear Lisa Nandy's response when asked what prison a male rapist who says he identifies as a woman should be in?

Absolutely disgusting.

Lisa Nandy's comments were made in February 2020. A whole world of learning and experience has happened since then.

Here is a more recent view from Labour " Steve Reed, the Labour shadow Justice Secretary, gave a good example on Good Morning Britain this morning, declaring clearly: ‘Women’s prisons are for biological women.’ Reed was setting out his view that a transwoman who is convicted of sexual crimes should not be housed in female prisons. "

If you are wanting change @MargotBamborough then it is happening.

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/so-what-is-labours-position-on-transwomen-in-prisons/

What is Labour's position on transwomen in prisons?

The fallout from Scotland’s trans prison debacle continues, raising some awkward questions for Westminster politicians. Many are scrambling to insist that – despite keeping very quiet on the trans issue for years – they were, in fact, never convinced t...

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/so-what-is-labours-position-on-transwomen-in-prisons

TheHandmaiden · 28/05/2023 10:26

What is interesting is that the Conservative intended vote is dropping, Labour is about static, but the Lib Dem vote is starting to pick up. Looks like the Conservatives are losing the traditional true blue vote to the Liberals.

It's economics that is driving this, mortgages going up for the next 12 months, inflation staying about where it is, and Hunt saying a recession is acceptable.

Truly incompetent - the standard of living in the U.K. for a pretty well off middle England voter is being affected. The Conservatives are finished unless they can address that, and immigration for their red wall vote.

waterlego · 28/05/2023 10:26

I’d vote Labour purely because they are the only ones who have a chance of ousting our Tory MP who has held this seat for 26 years and Labour are a bit less awful than Conservative in my eyes.

If it weren’t for that, I probably wouldn’t vote at all as I don’t respect or trust any of them.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:25

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:24

Why do Labour think women and girls are less important than this tiny, self-identified, not actually remotely oppressed minority?

They don't.

Yes they do.

Did you hear Lisa Nandy's response when asked what prison a male rapist who says he identifies as a woman should be in?

Absolutely disgusting.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:25

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:21

@MargotBamborough I have detailed Labour's intentions regarding protecting women's rights earlier in this thread.

I won't do it again especially as I've just read your previous post which asks us to stop wasting our time trying to persuade women who have very clear reasons for not voting Labour to do so. That's your choice, but having experienced 13 years of Tory government and its negative impact on women I will vote Labour next time.

I would also take your sensible advice on speaking to my local labour party about about women's concerns had I not already done so.

Thank you for speaking to your local party about women's concerns. I suggest every woman on this thread trying to convince us all to vote Labour does likewise.

If they do a complete U turn before the next election I might vote for them.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:24

Why do Labour think women and girls are less important than this tiny, self-identified, not actually remotely oppressed minority?

They don't.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:22

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 10:17

In the context you mean there isn’t one. No party supports your version of “women’s rights”. I personally think actions speak louder than words and the Tories’ record of damaging women over the last 13 years shouts that they don’t give a flying fuck about women.

Rather than constantly saying, "But the Tories!" can we take a moment to reflect on how fucking appalling it is that there isn't one?

Why isn't Labour that party?

No need for inverted commas around "women's rights" by the way.

We DO have the right to be treated like actual human beings and not just support animals for men who think they identify as women.

Why do Labour think women and girls are less important than this tiny, self-identified, not actually remotely oppressed minority?

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:21

@MargotBamborough I have detailed Labour's intentions regarding protecting women's rights earlier in this thread.

I won't do it again especially as I've just read your previous post which asks us to stop wasting our time trying to persuade women who have very clear reasons for not voting Labour to do so. That's your choice, but having experienced 13 years of Tory government and its negative impact on women I will vote Labour next time.

I would also take your sensible advice on speaking to my local labour party about about women's concerns had I not already done so.

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 10:17

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:13

Can you tell us which party to vote for which will actually protect women's rights then?

In the context you mean there isn’t one. No party supports your version of “women’s rights”. I personally think actions speak louder than words and the Tories’ record of damaging women over the last 13 years shouts that they don’t give a flying fuck about women.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:13

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:11

All of the people born male playing in women's sports you are currently seeing in this country is happening under a Tory government.

Can you tell us which party to vote for which will actually protect women's rights then?

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:11

Tots678 · 28/05/2023 07:32

Tories as I don't want people born male to play in women's sports.
Otherwise they are all crap.

All of the people born male playing in women's sports you are currently seeing in this country is happening under a Tory government.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 10:08

coffeerevelsrule · 28/05/2023 09:54

It's a bit annoying to say the least when people make comments like those quoted above claiming that Labour have given no details of their plans. They've said a lot about the NHS, though their actual manifesto hasn't come out yet. If you can't be bothered to read the details, that's on you.

The trans issue has been difficult for them without a doubt but Starmer's latest comment is that 99.9% of women don't have a penis, and he goes on to talk about the minority of people who identify differently from their biological sex who need to be protected but that women's rights won't be rolled back in doing so. It's not perfect at all, but the Labour leadership is categorically not insisting blithely that women can have penises and that you're a bigot if you disagree.

Lammy made the stupid dinosaur comment about a year ago, but since then front benchers' comments have been far more nuanced. Not ideal, but clearly moving in the right direction. There are lots of Labour supporters who have been 'captured' and they do have to be very careful not to alienate them. I think Starmer means it when he says the debate has become toxic. He's obviously trying to avoid divisive rhetoric while also trying to appease both sides, which does carry the problem of appearing weak or a bit mealy-mouthed at times, but I prefer that to the Tory's approach which is to go all out on turning it into simplified wedge issue, not giving a toss who gets hurt in the process and not giving a shit about trans people or women really. I don't love Labour's stance, but it's totally inaccurate to say the party's official position is 'women have penises and you're a bigot if you disagree.' Labour do have back benchers who are a lot more strident on the matter, but I truly believe Starmer has them under control. Unlike the Tories, who extreme right-wing back benchers have been pandered to by successive weak leaders and have pretty much wrecked the country as a result, though happily they've done a lot of damage to their own party too, which is nice.

100% of women don't have a penis.

Has David Lammy apologised for his comment? Has he fuck.

Stop wasting your time trying to persuade women who have very clear reasons for not voting Labour to do so. Left wing misogynists are not better than right wing misogynists.

Your time would be better spent writing to your local Labour MP or candidate and telling them that whilst you plan to vote for them, you are hearing of quite a few women who won't, until Labour acknowledge that we are a distinct category of people based on biological sex, not magic gender feels, and that we are entitled to have words to discuss our lived reality, and single sex spaces free from penis people.

Until they admit that they have got this wrong, I am not interested.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 10:07

FKATondelayo · 28/05/2023 00:00

Just because I am not planning on voting doesn't mean I'm not politically active - quite the opposite. Showing up every 5 years to put a tick next to a stranger is not the only way to influence democracy. In fact I think it's the least effective way. You're just choosing from a range of policies you had no involvement in creating. Lobbying, campaigning and forming relationships with your local MP and councillors regardless of party is harder but more effective.

Now there's some stuff we completely agree on. I've always been a campaigner (learned that at my mother's knee and will never break the habit). It's the best way to make change and to feel that you're doing something positive in a crazy world.

verdantverdure · 28/05/2023 10:06

I'm not at all angry @MargotBamborough

I'm bewildered.

Thee are a lot of things I want for my children, but a meaningless slogan isn't one of them.

The thought of choosing a slogan over practical and tangible things our children need is really out there to me.

verdantverdure · 28/05/2023 09:58

Tots678 · 28/05/2023 07:32

Tories as I don't want people born male to play in women's sports.
Otherwise they are all crap.

You've looked at the state of the NHS, education, the economy, sewage on our beaches, the hit our pension funds took because of the Mini Budget, your energy bills, the price of the weekly shop, your monthly mortgage bill, and your shrinking rights, and you thought
^"Five more years of this please!"
^
That's so Brexit.

Voting to be worse off because of a slogan.

coffeerevelsrule · 28/05/2023 09:54

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 06:48

It's going to be one of them, yes.

But whichever one of them is going to win can do so without my help.

Not sure why there's so much anger being directed at me for planning to spoil my ballot instead of at Labour for being misogynistic ideologues mired in identity politics rather than sane and sensible politicians with an actual plan for fixing the country.

How exactly do you think Labour is going to fix all these things anyway? Sure, they say they'll sort out the NHS and blah blah blah, but HOW?

Because right now we have absolutely no details, and someone who is going to keep a straight face whilst they say women can have penises and if you disagree you're a bigot is not someone I would trust to run a bath, let alone a country.

It's a bit annoying to say the least when people make comments like those quoted above claiming that Labour have given no details of their plans. They've said a lot about the NHS, though their actual manifesto hasn't come out yet. If you can't be bothered to read the details, that's on you.

The trans issue has been difficult for them without a doubt but Starmer's latest comment is that 99.9% of women don't have a penis, and he goes on to talk about the minority of people who identify differently from their biological sex who need to be protected but that women's rights won't be rolled back in doing so. It's not perfect at all, but the Labour leadership is categorically not insisting blithely that women can have penises and that you're a bigot if you disagree.

Lammy made the stupid dinosaur comment about a year ago, but since then front benchers' comments have been far more nuanced. Not ideal, but clearly moving in the right direction. There are lots of Labour supporters who have been 'captured' and they do have to be very careful not to alienate them. I think Starmer means it when he says the debate has become toxic. He's obviously trying to avoid divisive rhetoric while also trying to appease both sides, which does carry the problem of appearing weak or a bit mealy-mouthed at times, but I prefer that to the Tory's approach which is to go all out on turning it into simplified wedge issue, not giving a toss who gets hurt in the process and not giving a shit about trans people or women really. I don't love Labour's stance, but it's totally inaccurate to say the party's official position is 'women have penises and you're a bigot if you disagree.' Labour do have back benchers who are a lot more strident on the matter, but I truly believe Starmer has them under control. Unlike the Tories, who extreme right-wing back benchers have been pandered to by successive weak leaders and have pretty much wrecked the country as a result, though happily they've done a lot of damage to their own party too, which is nice.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 09:14

Tots678 · 28/05/2023 07:32

Tories as I don't want people born male to play in women's sports.
Otherwise they are all crap.

Oh dear.

user1471505356 · 28/05/2023 09:13

Those who do not vote are trusting someone else to vote for them, what a risky choice.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 09:13

@Colourfingers2 you are making a fool of yourself.