Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

General election tomorrow - who do you vote for?

534 replies

IaminRome · 15/11/2022 19:12

I'm so sick of this government and reading a lot of the posts on here, it feels like on the one hand, so are lots of people, but there are also lots of other people who are very sceptical about labour or lib dem or greens. Added to which, there are so many issues at the moment, I know there's a lot of GC and what makes a woman, that is particularly important at the moment, and cost of living, private rentals, the environment, etc etc

So knowing what you know about the parties, if there was a general election tomorrow, who would you vote for..

YABU - Tories
YANBU - Labour
Comment for a third option

I used to be green, but I'm so not sure any more. So I think I'd vote labour, to stand best chance of keeping Tories out. (What I'd really like to vote for is a more representative government)

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
verdantverdure · 28/05/2023 17:45

I'm a bit GC.

I think Brexit is an insanity that will have to be reversed if we want to get our economy back on track

But I won't allow this to stop me from voting in the best interests of our country in every other category.

And after 13 years it is clear to me that it's in the best interests of our country to get the Tories out.

So I will vote for whoever I have to to get our safe seat Tory MP out.

Our kids need good education, good healthcare, good public services, good law and order, good government.

Not to be told "the country can't afford" things we used to be able to afford before we had 13 years of the Tories.

L1ttledrummergirl · 28/05/2023 15:50

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 13:17

Protecting biological women's language and spaces is completely incompatible with saying that trans women are women or being in favour of self ID.

If Labour have changed their position on self ID then they need to shout it from the rooftops.

I agree, and that's why pressure needs to be maintained.

I disagree that the solution is to allow the conservatives to continue to treat the country like its own private bank account, using civil servants like personal servants and continuing to introduce ideals that are detrimental to women, whilst blaming Labour for being worse.

I think that our politicians were lead down the twaw narrative in baby steps, each one seeming innocuous. I think backtracking from this is hard, but not impossible. It's happening in athletics, it can happen in other areas too.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 14:48

TheHoover · 28/05/2023 14:45

pointythings · Today 12:15
If they said, "We are committed to protecting trans people's rights but we also acknowledge that biological women need their own single sex spaces and sports, so we want to ensure that biological women and trans women are both catered for, equally but separately", that would be a game changer.

The problem is that journalists (and voters) demand answers to inane questions such as ‘can women have penises?’ and ‘are trans women women’? The far better question is ‘given that there are a proportion of people in this country that are not born biologically female but wish to be treated as such, how should they be accommodated?’

You would then get a much better quality of answer.

I agree with that, but would be even more specific.

How should they be accommodated in toilets and changing rooms? How should they be accommodated in rape crisis groups? How should they be accommodated in prisons? How should they be accommodated in sports?

How should women who don't feel able to share these spaces with biological males be accommodated?

Are there actually any situations in which men and women are accommodated separately, where they should be accommodated as though they were women?

TheHoover · 28/05/2023 14:45

pointythings · Today 12:15
If they said, "We are committed to protecting trans people's rights but we also acknowledge that biological women need their own single sex spaces and sports, so we want to ensure that biological women and trans women are both catered for, equally but separately", that would be a game changer.

The problem is that journalists (and voters) demand answers to inane questions such as ‘can women have penises?’ and ‘are trans women women’? The far better question is ‘given that there are a proportion of people in this country that are not born biologically female but wish to be treated as such, how should they be accommodated?’

You would then get a much better quality of answer.

TheHoover · 28/05/2023 14:31

Lib Dem are the only party prioritising significant investment in state education and closer ties to Europe.
That gets my vote.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 13:17

L1ttledrummergirl · 28/05/2023 13:13

Starmer has said that. I saw an interview about 6 months ago where he said. I can't remember which journalist it was with, but I definitely heard it.

Protecting biological women's language and spaces is completely incompatible with saying that trans women are women or being in favour of self ID.

If Labour have changed their position on self ID then they need to shout it from the rooftops.

L1ttledrummergirl · 28/05/2023 13:13

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 11:48

The problem is that anything they say on the subject of women's rights is inherently unreliable because they are using the word "women" to mean a mixed sex group which includes male people. As long as the percentage of women who don't have a penis is, according to Labour, less than 100%, the category of people who actually are women and need women's rights is not a category they acknowledge actually exists.

That's why I don't trust them when they say they will protect women's rights, because their idea of what a woman is and my idea of what a woman is are not the same.

If they said, "We are committed to protecting trans people's rights but we also acknowledge that biological women need their own single sex spaces and sports, so we want to ensure that biological women and trans women are both catered for, equally but separately", that would be a game changer.

Starmer has said that. I saw an interview about 6 months ago where he said. I can't remember which journalist it was with, but I definitely heard it.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:57

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 12:46

It tells me we need to be asking serious questions about why so many teenage girls don't want to be women rather than just affirming them and allowing them to make permanent body modifications.

Why aren’t we asking why boys don’t want to be men? Or doesn’t that matter?

Because the massive explosion in numbers you are talking about is largely adolescent girls wanting to be men. A phenomenon which simply didn't exist a few years ago. And the majority of the research into the best way to treat gender dysphoria has been done on male patients and isn't necessarily applicable to this demographic.

There have always been a small number of boys with early onset gender dysphoria, and a number of men who suddenly decide in middle age that they want to present as women.

In the former case, yes, it matters, and we need to be looking into what is causing young boys to decide they are girls. I suspect a lot of it is internalised homophobia as a result of having homophobic parents like Susie Green and her ex husband.

In the latter case, i.e. middle aged men, we need to have an honest discussion about whether there is actually anything society needs to be doing to accommodate what is, in most cases, a sexual fetish.

stargirl1701 · 28/05/2023 12:57

I spoiled my ballot paper last time. None of them are worth my vote.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:54

In practice parties don't win elections - other parties lose them. I think the Labour Party is best served in highlighting all the areas of the government's failures over the last 13 years - including the many ways in which they've failed all vulnerable people.

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 12:46

It tells me we need to be asking serious questions about why so many teenage girls don't want to be women rather than just affirming them and allowing them to make permanent body modifications.

Why aren’t we asking why boys don’t want to be men? Or doesn’t that matter?

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:38

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 12:34

I genuinely do not understand why they have taken this position

Because most voters aren’t single issue voters
Because their exhaustive market research on the issues voters care most about shows it’s well down the list
Because words are cheap and the Tories have shown for the last 13 years they don’t give a shit about women

Did you know that in the last decade the numbers of referrals to GIDS has risen from 210 a year to over 3,000? What does that tell you?

It tells me we need to be asking serious questions about why so many teenage girls don't want to be women rather than just affirming them and allowing them to make permanent body modifications.

Yes, it's been a shit show under the Tories.

But Labour aren't saying the Tories' trans policy has been a shit show because it has undermined women's rights and child safeguarding. They're saying the Tories haven't gone far enough!

Oh and by the way, Labour should care about women's rights regardless of whether they think it will be a vote winning issue.

Blossomtoes · 28/05/2023 12:34

I genuinely do not understand why they have taken this position

Because most voters aren’t single issue voters
Because their exhaustive market research on the issues voters care most about shows it’s well down the list
Because words are cheap and the Tories have shown for the last 13 years they don’t give a shit about women

Did you know that in the last decade the numbers of referrals to GIDS has risen from 210 a year to over 3,000? What does that tell you?

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:32

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:21

But WHY can't Labour just admit that they know what a woman is, everyone knows what a woman is, women don't have penises and we deserve to be treated like human beings in our own right, rather than just there to validate men who identify as women?

I genuinely do not understand why they have taken this position.

If they actually stuck up for the penis free half of the population then it would be a no brainer.

But once you've seen the misogyny lying just underneath the surface of the "be kind" people, you can't unsee it. I can't pretend that David Lammy didn't make those comments about women, and I can't forget that he made them. So unless he apologises for making them then I have to assume that that's still what he thinks of us, and I can't vote for that.

As I said, I think we'll have to agree to disagree.

I don't think Labour's stance on self ID is that important when looking at the wider picture. It's probably better for them if they simply don't get drawn into any further controversy on the issue leading up to an election anyway. Courting single issue voters probably won't benefit them much when there are other issues at stake.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 28/05/2023 12:27

The only parties I can vote for are the SNP, Scottish Greens, or Alba, so it would be (and will be) one of them. Not that it matters, Scottish votes are worthless in a general election.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:21

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:17

In terms of being untrustworthy and incompetent I think the Tories are ahead by a country mile, whatever Labour's stance on self ID, so I think we'll have to agree to differ there.

But WHY can't Labour just admit that they know what a woman is, everyone knows what a woman is, women don't have penises and we deserve to be treated like human beings in our own right, rather than just there to validate men who identify as women?

I genuinely do not understand why they have taken this position.

If they actually stuck up for the penis free half of the population then it would be a no brainer.

But once you've seen the misogyny lying just underneath the surface of the "be kind" people, you can't unsee it. I can't pretend that David Lammy didn't make those comments about women, and I can't forget that he made them. So unless he apologises for making them then I have to assume that that's still what he thinks of us, and I can't vote for that.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:17

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:10

Of course that is your right.

But if you actually want more people to vote Labour and have a better chance of getting rid of the Tories, surely it would be a better use of your time to encourage Labour to re-examine their thinking on this issue. Their position is basically that people born without a penis don't have the right to a word for themselves or any penis free spaces or sports, and that a woman is anyone who says they are one.

That renders anything they might have to say about "women's rights" null and void. It makes them untrustworthy. It makes them liars. It makes them not obviously more competent to run the country than the Tories.

In terms of being untrustworthy and incompetent I think the Tories are ahead by a country mile, whatever Labour's stance on self ID, so I think we'll have to agree to differ there.

pointythings · 28/05/2023 12:15

If they said, "We are committed to protecting trans people's rights but we also acknowledge that biological women need their own single sex spaces and sports, so we want to ensure that biological women and trans women are both catered for, equally but separately", that would be a game changer.

You've just articulated my position on the trans debate so much better than I ever could. Wouldn't it be great if everyone could just listen to your words and set about redesigning public spaces so that everyone could live their lives?

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 12:10

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:01

Of course you have every right to be. I expressed the view that I hope and believe that others have a wider perspective. Personally I have no time for single issue voters and that is my right too.

Of course that is your right.

But if you actually want more people to vote Labour and have a better chance of getting rid of the Tories, surely it would be a better use of your time to encourage Labour to re-examine their thinking on this issue. Their position is basically that people born without a penis don't have the right to a word for themselves or any penis free spaces or sports, and that a woman is anyone who says they are one.

That renders anything they might have to say about "women's rights" null and void. It makes them untrustworthy. It makes them liars. It makes them not obviously more competent to run the country than the Tories.

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:04

L1ttledrummergirl · 28/05/2023 11:35

@Colourfingers2 Pmsl. Typical conservative, not liking being told they are wrong, so start acting as though they are above the rules, whilst trying to shut down debate with threats.
This is one reason I won't vote conservative.

My feeling is that we need the tories out ASAP, the country has been robbed enough and I don't like the current direction of travel. If we had an election tomorrow, I would vote labour as most likely to remove the takes cash for fastracking a business with no links to ppe down the vip lane for contracts, doesn't respond to letters and emails until told what to write by cchq, total waste of space MP in my constituency.

My local Labour candidate is a GP so I hope they know what a woman is. I am planning to attend hustings to ask the questions and see the responses when we actually get an election.

To be fair to Conservative voters I doubt most of them go to bullying and threatening behaviour like @Colourfingers2 has

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 12:01

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 11:19

Damn right I'm a single issue voter. I have every right to be.

All Labour need to do to get my vote is commit to not shitting all over women's rights - actual women, I mean - and they won't.

It's shameful.

Of course you have every right to be. I expressed the view that I hope and believe that others have a wider perspective. Personally I have no time for single issue voters and that is my right too.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 11:48

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 11:31

@MargotBamborough I don't think the majority of the electorate are bigoted. I think they just need time to think about issues to ensure they and their families are safe and that society is fair.

Past and current evidence demonstrates that Labour's intention is the protection and advancement of women's rights. Keir Starmer was clear in March 2023 that plans for Self ID would require reflection before any action is taken, in light of recent events.

Single issue voting is absolutely your right but definitely ignores the wider picture which is having terribly negative impact on so many, especially the poorest, many of whom are women and girls.

I've enjoyed talking with you @MargotBamborough

I hope Labour can win you and others over with their positive actions as we are in a mess with this current government.

The problem is that anything they say on the subject of women's rights is inherently unreliable because they are using the word "women" to mean a mixed sex group which includes male people. As long as the percentage of women who don't have a penis is, according to Labour, less than 100%, the category of people who actually are women and need women's rights is not a category they acknowledge actually exists.

That's why I don't trust them when they say they will protect women's rights, because their idea of what a woman is and my idea of what a woman is are not the same.

If they said, "We are committed to protecting trans people's rights but we also acknowledge that biological women need their own single sex spaces and sports, so we want to ensure that biological women and trans women are both catered for, equally but separately", that would be a game changer.

L1ttledrummergirl · 28/05/2023 11:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

@Colourfingers2 Pmsl. Typical conservative, not liking being told they are wrong, so start acting as though they are above the rules, whilst trying to shut down debate with threats.
This is one reason I won't vote conservative.

My feeling is that we need the tories out ASAP, the country has been robbed enough and I don't like the current direction of travel. If we had an election tomorrow, I would vote labour as most likely to remove the takes cash for fastracking a business with no links to ppe down the vip lane for contracts, doesn't respond to letters and emails until told what to write by cchq, total waste of space MP in my constituency.

My local Labour candidate is a GP so I hope they know what a woman is. I am planning to attend hustings to ask the questions and see the responses when we actually get an election.

Owlglasses · 28/05/2023 11:31

@MargotBamborough I don't think the majority of the electorate are bigoted. I think they just need time to think about issues to ensure they and their families are safe and that society is fair.

Past and current evidence demonstrates that Labour's intention is the protection and advancement of women's rights. Keir Starmer was clear in March 2023 that plans for Self ID would require reflection before any action is taken, in light of recent events.

Single issue voting is absolutely your right but definitely ignores the wider picture which is having terribly negative impact on so many, especially the poorest, many of whom are women and girls.

I've enjoyed talking with you @MargotBamborough

I hope Labour can win you and others over with their positive actions as we are in a mess with this current government.

MargotBamborough · 28/05/2023 11:19

ilovesooty · 28/05/2023 11:07

@MargotBamborough you are so entrenched in your view that the Labour Party is actively damaging to women that no amount of evidence is going to change your mind.

Single issue people like you aren't going to change their views on things

Other people don't operate in a single issue world - and I'm thankful that there are people with a wider perspective on what is important for wider society.

Damn right I'm a single issue voter. I have every right to be.

All Labour need to do to get my vote is commit to not shitting all over women's rights - actual women, I mean - and they won't.

It's shameful.